AMD Replies to NVIDIA

I did read it, and to me it looks like a retalitory act, but dont dismiss the fact that perhaps nV changed the driver structure a bit and it would cause problems.

Physics and graphics are two different elements in a game. It isn't like we're talking SLI mode where the two cards have to work together on 1 thing. I know it might confuse some people because they think "Well, the physics are being done on a GPU." but ATI working with DirectX to render a scene, and the nVidia card being used in the form of a processor, a processor dedicated to physics, are two different tasks that don't conflict.

After Intel comes out with Larrabee would you be ok with them putting out chipset driver updates that detect you are using an nVidia videocard and refuse to let you use it for 3D graphics under the guise of them not wanting to have to 'work on compatibility for their processors and a competitor's graphic card'? That's the situation we have now with nVidia. They're saying if you don't use us for graphics, we aren't going to let you use the product of ours you do have as a general purpose processor. Even though it's perfectly capable of being used that way without interference just as you can currently use nVidia to generate 3D graphics while using an Intel processor.
 
Good thing round mean nothing, when you get KO'd in the 12th!
ATI will enjoy all this till NV lowers the boom with the GT300, then ATI will hammer back with the 5870x2, then NV will close the show just like last time with an GX2 of w/e their top cards are.
This is never ending, why we get so wrapped up in it is just silly.

I love the fact that AMD/ATI keep NV and Intel in check, cause we sure dont want $700-800 video cards agin like the 8800GTX/Ultras.
 
Very original...How bout you show some proof they went out of their way to change it? Or is that just a hunch that every nV hater has...

NV will never come out and admit it. It would be PR suicide if they did.

But let's look at the facts:

It worked for quite a while amidst other driver updates. Batman: Arkham Asylum comes out and there's a new driver update. Suddenly it no longer works. Older drivers still work but don't function with Batman: AA. Nvidia just happens to be pimping Batman and PhysX as hard as they can because it's probably the first game that actually makes what I would call "good" use of PhysX.

Could that all be a coincidence? Sure, but the Lions have a better chance of winning the Super Bowl then all that being coincidence.
 
Good thing round mean nothing, when you get KO'd in the 12th!
ATI will enjoy all this till NV lowers the boom with the GT300, then ATI will hammer back with the 5870x2, then NV will close the show just like last time with an GX2 of w/e their top cards are.
This is never ending, why we get so wrapped up in it is just silly.

I love the fact that AMD/ATI keep NV and Intel in check, cause we sure dont want $700-800 video cards agin like the 8800GTX/Ultras.

I think nV has lost this one dude. This scenario is entirely different than the GX2 or 295 ones. Those both had cards that were released near the same time, and nV has fallen behind now seeing as they don't even have a slight clue as to when the GT300 series cards will be released.
 
Gotta give it to AMD. I am not a zealot by any means... but ATI/AMD has been impressive hardware wise. I just think ATI has never gotten drivers right like Nvidia has. Additionally I agree PhysX is stupid imo... physics should be done by the extra cores... no need to run that on the video card... let it render the graphics. This is just a gimmick... that should have died a long time ago... similar to the Killer nic crap.
 
Could that all be a coincidence? Sure, but the Lions have a better chance of winning the Super Bowl then all that being coincidence.

This made me laugh.


You are entirely correct and they also stated that they did this all on purpose, as seen right here:

For a variety of reasons - some development expense some quality assurance and some business reasons NVIDIA will not support GPU accelerated Physx with NVIDIA GPUs while GPU rendering is happening on non- NVIDIA GPUs.
 
I think ATi has to focus on building good products and let Nvidia take care of themselves. Or is it Intel?
Ohh--Me gonna wopen Can 'O HWuoop alse Nauw!!!
^In English: I'm gonna open a Can of Whoop Ass Now.
 
Gotta give it to AMD. I am not a zealot by any means... but ATI/AMD has been impressive hardware wise. I just think ATI has never gotten drivers right like Nvidia has. Additionally I agree PhysX is stupid imo... physics should be done by the extra cores... no need to run that on the video card... let it render the graphics. This is just a gimmick... that should have died a long time ago... similar to the Killer nic crap.

Right...The extra cores. Lets ignore that MOST people don't have quad-core CPUs so there are no extra cores to be used. Yes lets design a physics engine that only allows a game to be run on a tiny niche of systems and completely kill any profit. Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. GPGPU apps like PhysX have a place because they off-set other weakeneses. That being said, PhysX has its own major weakness, it really requires a GPU dedicated to it so that hurts any game using more than just some basic effects. Not sure how the up-coming Havok GPU API will react to just having one card, but hopefully it can manage better than PhysX. I don't see PhysX lasting, but it should prove to be a nice little stepping stone in the advancement of physics.
 
Right...The extra cores. Lets ignore that MOST people don't have quad-core CPUs so there are no extra cores to be used. Yes lets design a physics engine that only allows a game to be run on a tiny niche of systems and completely kill any profit. Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. GPGPU apps like PhysX have a place because they off-set other weakeneses. That being said, PhysX has its own major weakness, it really requires a GPU dedicated to it so that hurts any game using more than just some basic effects. Not sure how the up-coming Havok GPU API will react to just having one card, but hopefully it can manage better than PhysX. I don't see PhysX lasting, but it should prove to be a nice little stepping stone in the advancement of physics.

:rolleyes:

OMG let's put in a slider to allow people to choose their level of physics so they can decide how best to set their performance! Or better yet games can already detect what is "best" for them. If you only have a single core CPU have it auto-disable crazy physics for few or none.
 
:rolleyes:

OMG let's put in a slider to allow people to choose their level of physics so they can decide how best to set their performance! Or better yet games can already detect what is "best" for them. If you only have a single core CPU have it auto-disable crazy physics for few or none.

Yes I'm sure it would be just as easy as you make it sound.
 
I actually wonder what is NVIDIA going to do now. Let's sumarize :
1) GTX285 - overpriced when comparing to HD5870
2) GTX275 - questionable where will it stand in performance compared to 5850, but probably it won't be in a very good shape. Even bigger question is where will it stand against HD5770, which will have higher performance than HD4870, so it can be a very good competitor to GTX275 for lower price.
3) GTX260 - overpriced when comparing to HD5750 (should be in same performance range).

So the whole G200 line will either move down with price (that will hurt) or only the hardcore NVIDIA/PhysX fans will buy those cards. Lowering the price of push down G92 prices too - and that will hurt too.

So NVIDIA needs to act very fast and bring out the card this year, or they will have very sad holidays. I even can't imagine what would happen to NV if they will need to push their card to the end of Q1 or even Q2. GT300 so far reminds me R600 way too much.

Btw, it's NVIDIA who doesn't want my money - i was ready to shell out ~50€ for 9500GT as PhysX accelerator. Well, NVIDIA said no by disabling PhysX if there is ATI card in the computer. :)
 
NV will never come out and admit it. It would be PR suicide if they did.

But let's look at the facts:

It worked for quite a while amidst other driver updates. Batman: Arkham Asylum comes out and there's a new driver update. Suddenly it no longer works. Older drivers still work but don't function with Batman: AA. Nvidia just happens to be pimping Batman and PhysX as hard as they can because it's probably the first game that actually makes what I would call "good" use of PhysX.

Could that all be a coincidence? Sure, but the Lions have a better chance of winning the Super Bowl then all that being coincidence.

I find it hard to believe that instead of taking advantage of showcasing PhysX on all systems using PhysX instead of just nV systems using PhysX , they just simply pulled the plug on AMD. I already admitted it seems like a retalitory move, but im also inclined to think they may actually have been better off not supporting there hardware for use in conjunction with its competitor, for the reasons they actually stated. AMD being able to use nV PhysX cards is good for both of them, which is why i cant see this as being strictly a retaliation.

This made me laugh.


You are entirely correct and they also stated that they did this all on purpose, as seen right here:

You and shansoft and whoever else wants can assume all you want that they did it with sheer intent to cut ATI out. I just like how the variety of reasons gets spun to automatically mean "nVidia sucks and are idiots and blah blah blah", which is really what the anti-nV boys thrive on...making assumptions with out knowing anything and only seeing what you want to see...kinda like Charlie.
 
You and shansoft and whoever else wants can assume all you want that they did it with sheer intent to cut ATI out. I just like how the variety of reasons gets spun to automatically mean "nVidia sucks and are idiots and blah blah blah", which is really what the anti-nV boys thrive on...making assumptions with out knowing anything and only seeing what you want to see...kinda like Charlie.

far from that, if I am a fan in either one of it, I wouldn't even buy or use the other brand..

if you want to start the name calling, go ahead, it proves nothing and only reflecting yourself.
 
Yes I'm sure it would be just as easy as you make it sound.

Actually, it is.

Guess you haven't heard of the Batman Arkham Asylum hack that lets you do PhysX on your processor?

While the hack requires replacing the EXE and doing other things to bypass Nvidia's checks, the actual physics quality is controlled by one setting:
MaxPhysicsSubsteps=1 (default is 5)

You can read about it at http://forum.beyond3d.com/showthread.php?t=55143 .
 
I can't believe anybody would defend Nvidia on this one. Hardware-based Physx is bad for EVERBODY.

- game devs will be less likely to support it if only Nvidia GPUs can run it
- since it's Nvidia exclusive, games that do get Physx hardware support will most likely just use it for extra eye candy instead of stuff that affects the gameplay

It makes so much more sense to use a standards-based GPU physics engine. GPU Physx can't die soon enough.
 
Yes I'm sure it would be just as easy as you make it sound.

Batman already has it. My system was auto-maxed out on all settings because I'm a C2Q with Crossfired HD4870s.

For PhysX there's already three options available to you.

Hardware Accelerated PhysX
Normal PhysX on the CPU
High PhysX on the CPU

Fine tuning that based on hardware wouldn't pose an issue.

I find it hard to believe that instead of taking advantage of showcasing PhysX on all systems using PhysX instead of just nV systems using PhysX , they just simply pulled the plug on AMD. I already admitted it seems like a retalitory move, but im also inclined to think they may actually have been better off not supporting there hardware for use in conjunction with its competitor, for the reasons they actually stated. AMD being able to use nV PhysX cards is good for both of them, which is why i cant see this as being strictly a retaliation.



You and shansoft and whoever else wants can assume all you want that they did it with sheer intent to cut ATI out. I just like how the variety of reasons gets spun to automatically mean "nVidia sucks and are idiots and blah blah blah", which is really what the anti-nV boys thrive on...making assumptions with out knowing anything and only seeing what you want to see...kinda like Charlie.

I guess it's true that love is blind...
 
Actually, it is.

Guess you haven't heard of the Batman Arkham Asylum hack that lets you do PhysX on your processor?

While the hack requires replacing the EXE and doing other things to bypass Nvidia's checks, the actual physics quality is controlled by one setting:
MaxPhysicsSubsteps=1 (default is 5)

You can read about it at http://forum.beyond3d.com/showthread.php?t=55143 .

What does that have to do with the conversation? We're not talking about PhysX on the CPU, but why the whole "use extra cores" things makes no sense and the "ease" of having a slider or having the game detect the performance level of a CPU and adjust accordingly.
 
Isn't Batman the only game to be delayed to add PhysX ?

So, dirt gets delayed for DX11 support.
Batman gets delayed to add PhysX.


who cares :\
 
Another victory for AMD (small as it is.) I can't wait for a 5850. I am interested to see how much of an affect this is going to have on both companies sales. With AMD getting smacked on the processor side of things, this could be a very important victory heading into the coming years.
 
What does that have to do with the conversation? We're not talking about PhysX on the CPU, but why the whole "use extra cores" things makes no sense and the "ease" of having a slider or having the game detect the performance level of a CPU and adjust accordingly.

That guy said they should just do physics on our CPUs, you tell him that most people's computer can't handle physics, he tells you they just have a quality slider that determines quality of physics. You reply to him with sarcasm and say "Yes, I'm sure it would be just as easy as you make it sound."

I reply that in fact games using PhysX already have the ability to alter physics quality, thereby proving that the other guy was in fact right.

Seeing as you made mention of 'quad-core' in an earlier post of yours I'm not sure how you can say you didn't know he was talking about PhysX on a CPU.
 
Pwned_by_whale.jpg
 
arghhh ive always hated nvidia with there lies since HL2 came out and there FX cards defaulting to dx 8.1 not 9.0c for HL2 at that time, then you all get rebranded cards 8800's and on..even the 9800's and gt,gtx's and such..and if its meant to be played on nvidia why the hell does it play better on MY ATI LOL :D Nvidia the lies were meant to be ,YES, AMD should say Let Teh Truth Be Told...:D
 
and amd got 99 usd quads.

CAnt do physics ?

Ohh yes it can, very good!

AMD putting one nail after the other to nvidia, and intel isnt helping nvidia either, i bet intel is laughing their ass off and thinking( well, amd is taking care of our future problem, :) )
 
AMD [to nVidia]: How do you like me now?!

or "How you like them apples?! "


Nvidia better start putting up or shutting up, and this is coming from an NV fanboy

Nvidia isn't really in a bad position except that they're going to have to drop their prices so they match up price/performance. And with their die sizes being bigger thats going to hurt. But AMD's performance is NOT a grand slam in anyway. They trade blows for single card performance when its AMD new gen vs NV's old gen. I want to see some what NVidia will do to counter.
 
Ummm... You do understand that AMD has to license patents from Intel to make processors, right?

Do you understand how that works in the world of businesses and patents? PhysX is owned by Nvidia, that means that licensing is involved. Would you pay money to your competitor?
 
All we are seeing in the press from Nv is just the standard fair in the marketing world. Accuse your competitor of something while you do something just as bad or worse. Downplay any features your competitors product has and you lack, while singing the praises of any feature you have but your competitor lacks. It's just S.O.P..

But, Nv sure does know how to put their feet in their mouth. If they were going to say that sort of thing, they should have done so b4 whatever part they played in, or the appearance of gimping CPU PhysX in Bat Man, and certainly b4 they killed GPU PhysX on Nv cards if an AMD card was doing the rendering for solely marketing reasons.
 
This was amusing... Let the price wars begin! And may the best man (or woman) win! :)
 
Proprietary standards punish gamers, not industry standards like DirectX11.

Marketing department (minor) problem: how to present Microsoft's DirectX as "not proprietary"?
Answer: just call it "industrial".

Hey, I enjoy ATI's comeback as much as the next guy, but please...
 
Do you understand how that works in the world of businesses and patents? PhysX is owned by Nvidia, that means that licensing is involved. Would you pay money to your competitor?


agree'd.. AMD already has to pay out of their asses to intel to use SSE and x86.. they shouldnt have to pay nvidia just to use physX as well..
 
I have to agree with AMD on this. NVIDIA's just crying because they weren't first on the market with DX11 parts. NVIDIA is always working closely with developers to implement features that help them sell video cards and now that AMD is doing it they are going to whine about it. When NVIDIA had SM3.0 support before ATI did, NVIDIA was quick to take advantage of that advantage in their marketing. This time NVIDIA is running their collective mouths as usual and AMD responded appropriety. You'd think after NVIDIA's last round of smack talking with Intel (which didn't turn out all that well for them) that they'd learn to keep their mouths shut a little better.
 
I am not sure what you all think but I love what AMD have to say and its 100% true. nVIDIA is punishing players in reality. BTW Ive never purchased ATI cards since I am big fan of nvidia since CREATIVE RIVA TNT2.
 
Marketing department (minor) problem: how to present Microsoft's DirectX as "not proprietary"?
Answer: just call it "industrial".

Hey, I enjoy ATI's comeback as much as the next guy, but please...

There's a big difference between the proprietary DirectX that's owned and operated by Microsoft that ANYBODY can use versus the proprietary PhysX that is controlled by one of the major video card manufacturers and can ONLY be used on their cards.
 
Back
Top