You Can’t Multitask

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
You can’t multitask. Seriously, this guy says so. Not very scientific but mildly entertaining.

I can only think about one thing at a time. Any girl reading this just going to roll her eyes and think, “Of course. You’re a guy!”. But it’s not just true for me, it’s true for everyone. It’s true for you. And not in that way.
 
If you can't multi task in a way, you don't belong in IT.

Now multi tasking on complex issues is a bit harder lol
 
You can view a lot of things, but if you think about it, nobody can do more than 1 thing at a time, even if by a millisecond. I have 4 monitors at work, each with a task, but I can only look and work in one of the applications at a time. In a way, he is completely right, we aren't multitasking, we are doing multiple tasks. Think about that one! :D
 
He is correct.

Blue
Yellow
Red

At first, reading either the word or the color of the word is hard. Especially if asked to read/speak quickly. Use this analogy for working on two projects at the same time. Given enough practice and determination it is possible to be proficient but this guy is still correct. One task at a time, regardless of how fast we can switch between.

I hope that made sense.
 
Unless you train your brain enough. Those color/word tests don't even trick me anymore. Anyone can multi task if you work at something long enough because then it becomes natural. A Chef has to do alot of multi tasking, they have to maintain multiple orders at once, constantly having to make sure the food is prepared to specifications.
 
Multitasking is just micromanagement.. Ability to handle several tasks small bits at a time..

This guys explanation is just taking the word "multitasking" and trying to define it as something that its not.. Even at the very beginning he basically states that its not multitasking if its automatic, like were cheating at life if we thoroughly learned something..
 
All I know is that if I'm driving and my passenger is talking I have no Idea what they're talking about. I'm driving.
 
What he is saying is scientifically correct, he is just not expressing it very well.

Study upon study have shown that people perform better if they focus on one task at a time rather than keep switching back and forth between them. These same studies have show that there is no difference between groups of people who think they are good at it, and those that don't.

Quite simply, the human brain is unable to multitask. We fake it by time sharing, (sortof like Windows 3.11 and old versions of MacOS 9 used to multitask) but the results are always worse than if we focus on one task at a time.

This goes for ALL people, no exceptions.
 
Steve, a Blog? Really? I *peeeh!* at your blog. :p PEEEH

Anyway I'm not impressed. I verbally explained to someone how to build a multipoint circuit this morning while watching a movie one screen and playing a game on another. and I completely his task in 10 seconds, good enough for me.
 
When I first read this, I read it as "You Can't Mutalisk". Perhaps it's time to take a break from SC2...
 
moron.
efficient multitasking is more about finding empty gaps in one task and switching to the other. so yeah, you can't multitask sawing a piece of wood + drilling some holes, but you can multitask them if you have a helper bringing the wood.
 
Well, he's absolutely correct on most parts. The human brain can only do so much at once. But how do you define multitasking? Regardless of means, does not suceeding at multiple tasks in seemingly unison make for multitasking? Most people can do 2 tasks at once (talking to the wife while listening to the game?), we might have to switch back and forth to do them, but they can get done. I think he is pigeon holing the term a little too much.
 
Man, this guy doesn't know anything. I can multitask. I can take a piss and pick my nose at the same time.
 
Unless you train your brain enough. Those color/word tests don't even trick me anymore. Anyone can multi task if you work at something long enough because then it becomes natural. A Chef has to do alot of multi tasking, they have to maintain multiple orders at once, constantly having to make sure the food is prepared to specifications.

I think your missing the point he was making. And an individual's definition/perception of multitasking is going to affect how you react to the article in question.
The author of said article has a very narrow, but not completely off-base, view. You can only process one task at a time, one thought at a time.
However, how quickly you are able to do so and move on to the next, in particular moving on to unrelated task/thought determines your ability to "multitask".
 
Unless you train your brain enough. Those color/word tests don't even trick me anymore. Anyone can multi task if you work at something long enough because then it becomes natural. A Chef has to do alot of multi tasking, they have to maintain multiple orders at once, constantly having to make sure the food is prepared to specifications.

the first time I saw that it messed me up as well. but now nothing. but it is ture that the human mind can not hold much in memory, three items only. its hard to prove to people at first but irrefutable once you do.
 
Hey I can play the piano with one hand while typing with the other. Surely thats multitasking and shows that he's talking shit. I can also talk and walk at eh same time. And read and walk, and chew gum and walk. Even chew gum walk AND talk.
 
Apparently you can walk and chew gum at the same time:

Brain Res. 2009 Aug 4;1283:41-9. Epub 2009 Jun 6.

Dual-tasking: Is manual tapping independent of concurrently executed saccades?
Sharikadze M, Cong DK, Staude G, Deubel H, Wolf W.

Institute of Communication Engineering, University of Federal Armed Forces, Werner-Heisenberg-Weg 39, Neubiberg 85579, Germany. meg.sharikadze@unibw.de

Abstract
Maintaining both spatial and temporal accuracy of concurrent motor actions is a challenging behavioral requirement in multi-tasking, where possible resource bottlenecks may become apparent when these units are shared between tasks. This study addresses the question of whether periodic self-paced finger movements (tapping) compulsorily interact with concurrently executed saccades, because they share some common neural control pathways. We employed a dual-task paradigm which was previously used to demonstrate strong interference between independent but concurrently conducted bimanual tapping tasks (Wachter, C., Cong, D.K., Staude, G., Wolf, W., 2008. Coordination of a discrete response with periodic finger tapping, additional experimental aspects for a subtle mechanism. J. Motor Behav. 40, 417-432). Instead of the discrete left hand response, the 13 participants now executed a single saccadic eye movement to a fixed visual target in parallel to continuous periodic tapping of the dominant hand. We expected these reactive saccades to act as a strong perturbation event to the continuous tapping, but the experimental data did not reveal a considerable interference in this specific oculo-manual dual-task experiment.

PMID: 19501065 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
 
All I know is that if I'm driving and my passenger is talking I have no Idea what they're talking about. I'm driving.
Odds are your passengers is most often female and you wouldn't hear them if you were watching TV or gaming either ;)

I'm the same way.
 
I wonder how long it takes him to type? All those examples he gives I can do at the same time...
 
Hey I can play the piano with one hand while typing with the other. Surely thats multitasking and shows that he's talking shit. I can also talk and walk at eh same time. And read and walk, and chew gum and walk. Even chew gum walk AND talk.


You can do those things at the same time because one of them is automatic and thus... you are not thinking about... thus not multitasking.

I agree that he did not state things in a manner that would be easiest for most people to understand (depending on their own view of multitasking) but he did state things correctly and in line with more scientific reasoning at this time.

Here is some more fun reading on the topic
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8219212.stm
http://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/episode.cfm?id=the-myth-of-multitasking-09-07-15

The main thing is we are not "multitasking" as in actually thinking of 2+ things at once, but getting better at task switching (switching from one train of thought to another) better as we train one thing to become more automatic (driving and talking, walking and chewing gum, typing and talking etc..)

Take it for what it's worth

D.
 
What does the guy consider multi tasking? You already have to breath, blink, walk, speak...ETC

All the while, either directly doing another task that is not related to motor function, or indirectly using your brain mass to think about said ancillary task.

No computer could even come close to amount of calculation your brain is doing while navigating and interpreting your environment and at the same time allowing you to still think about what you want for lunch and when is that next brief due. ;)

Yet at the same time, your can automatically switch focus from one or more tasks and concentrate nearly 100% on an issue that may require all of your attention. Like when you pay a video game or do math.

That sounds like multitasking to me. Multitasking with a little turbo boost thrown in for the times when it gets edgy.;)
 
LOL^^^ doesn't help you spell any better though.

"breathe"
"play"

Damn it. Spy sappin my edit button.
 
Still not convinced? Then try this experiment: Think about the taste of chocolate (that glorious silky rush of sweet earthy flavor) at the exact same time as you add 47 and 56.
Ok, did it.
Really try.
I really did.
At the same time.
Yup.
If it makes your brain fuzzy in the way your mouth feels after you’ve had an unripe banana,
It didn't.
you’re in good company:
Apparently I'm not.
it’s impossible.
Nope.
You can switch back and forth really quickly
Ok.
but you can’t actually think about both things at the same time.
I did.
 
The author should have just said you can only think of one thing at a time. That is true for everyone, and I really think hits closer to the crux of his argument then compounding the word multitask into the mix.

I understand why he says that and what he's trying to prove, but it seems a few people miss it because of his poor choice of words.
 
so he's saying you have to be 'thinking' of more than one thing at a time to multi-task? so that means teaching yourself to do several things at once doesn't count? sounds like somebody's a lil' butt-hurt because they got into an argument with a guy at work that could do more than just their job and do it better than he could.

I'll have to agree with other posters that this guy's definition of multi-tasking is out of place, I mean since when do you have to be specifically thinking of the task at hand in order for it to be considered getting done?
 
Complex thoughts are more difficult to FOCUS on sure, but it's doable. Simpler ideas, like say the color and taste of an orange, while spinning a triangle in various colors and sizes in your mind, not difficult, just not something people actually need to focus on for any good reason, so the skill for more complex ideas is undeveloped. Why waste time doing that sort of thing when there's no real benefit to it outside of zen-bullshit class?
 
The human brain is extremely poor at multi-tasking. There are countless articles on the subject, one can view, with a quick search.
 
Man, this guy doesn't know anything. I can multitask. I can take a piss and pick my nose at the same time.

This is indeed two tasks at once... but a better one would be writing and picking your nose, since pissing doesn't take any real effort on your part and can be considered an automated action... if you don't... then everyone multitasks with breathing.. or else we'd all be dead.
 
I am thinking that a lot of people here didn't bother to read or even skim the posting due to their comments. He said that you can do stuff like drive a car and talk on the the phone. or think and type... but only because one of those is automatic for you. so walking, chewing gum, while listening to music would not fall into his category of multitasking. As a few pointed out, the problem is his definition of multitasking.

He is talking about multiple task that require actual thought at once like trying to figure out the sq root of 101282, while multiplying 287 and 94, while figuring out pi to the 20 place all in your head at the exact same moment.
 
Alot of people don't know the semantics behind the word mutlitasking used in this article. What alot of you are describing is usually one thinking job then a job that is an acquired skill to the you. Studies show humans are poor at mutlitasking.

Try this Read 2 books, read one word from book a then read 1 word from book b. See how long it takes you to do that then a day later read book a then book b and compare how long that took and how much easier it was for you to understand the books.
 
I cannot believe how many people here cannot even understand how their own mind works. I've been single my whole life, so I have had way too much time to think about this. And I completely agree with that guy.

Your mind has several "subprocessors" that handle many tasks concurrently, like breathing for example. Walking and chewing gun are learned actions that the subprocessors take over.

I believe most here never read half of that article. Just because you think you are thinking about chocolate at the same time as performing addition does not make it so. Although that is a bad example, your mind plays tricks on you to make you think that some things are true when they're not.

He was saying that you can only multitask simple tasks that have been "programed" into a "subprocessor" of sorts. Walking is NOT automatic for a one year old, you had to learn it sometime. Driving may seem automatic, until it rains at night and a cars pulls out in front of you, but there is a pedestrian beside you wearing black. You cannot predict everything that will happen while driving. When something out of the ordinary happens, the subprocessors hand the job back to your conscious mind.

All of you who think you can multitask have simple lives. My job involves figuring things out. Chef's do the same thing all day, every day. Very little changes. I have new problems all day, every day. Nothing can be automatic for me.

Talking on the cell phone while driving is a complicated argument. The act itself is easy, but the conversation may not be simple. Both driving and conversation occasionally requires your focused attention. Driving safely requires that you are ALWAYS paying attention. Split seconds matter. Did you see the pedestrian in black? Were you paying attention? What about that puddle you just hit? Are you now hydro-planing? Have you slow down yet? Or are you chatting it up with Becky about her computer problem? If you were paying attention you would have slowed down a long time ago.

I once was able to follow two conversations at once. I realized that this was possible because I was predicting what was being said by each of the others. I was able to reconstruct what was said after I switched back from the other person. I could actually hear both at once, but only comprehend one at a time. I still was able to comprehend more than half of each conversation, because I remembered a mumble that I could reconstruct into a word that fit what I predicted was being asked of me. These were both common requests at work.

Again, common = learned = programmed = subprocessed(mostly) = multitasking(mind-tricked).
 
All I know is that guys are exceptionally poor at noticing when someone is talking to them while they're busy doing something else. I practically have to start dancing in front of my housemate if I want to get his attention :p
 
Back
Top