Windows 10 Will Be An Automatic Recommended Update

making applocker enterprise only is a sign of how dumb microsoft can be, that thing should be on every edition and actually used by default the same way google have started using selinux on android.

Or maybe microsoft like having a reputation of building insecure operating systems.

Unless something has changed, I really can't imagine many home users using applocker. That sounds like an enterprise feature if ever their was one.
 
not really, sure in its policy editor form it will confuse user's but the core feature is not an enterprise only thing, applocker is capable of making desktop many time smore secure and is probably even better than many anti virus software for that job.

All they need to do is develop some default templates for it and a friendly front end, either that or do the same for SRP.

Selinux is way more complicated than applocker yet its been rolled out now on comsumer phones.
 
Just made a cool buck fixing a couple of high school kids computers over this. Just like the ps3 reboot loop.
 
Just keeps getting better and better:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonk...oft-confirms-unstoppable-windows-10-tracking/
Speaking to PC World, Microsoft Corporate Vice President Joe Belfiore explained that Windows 10 is constantly tracking how it operates and how you are using it and sending that information back to Microsoft by default. More importantly he also confirmed that, despite offering some options to turn elements of tracking off, core data collection simply cannot be stopped

Why anyone wants to use this OS is beyond me.
 
to the 3 above, as far as I have heard at this point NOTHING we the users can do will turn it off, no firewall etc will make it do so, will always be bits going out, who knows what they collect except for themselves and who they sell it to or give access to this info, be awesome if they did a DLC style for windows in my mind to get all the performance benefits and so forth without having to more or less completely mess the core OS up, nothing wrong with win 7 IMO whereas there are many downfalls with win 8/8.1 and 10 least of which is the removal of many thing, forced data tracking etc.

Performance and some fancier DX settings appears to be all the "major" benefits, in other words to my knowledge, stuff they could have very well "tweaked" for win7 as well, but they would rather make $100-$500 or whatever x1000bajillion new copies every 4-7 years instead.

Security is all fine and dandy however being FORCED updates for both security AND optional is just retarded, in many folks cases they would simply not understand how to "fix" their system if it does "bork" they really really should have left well enough alone and just focused on the security side of things and left everything 3rd party for the most part, well have left it the hell alone, they should not be messing with stuff that really does not affect them whatsoever.

All in the name of $$$$ who cares who they fk over, as per usual.
 
to the 3 above, as far as I have heard at this point NOTHING we the users can do will turn it off, no firewall etc will make it do so, will always be bits going out,

I don't see how this can be the case, unless they are actually actively tryign to circumvent firewall blockage by randomly changing ports and hosts the data goes to. They could do this by using the same P2P network they use to distribute updates, to also harvest the data.

If you track what hosts it connects to (like bing.com, etc.) it shouldn't be too difficult to create firewall rules to block them, if they are actually pointing at a microsoft server.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041946332 said:
There's always snort + the creation of firewall rules.

Supposedly 10 connects back to Redmond via hardcoded IP's in the DLL files; I have no idea who found this out and how, but that's what I've read (re: using firewall rules to block). Supposedly with the DLL files this way, it bypasses firewall (or at least the built in Win firewall). People on the MDL forums have resorted to using PeerBlock and a custom blocklist to supposedly block this communication, but who knows how long those IP's or DNS names will remain active because obviously they [MS] can change up and people are back to square 1 again.

I want DX12 but not at these costs.
 
Just keeps getting better and better:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/gordonk...oft-confirms-unstoppable-windows-10-tracking/


Why anyone wants to use this OS is beyond me.

To their benefit, they are being fairly open about the on-going data collection stuff. It's sort of the same thing that Google does. They tell you that all your data cheezburgers are belong to them and that's it. Honestly, as much as I'm creeped out by Google, I'd almost rather use their stuff than Microsoft's things. It was only a couple of years ago that Microsoft was all like advertising that they didn't collect any data and now they've turned completely around and gotten super scary about mining for information without a lot of advertising revenue to justify it even.
 
Supposedly 10 connects back to Redmond via hardcoded IP's in the DLL files; I have no idea who found this out and how, but that's what I've read (re: using firewall rules to block). Supposedly with the DLL files this way, it bypasses firewall (or at least the built in Win firewall). People on the MDL forums have resorted to using PeerBlock and a custom blocklist to supposedly block this communication, but who knows how long those IP's or DNS names will remain active because obviously they [MS] can change up and people are back to square 1 again.

I want DX12 but not at these costs.

Yeah, I was talking about doing it network wide in the firewall in my router, not at the local machine level.

If MS. really wants to make sure people don't do this, and don't mind being a bit devious they could just tie the delivery of spy data to the activation server, and make them one and the same. If the OS doesn't check in every X days and deliver spy data, it gets deactivated, and remains deactivated until the next spy packet is received.

Lets hope they haven't. I know most people are connected to the internet most of the time these days, but I could imagine a hellish level of complaints from those who aren't if they are suddenly required to be online in order for the OS to remain activated...
 
Supposedly 10 connects back to Redmond via hardcoded IP's in the DLL files; I have no idea who found this out and how, but that's what I've read (re: using firewall rules to block). Supposedly with the DLL files this way, it bypasses firewall (or at least the built in Win firewall). People on the MDL forums have resorted to using PeerBlock and a custom blocklist to supposedly block this communication, but who knows how long those IP's or DNS names will remain active because obviously they [MS] can change up and people are back to square 1 again.

I want DX12 but not at these costs.

I assume he means rules in your router. That's where I'd put any firewall rule.
 
Honestly, as much as I'm creeped out by Google, I'd almost rather use their stuff than Microsoft's things.

This...while it makes me probably come off as a hypocrit, I don't mind Google's snooping on my Google account. I know what they have access to, and it's not my computer. I don't have much on my phone, and what I do, I don't care if they snoop it.

I don't want any company poking it's nose around my computer; there's too much shit on there. Secondly, Google was against CISA and Microsoft wasn't....that's a damn strong reason #2 that I don't want Microsoft doing it and refuse to use Win10.

I'd rather babysit 7's updates (making sure to not allow any updates pertaining to telemetry or CEIP) than constantly be fighting with 10 trying to cut it off at all corners just to have DX12. Again I also bring up the forced non-opt out updates. They can just FOAD with that nonsense.
 
Supposedly 10 connects back to Redmond via hardcoded IP's in the DLL files; I have no idea who found this out and how, but that's what I've read (re: using firewall rules to block). Supposedly with the DLL files this way, it bypasses firewall (or at least the built in Win firewall). People on the MDL forums have resorted to using PeerBlock and a custom blocklist to supposedly block this communication, but who knows how long those IP's or DNS names will remain active because obviously they [MS] can change up and people are back to square 1 again.

I want DX12 but not at these costs.

the guy who was the source of that information has since pulled the page of the internet.

I can tell you when I blocked those hardcoded ip's bing stopped working, so it seems he went in a bit hot headed with his list of ip's.

The hostnames fromt he list seem legit with tracking but I unblocked all the ip's as I think none of the ips he listed are used for tracking, only the hostnames.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041946388 said:
I don't see how this can be the case, unless they are actually actively tryign to circumvent firewall blockage by randomly changing ports and hosts the data goes to. They could do this by using the same P2P network they use to distribute updates, to also harvest the data.

If you track what hosts it connects to (like bing.com, etc.) it shouldn't be too difficult to create firewall rules to block them, if they are actually pointing at a microsoft server.

I'm a little surprised to see you making excuses for this, but the average user isn't going to be able to do that, and it's too much trouble for even a power user to have to put that much work in playing cat and mouse with Microsoft and their OS.

I don't want to work for my OS, I want me OS to work for me. That said, take a look at these hardcoded mothership IP's. Hell, I don't even think botnets have this many master nodes. Really highlights the absurdity of the apologists that insist "Telemetry is fine, Microsoft is just collecting crash dumps like they always have, put your tinfoil hat away".

dns.msftncsi.com
ipv6.msftncsi.com
win10.ipv6.microsoft.com
ipv6.msftncsi.com.edgesuite.net
a978.i6g1.akamai.net
win10.ipv6.microsoft.com.nsatc.net
en-us.appex-rf.msn.com
v10.vortex-win.data.microsoft.com
client.wns.windows.com
wildcard.appex-rf.msn.com.edgesuite.net
v10.vortex-win.data.metron.life.com.nsatc.net
wns.notify.windows.com.akadns.net
americas2.notify.windows.com.akadns.net
travel.tile.appex.bing.com
www.bing.com
any.edge.bing.com
fe3.delivery.mp.microsoft.com
fe3.delivery.dsp.mp.microsoft.com.nsatc.net
ssw.live.com
ssw.live.com.nsatc.net
login.live.com
login.live.com.nsatc.net
directory.services.live.com
directory.services.live.com.akadns.net
bl3302.storage.live.com
skyapi.live.net
bl3302geo.storage.dkyprod.akadns.net
skyapi.skyprod.akadns.net
skydrive.wns.windows.com
register.mesh.com
BN1WNS2011508.wns.windows.com
settings-win.data.microsoft.com
settings.data.glbdns2.microsoft.com
OneSettings-bn2.metron.live.com.nsatc.net
watson.telemetry.microsoft.com
watson.telemetry.microsoft.com.nsatc.net"
 
And if you're okay with this YOU, and people like you are the problem

Okay, but I didn't say I agreed with this. Settle the fuck down.
Do you know what I use my computer for more these days than anything? Simply gaming. I use my MacBook for everything else. Free W10 for some bullshit data and free updates for the OS? Not entirely awful.
 
This...while it makes me probably come off as a hypocrit, I don't mind Google's snooping on my Google account. I know what they have access to, and it's not my computer. I don't have much on my phone, and what I do, I don't care if they snoop it.

I don't want any company poking it's nose around my computer; there's too much shit on there. Secondly, Google was against CISA and Microsoft wasn't....that's a damn strong reason #2 that I don't want Microsoft doing it and refuse to use Win10.

I'd rather babysit 7's updates (making sure to not allow any updates pertaining to telemetry or CEIP) than constantly be fighting with 10 trying to cut it off at all corners just to have DX12. Again I also bring up the forced non-opt out updates. They can just FOAD with that nonsense.

Exactly. Building data collection into the DNA of a PC's computing OS is crossing a far bigger boundary than a phone OS or website. I can close Chrome, I can decide not to send certain data through Gmail or my phone. I can still use my desktop without those, and Google/Facebook will not know what I am doing on that desktop. I can close an app and still work/play. I cannot close my desktop and still work/play.

When Windows 10 is collecting data, there's nowhere to run for general purpose computing, unless you roll back to 7/8 and then either leave updates disabled or employ hacks to keep the spying updates from coming down.
 
Honestly, as much as I'm creeped out by Google, I'd almost rather use their stuff than Microsoft's things. It was only a couple of years ago that Microsoft was all like advertising that they didn't collect any data and now they've turned completely around and gotten super scary about mining for information without a lot of advertising revenue to justify it even.

Time for a name change then? :p
 
I've got to say that I am still conflicted about the Forbes article "Microsoft Admits Windows 10 Automatic Spying Cannot Be Stopped". I wanted to point out that many on this forum said this wasn't true, that you could turn it off in Pro. My first reaction was to be offended or outraged and say Microsoft, you suck. At the moment, it's only one news site (among many who said you could turn data sent back to Microsoft off) and one Microsoft employee that was cited. I still think I want to hear this issue out as it develops. For my part, I had already uninstalled the so called Microsoft telemetry updates and would urge the cautious among us to stick with Windows 7 and 8. Even though it is my fastest computer, my dedicated Windows 10 laptop doesn't get used much, sadly. I have images of it running Windows 7 and Windows 8.1 though.

I would like to point out though that even if we trust Microsoft (and some would argue if you run Windows, you trust Microsoft implicitly), do we trust the government or legal system who could force Microsoft to gather data on us, as it has mechanisms to do so in the operating system now, and order Microsoft not to let it be known that this is being done in the name of national security? Do we trust that bad actors couldn't find a way to exploit mechanisms in the operating system, even if they are turned off and only exist for Windows Insiders? If Microsoft said "there are no backdoors in Windows for government organizations like the NSA," are we left to wonder "what about the front doors?"

There is a lack of details out there right now. maybe this automatic "spying" isn't anything to be concerned about. But this comes after denials that Microsoft was doing this at all. People are crediting Microsoft with being open and transparent about the data they're collecting, but this can only be said if we know the total extent of what Microsoft is collecting and can compare it to statements made about data it's collecting. We have to take their word for it that they are only collecting what they openly admit to collecting. It could be a situation where this is the part of the data they're collecting that they are willing to tell us. The only way we could know this isn't the case is to have an independent party auditing them who has no allegiance to Microsoft.

This may all sound like tinfoil hat paranoia. I think it is trying to reason out a collection of sometimes contradicting information. Like Forbes: "Microsoft Admits Windows 10 Automatic Spying Cannot Be Stopped" and Forbes: "It's Just Foolish Not To Upgrade To Windows 10"
 
For my part, I had already uninstalled the so called Microsoft telemetry updates and would urge the cautious among us to stick with Windows 7 and 8.

7 & 8 still collect data and telemetry. Not as much, but Win10 has a lot more things that rely on the "cloud" (Cortana, Windows Updates, OneDrive, etc..). Windows as a Service, so it's going to have a decent connection to the internet and Microsoft services.

I do wish they'd be more open with exactly what is being sent, where, and why. That's something they haven't really spilled the beans on. Belifore did say that a lot of it is overdramatized (which I agree). I think they need a lot more transparency. Otherwise, it does come off as them collection something they shouldn't (the whole 'if you have nothing to hide, you'd tell us' hypocrisy').

Although, some of the stuff they say they collect is scary. Google does similar stuff, though (all voice searches are saved).

The Information Age.
 
To be honest, assuming those DNS entries are what they claim to be, some of them are harmless.

For example, NCSI is Network Connectivity Status Indicator. It has been around since Vista and is what Microsoft uses to determine network connectivity on the network diagnostics tool: http://www.techrepublic.com/blog/data-center/what-do-microsoft-and-ncsi-have-in-common/

We know what Bing is. We know what "SkyDrive" (now OneDrive) is.
Akamai (Akamai and akadns) is a content delivery network. nsatc.net and edgesuite.net appears to be associated with Thomson Reuters. I think we can assume "directory.services.live.com" is used to authenticate Microsoft accounts. In Windows, Dr Watson and Watson usually refer to crash analysis, so that's probably what "watson.telemetry.microsoft.com" does. Many of those look to be a server and a backup run by someone else.

There are some I can't explain. I can't hazard a guess as to what these are: win10.ipv6.microsoft.com and v10.vortex-win.data.microsoft.com for example. I think this seems self-explanatory: settings-win.data.microsoft.com
 
At the moment, it's only one news site (among many who said you could turn data sent back to Microsoft off) and one Microsoft employee that was cited.

This isn't a pencil pusher though, this is the VP.
He's admitted some of the tracking cannot be turned off.
In Belfiore's view, Microsoft's current setup properly addresses users' privacy concerns, since it lets them opt out of the collection of personal information. For those tracking features that users can't opt out of, he said the company doesn't consider them to be a privacy issue.

"And in the cases where we've not provided options
, we feel that those things have to do with the health of the system, and are not personal information or are not related to privacy," he said.

At this point can Microsoft be trusted for anything?
They've downloaded the OS to computers, first they said to users who reserved a copy of 10, then they backtracked and said everyone.

They manually ticked the update to install 10 without users asking for it, then backpedaled saying that was a mistake, now they're saying that's what's going to happen anyway in a few months.

People who have hidden telemetry and CEIP updates in 7 & 8 have seen those updates reappear, either mysteriously unhidden or released as a "new" update with a new KB article assigned with no reason other than to circumvent their user's ability to hide updates - which they [MS] then sneaks back in with this questionable loophole.

Now you have the VP saying you can turn some tracking off, and that which you cannot, there is no way to disable it. Are we to now believe that he's lying and you can disable it? Why would he go on record saying you cannot? If anything, he'd say you can disable everything, be found out to be a fraud, then backtrack and say 'not everything'.

I don't care what he (or they) says it's for; I have lost trust in Microsoft.

I would like to point out though that even if we trust Microsoft (and some would argue if you run Windows, you trust Microsoft implicitly)

No, absolutely not.
The only reason they've been trusted up until this point is because they've never done anything in the past of this magnitude to lose that trust.

do we trust the government or legal system who could force Microsoft to gather data on us, as it has mechanisms to do so in the operating system now, and order Microsoft not to let it be known that this is being done in the name of national security?

Again - MS was not against CISA, which even Google was.
That should tell you something.
You now have an OS with known spying, known data collection, now admittedly known spying and data collection which cannot be turned off.

It's been proven that the sliders in 10 to turn off these things by and large don't do much and are essentially placebos. They claim you can disable telemetry in 10 Enterprise, but again I say - do they deserve that trust? I say no.

I've never been a tinfoil hat person, I've always been a fan of MS - however, I've lost all faith in them at this point.

7 & 8 still collect data and telemetry.

Complete nonsense.
You can opt out of CEIP and installing CEIP & telemetry updates.
I can run Fiddler on my workstations for days and see no communication to MS.

There is no data collection or telemetry in 7 & 8 unless you install it.
 
Complete nonsense.
You can opt out of CEIP and installing CEIP & telemetry updates.
I can run Fiddler on my workstations for days and see no communication to MS.

You obviously do not know what Fiddler is for or how to use it; it only works with HTTP and HTTPS (and FTP requests). Try the same experiment with Wireshark or a similar packet capturing program.
 
You obviously do not know what Fiddler is for or how to use it; it only works with HTTP and HTTPS (and FTP requests). Try the same experiment with Wireshark or a similar packet capturing program.

Actually I do; I also have a degree in networking and experience with routing and iOS.

I also know that Wireshark does not capture encrypted traffic which Fiddler can; that's why all articles demonstrating the snooping of 10 have been done with Fiddler, not Wireshark.
 
zero2dash-
I agree with what you're saying.

I agree that Microsoft Corporate Vice President Joe Belfiore is more than just an employee. If this was a misquote, there surely would have been demands for correction, and his words shouldn't be taken lightly. It's odd that he didn't say that only health and performance data is automatically sent to Microsoft, he said about the data being sent "we feel that those things have to do with the health of the system." Sounds ambiguous and open to interpretation.

The argument that it is better for everyone if we extract data from your machine whether you would like us to or not is no justification. Terrible things have been done in the past using this line of thinking as justification.

And what does it say that Microsoft has been able to produce Windows through Windows 8.1 that on the whole doesn't crash and doesn't experience serious performance problems without this sort of data/telemetry and only now needs this “In the case of knowing that our system that we’ve created is crashing, or is having serious performance problems, we view that as so helpful to the ecosystem and so not an issue of personal privacy, that today we collect that data so that we make that experience better for everyone”? What does this say about who Microsoft thinks owns the operating system? If the company I work for does this, well ok, it's their system, their network, their software, etc. And what does it say for how Microsoft views it's enterprise customers versus it's professional and home customers? These same enterprise customers that likely aren't even considering Windows 10 at this time by and large, given many held out on Windows 7.

At this point, I have more trust for Apple (but not Google) than Microsoft.
 
I meant "What does this say about who Microsoft thinks owns the computer and its data?" (not who owns the operating system)
 
The sad thing is, 10 is a really good OS, but it's overshadowed somewhat by the few glaring issues that people have with it. 10 Enterprise LTSB N is probably the leanest most pure version of Windows since 2k, but I just don't trust it.

Unfortunately I don't see MS back pedaling on these new ideals they've adopted; I think this is them from here on out, take it or leave it. That being the case, I'll run 7 as long as possible and when it's no longer feasible to do so, I'll be switching to Mint.
 
Supposing you were transferring large files to hard drive for backup at the time - you could lose your data. or, are in the middle of a transaction. Windows 10 is insane, you have lost control over your machine.
Rendering video takes time and all your work can be lost if interrupted. What a terribly unreliable 'tool' the PC has become. To my mind this breaks trade description regulations, not to mention privacy law.
 
I can't help but wonder how the European Commission will respond to all of this.

They haven't exactly been easy on Microsoft in the past for bundling IE (now they are bundling a music streaming service, a cloud backup service, a software stores, etc, etc)

They also tend to take privacy more seriously than we do over here.

It ought to be popcorn worthy. In the end, I wonder if there will be a special European version, or if we will all benefit from Europe fighting the good fight.
 
I don't want to work for my OS, I want me OS to work for me.

Playing devil's advocate here, but if this is true, then why are you trying to stop it from sending the data back to Microsoft that allows them to improve the OS so that it works better for you?

If Windows 10 is an OS-as-a-service, it needs to be continually improved. The only way to continually improve it is to look at how users are actually utilizing it and make improvements based on that data. Regardless of what other information is in the telemetry packets, we can already see from the Technical Preview that at least SOME of the data is being used for UX and hardware optimization purposes.

UX stagnation has always been a huge problem for Microsoft. They are unable to iterate on their UIs in an intelligent way so we get massive, controversial shifts like the Ribbon and the Start Screen. This is a glimpse into a future where the UI is improved iteratively over a series of threshold releases. This kind of work simply isn't possible without directly watching a lot of users over a long period of time.

If you want the OS to work for you but you want to be the one who determines how it improves and works better for you, then why are you using a closed-source OS to begin with?
 
Playing devil's advocate here, but if this is true, then why are you trying to stop it from sending the data back to Microsoft that allows them to improve the OS so that it works better for you?

If Windows 10 is an OS-as-a-service, it needs to be continually improved. The only way to continually improve it is to look at how users are actually utilizing it and make improvements based on that data. Regardless of what other information is in the telemetry packets, we can already see from the Technical Preview that at least SOME of the data is being used for UX and hardware optimization purposes.

UX stagnation has always been a huge problem for Microsoft. They are unable to iterate on their UIs in an intelligent way so we get massive, controversial shifts like the Ribbon and the Start Screen. This is a glimpse into a future where the UI is improved iteratively over a series of threshold releases. This kind of work simply isn't possible without directly watching a lot of users over a long period of time.

If you want the OS to work for you but you want to be the one who determines how it improves and works better for you, then why are you using a closed-source OS to begin with?

None of Microsoft's data collection would have been a problem had they made it opt-in, truthfully described what the data contained, and how it was being used, and making the operating system actually obey and not send any data if the user neglected to opt in..

Transparency really is what is at issue here.

People tend to get weary - and for good reason - when it looks like someone is trying to pull a fast one on them.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041947834 said:
None of Microsoft's data collection would have been a problem had they made it opt-in, truthfully described what the data contained, and how it was being used, and making the operating system actually obey and not send any data if the user neglected to opt in..

Transparency really is what is at issue here.

People tend to get weary - and for good reason - when it looks like someone is trying to pull a fast one on them.

Combine this with the heavy handed approach they have used to get people to upgrade to Windows 10, and it's not difficult to understand why many people are concerned.

They are pushing really hard to get people to upgrade (for free) to Windows 10, so they must stand to benefit.

How do they stand to benefit? Well, there is all this poorly documented data collection, etc. etc.

It's like they couldn't have set themselves up for more conspiracy theories if they had tried.

If it really is innocuous, publish a technical document illustrating the contents of the telemetry packets. Show - in excruciating detail - what each level of setting sends back to Microsoft. (Mouse pointer location, search terms, kernel dumps, whatever)

it's all about transparency.

The sooner they can get away from the "hard push to adopt new operating system that sends an unstoppable stream of encrypted mystery data packets to the mothership" scenario, the better.
 
Playing devil's advocate here, but if this is true, then why are you trying to stop it from sending the data back to Microsoft that allows them to improve the OS so that it works better for you?

If Windows 10 is an OS-as-a-service, it needs to be continually improved. The only way to continually improve it is to look at how users are actually utilizing it and make improvements based on that data. Regardless of what other information is in the telemetry packets, we can already see from the Technical Preview that at least SOME of the data is being used for UX and hardware optimization purposes.

UX stagnation has always been a huge problem for Microsoft. They are unable to iterate on their UIs in an intelligent way so we get massive, controversial shifts like the Ribbon and the Start Screen. This is a glimpse into a future where the UI is improved iteratively over a series of threshold releases. This kind of work simply isn't possible without directly watching a lot of users over a long period of time.

If you want the OS to work for you but you want to be the one who determines how it improves and works better for you, then why are you using a closed-source OS to begin with?

UX stagnation is a sales problem, not a technical one. Using the idea of moving a few icons around and changing the number of things one clicks to get to something they're trying to do in order to keep things interesting to the user who will then act as a source of income isn't an excusable justification for data mining on a global scale.

Branding a piece of software as <insert whatever>-as-a-service also doesn't give it a free pass to collect data. Programs that rely on an external connection don't, by nature of that need, automatically require baked-in user monitoring.
 
Using the idea of moving a few icons around and changing the number of things one clicks to get to something they're trying to do in order to keep things interesting to the user who will then act as a source of income isn't an excusable justification for data mining on a global scale.

Obviously Microsoft disagrees, but if you're on the W10 TP Fast Ring you'll see they've done a lot more than "move a few icons around" in only a few months.

Branding a piece of software as <insert whatever>-as-a-service also doesn't give it a free pass to collect data.

Do you know what software-as-a-service even is? Continuous improvement is baked into the concept. It wouldn't be SaaS if it didn't keep getting updated on a rolling basis. The only way to improve the product in a user-centric way is to actually see how the user is using it and them making adjustments based on that information. All SaaS products are collecting at least some data about how the user behaves or they're doing it wrong.
 
Obviously Microsoft disagrees, but if you're on the W10 TP Fast Ring you'll see they've done a lot more than "move a few icons around" in only a few months.



Do you know what software-as-a-service even is? Continuous improvement is baked into the concept. It wouldn't be SaaS if it didn't keep getting updated on a rolling basis. The only way to improve the product in a user-centric way is to actually see how the user is using it and them making adjustments based on that information. All SaaS products are collecting at least some data about how the user behaves or they're doing it wrong.

Microsoft has a lot of employees. They can farm a statistically significant sample of usage information from their own people rather than shoveling that chore off onto the rest of the planet. There's more than just a "improve the UI" motive behind the hush-hush data collection that can't be turned off and the shove-it-down-your-throat actions of the company's been taking since 10's rollout.

And yes, I know what SaaS is and I also know that improving a product doesn't require mysterious encrypted data streams. I also know that SaaS isn't Win10 as it can operate offline and is executed with local computing resources. I think a better question to ask at this point is, "Do YOU know what SaaS even is?"
 
Zarathustra[H];1041947845 said:
If it really is innocuous, publish a technical document illustrating the contents of the telemetry packets. Show - in excruciating detail - what each level of setting sends back to Microsoft. (Mouse pointer location, search terms, kernel dumps, whatever)

I agree, but I'm not sure it would actually help their case. I think it would just result in more user backlash if MS actually came out and said it was doing things like watching cursor position and monitoring what you click on and when.

It's much easier for Microsoft to ask for forgiveness than permission here, but in order for it to work, they need to be able to come back in a relatively short amount of time and demonstrate how the telemetry actually creates value for the customer (rather than only Microsoft). Threshold 2 starts this process, but they have a long way to go still.
 
Microsoft has a lot of employees. They can farm a statistically significant sample of usage information from their own people rather than shoveling that chore off onto the rest of the planet.

That's not how UX works. Microsoft is huge, but they're still far too homogenous to do this process properly using only internal data. Remember they've been trying to do this for a long time and it resulted in the Ribbon and the Start Screen, among piles of other, old, failed UI "revamps" like Microsoft Bob. Microsoft is finally understanding how to do UX right in the past couple of years and this is part of it.

And yes, I know what SaaS is and I also know that improving a product doesn't require mysterious encrypted data streams. I also know that SaaS isn't Win10 as it can operate offline and is executed with local computing resources. I think a better question to ask at this point is, "Do YOU know what SaaS even is?"

SaaS normally doesn't require "mysterious encrypted data streams" because the product is often remotely hosted on the servers of the company who owns the product and they opt not to encrypt the local traffic. If they chose to encrypt their local network traffic, then there'd be the same sort of "mysterious encrypted data streams" as when you do online banking or shopping.

The OS-as-a-service thing is fairly new. It's not exactly the same as SaaS, which is why I differentiated it originally, but it shares a lot of common attributes, like continual improvement through rolling, forced updates. Just because it can operate offline now doesn't mean that's the future. Microsoft almost launched the Xbox One as a console that required constant internet connectivity to function, relenting at the last moment before launch. I don't think they are afraid to move in a direction of constant internet connectivity. Windows 10 running on a phone has (and needs) almost constant data connectivity.
 
That's not how UX works. Microsoft is huge, but they're still far too homogenous to do this process properly using only internal data. Remember they've been trying to do this for a long time and it resulted in the Ribbon and the Start Screen, among piles of other, old, failed UI "revamps" like Microsoft Bob. Microsoft is finally understanding how to do UX right in the past couple of years and this is part of it.

Bob was like...before I was born. I kinda doubt that many people who were alive then are still alive now. The Ribbon was liked by a lot of people as much as people freaked out about it. Either way, it's still around and Office is like the main moolah-making thing for MS right now which might imply that the Ribbon wasn't a mistake. From reading the old Windows 8 dev blogs, I recall seeing that the Start Screen was designed after taking into account vast amounts of collected system usage metrics. Ultimately, it's implementation and failure was more of a management and people problem than a technical one related to the lack of information.

SaaS normally doesn't require "mysterious encrypted data streams" because the product is often remotely hosted on the servers of the company who owns the product and they opt not to encrypt the local traffic. If they chose to encrypt their local network traffic, then there'd be the same sort of "mysterious encrypted data streams" as when you do online banking or shopping.

That sort of traffic isn't mysterious at all as it's expected and the contents are known. What's going back to Microsoft after a bunch of silders are shuffled around isn't disclosed yet which is where there's a very important difference.

The OS-as-a-service thing is fairly new. It's not exactly the same as SaaS, which is why I differentiated it originally, but it shares a lot of common attributes, like continual improvement through rolling, forced updates. Just because it can operate offline now doesn't mean that's the future. Microsoft almost launched the Xbox One as a console that required constant internet connectivity to function, relenting at the last moment before launch. I don't think they are afraid to move in a direction of constant internet connectivity. Windows 10 running on a phone has (and needs) almost constant data connectivity.

Continual improvement will only last through the life cycle of the product which makes it nothing different than a video game or basically any other program that a developer supported with updates for a few years after its release by offering patches and updates. Microsoft has already announced that Win10 is on the usual 10 year support cycle of previous operating systems. It might get some patches and improvements like prior versions, but it isn't the Omega of operating systems and it certainly doesn't have any new attributes that make it different enough to consider it something other than what it is -- another MS OS.
 
Playing devil's advocate here, but if this is true, then why are you trying to stop it from sending the data back to Microsoft that allows them to improve the OS so that it works better for you?

If Windows 10 is an OS-as-a-service, it needs to be continually improved. The only way to continually improve it is to look at how users are actually utilizing it and make improvements based on that data. Regardless of what other information is in the telemetry packets, we can already see from the Technical Preview that at least SOME of the data is being used for UX and hardware optimization purposes.

UX stagnation has always been a huge problem for Microsoft. They are unable to iterate on their UIs in an intelligent way so we get massive, controversial shifts like the Ribbon and the Start Screen. This is a glimpse into a future where the UI is improved iteratively over a series of threshold releases. This kind of work simply isn't possible without directly watching a lot of users over a long period of time.

If you want the OS to work for you but you want to be the one who determines how it improves and works better for you, then why are you using a closed-source OS to begin with?
Microsoft has determined UX stagnation is a problem for Microsoft. More tellingly, Microsoft has determined that they have not succeeded in what appears to them to the computing growth markets: tablets and mobile. It appears they are focusing on the mobile paradigm rather than the desktop paradigm. It seems they are trying to take cues from other vendors.

If you look at mobile and tablets, you could say that Microsoft hasn't kept up to date with changing UX/UI. If you look at desktop, you could say that Microsoft hasn't been nearly consistent enough. Microsoft's closest competitors are not changing their desktop or laptop UI/UX like Microsoft is trying to do.
 
Microsoft has determined UX stagnation is a problem for Microsoft.

What's funny to me is this notion that they need all this feedback; no they don't.

You changed the UI greatly in 8 and it backfired horrendously.
You reinstated a Start icon in 8.1 which did practically nothing other than further confuse people, and that backfired horrendously.

You have 2 versions that failed from a sales/user migration standpoint; if failures don't indicate to you that "maybe that last idea wasn't a good one", then you shouldn't be in business anymore.

You go back to what works in 10 and you don't need to snoop on people to find out whether they like it or not; the adoption rates alone should be indication enough. Only, now those have sloped off so they'll probably spy even more (since obviously that's the only way to find out what people want or like). :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top