Is the Internet Making Us Stupid?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
While most of us believe that you can use the internet and its unlimited source of information to actually learn something, this article says teh intarweb maeks us st00pit.

In fact, Carr argues, when we give in to the natural impulses to click and skim, rather than to read and think, the Internet may actually doing us a disservice: It shortens our attention spans and even inhibits our ability to read longer books and articles.

Personally I think the internet, when compared to TV or a book, is a far greater learning tool because you can expand / research / fact check anything you are reading or watching on the internet. With TV or a book, you are basically stuck with what they are telling you with no real way of exploring beyond the information contained in the book or TV program.
 
I disagree. If I could have half the argument in real life as I could with people on these forums, I would be amazed.

Internet folks are much more capable of a good argument than in real life. Sure, most of us searches for answers, however, searching is a good thing. It takes a piece of a brain to know something, but it takes more than that to know where to find something and back it up at the same time.
 
I was a big reader before the internet and I am still a big reader during the internet age. I even continue to read my daily newspaper (at least the articles I haven't read online the afternoon before ;)).

I haven't seen any negative effect on my reading ability or interest in reading. My debating skills have definitely increased because of message boards. :D

I just don't consider myself a "click and skim" sort of guy. I imagine that most of us on these boards read the multiple pages of each review to get the full picture of a product.
 
Lies. I've read over 100 new books just in the past year... And I'm on the internet 24/7. ;)

And I agree, I've learned SO much just using the internet. Like when you go to Wikipedia to look up something like Singapore, and next thing you know you're reading about the person who invented spoons. It's like having all the knowledge of the world at your fingertips :)
 
I click and skim with things I have no interest in reading. For articles, etc. that I am interested in, I don't just read...whatever it is I'm reading, but I also do some background research to find our more about the subject.

There's nothing wrong with not wanting to read longer books and articles, imo. Isn't brevity the soul of wit?
 
I still love books now as I have for the past 30 years. The internet hasn't changed my mind. But I agree with the internet being a better learning tool than books. The world's explorations, inventions and discoveries are moving too rapidly and many old facts have been disproved. It's difficult to edit books, but you'll always find current and updated information on the internet.

Our solar system having only 9 planets come to mind.

However I should also add that the internet has more wrong information and opinions than correct ones. As with books and libraries, you should always research research research!
 
Horsepoop. Ive learned much more about so many more topics in the last 5 years as I did in my entire life before then. Yes, you have to be careful about information be factual. Having more information about more things is always a good thing...
 
However I should also add that the internet has more wrong information and opinions than correct ones. As with books and libraries, you should always research research research!


I don't fully agree with this. The internet brings you many points of view, points of view other than your own or those you agree with are usually deemed "wrong". However, others may see that information as being right or correct.

With a book, you can take it or leave it, a book has an authors perspective and opinion and it may not be indeed factual or accurate. Basically the internet is a collection of books, so you don't look at a single viewpoint through a parascope.
 
I don't fully agree with this. The internet brings you many points of view, points of view other than your own or those you agree with are usually deemed "wrong". However, others may see that information as being right or correct.

With a book, you can take it or leave it, a book has an authors perspective and opinion and it may not be indeed factual or accurate. Basically the internet is a collection of books, so you don't look at a single viewpoint through a parascope.

You're wrong! I researched your opinion and Wikipedia says you're wrong! :D
 
I agree, infact I actually picked up on this problem a while ago. On the internet I would usually click and skim, and then when it was time for me to read a book, I was turning and skimming. I could no longer accurately read and recall books. Right now I am forming a habit of reading entire articles.

Even though there is a mass collection of knowledge here, some people can't wait to take the time to read what the have, and not skip to the next post.
 
"i'm posting this after just reading the headline of the thread because i don't want to waste time reading everything that people posted."

is it something like that?
 
Internet in making kid ins school ( i have a younger brother ans sister) stop reading science books and just Google the answer.

but hey doesn't Wikipedia and Google have more info that a book?
 
I agree, infact I actually picked up on this problem a while ago. On the internet I would usually click and skim, and then when it was time for me to read a book, I was turning and skimming. I could no longer accurately read and recall books. Right now I am forming a habit of reading entire articles.

Even though there is a mass collection of knowledge here, some people can't wait to take the time to read what the have, and not skip to the next post.


i'm having the same issue. i noticed it about 4 months ago. unfortunately it started affecting my school work because i would no long do the proper researched i needed to actually solve a problem (which could be bad when you're a physics major). so i too have also made a conscious effort to start reading the full articles so i can start focusing my mind when i need to.
 
the problem is people dont know how to focus. learn to skim and glance when its ok, but learn to focus and read and comprehend more details when you need too.
 
Internet in making kid ins school ( i have a younger brother ans sister) stop reading science books and just Google the answer.

but hey doesn't Wikipedia and Google have more info that a book?

they might have more specific example but you're not getting the full structure and framework of the topics. you're not getting the proper theory behind it you are just skipping to the solution. i'll admit that i do it a lot but mainly when i'm pressed for time. i've seen a dramatic decrease in my test grades since i've started.
 
I tend to click-and-skim on the internet because I use the internet to have a bit of distraction and relax at work, when I take a break. I just don't have the time to read in-depth items and things.
 
I don't know if it's made us more stupid, but it's certainly made kids in school understand why they believe a certain thing or think a certain thing less.

It's made people less reflective and their knowledge is very surface skim.
 
when we give in to the natural impulses to click and skim, rather than to read and think,

That may be his natural impulse, but that doesn't mean it's the case with everyone.

As I think we've shown via the responses in this thread :cool:
 
I agree, we are just searching for the answer. but not finding out WHY and or reason behind it. One of my Uni teacher tells us to find the answer in a SPECIFIC book. if he sees something that not in the book you don't it graded. he is a firm believer that internet makes people stupid and lazy
 
It seems to me that the internet is actually allowing the way we think to evolve. I agree the internet can do that (what the article criticized it for) at first, but it's taught me to be more focused exactly because of that. Computer science is all about algorithums and the massive variety of information/interests that computers and the internet can cater to force people to prioritize and be aware of the algorithums they themselves use to organize approaching a series of goals.

The internet is exposing a weakness in how we gather information. An immaturity in our thinking. It highlights a habit we've already developed and exploits it. People who want to become more accute information gatherers/thinkers will do something about it while people who don't have the awareness to identify skimming as a problem that demands enough focus to change it will simply become less focused.

What I thought was funny was how he says:

"But he says that Google is very much the dominant player, and it both governs and symbolizes the way information is structured. "

lolz. I mean, google is pretty bad ass, but the internet is still bad ass with or without google. Search engines are kind of irrelevant in the end. As long as the information exists, people will find it.

The article linked to is an article about an article. And the actual article is apparently much more focused on google.

But maybe I've already written too much and will just end up being skimmed. ;)
 
it's hard to disagree with that article when threads like this http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1316991 exist in mass quanities.......

anonanimity on the internet probably make us all look dumber than we are in real life. For example:

Poster 1 posts something with a semi descriptive title but the posted subject ends up not having anything to do with the title in the end.
Poster 25 with out reading anything but the title posts something totally inane that nothing to do with what Poster 1 wrote.
Posters 27, 30, 35 call Poster 25 a moron then the mudslinging and e-peen waving about who makes the most money, who has the fastest computer, who has what job, etc., etc. starts in full force.

What could have been a decent informative thread has degraded into crap.

Why, first because someone didn't take the time to read the whole thing and second because the internet makes us nameless and faceless entities.

Use of the internet doesn't make you stupid, that fact the anyone, anywhere, can post almost anything they want be it well though out and intelligent or be it complete useless drivel that makes us all dumber for having read it makes it just seem that way.
 
Internet folks are much more capable of a good argument than in real life. Sure, most of us searches for answers, however, searching is a good thing. It takes a piece of a brain to know something, but it takes more than that to know where to find something and back it up at the same time.

In some cases that's true, but I think political discussion has become much more partisan because of the internet. With anonymity on their side, most people just dive into name calling and refuse to acknowledge counterarguments, whereas people are much less confrontational in real life.
 
I have a hard time reading anything more than a couple dozen pages on my computer screen. I prefer a hardcopy for long texts. It may be because of my diminished vision, but there it is.
 
I start reading Wkipedia after I get home from work, next thing I know its 2AM and I've gone from seeing if Wikipedia actually has an article on the word "poop" to reading about nuclear physics.
 
I start reading Wkipedia after I get home from work, next thing I know its 2AM and I've gone from seeing if Wikipedia actually has an article on the word "poop" to reading about nuclear physics.


Same here.
 
I start reading Wkipedia after I get home from work, next thing I know its 2AM and I've gone from seeing if Wikipedia actually has an article on the word "poop" to reading about nuclear physics.

i'm a slave to the wiki-effect as well. unfortunately it happens to me AT work... shhhh
 
Bullshit. I have learned more from the internet than I ever learned from any teacher in any school and that includes college.
A list of the things I can think of right now.
How to make my own CNC router.
How to make my own projector.
How to make a power producing windmill.
How to paint my car for $50.
How to rebuild my engine.
How to build a thermal control for a TEC...still in progress
I could go on. The shear amount of information available makes me quiver.
 
I read the Atlantic Monthly article. The headline of the article (and the magazine cover) was something along the lines of "Is Google Making Us Stoopid?"

The meat of the article suggests that people are becoming more adjusted to skipping from topic to topic and thus are unable to focus on a single topic for any length of time.

I agree a little because I see it in people (and video games). Plus I've followed that practice and learned a little about a lot of different things.

OTOH I disagree, and last night I sat down and read a book from cover to cover. I can also focus on a single thing and I think a lot of people at the [H] can, too, whether it's a video game, debating a topic or practicing one of the hobbies this board covers. However, I don't think the [H] is necessarily representative of the population in general, and to speak for myself I've always been able to focus on a single topic for a long period of time.

Mark Warner said:
I prefer a hardcopy for long texts.

Same here. I look at a computer all day but for serious reading I need paper.
 
I've had more intelligent debates on this forum in the past week than I have had the past several months anywhere else. Most of my friends are more concerned with what beer tastes better... I don't have conversations with them about the pros and cons of nuclear, wind and geothermal power.
 
Who is this guy? A psychologist? A research professor?

Oh, you say he's a business major with a master's in english literature?

I thought he might be someone that mattered, or knew what they were talking about.
 
Who is this guy? A psychologist? A research professor?

Oh, you say he's a business major with a master's in english literature?

I thought he might be someone that mattered, or knew what they were talking about.

And who are you? Do you matter?

I highly recommend Neil Postman's book "Amusing Ourselves to Death". It was written in the 80's in response to the onslaught of TV media (cable, etc) but is relevant to this discussion. He is Professor of Communications at NYU, so he is generally acknowledged to "be someone". Chapter 2- "Media as Epistemology" is excellent.
 
Back
Top