Wi-LAN Sues Everybody over Bluetooth

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A small Canadian wireless company has filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Apple, Acer, Dell, HP, Lenovo, Sony and Motorola claiming PC and mobile phones with Bluetooth infringe on their patents.

Announced Thursday, the suit claims a violation of Wi-LAN's U.S. Patent No. 5,515,369. Issued in 1996, the patent covers a "method for frequency sharing and frequency punchout in frequency hopping communications network." In plain English, that means the patent is for a technology by which wireless systems such as Bluetooth avoid interfering with other wireless systems such as Wi-Fi, which operate in an unlicensed frequency, according to Tyler Burns, Wi-LAN's director of investor relations and communciations.
 
Sounds like one of those cases where a person(s)/Company sits on a patient until it becomes industry standard then sues everyone into oblivion over it.....
 
Reminds me of someone registering a domain name before the company can do it, then demanding a ransom to give it up.
 
This vague and all-encompassing patent shit really needs to stop. I get that it's supposed to protect innovation, but there are a lot of trolls that just net a broad range of ideas with foreseen and unforeseen applications and squat em. Just waiting for innovators to come along, do the work and get blasted.

It's gonna be a long, legally restrained journey to advancement. :(
 
Holy Carp...

I hope they have very, very deep pockets and a virtual army of Lawyers. They may have just sued themselves into oblivion...
 
There should be a rule.

You ship a viable product based on your patent within 5 years, or you lose it. Or you must show sustained, recorded progress towards the use of the patented technology.

This vague and all-encompassing patent shit really needs to stop. I get that it's supposed to protect innovation, but there are a lot of trolls that just net a broad range of ideas with foreseen and unforeseen applications and squat em. Just waiting for innovators to come along, do the work and get blasted.

It's gonna be a long, legally restrained journey to advancement. :(
 
http://www.wi-lan.com/

Not exactly in this case, no.

Yes, they have licensed many products over the years, but it seems they've changed their focus recently to intellectual property protection. From that site:
WiLAN was founded in 1992 to commercialize technology inventions that made low-cost, high-speed wireless networking a reality. Used in several generations of proprietary products manufactured by WiLAN and other products offered by industry, these inventions were, by 2005, commercialized in millions of wireless networking devices worth many billions of dollars. Realizing the value that its intellectual property brought to industry, WiLAN chose in 2006 to focus its business on developing, protecting and monetizing patented inventions.
 
Yes, they have licensed many products over the years, but it seems they've changed their focus recently to intellectual property protection. From that site:

Indeed so, but they must invent them nonetheless. It also seems that every company on the list of those being sued has chosen not to license from them; Sony being an exception, but is being sued in nonetheless in this case.

I empathize with companies who look at the tangled web of patents and just say "fuck it" and forge ahead with their product, but not to the point of excusing lawlessness. If they're using somebody else's property they ought to pay for it.

Wanting the laws to change does not give anyone the right to violate them before they do.
 
Indeed so, but they must invent them nonetheless. It also seems that every company on the list of those being sued has chosen not to license from them; Sony being an exception, but is being sued in nonetheless in this case.

I empathize with companies who look at the tangled web of patents and just say "fuck it" and forge ahead with their product, but not to the point of excusing lawlessness. If they're using somebody else's property they ought to pay for it.

Wanting the laws to change does not give anyone the right to violate them before they do.

The problem with these patents is they are vague, very vague.
 
Indeed so, but they must invent them nonetheless.
It's a bit of both. They started by inventing, but judging from their history, they now acquire patents from inventors and enter into patent licensing agreements with other companies.
If you have patents that are not making money for you or are no longer core to your business, WiLAN can help you utilize these assets to generate additional income.
WiLAN’s experienced team can take responsibility for licensing your patented inventions through a revenue-sharing licensing partnership program. Alternatively, WiLAN can acquire your technologies.
 
I seriously doubt they were the first to come up with FHSS
 
It's a bit of both. They started by inventing, but judging from their history, they now acquire patents from inventors and enter into patent licensing agreements with other companies.

Interesting business model they've cooked up for themselves, there. This situation reminds me of the Metallica "Death Magnetic" release that blew up the loudness wars into the public consciousness; if Wi-LAN really is the epitome of everything that's wrong with the current patent issuing process, this lawsuit could spark the kind of change people want.
 
The companies they are suing use bluetooth chips and technology that other comapnies have made. These companies are simply implementing other companies products. Qualcomm may make the chip that has the bluetooth. Then Wi-LAN should be suing Qualcomm, not HP, Dell, or another mid-user of a product.

That's like if Walmart was using scanners made by IBM but someone who had a patent on scanner technology sues Walmart instead of IBM.
 
The companies they are suing use bluetooth chips and technology that other comapnies have made. These companies are simply implementing other companies products. Qualcomm may make the chip that has the bluetooth. Then Wi-LAN should be suing Qualcomm, not HP, Dell, or another mid-user of a product.

That's like if Walmart was using scanners made by IBM but someone who had a patent on scanner technology sues Walmart instead of IBM.

Wait, didn't SCO sue Autozone and Chrysler for using Linux-based servers and apps? But AZ and Chrysler didn't write Linux, only implemented it.
 
They usually are. Problem is, you get a few big names licensing your stuff and you have justification for suing the rest.

But wait, they have Sony on that list and they are suing Sony... :confused:

Also, maybe I'm confused here but this is a Canadian company suing regarding U.S. patent law?
 
l already know who is going to win.




Lawyers. the great parasitic plague of modern society.
 
The companies they are suing use bluetooth chips and technology that other comapnies have made. These companies are simply implementing other companies products. Qualcomm may make the chip that has the bluetooth. Then Wi-LAN should be suing Qualcomm, not HP, Dell, or another mid-user of a product.

That's like if Walmart was using scanners made by IBM but someone who had a patent on scanner technology sues Walmart instead of IBM.

Title 35 covers a lot of ground.

35 U.S.C. 271 Infringement of patent.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in this title, whoever without authority makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells any patented invention, within the United States, or imports into the United States any patented invention during the term of the patent therefor, infringes the patent.

The reason they do this is they are seeking a "reasonable royalty" as permitted in title 35. That reasonable royalty is usually expressed as a percentage. Plaintiff-patentees would rather get a smaller percentage of a big number than a larger percentage of a small number.

Technically, as a user of one of these products, patent holders could sue individuals directly. However, their recovery would be pretty limited...
 
But wait, they have Sony on that list and they are suing Sony... :confused:

Also, maybe I'm confused here but this is a Canadian company suing regarding U.S. patent law?

Their patents are issued by the US Patent and Trademark Office which provides them with an exclusive right to their inventions in the US for a limited period of time. They can sue anyone who makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells their invention(s) without authority (e.x., a license) in the US. There's nothing in the patent code that limits protection so that only citizens can use it...
 
l already know who is going to win.




Lawyers. the great parasitic plague of modern society.

I got tired of the never ending layoffs when I was an engineer. It's a service economy. You can be a doctor, lawyer, or walmart greeter. I picked lawyer.
 
Their patents are issued by the US Patent and Trademark Office which provides them with an exclusive right to their inventions in the US for a limited period of time. They can sue anyone who makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells their invention(s) without authority (e.x., a license) in the US. There's nothing in the patent code that limits protection so that only citizens can use it...

That's kind of what I figured must be the case but I wasn't sure, as I don't know a whole lot about international U.S. patent law. Thanks. :cool:
 
Yeah, how do patents work internationally? Must be chaos

Either they are enforceable in accordance with a treaty, or they also patented it in the US. Parenting the same IP in multiple countries to "protect" it is common practice.
 
Well the judge and jury are going to be asking.... What took you so long? Since the patent is from 1996. They sue in 2010?

Prognosis: a Loooooser.
 
Back
Top