DVD, Blu-ray Shrinking. Digital Distribution Rising

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The bad news is that DVD sales are falling and Blu-ray sales, with only 4% of the market, aren’t taking up the slack. The good news is that digital distribution, with ten percent of the market share, is up 18% and rentals are up too.

Total disc sales, including standard DVDs and Blu-ray, plunged 13.9%, a slightly bigger drop than the 13.5% decline in the first six months of 2009. In an effort to downplay just how dismal revenue from DVD sales has become, DEG didn't disclose total revenue for the category.
 
i thought bluray sales were skyrocketing and noone wanted shitty dvds anymore (at least shitty dvds are good enough for me even on 1080p tv)? i guess by the time bluray actually takes off we will already have the next format war with 25 channel uncompressed sound and a 4k resolution, both of which noone needs. oh wait this ins't a bluray fanboi vs haters thread =)

on topic: does "digital distribution" mean bittorrent? :D
 
Umm, recession anyone? People care about their homes more than their DVD's or Blu-Ray movies?
 
Umm, recession anyone? People care about their homes more than their DVD's or Blu-Ray movies?

Oh no, people still watch movies. They just don't feel it is quite as important to horde them and pay 4x as much to store them on their shelf in case they wan't to watch it again one day.
 
It's the Economy.

I have over 1000 DVD's. I haven't bought one in 8 months (though I will be getting transformers today).

I've settled for TV and rentals for a while until things improve.

Bad time to collect data on sales.
 
It's the Economy.

It's *mostly* the economy, that much I can believe. It's also due to a certain HD format having no competition and still believing that jacked up prices are justifiable. Those two forces are creating chaos in the segment. Then you throw in Netflix/Blockbuster mail rentals and the fact that lots of people are making um, "archival backups" of those movies, saving them big $$$ for something they might watch 1-2 times...
 
It's the Economy.

I have over 1000 DVD's. I haven't bought one in 8 months (though I will be getting transformers today).

I still buy DVDs when the new releases come out on Tuesday but not as many...

BECAUSE

...I have been renting a lot more too, downloading them on XBL, etc. etc. to help weed out the bad ones.

Blu-ray prices are just too insane, not just because of the economy either. I have the big BR titles that look good on my home theater (like Tranformers 2 today) that benefit from the big screen but there is no way I am going to replace 3000+ movies with Blu-ray unless it becomes the standard.
 
It's *mostly* the economy, that much I can believe. It's also due to a certain HD format having no competition and still believing that jacked up prices are justifiable. Those two forces are creating chaos in the segment. Then you throw in Netflix/Blockbuster mail rentals and the fact that lots of people are making um, archival backups of those movies, saving them big $$$ for something they might watch 1-2 times...

Most people I know tried hording archives until they realized it was time, effort, and storage space dedicated to things they never got around to watching again. Even had a friend who had burned TONS of them... he threw them away. Wasn't worth the space when he can just request any of them and have it the next day IF it isn't already on instant.
 
Bit-torrent > Blue-Ray

Actually I own about 30 BR movies, I would own more but really getting old movies on BR is pointless as they are just upscaled DVD's... so why pay 1.5x the price when I can just buy the DVD and often times get that DVD out of the 3/$10 bin at Walmart.
 
Internet usage caps will kill digital distribution.

And that is why you borrow unused bandwidth from your neighbors who never even bothered to change anything in their wireless router from default.

/I do not condone the theft of bandwidth, I do condemn dumbasses who do not even bother changing the PW on their router from the default "admin" and who further don't even bother to use any sort of encryption on said router.
 
Digital distro is still on my do-not-buy list until they implement closed captioning. The FCC needs to step on a few necks in this area. FCC laws for closed captioning only extends to television and physical media (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS), not the internet. It should be amended to "all broadcasts distributed by television networks, be it on television or internet".

Netflix says it's not a priority and they might have it implemented in a year. Hulu only has a few shows captioned.

Until then, it's DVD and Blu-ray for me.
 
I have owned a 1080p TV for 3 years. I bought a cheap BR player a few months ago. I now own a total of 2 BR movies... and will add Transformers to make it 3 this week.

There's no reason to pay pumped up prices to get regular movies that you'll only watch once. Certain movies, like Iron Man, have enough cinematics to make Hi-Def worth paying for. Otherwise, a good upconverting DVD player (most BR players do a good job also), will save you a lot of money and you'll enjoy the movie just as much. I'm also on the 3 movie Netflix plan. It's great! My wife and I can watch all the movies we want, knowing we won't ever want to see most of them ever again so there's no need to buy and store a useless movie.
 
Netflix pure and simple. Why buy when a can stream or have it the next day?

Also, BR isn't the jaw dropping experience that it is hyped up to be.

Yes I can tell a difference on my 47" Full HD TV. At 15 feet away though, I'm having a hard time with the justification of the extra expence. Maybe if I was closer.... and had more time.
 
Bit-torrent > Blue-Ray

Actually I own about 30 BR movies, I would own more but really getting old movies on BR is pointless as they are just upscaled DVD's... so why pay 1.5x the price when I can just buy the DVD and often times get that DVD out of the 3/$10 bin at Walmart.

Meh, older movies buy the DVD, I mainly get newer movies on Blu-ray. On a side note Star Trek TOS and Blade Runner look incredible on Blu-ray. As convenient as digital media is, most of it is content protected (heavily) and you can't let your friends borrow it (unless...).
 
It's the Economy.

I have over 1000 DVD's. I haven't bought one in 8 months (though I will be getting transformers today).

I've settled for TV and rentals for a while until things improve.

Bad time to collect data on sales.

That's kind of how things are at my house. My wife has probably 1000 DVDs but we almost never buy them any more.

Personally, I find that I want a movie, but that I want the BD (if available). But the BD is too expensive on release so I don't buy it right away. Then somehow I never buy it.
 
Digital distro is still on my do-not-buy list until they implement closed captioning. The FCC needs to step on a few necks in this area. FCC laws for closed captioning only extends to television and physical media (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS), not the internet. It should be amended to "all broadcasts distributed by television networks, be it on television or internet".

Netflix says it's not a priority and they might have it implemented in a year. Hulu only has a few shows captioned.

Until then, it's DVD and Blu-ray for me.


I agree there needs to be CC on streaming media. My GF likes to have subtitles on, but i can't do that with netflix. For us its just a convienence, while to some they have no other way of watching.

I think CC should be a standard for ALL media, Well, maybe not Youtube, but you get the point
 
I agree there needs to be CC on streaming media. My GF likes to have subtitles on, but i can't do that with netflix. For us its just a convienence, while to some they have no other way of watching.

I think CC should be a standard for ALL media, Well, maybe not Youtube, but you get the point

Well it should be all media distributed by television networks and Hollywood, even on YouTube. YouTube Shows is similar to Hulu (http://www.youtube.com/shows).

Amateur and homemade videos are exempted of course,
 
The bad news is that DVD sales are falling and Blu-ray sales, with only 4% of the market, aren’t taking up the slack. The good news is that digital distribution, with ten percent of the market share, is up 18% and rentals are up too.

This is just another one of those contradictory things. Just the other month I read about how blu-ray was ahead of DVD at this same point in DVD's life. I mean, every time you turn around some "study" is saying something different. There's no "I told you so" in this. Digital distribution is still a long ways off to become mainstream.
 
Studios love Blu-ray disc sales more than any other type of transaction because profit margins are the highest.
And that's why so many people won't buy them; they know they are getting ripped off. Who wants to be the MPAA's bitch.
 
The title lead me to believe that Blu-ray sales were shrinking when in fact they are up 60 some odd percent for this quarter.
 
The bad news is that DVD sales are falling and Blu-ray sales, with only 4% of the market, aren’t taking up the slack. The good news is that digital distribution, with ten percent of the market share, is up 18% and rentals are up too.

wow talk about spin doctoring...

Total media sales is down compared to last year... but BD sales are up from last year.

The growth of BD sales is up higher than the growth of digital distro or rentals...

but BD is "shrinking" Gotcha. BTW for new movie releases on BD and DVD, sales of BD version are from 12% to 30%.

Someone on this site sore that HD-DVD died?
 
Blu-ray is not worth the price premium for the players or the discs. A 20% markup over DVD discs is not worht it. Especially with upscalling DVD players. We need cheaper players and the dsics to be sold for the same price as DVD's. Digital distribution is great for games and for renting movies on demand. Hd content takes up a lot of space. I do see digital disribution taking over but not completely. Physical media is great for giving presents, the elderly, luddites, and impulse buyers. I know very few people with HDTV in addition. I own one, my ex-girlfriend has one. But they are still quite expensive. i figure int he enxt year or two HDTV's abnd blu-ray will become mroe mainstream as prices drop, load times drop, And every tv is 1080P. So give it till 2012 or when the zombie apocalypse occurs.
 
Oh no you didn't just compare upscaled DVD to Blu-ray~:D

Transformers Revenge of the Fallen this morning $20 on release, Observe and Report $17 week of release, Blu-ray; both on DVD at the $20 mark, mark up my ass.

One thing I have to say about digital Streaming and media, they are a good price for the format $7-$17 from iTunes to buy (if not free with Blu-ray) and unlimited Steaming from Netflix for $13 a month (for the selection). Buying and downloading stuff like The Adventures of One eskimO and X-Men Evolution off of iTunes and getting my numerous collection of Digital Copies of movies has made me a believe of digital distro, but there are some serious draw backs, like the new format war about to break out over Digital Copies. Godzilla (Sony only), Observe and Report (Windows Media only) and then all the iTunes digital copies.
 
You're reading too much into it ;)


Exactly. Trust me on this one, I just ignore the people that cry when {insert their favorite whatevermajig} gets bad press. None of them EVER taken into account...I....didn't....write....the....article. :D

Last time when Blu-ray was 6% and digital downloads were 1% I was biased against digitial downloads:rolleyes:

The article flat out said:

"Total disc sales, including standard DVDs and Blu-ray, plunged 13.9%"

"Blu-ray sales in the quarter were $161 million, just 4% of the home-entertainment industry's $4 billion total. Industry hopes that Blu-ray could make up for plummeting sales of standard-definition DVDs have not been realized."

"Digital distribution, which includes online downloads and streaming as well as cable video-on-demand, rose 18%, down slightly from 21% in the first six months. It remains about 10% of the total industry with $420 million worth of revenue."
 
. The good news is that digital distribution, with ten percent of the market share, is up 18%

Uh, I hate to point out that heavily DRM'd videos that you can't make reasonable uses of (transcoding for example) isn't 'good news'.

I haven't seen Steve Jobs championing the DRM free videos on iTunes.
 
All I have to say is when movies go DRM free, hell will be an ice skating ring for little kids. What scares me is BD DRM which is constantly evolving and will eventually cut all analog out of the equation or potentially bargain BD players (yeah, I still have flashbacks to Fantastic Four 4 and the Silver Surfer BD release, funny stuff). Can't wait till some company incorporates AnyDVD HD into their players just for 'future proofing' BD playback.
 
Ever try selling your iTune movies?

Damn no edit, that is the whole point of them being so cheap. When you resell you old movies or tv series you take a big hit, but the movies on iTunes tend to be priced, at about the same value as if you bought and then resold the movie however many months later. I think iTunes Season passes are a huge rip off though. iTunes is priced fair for buying most digital video content. Still cheaper to buy music on Amazon though.

Plus X-Men Evolution and a lot of their animated content has yet to be released on DVD in its entirety. I just wish they would of mastered it a bit.
 
Damn no edit, that is the whole point of them being so cheap. When you resell you old movies or tv series you take a big hit, but the movies on iTunes tend to be priced, at about the same value as if you bought and then resold the movie however many months later. I think iTunes Season passes are a huge rip off though. iTunes is priced fair for buying most digital video content. Still cheaper to buy music on Amazon though.

Plus X-Men Evolution and a lot of their animated content has yet to be released on DVD in its entirety. I just wish they would of mastered it a bit.

So you are saying you can't sell your iTune movies? That there is a deal breaker. I demand to OWN my purchases.

My cost on average for a DVD movie shipped is ~$5-7 and I get the benefit of:

re-sale

transcoding

no big brother (how many times I watched etc...)

Those are pretty big barriers for 'digital distribution' to overcome.
 
If true, its too bad. I don't like DVD but I'm not a huge fan of digital downloads eitherm outside of convenience.

Blu Ray however, amazing, best media for watching movies ever. I'm a home theaternut, owned a Laserdisc player and was one of the first to jump into DVD, and Blu Ray is the holy grail as far as I'm concerned.

If you like digital downloads for convenience, great, I do too, but if we're trying to compare quality then they aren't even in the same zip code. If you still insist on this then I suggest getting your eyes checked. :)
 
I havn't bought a new BD movie in like 6 months. After I bought my favorite old movies on BD there hasn't really been anything good released imo. Personally I think they just need to start making movies that don't suck.
 
I'm a home theaternut, owned a Laserdisc player and was one of the first to jump into DVD, and Blu Ray is the holy grail as far as I'm concerned.

I'm right there with you on that...I just wish they could chisel some of the price off that holy grail ;)

Already had the wife pick up Transformers II. It was $14.99 on DVD or $24.99 on Blu-ray mentioned, just cheap versus not cheap.

First thing, she calls me and says "you want to $14 or the $24 one." No DVD and Blu-ray. I get sick of explaining WHY one is $10 more than the other one. every. single. time.


I havn't bought a new BD movie in like 6 months. After I bought my favorite old movies on BD there hasn't really been anything good released imo. Personally I think they just need to start making movies that don't suck.

what he said.
 
I'm right there with you on that...I just wish they could chisel some of the price off that holy grail ;)

Already had the wife pick up Transformers II. It was $14.99 on DVD or $24.99 on Blu-ray mentioned, just cheap versus not cheap.

First thing, she calls me and says "you want to $14 or the $24 one." No DVD and Blu-ray. I get sick of explaining WHY one is $10 more than the other one. every. single. time.

That's a headache. I bypass that by using Amazon for all my Blu Ray purchases. Its only $20 there and no sales tax for me. It may not be worth it for you but I also use Amazon Prime, $80 a year for unlimited two day shipping. I buy everything using Prime, Blu Ray, video games, cleaning supplies (really), even my uber-massive Corsair 800D case came via Prime. :)

Blu Ray sucks at B&M retail but for me its actually been cheaper building my Blu Ray library than it was my DVD library, and its all thanks to Amazon. If it isn't their discounts it is the usual buy-2-get-1-free deal they're usually doing.

Damn, Amazon needs to put me on commission. :)
 
That's a headache. I bypass that by using Amazon for all my Blu Ray purchases. Its only $20 there and no sales tax for me. It may not be worth it for you but I also use Amazon Prime, $80 a year for unlimited two day shipping. I buy everything using Prime, Blu Ray, video games, cleaning supplies (really), even my uber-massive Corsair 800D case came via Prime. :)

Blu Ray sucks at B&M retail but for me its actually been cheaper building my Blu Ray library than it was my DVD library, and its all thanks to Amazon. If it isn't their discounts it is the usual buy-2-get-1-free deal they're usually doing.

Damn, Amazon needs to put me on commission. :)

I'll have to check that out next time I go Blu-ray shopping. I don't shop at Amazon often enough to justify the cost of Prime though.

Historically I purchase Blu-ray at Fye used. They guarantee 100% condition and the clerk lets me check myself before I buy. The guys at the local Fye are pretty cool. Never ran across a faulty used Blu-ray yet.
 
On the side note, the "best" Blu-Ray player (PS3), outsold both Wii and XBox360 in September.
 
Back
Top