Zuckerberg: The iPad is a Computer

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The iPad is not mobile, it’s a computer. Well, according to Mark Zuckerberg anyway.

The iPad's not mobile. It's a computer. I don't want to be rude to Apple -- we all love Apple products -- but this is a mobile event and we want to stay focused on that. The iPad isn't mobile in the same way.
 
lol, next up we'll have Apple's response of "anything less than 10 inches is useless."
 
I think Zuck is just mad that he can't seem to find pants with large enough pockets to fit an iPad. Jobs should be taking notes and going into clothing design too.
 
if you browse the web on an iPad, does it redirect you to mobile sites? Like m.cnn.com or mobile.facebook.com? If so, it falls under the mobile category since it acts like one.

I'm willing to concede it may fall under netbook category, however. Apple would need to remove the mobile site redirects.
 
The iPad is a computer... may not be a desktop but it is still a computer. Laptop without a keyboard and no flip up screen.

I've seen tablet computers since the days of the Star Trek... it's taken 50 years for it to become chic thanks to Apple.
 
This is just shoddy journalism taking a statement and using it out of context. They were discussing building a platform for mobile phones. The iPad is NOT a mobile phone. Just like a laptop is not a mobile phone, but it is still mobile.
 
iPad isn't a computer because it lacks 4 rubber feet. You carry it around - thus mobile.

Do you carry your PC (a.k.a. computer) around like it's mobile?

It's simple common sense, isn't it?

Case closed.
 
I think the term "computer" is being misunderstood by some here including Mr. Zuckerberg himself.
 
iPad isn't a computer because it lacks 4 rubber feet. You carry it around - thus mobile.

Do you carry your PC (a.k.a. computer) around like it's mobile?

It's simple common sense, isn't it?

Case closed.

:rolleyes:

Yay semantics.

I understand what the Zuck is trying to say, read it in context and it's fairly obvious.
 
Wait but if you compare even the simplest of mobiles they're also computers too. I mean, I have no doubt that the ARM powered or another modern mobile chipset to perform slower than an 8086.

What's the big deal?
 
Sorry should read: "I have doubts that the ARM powered or another modern mobile chipset will perform slower than an 8086."
 
Do you carry your PC (a.k.a. computer) around like it's mobile?

Actually I do. My W100 will fit in my pocket and easily fits in my wife's pocketbook and I thumb type on it much like a phone. The W100 for it's faults is the most mobile desktop OS based computer I've ever used, including the iPad.

With 4G in a good area it loads web pages faster than a lot of peoples desktops.
 
Actually I do. My W100 will fit in my pocket and easily fits in my wife's pocketbook and I thumb type on it much like a phone. The W100 for it's faults is the most mobile desktop OS based computer I've ever used, including the iPad.

With 4G in a good area it loads web pages faster than a lot of peoples desktops.

how responsive is the typing? Could I take notes in class with it?
 
After having had to use an iPad for a day I'd have to say it is mobile in the same way a netbook is mobile. It isn't going into your pocket the way a phone is.

It's not even as mobile as a netbook in the sense the it is much more fragile than a netbook. It would be a pain in the ass to carry around all day.
 
After having had to use an iPad for a day I'd have to say it is mobile in the same way a netbook is mobile. It isn't going into your pocket the way a phone is.

It's not even as mobile as a netbook in the sense the it is much more fragile than a netbook. It would be a pain in the ass to carry around all day.

http://www.hypebeast.com/image/2010/04/temple-bags-ipad-case-1.jpg

There's tons of padded cases you can purchase for them to protect it and the screen just like closing netbooks and laptops.
 
It's a mobile device, and saying it's not is just plain stupid, but i guess it depends on how you define what a computer is. Mobile devices are implementing more and more PC like functions as we speak, but you can't just blatantly say ''it's not a mobile device'', because it is, anyone who's alive and breaths air should understand why that is..

Just another reason to hate Zuckerberg..
 
Not a fan of Zuckerberg, but I agree with his statement.

The ipad is not mobile in the sense that it's not a cell phone, and it doesn't meet the resolution standards for mobile devices (aka cell phones[or smartphones as the case may be]).

Laptops and and tablets are not mobile devices either, so why should the ipad be too?
 
Not a fan of Zuckerberg, but I agree with his statement.

The ipad is not mobile in the sense that it's not a cell phone, and it doesn't meet the resolution standards for mobile devices (aka cell phones[or smartphones as the case may be]).

Laptops and and tablets are not mobile devices either, so why should the ipad be too?

Ya i think it depends on the aspect of it, in the realms of mobile phone devices that is correct, but is that what he's exactly talking about?, The IPad is a mobile device in the sense of portability and the features implemented into iOS that make is useful for an outdoor setting.
 
ipad = old = keyboard-less touch screen tablet/laptop (but back then it was called tablet PC and doctors have used them for at least 5 years before the ipad came out)

Apple just used their mass marketing as always and the stupid people think its something new when really its an old, niche thing that has just been updated with new technology and marketed to be trendy.
 
It's a mobile device, and saying it's not is just plain stupid, but i guess it depends on how you define what a computer is. Mobile devices are implementing more and more PC like functions as we speak, but you can't just blatantly say ''it's not a mobile device'', because it is, anyone who's alive and breaths air should understand why that is..

Just another reason to hate Zuckerberg..

The problem is that even PCs are mobile devices too, some even more mobile than the iPad. The lines are just blured. If you mean mobile phone just say mobile phone.
 
Ya i think it depends on the aspect of it, in the realms of mobile phone devices that is correct, but is that what he's exactly talking about?, The IPad is a mobile device in the sense of portability and the features implemented into iOS that make is useful for an outdoor setting.

The ipad, in my opinion, is a mobile device in definition, but not in the context that the title is used in.

if the ipad is to be considered a mobile device in the same way that smartphones are, then the tablets, laptops, etc should be given that title too.
 
To Zuckerberg -

Who the fuck are you? Make another myspace. And no, not everyone likes crApple things, shows how "in touch" you are doesn't it.

- Princess Death

p.s. give back peoples privacys before they burn you. Plus the ipad is a POS that you need needle fingers for as it's not sensitive enough.




someone find their email!
 
Since it's most likely the case, he probably made the statement in light of most iPads being sold in the WiFi-only flavor.
 
I've seen tablet computers since the days of the Star Trek... it's taken 50 years for it to become chic thanks to Apple.

The iPad *looks like* a Star Trek tablet computer. It doesn't operate the same at all, and its computational power is nowhere near as potent. You may think it is "chic" but that is all it is...a "Star Trek tablet" the iPad is not...;) (Why is it with Apple devotees, beauty is always only skin deep?)
 
a "computer" what is it anyways? Just because it's not huge doesn't mean it cant be a computer.

in dictionary.com it stated that a computer is:
Also called processor. an electronic device designed to accept data, perform prescribed mathematical and logical operations at high speed, and display the results of these operations. Compare analog computer, digital computer.

So technically, yes ipad is a computer, TI 89 is a computer, an xbox is a computer.

An iPad may be a computer but it is not a desktop. People may have fused the meaning of computer and desktop to mean the same thing.
 
well, mobile is a spectrum, right? blackberrys dont exactly fit very well in my jeans either.
 
Well, I guess you could call it a netbook without a keyboard, in which case it is a computer.

I tend to view it more as an overgrown mutant iPod.
 
Back
Top