Windows Vista SP2 Beta Next Week

All they've done is help the 10% and SCREW the 90% if they only ad blu-ray recording and not blue ray decoding or at least playback in media center with an installed decoder.

Amen to that! I'm dying for native blu-ray playback in vmc - why the hell is it so hard for them to implement? If it's about licensing issues, just implement playback by installing a damn decoder! :mad:
 
More than likely for the same reason that DVD playback wasn't originally implemented.

1)The decoder was expensive (this being a relative term, mainly in a buisness sense)
2)They are afraid of anti-trust allegations. You would be suprised at how often this enters into their thinking in certain divisions (I have a close friend in the core division and he says it enters on a weekly to daily basis).
 
Grr... I just read my post and realized how harsh I came off. I wanted to edit but couldn't. Oh well. Hopefully you take my post with a grain of salt and realize while I meant what I said, I didn't mean it so harsh.

No worries! Most folks here have thick skin (and skulls) so don't worry about it. Much of what goes on here is just tech smack anyhow. :cool:
 
Windows Vista search still isn't nearly good enough though. I'd like to be able to add tags and other search metadata to all kinds of files (not just documents and photos). I also wish searching through the index was faster...it takes a very long time (several seconds) if you have more than 200,000 or 300,000 files indexed. As someone mentioned earlier, it also needs to properly index network locations. I do believe Vista will use the index of another machine running Vista though, so if you REALLY want to be fast, you could run Vista on your server (argh). It would be nice if indexing/lookup became a standardized interface between computers so that Apple/Microsoft/Linux/whoever machines can all share index information...I have a home network with half a dozen computers (and occasionally more, i have several old computers sitting around collecting dust) and I'd like to be able to instantly search for files across my whole network.

I have well over 650,000 files indexed across four hard drives and searching is still almost instantaneous for me. The stuff I access the most is instant, and the stuff I have forgotten about, but sometimes suddenly need out of the blue follows in mere seconds. Definitely on par with spotlight in my Mac, and requires no 3rd party Googleware.
 
2)They are afraid of anti-trust allegations. You would be suprised at how often this enters into their thinking in certain divisions (I have a close friend in the core division and he says it enters on a weekly to daily basis).

Yeah i agree; it would be similar to the big fuss over locking out the kernel from anti virus vendors and Realplayer crying about media player in Europe.
 
as long as they fix Folder views always changing and the other one that pisses me off, when Vista decidesyour network is local access!! only, randomly, while in the middle of doing something or after a reboot!
 
as long as they fix Folder views always changing and the other one that pisses me off, when Vista decidesyour network is local access!! only, randomly, while in the middle of doing something or after a reboot!

Yeah that would be really nice.

You know, it would be ok if they didn't necessarily include a decoder, for anti-trust reasons, in Vista, but they should at least integrate playback ability into media center so that it can use whatever decoder you install, like PowerDVD for example. Windows Media Player was that way back in the day. In early XP you couldn't play DVD's with just windows media player, but once you installed a decoder, you were good to go. How hard would it be with MS's resources to do the same thing with media center? We would still have to buy something 3rd party, not from MS, so no anti-trust issue there. I just hate having to have two separate apps for one purpose: watching movies.
 
as long as they fix Folder views always changing and the other one that pisses me off, when Vista decidesyour network is local access!! only, randomly, while in the middle of doing something or after a reboot!

Folder views can actually be fixed. It's a registry hack that disables Vista trying to "auto-detect" the folder content type and adjust view accordingly. I applied it and it's great - Google for it. Nothing is more obnoxious than Vista switching the view type of your root C: drive because it found a .jpg file in a subfolder. :rolleyes:
 
Folder views can actually be fixed. It's a registry hack that disables Vista trying to "auto-detect" the folder content type and adjust view accordingly. I applied it and it's great - Google for it. Nothing is more obnoxious than Vista switching the view type of your root C: drive because it found a .jpg file in a subfolder. :rolleyes:

Hmmm ... I really hope they fix this too. I shouldn't have to hack the registry so that my computer will work properly ... silly microsoft.
 
I don't know, sometimes I get annoyed having to edit the registry but I'd rather have cleaner GUI option dialogs than have them cluttered with every option every geek around the world ever wants to change.

On OS X you sometimes have to issue defaults commands (translucent dock icons for hidden applications), on other *nix systems you sometimes edit text config files. Sometimes people create GUIs to manage these less accessible settings (TweakUI, Secrets) and sometimes they don't. Mistakes are made as to which options to include in default GUIs and which to leave out but I'm glad they don't just dump everything on us.
 
No, I think thats more back to the traditional period. NT 4 had 6 service packs over 6ish years. W2K had 4 SP over four years. XP SP2 was so big they waited a lot longer for SP3.

Personally, I love annual service packs. It keeps me from needing to download 150 hot fixes after installing the last one. Before SP2 came out for XP, the initial patch always took forever.
 
wow, 2 service packs in a year... that must be some sort of record?
:rolleyes:

Not at all. In the early days service packs were scheduled to be quarterly. Of course they didn't always hit that target, but i was shocked when SP2 for XP took 2 years. That was a record. We won't even mention SP3. I doubt there was a 2 year gap before that. In the old days they tried to have a new OS faster than that. And they usually did.
 
2 comments here...

1. Will Vista stop forgeting my folder settings ..

2. There is zero performance loss by having Indexing on. WHO CARES that your computer is DOING SOMETHING while at idle? As long as it's not indexing/building database while your doing something important, who cares? Stop the whining people. It's just like people who bitch about Superfetch. They are trying to make your computer do more at idle to make your time while your using it better. Why is it a epic failure that your CPU doesn't sit at 0% utilization while your away from your pc?
 
The Vista bashing really has gotten so out of hand... Half the time the people bashing it the most never even used it or know why they're bashing it.

Both Apple and MS's commercials are just making it even worse. The weak-satire Apple commercials stopped naming reasons why Vista sucks or OS X is better about five rounds ago, now it's just the same stereotypical nonsense over and over, who are they trying to go after with that? People who already own Macs? Half the time, the only other ones who'll get the ads are power users who know better what they need, one way or the other. Then there's MS trying to repair their broken image (w/o really speaking about Vista) w/the 'I'm PC' campaign or trying to fool people (never wise) with the whole Mojave shtick; way too late for either.

Vista really isn't a hugely compelling upgrade, no, 'specially if you're using 2GB of memory or less... DX10 games haven't been anything to write home about (since the DX9 path can usually provide very similar results after a few tweaks)... And no one feature of the OS by itself will really lure anyone to upgrade on a whim, but at this point it's perfectly usable and better than XP in a number of ways. The way it handles memory, security, etc.

/rant off
 
Nothing special so far, playing around with it a bit, let you all know how it is. Looking forward to the Bluetooth 2.1 though.

VistaSP2.jpg
 
Maybe just me, but Service Pack 2 has come fast!

wow, 2 service packs in a year... that must be some sort of record?
:rolleyes:

Let's see here:

OSX Leopard came out October 26th, 2007 - one year ago today basically (not counting the fact that today is a Sunday and last year it was a Monday). Since then it's had 6 major updates to improve functionality and improve performance which still sucks but they won't fix all that till... <drumroll please>

OSX 10.6 Snow Leopard sometime in 2009.

As far as Ubuntu is concerned (not to leave Linux unscathed), if you do a clean installation of Ubuntu 7.10 (October 2007 release) and when that's done and you do a full update you'll end up getting several hundred updates, patches, bug fixes, etc that total nearly a gig of downloads (I just did it earlier in a VM to verify this) and would qualify as at least 4 service pack-level Windows Updates...

So, take your service pack frequency arguments and stuff 'em, bub. ;)
 
Funny how the Vista bashers claim they don't spread FUD about Vista because they do have experiences with it.. yet SP2 isn't even here yet and hey lookie what the Vista bashers are already doing!
 
Stop the whining people. It's just like people who bitch about Superfetch. They are trying to make your computer do more at idle to make your time while your using it better. Why is it a epic failure that your CPU doesn't sit at 0% utilization while your away from your pc?

I turned off superfetch for user files because when I booted I would start up the performance monitor and see which files superfetch was caching, and it would cache things like the huge 1080p episode of Heroes I recently watched. A useless use of my hardware is worse than it sitting idle, especially when I have just booted and likely want to do something with my system.

After seeing that fiasco I was skeptical of the whole feature so I did some benchmarks and superfetch did nothing to speed up my computer booting. I never whined about it till now, and I'm sorry that I couldn't hold it in, but you, bigdogchris, need to stop and think that there may be reasons why people do the things they do. (Like buying quad-core CPUs ... heh, I should probably leave that one alone ;))
 
Most power users rarely power off their desktop systems... Superfetch might be better tuned under those conditions, just a thought.
 
Funny, I wondered if that's why superfetch sucked for me (my computers are always on). I thought MS had the idea that "professional" users would arrive at the office, switch on the computer, and want whatever they previously worked on available right away.

Regardless, Windows has a disk cache like every other OS and if you just use your computer then the cache is filled eventually anyway, in good old fashioned LRU style (I would think anyway). No need to have Windows guess wtf you might use, only to have it invalidated and replaced with what you're actually doing.
 
If your computers are always on why does it inconvenience you that Superfetch isn't instantly aware of what you use/need most the second you walk into the office in the morning? Are you saying it was always moving stuff to the cache that made no sense all throughout the day? Because that's another situation entirely than what you've painted... The general idea is to avoid the disk cache either way, it's slow, and has never been of much use other than as a safety net for when you run out of actual RAM.
 
I turned off superfetch for user files because when I booted I would start up the performance monitor and see which files superfetch was caching, and it would cache things like the huge 1080p episode of Heroes I recently watched. A useless use of my hardware is worse than it sitting idle, especially when I have just booted and likely want to do something with my system.

After seeing that fiasco I was skeptical of the whole feature so I did some benchmarks and superfetch did nothing to speed up my computer booting. I never whined about it till now, and I'm sorry that I couldn't hold it in, but you, bigdogchris, need to stop and think that there may be reasons why people do the things they do. (Like buying quad-core CPUs ... heh, I should probably leave that one alone ;))

Sorry your superfetch is broken. Mine works fine, and I see a noticeable benefit in loading my favorite apps/games.
 
It sounds like someone is a spoiled child who grew up in the GUI era.

Back in the early days, everything was character based. Everything was FAST. Windows Vista brings a bit of that back. My hands never have to leave the keyboard - I can do everything at lighting fast typing speeds like I used to. E.g.: to launch calculator, I go Win, C-A-L-C-Enter and boom! I'm in there. What do you have to do? You either have to use the Win key and up/down arrows, or your hands have to leave the keyboard and get the mouse. Not cool.

no actually, i am not, quite the opposite, i am 32, grew up with PC's starting from a 4.7Mhz IBM XT Clone, monochrome monitor, DOS 3.1 (if i remember correctly).....learning command lines to do the simplest things...it sucked

and honestly, i dont miss any of it, i would much rather have a double click style experience, i love Vista, especially 64bit Ult.

several people have now given examples of how search can be useful to some people, and i agree, i just don't know anyone who has a gazillion files on terabytes of hard drive space, it just never occurred to me outside of servers that any individual would have any reason to have such a huge database and needed to search it often enough to make the new search indexing tools actually useful.....but i see there are some....i just dont know anyone, which is why i said what i said
 
My problem is that I store all my data on a network share.I can add a network share to the index. So searching a network share is really really slow. How stupid is this. 95% of business shore info on network shares

How stupid are you for not using the business version of the search tool in a business environment.

They have search server express 2008 (free) for businesses to use for those that don't want to buy Search Server. The desktop search tool is meant for your desktop. The enterprise search software is meant for businesses with files out on servers.
 
Also for those talking about how quickly the service pack it coming out, remember this is the BETA not the final version. I wouldn't expect to see the final version out till at least around March. You are going to have about a month or two for the close beta 1, then a month or two for the open beta 2 release.

SP 1 came out back in April. That would put them about a year apart. Which like people said is what they use to do for service packs.
 
How long was SP1 in beta? Seemed like forever, though it's probably the fact that there was a lot of talk about it before the beta even began... And the automatic rollout was pretty slow too. Didn't have a single issue installing it on any of the machines I've installed it on though, new or old (and I do mean old).
 
A new service pack per year sounds reasonable to me. And if that's the case, they are on track with the timing of the beta release of SP2.
 
How stupid are you for not using the business version of the search tool in a business environment.

They have search server express 2008 (free) for businesses to use for those that don't want to buy Search Server. The desktop search tool is meant for your desktop. The enterprise search software is meant for businesses with files out on servers.

you need sharepoint for this to work...
 
I hope SP2 will get the XP zealots to start about thinking of jumping onboard.
 
If your computers are always on why does it inconvenience you that Superfetch isn't instantly aware of what you use/need most the second you walk into the office in the morning?

That doesn't inconvenience me. Since my box is always on when I reboot it's often because I'm changing BIOS settings or something and want to test stability. When all I want to do is run cpu-z, linpack, everest, and whatever else, the last thing I want is for superfetch to start caching mp3s and videos.

Are you saying it was always moving stuff to the cache that made no sense all throughout the day?

Not throughout the day that I saw, just at boot. It's not a big deal at all I just noticed it wasn't doing useful (for me!) so I turned it off.

If I always did my programming in a VM or something and superfetch cached it that would probably be nice. It's good that they made it transparent but at the same time it would be nice for power users to tune it, e.g. "never cache this directory" and such.
 
There is no convention, its the same for some of the Apple and Linux folks, they have their excuses why they don't wanna switch. It took my friend well into SP2 to get Windows XP and that was because he got a new computer with XP on it. I personally know no one around here that's like me willing to jump head first into a new OS, they all just want what they know (ridiculous argument here) and what they know works (how do you know something doesn't work unless you try it). I just tried to buy a copy of Vista through my College and guess what, the guy managing the store did not want to touch Vista and advice me against getting it, because he has a relations, nephews, son who is a tech guru that thinks its crap, because he got a laptop with Vista pre-installed and its slow (as if XP would do any better). I swear, people like that should not be allowed anywhere near a college campus.
 
you need sharepoint for this to work...

The requirements list Windows SharePoint Services 3.0 as being needed.

http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/...B5-48FC-4CA2-B454-8DC2CAF93951&displaylang=en

I will admit that I have not installed the software yet (its a ways down on my list of things to test and deploy if they work out), however from what I could tell the express version should be able to be installed with all free software.

The point that I was trying to make is that Microsoft already thought about business's with shares and did not mean for a desktop search tool to be used for every possible instance of a windows install. They have other software in place for businesses to use. As is similar with a lot of their stuff. You have your everyday home user software, then you have your business software that is designed for what a network needs more than a single home computer.



How long was SP1 in beta? Seemed like forever, though it's probably the fact that there was a lot of talk about it before the beta even began... And the automatic rollout was pretty slow too. Didn't have a single issue installing it on any of the machines I've installed it on though, new or old (and I do mean old).

I do think it was about 5 or 6 months if not a little more. Vista SP1 and XP SP3 were both in beta by the end of 2007. That is what I was trying to point out above. If beta 1 is just now starting this week we won't see the final version for some time. Then after that you are going to have a month or two between download and installable version gets released and windows updates carries it as an update. This will give people a chance to download it and test it before they start deploying it to other machines, plus it gives them a chance for a slower rollout instead of giving it to the entire windows vista user base in one day.
 
There is no convention, its the same for some of the Apple and Linux folks, they have their excuses why they don't wanna switch. It took my friend well into SP2 to get Windows XP and that was because he got a new computer with XP on it. I personally know no one around here that's like me willing to jump head first into a new OS, they all just want what they know (ridiculous argument here) and what they know works (how do you know something doesn't work unless you try it). I just tried to buy a copy of Vista through my College and guess what, the guy managing the store did not want to touch Vista and advice me against getting it, because he has a relations, nephews, son who is a tech guru that thinks its crap, because he got a laptop with Vista pre-installed and its slow (as if XP would do any better). I swear, people like that should not be allowed anywhere near a college campus.

Those are the types of people that are this country's future leaders ... and seems like running it now.

And I'm not referring to the presidency. Anyone who thinks the presidency actually runs this country has been in la la land for decades.

/off topic part.

A local computer shop owner publicly said in an interview - and my stupid local news station actually broadcast it - that none of your old software would work in Vista. He threatened any new computer buyers and potential Vista upgraders that, and I quote, "You will have to spend $400 on new software including Microsoft Office just so it will work with Vista!" Office 2003 ran flawlessly on all three of my Vista machines, one of which was built on Vista right after it came out. I never had any Office '03 issues. Don't know about 2000 or older, though.
 
Vista's indexing has actually caused me to become extremely lazy and negligent in organzing my file system. My desktop is a mess. God knows how many "unsorted" folders I have in random locations. I rarely check where a video game or program installs anymore. I just use the search to find what I need.

I have also become extremely lazy in how many processes I have loaded or what my physical memory usage is at any given time. In XP, I had to keep my running processes under 30 at boot, with highly tweaked service settings, to keep my memory usage minimal. With Vista, I just don't care. After my PC is on for about a day, I'm at 40-60% usage in idle. After a week, I go up to 60-70% idle. But I still play Warhead, load Photoshop with huge image files, do whatever I have to do without a problem. My machine still flys.

Doing all of this... since November 2008 I have not had the need to reformat (did one before I have having issues with nVidia drivers). And, I really don't even slightly feel the need for one coming anytime soon.

Thank you Vista for having such a great feature. My file system is a mess because of it.
 
Vista's indexing has actually caused me to become extremely lazy and negligent in organzing my file system. My desktop is a mess. God knows how many "unsorted" folders I have in random locations. I rarely check where a video game or program installs anymore. I just use the search to find what I need.

I have also become extremely lazy in how many processes I have loaded or what my physical memory usage is at any given time. In XP, I had to keep my running processes under 30 at boot, with highly tweaked service settings, to keep my memory usage minimal. With Vista, I just don't care. After my PC is on for about a day, I'm at 40-60% usage in idle. After a week, I go up to 60-70% idle. But I still play Warhead, load Photoshop with huge image files, do whatever I have to do without a problem. My machine still flys.

Doing all of this... since November 2008 I have not had the need to reformat (did one before I have having issues with nVidia drivers). And, I really don't even slightly feel the need for one coming anytime soon.

Thank you Vista for having such a great feature. My file system is a mess because of it.

I guess a big thing with Vista are going to be programs to track HDD usage and the likes :D I personally just download everything into the downloads folder and then sort it out every few week. Vista has just taken so much of the headache out of maintenance. I would however keep a closer eye on where those files are going, otherwise we are going to have things like "there was this cool video file I wanted to show you, but I don't remember what it was called so I can't find it on the UBER 100TB HDD of mine".
 
Back
Top