Forums Can Be Helpful… O RLY?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Sounds like the mainstream media is just starting to wise up to what [H] readers have known about our forums for a long time. No, I’m not talking about trolls again. I’m referring to the 1-9-90 rule that analysts use when talking about online user groups. See the quote for the definition and rate yourself via the comments link.

About 1 percent of those in the community, she explained, are super-users who supply most of the best answers and commentary. An additional 9 percent are “responders” who mainly reply and rate Web posts, she said, and the other 90 percent are “readers” who primarily peruse and search the Web site for useful information.
 
I'm probably more in the 90 than the 9. I don't respond a heck of a lot unless something grabs my attention. Not too much of an answer type either, unless I feel like doing so.
 
Well I always considered myself a member in good standing of "The One Percent Club" so this is great news... :D
 
I prefer to call myself a "responder" that supplies most of the best answers and commentary. :)
 
Does anyone feel like a certain category is missing?

I hereby propose the 1-9-89-1 rule, the last 1% being TROLLS!
 
Can't tell if I'm part of the 1% or the 9% category :confused:
 
I think our 1 percent here is a little bigger. I will have to do the math next time I am digging through the data.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
I reply / post when I feel it contributes value, or insults well enough that people run screaming from the burning pile of ashes that was once their discussion. :)

I'm goddamn big in Japan though I swear it
 
You can track that data? Wow.
If you assume that most posts in general contain useful information, determining that ratio would be a matter of taking the group of active forum users and grouping them based on posting frequency. I would guess that the tracking is done with an approach somewhere along those lines. The difficult part would be separating the 1% from the 9%.
 
90 here..... I like reading and learning, but I'm not as edumacated as some others.
 
Great. Kyle's gonna give everyone new designations.

Actually this wouldn't be such a bad idea. The Citrix and the experts-exchange.com support sites have a 5-star rating system where if you appreciate a person's service, you rate them 1-5 stars.

It has potential, yet it could also be abused.

(though, maybe we should use 5-circles or 5-squares as not to offend Holocaust victims :p)
 
Actually this wouldn't be such a bad idea. The Citrix and the experts-exchange.com support sites have a 5-star rating system where if you appreciate a person's service, you rate them 1-5 stars.

It has potential, yet it could also be abused.

(though, maybe we should use 5-circles or 5-squares as not to offend Holocaust victims :p)

Stars would all go to hell if it was implemented in the news or genmay section... I know mine would :p
 
Put in some deterrents to prevent abuse, like logging people when they rate, and keeping an eye on the ones who rates 1-star all the time. If they're obvious trolls or abusers, boot them off the forums.
 
I wouldn't think the 1-9-90 applys to the [H]. It would be interesting to see our numbers, but I would think it would be real subjective deciding who falls into what category.

I've floated in and out of 1 and 9 depending on my available time here IMO. Of course we all had our time asking more than answering.
 
I fluctuate through all three categories. Most of the time, I'm in the 90% as I spend most of my time here, commenting on news items, and occasionally browsing the other forums but not posting in them.

Then, when I decide its time to upgrade, I spend a month in the 9% as I become more active in the hardware forums in order to get back into the loop, posting and responding about equally.

After the upgrade, I spend the next month in the 1% as I share my experience with others looking to do the same thing.

Eventually, I fall back out of the loop and fade back to the 90% again, which is where I am now.
 
I fluctuate through all three categories. Most of the time, I'm in the 90% as I spend most of my time here, commenting on news items, and occasionally browsing the other forums but not posting in them.

Then, when I decide its time to upgrade, I spend a month in the 9% as I become more active in the hardware forums in order to get back into the loop, posting and responding about equally.

After the upgrade, I spend the next month in the 1% as I share my experience with others looking to do the same thing.

Eventually, I fall back out of the loop and fade back to the 90% again, which is where I am now.


you know, i think i do that same pattern unconsciously too. after doing my vid mod to my cpu i have a need to write up a basic guide to overclocking intel on a budget. im not sure how many people would care around here though...
 
I fluctuate through all three categories. Most of the time, I'm in the 90% as I spend most of my time here, commenting on news items, and occasionally browsing the other forums but not posting in them.

Then, when I decide its time to upgrade, I spend a month in the 9% as I become more active in the hardware forums in order to get back into the loop, posting and responding about equally.

After the upgrade, I spend the next month in the 1% as I share my experience with others looking to do the same thing.

Eventually, I fall back out of the loop and fade back to the 90% again, which is where I am now.

Hmm. There is something to this.
 
Back
Top