MySpace Suicide Trial Underway

Unless I'm mistaken, some people seem to have some facts about this situation wrong.

I'm too lazy to look anything up but from what I remember, the 49 year old woman has a 13 year old daughter and that 13 year old daughter was previously friends with the 13 year old that killed herself. Some time after the friendship ended the 49 year old asked/hired an 18 year old to setup the Myspace account in order to get some information from the 13 year old that killed herself and/or to fuck with that 13 year old. The account was setup with malicious intent from the beginning and the 49 year old would have known the 13 year old had mental problems.

With these facts, that's why many of the analogies here aren't correct. If it was an actual 13 year old boy that did this, there wouldn't be a case. He's not an adult and it's unlikely he would have had as much information about the 13 year old's mental instability. The 49 year old is an adult and knew her actions were wrong and could cause problems. A relationship or even a contrived relationship between two 13 year olds is completely different from the reality which is a 49 year old preying on a known mentally unstable 13 year old.

 
Unless I'm mistaken, some people seem to have some facts about this situation wrong.

I'm too lazy to look anything up but from what I remember, the 49 year old woman has a 13 year old daughter and that 13 year old daughter was previously friends with the 13 year old that killed herself. Some time after the friendship ended the 49 year old asked/hired an 18 year old to setup the Myspace account in order to get some information from the 13 year old that killed herself and/or to fuck with that 13 year old. The account was setup with malicious intent from the beginning and the 49 year old would have known the 13 year old had mental problems.

With these facts, that's why many of the analogies here aren't correct. If it was an actual 13 year old boy that did this, there wouldn't be a case. He's not an adult and it's unlikely he would have had as much information about the 13 year old's mental instability. The 49 year old is an adult and knew her actions were wrong and could cause problems. A relationship or even a contrived relationship between two 13 year olds is completely different from the reality which is a 49 year old preying on a known mentally unstable 13 year old.


Just some Food for Thought. If you have watched "are you smarter than a 5th grader" you would know not to over-rate people based on their age and intellect. :p

take the mothers child.


give it to the other parents.

Two birds with one stone solution, bravo :D
 
Kids picking on kids also results in death. When I first heard about Columbine, my first thought was - finally - some asshole bullies got what they deserved. But I don't keep thinking that if I really think about it.

yes but a 13 year old, is far less accountable for their actions than someone of age, its still bad, but kids are easily influenced by their peers so it's a bit unfair. Adults are old and jaded and make their own decisions, and are fully accountable for them.

If some kid bullied my kid, my first wish would be that I wish I could smack that other kid down to the ground. My second thought would be, the kid might die, I would get in trouble, I can't do that, and I would TALK to the kid and ask him "what are you doing? are you going to bother my son again? are you going to leave him alone, or do we need to have a talk with the police?"
Exactly, how old are you? and you figured that out already, she's 49 and not reached your maturity.

The 49 year old lady - what she did, I guess that was vile, maybe she should go to prison for 6 months to a year, do community service for a couple years, and probation for 5 years. But, I'm just as concerned about keeping the internet free - if you call people names online, I don' think that should be taken as seriously as in person. And if you want to make a fake online personality, I think that's fine, you shouldn't have to be worried you might get in trouble for online fantasies.

There is an important difference between online and in person. You can delete an online account a lot easier than you can pull yourself out of a life, out of a school, change jobs, etc.

If I don't like emails from a certain person, I can just send them to my junk mail folder, or block their email/messages. If I'm at work, I can't just "block" a certain employee that's bothering me.
Ok, well what i'm about to say may not be quite relevant to this case. But, what about those for a better term 'weirdos' who have really adopted online life as their primary source of communication, their 'online life' is for all intents and purposes 'their real life'. To say online communtication is separate from other communication is a mistruth, where do you draw the line? what about writing a letter to somebody? what about using a telephone? text messaging? On-line life is just an extension of our real life, and as we have just seen it can affect somebody just as much..

I think the mother of the girl should be held just as responsilbe as the 49 year old lady who's on trial - they should BOTH be on trial, they are BOTH resonsible for that girl's death.
moronic. the mother did nothing. she didn't attack her own daughter. as far as she knew her daughter was talking to her boyfriend. what was she supposed to do ban her from talking to her boyfriend? that would have made the daughter resent the mother and who knows how that would've resulted, the mother knows the girl is unstable and knows not to upset her... its called tact.
 
That MySpace suicide trial is coming to a close. Whether or not you think this lady deserves jail time for her actions, one thing is for sure, people will be talking about the verdict for a long time regardless what it is.

Drew bragged to friends and business associates for weeks about her involvement in the MySpace page, Krause said, demonstrating that she was in violation of her user agreement with MySpace in a way that constituted criminal charges. "Even after the tragic death of Megan Meier," Krause said, "the defendant couldn't stop talking about her scheme."
 
if i was the parents of the deceased child, i'd be posting that lady's details on every website/bulletin board/supermarket/mental asylum i could...
 
if i was the parents of the deceased child, i'd be posting that lady's details on every website/bulletin board/supermarket/mental asylum i could...

Now that would be a crime. ;) :p
 
Way to resurect a popcorn thread. Some days I think your just a forum troll, Steve. :rolleyes::eek:


:D:D:D (Please dont' ban me! :p)
 
Solution: Tell your kids not to believe anything they read or trust anyone they meet on the internet

sad story though, to kill yourself over a hoax.. that is so rough
 
by someone said:
'Of course, if I were the parent then none of this would have happened'

Yeah, right.

The big issue here, I think, is just how far harassment (and, by proxy, bullying) laws should go. Given enough harassment,anyone can be broken and driven to suicide. And with technology as it is, it's either stricter harassment laws or bye-bye anonymity.
 
Although I encourage Cyberbullying, for someone to pick on somebody that is not their own size and then praise themselves in the aftermath is total BS. The bad thing about this whole ordeal is that it might effect all of us in the future when it comes to using the internet(As someone commented in the article). Even more possibly if she walks away.

However, like I said, I encourage Cyberbullying to the fullest, but only for the sake of the victim because it clearly points out who your enemies are, and that's a good thing. But then again, adults hacking children: That's like demons and angels disobeying the balance.

The mother may have truly done nothing wrong in legal terms, but I pray for Justice, with or without the law.
 
Reading this story made me sick. She may not have done anything illegal, but she deserves multiple serious beat downs. :mad:
 
This Drew knew exactly how this this would end because it was what she wanted. As a older female, Drew recognized the vulnerable state of mind Meier was in. Drew spent days builder up Meiers' low self esteem until the day came when pulled the chair out from under Meier by telling Meier she was ugly and the world would be better off without her. Drew indirectly suggested to Meier that she should kill herself. Trust me. Females are viscous to one another. This was the outcome Drew wanted all along.
Young girls are very vulnerable and many have very low self esteem such as Megan Meier. Drew posed as a teen boy and built Meier's self esteem so high that it could not get any higher. Then, Drew turned heel. She called Meier the worst thing you can call a teen female. The one word that is the strongest weapon that one teen female can use against another. Ugly. You guys know as well as I do how wrapped up teen girls are in their appearance. It is the number one thing to them. Lori Drew was a teen once. She knew the devastating effect it would have had on Megan Meier. She wanted to manipulate Megan Meier to kill herself.
 
//[T.0.P]//;1033365640 said:
Although I encourage Cyberbullying, for someone to pick on somebody that is not their own size and then praise themselves in the aftermath is total BS. The bad thing about this whole ordeal is that it might effect all of us in the future when it comes to using the internet(As someone commented in the article). Even more possibly if she walks away.

However, like I said, I encourage Cyberbullying to the fullest, but only for the sake of the victim because it clearly points out who your enemies are, and that's a good thing. But then again, adults hacking children: That's like demons and angels disobeying the balance.

The mother may have truly done nothing wrong in legal terms, but I pray for Justice, with or without the law.

Yeah and I encrouage anyone who personally knows a cyberbully to bully them in real life and give them an asskicking.

I personally had PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder) for nearly 15 years, going back to when I was 6. One thing I learned was that not socializing can have deadly effects on people who have been traumatized.

And I was bullied in school. And I spent years wanting to murder the people who did it.

People like you make me sick. I really hope people who choose to bully get their faces beatdown.
 
But bullying wasn't why I had PTSD.

And 6 is too young to be bullied in school.

My PTSD comes from my family. When I was 5 I saw my dad chocking my sister to death. When I was 8 my dad threw my mom against the wall of my room.

The fact that I was bullied in the midsts of watching my family suffer put me over the edge.

You don't know what kind of shit people deal with. You don't know what happens in their life. To bully anybody, is something only a pure asshole would do.

And anybody who causes someone to die from bullying deserves the death penality.
 
At 49 the lady should know better than to prey on a child with mental instabilities. She "premediatedly" harrassed a 13yr old girl telling her the world would be better off without her. That, to me, is manslaughter. Premeditated manslaughter. Sure, she didn't tie the rope around the girls neck and kick the chair out, but the effect was the same nevertheless.

What she did on Myspace was illegal as well. It's called fraud, any way you slice it or dice it.

Either way, telling someone to kill themself, and they do, leaves you liable for their death. Period.

I predict a 10 year sentence. Of which she'll probably do 3-5 then be released on parole. Not to mention the civil lawsuit that will follow from the girls parents. This woman essentially ruined the lives of 2 families with what she did.

To those that think this trial is bullshit, well, you're either not old enough to understand or don't have children of your own.

The thing is, a crime is not based on the effect, it's based on the act.

Robbing a bank to give money to a kid who needs a kidney transplant is still as much of a crime as robbing a bank just to have a shitton of cash....either way, you still robbed a bank.

In manslaughter, you have to have physically taken part in the death of a person, although in an unintentional manner. In this case she didn't....she did contribute to the death, but she did not supply rope, lack of supervision (why the fuck did her mother leave her alone knowing she was going through a problem?), and any other obvious immediate factors.

This is just like someone killing themselves over a phonecall....I haven't head of any thing of that sort getting a manslaughter charge.

As for the electronic tresspass....the question is: would she have been denied a Myspace if she used her real name? If not, then they have no legs to that charge....for tresspass, you have to go somewhere the average person of sound mind and morals would consider closed or access forbidden to them.
 
One more addition to the tresspass....if she was banned or had an account deleted...then a second account could be considered tresspass.
 
Boy has xbox 360 taken away, runs away, found dead. Most think he got what he desired. --> Darwin award.

Girls takes comment on website too personally, kills herself, Most think this is wrong and that the person posting is at fault. --> No Darwin Award.


I am going to go against most here and say good the girl deserved to die. One less messed up person to grow old and have more messed children. +1 for Darwin Award. The woman, her assistant and her daughter should be given a pat on the back for thier good jobs as Pool girls for the gene pool.
 
Boy has xbox 360 taken away, runs away, found dead. Most think he got what he desired. --> Darwin award.

Girls takes comment on website too personally, kills herself, Most think this is wrong and that the person posting is at fault. --> No Darwin Award.


I am going to go against most here and say good the girl deserved to die. One less messed up person to grow old and have more messed children. +1 for Darwin Award. The woman, her assistant and her daughter should be given a pat on the back for thier good jobs as Pool girls for the gene pool.

I'm certainly sure you'd feel the same way if you were in her shoes and heard that comment.

But since your basically saying people who treat others like shit are better genes then a person who was human, I can certainly see you'd die knowing your own piece of shit self is dead.
 
And to all people who are saying people like this are messed up and shouldn't live... Go join some neo-nazis and kill jews assholes.

The only messed up people are those who thinks it's okay to treat people like shit. And that goes for people in healthy lives, and people in miserable ones.

I'm pretty sure you also agree with the Weathermen, and all the kids who were in upper middle class homes and thought killing would be good, huh?
 
Sorry, no edit button.

The simple fact of what makes us humans is love and emotions. Rather or not you live correctly according to emotions, the fact that you have emotions based on love or lack thereof makes you human.

Anyone who thinks people who are cold, don't react to emotions or words, and spread hate everywhere, are the only people who are truly dead.
 
Are you trying to tell me that I should kill myself over my post? Thats it, after I get done with a few things I need to do after work I'm going to kill myself and leave a note showing how you told me in a round about way that I should kill myself, or at least that is the way that I took it and that you should be arrested for my death.

Actually how can you call the girl that died more human than the others? The reason that this started was because she was spreading lies about the other girl and they set this up as a trap to catch her saying bad things. That is no different than a person pretending to be a 12 year old to catch a child molester. Had she not be a bitch to others then she wouldn't have been lead down a path that caused her to kill herself.

Actually I was trying see what type of reaction my post would get. However I don't have a too much longer before i'll be away from a computer till late tonight. As I said a boy dies as a result of a stupid decision and a lot of people post how they thinks he deserved it, for this girls though it is a horrible thing and everyone seems to think the woman involved should be punished or killed or whatever. Both cases are not very much different at the core, troubled kid kills themself over something that could have been prevented.

As I stated above I think the fake account is about in line with a fake account to catch a molestor, assuming that they actually did set it up to catch the girl that killed herself saying horrible things about the other. Somebody mentioned confronting the girl. How do you do that without any proof. If you have transcripts from a chat than you can bring them before the girl and her parents and say "look I understand that girls had a falling out, but I do not appeariate these types of things being said about my daughter. " If the girl (believing the accused womain was not home but that it was her daughter that sent the last messages) over reaccted at the proof that her former friend was saying bad things about her then, you know what that happens. The same thing could have happened in person.

In my opinion the guilty part is the dead girls parents for not giving her the help that she needed and making sure she was of a sound mind. They knew she was missed up yet didn't do what they could to prevent her from hurting herself.

Ultimatly, I feel sorry for the family for losing their daughter, but I don't think that the others should be punished unless it can be shown that their intent the entire time was to force the girl to kill herself.
 
I'm certainly sure you'd feel the same way if you were in her shoes and heard that comment.

But since your basically saying people who treat others like shit are better genes then a person who was human, I can certainly see you'd die knowing your own piece of shit self is dead.

Your definition of "human" is pretty retarded. If you google it you'll find that "persons who treat others like shit" are very much human. It's called natural selection, the old chick did us all a service.
 
To those that are celebrating her death as a blessing to our gene pool, perhaps it would be better gene pool if the whacko 49 year old lady were removed instead. Maybe Ms. Meier was a prettier girl? ;)
 
i think it's because you dont see manic depression as a real illness. It is a real illness, and people really have no control over it, i've had a number of friends suffer it and one was particularly bad and has long since disappeared (she used to always disappear for months on end, but its been a few years now). It's really sad and i think you really have no grasp on that.

its like if somebody has a heart condition, and you scare the crap outta them and they have a heart attack and die.. its your fault. is exactly the same as messing with somebodys mental state when they have a severe mental illness.

Not if i wasnt aware of it... if i knew they had a heart condition sure, lock me up, but if i had no clue how can you blame me for the unknown..... same in this case as Dan said if the woman KNEW she had depression lock her up, but otherwise how can they....


i havent killed myself, i was bullied all through grade school and was publically humiliated in grade 7 when a bully decided to take it on me in the middle of the street when school was over, i was balling my eyes out with muy g/f at the time there even - did i kill myself... no......and yes i have been diagnosed with depression all through out my teenage years....
 
and the 49 year old would have known the 13 year old had mental problems.

how?

alot of people with depression issues dont go around telling the world about it, or even new friends, depressed people usually keep it to themselves because they are affraid if people find out they wont accept or like them.
 
Her daughter was her best friend right up until they had some falling out and "mommy" ran in to save the day.

I'll continue discussing this with adults. In a more mature forum. Maybe you guys should stick with technology.
 
next thing you know theyll send people to jail for trolling internet forums because they hurt peoples feelings
 
Your definition of "human" is pretty retarded. If you google it you'll find that "persons who treat others like shit" are very much human. It's called natural selection, the old chick did us all a service.

Humans have something above natural selection, and that is called love, and emotions.

If you have none, then feel free to go join:

Nazis
KKK
Weathermen
AIG

And all other groups who also feel the way you do.
 
Are you trying to tell me that I should kill myself over my post? Thats it, after I get done with a few things I need to do after work I'm going to kill myself and leave a note showing how you told me in a round about way that I should kill myself, or at least that is the way that I took it and that you should be arrested for my death.

Actually how can you call the girl that died more human than the others? The reason that this started was because she was spreading lies about the other girl and they set this up as a trap to catch her saying bad things. That is no different than a person pretending to be a 12 year old to catch a child molester. Had she not be a bitch to others then she wouldn't have been lead down a path that caused her to kill herself.

Actually I was trying see what type of reaction my post would get. However I don't have a too much longer before i'll be away from a computer till late tonight. As I said a boy dies as a result of a stupid decision and a lot of people post how they thinks he deserved it, for this girls though it is a horrible thing and everyone seems to think the woman involved should be punished or killed or whatever. Both cases are not very much different at the core, troubled kid kills themself over something that could have been prevented.

As I stated above I think the fake account is about in line with a fake account to catch a molestor, assuming that they actually did set it up to catch the girl that killed herself saying horrible things about the other. Somebody mentioned confronting the girl. How do you do that without any proof. If you have transcripts from a chat than you can bring them before the girl and her parents and say "look I understand that girls had a falling out, but I do not appeariate these types of things being said about my daughter. " If the girl (believing the accused womain was not home but that it was her daughter that sent the last messages) over reaccted at the proof that her former friend was saying bad things about her then, you know what that happens. The same thing could have happened in person.

In my opinion the guilty part is the dead girls parents for not giving her the help that she needed and making sure she was of a sound mind. They knew she was missed up yet didn't do what they could to prevent her from hurting herself.

Ultimatly, I feel sorry for the family for losing their daughter, but I don't think that the others should be punished unless it can be shown that their intent the entire time was to force the girl to kill herself.

Actually I was commenting in the same way you had commented.

The problem with the whole ordeal (And yes, telling somebody 'you shouldn't be in this world' IS intent), is that the parents couldn't do much. Like I said, keeping a person in mental anguish away from other people can have vastly worse effects. Now they should've counseled her, yes, but most people are saying that you should've isolated her.

A person has to find love from within, not because someone says something. But that doesn't change pure attacks of hate.

Act like male chauvinists all you want to guys, but anybody going around attacking people, esp. when their down, DOES NOT deserve an award. They deserve punishment.
 
And I'm pretty damn sure the male chauvinists responding to a person attacking someone while their down with laughter would love it if the same happened.

And your talking feelings hurt. I'm sorry, but theirs something called honor, and you guys have none. Some of the greatest martial artists in the world have the honor to not attack people while their down and near death. Try learning from someone with true strength.
 
One final thing:

The whole idea of rewarding people like this and applauding them is a sham in itself.

By high school (well, 12th grade), I was pretty strong. I remember a guy who did nothing but pick on kids far smaller. I told him if he's so strong, pick on me!

Now the thing is, it wasn't that simple. I was pretty scared to do it. The guy was almost twice my size! But apparantly, I was the first decently big guy to stand up to him and he shut up.

The thing I always find about little shits who pick on people who can't fight is, their nothing but worthless slobs. Their the same as people who cheat on online fps games. They suck at everything in life, so they have to cheat, which in the case of bullying means cheat by picking on people they know can't fight back.

If you guys wanna award miserable slobs who can't do anything in life, then please go ahead. But it seems to me that your wanting to award them makes you a loser too.
 
Sorry, no edit button.

The simple fact of what makes us humans is love and emotions. Rather or not you live correctly according to emotions, the fact that you have emotions based on love or lack thereof makes you human.

Anyone who thinks people who are cold, don't react to emotions or words, and spread hate everywhere, are the only people who are truly dead.

Of course we have to have these emotions, but the problem here is how one reacts to it.

People have said mean things to me, and I'm sure this is something all of us had experience before. That I have no control, they say what they want.

But the thing that I do have control over is how I react to it. If I kill myself because, generally speaking, something very bad happened to me, that's absolutely my own fault. I can't blame others of I kill myself because someone told me to. Its my own mental flaw.

Of course I'm not saying what the old lady did there was right, but IMO, suicide is not something we can blame on others. To me, this is just a very sad and unfortunate incident, but it isn't a crime.

Though if I had a daughter, there's no way in hell I'll allow her to have an online boyfriend at 13.
 
ok a little off-topic, when i saw her on tv, uhmm well i think she was hot :\. Maybe she wasen't i dont know, but she sure seemed like it :). Sadly she had to die because of a stupid comment :*(
 
Suicide is a terrible thing. If you have ever talked to someone who has wanted to commit suicide (a friend of mine way back in high school), or ever talked to someone while they are commiting suicide (about 2 years ago I found a guy who had slit his throat and jumped out of a third story window dying in the street), then the people who say it's the fault of the child might look at it a little differently. These people are broken, and like anything that is broken they need to be fixed. Suicidal people believe that they are a burden to everyone around them, that they have no worth, and the world would be a better place without them. My friend kept talking about the strength it would take to do it while the guy in the street was failing out of college and couldn't talk about it with his parents.

This 49 year old person created an online persona of a 13 year old male who then reached out to this girl. When people have low self-esteem they will attach to almost anyone or anything that reaches out to them. I can only imagine the elation this 13 year old girl must have felt when a boy her own age was expressing interest in her. I don't know the specifics, but I'm guessing she didn't start out by calling her worthless. The 49 year old woman probably started off by telling the girl that she was cute and looked like fun. According to the article their relationship went on for weeks and the entire time this 13 year old girl thought she was talking to a 13 year old boy. She didn't know it was her classmates mother and if she did she probably wouldn't have taken it seriously when, after weeks of talking, the person she was talking to told her the world would be a better place if she were dead. By affirming the belief of a suicidal person this 49 year old woman in effect pulled the trigger of this girls mental disorder and now she's dead.

She deserves to be called a murderer, maybe not to be charged with murder but she was the person who told her to do it. People laying dying in the street talk about how they think other people see them. This woman is trying to convince everyone it's not her fault.
 
Well said.

Only the most worthless of individuals would ever think it's okay to take advantage of someone who couldn't stop them, or even think it's okay for anybody to do it.

And these people who do this need to be treated like the worthless pieces of shit that they are by everyone.
 
Back
Top