Why Windows 8 Isn't An iOS Copycat

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Does this really need to be said?

In short, Windows 8 is Microsoft's big answer to that broadening landscape: a product that can power nearly all machines, with an interface that can adapt along the way. That right there is one of the biggest differences between Microsoft's vision of computing and Apple's, which created a separate OS to power its portables, while keeping the desktop OS for its Intel-based machines.
 
I'm sick of these dumb titles. iOS copy cat? iPhone killer?

All dumb. Not even closely related to iOS, other than they both are mobile OS's.
 
Do anything radically different and everyone will call you an Apple copycat. Until they start selling a locked down OS with uncustomizable hardware then it can't be considered an iOS rip off.
 
Does this really need to be said?

Windows 8 is a functional superset of iOS and Android and while shares things between those inmost important aspects it is anentirely different concept, in fact its the polar opposite of iOS in that is trying to do it all. The approach may prove to be unpopular but if they can pull it off, the hardware is there and the price is right its going to appeal to a lot of folks, particularly businesses, professionals and students.
 
By splitting up the two OSes, Apple was able to iterate quickly, rolling out major releases on an annual basis, while continuing to offer Mac OS X updates at their usual rate. ... For proof of that, you can look at the iPad, which launched without multitasking and a number of other features the iPhone had, only to get it later with a software update. Android users face a similar future, with the promise of additional software updates.

Can iterate quickly, check.
Cannot release new product containing the same features as old product, check.

:confused:



Read more: http://news.cnet.com/8301-27076_3-20107074-248/why-windows-8-isnt-an-ios-copycat/#ixzz1Y84fYq31
 
I am going to be honest, this article is actually one of the major reasons I am not liking the direction of win8. I have been involved in the software development side of industry for the better part of 10 years, that experience has taught me that the more things you try to do with a single piece of software, the worse it handles specific roles. While I am a fan of unified environments to a point, there is a line where it ceases being efficient and becomes less so. I feel that the push to unify the windows environment across multiple hardware platforms is actually a step in the wrong direction. It opens up the door to larger scale problems that can now affect multiple devices instead of being isolated and slows down how quickly problems can be responded too.

Now don't get me wrong, I would love a windows environment where my Outlook calendars, tasks, and other productivity are all synced across my laptop, desktop and phone. I have this currently, but it requires a number of third party applications in order to achieve this. While it works most of the time, it can be difficult to get things working smoothly all the time. Now given that I am a tech and even I have trouble keeping this stuff working flawlessly, I can only feel sympathy for the average user. To be fair this likely won't change for me as I tend to root and mod my phone, just saying.

As much as I hate to admit it, I feel that apple is going to come out on top by not unifying iOS and that MS is making a major mistake. This has a lot of potential to make windows far too cumbersome and far too inflexible when responding to threats/problems.
 
I am going to be honest, this article is actually one of the major reasons I am not liking the direction of win8. I have been involved in the software development side of industry for the better part of 10 years, that experience has taught me that the more things you try to do with a single piece of software, the worse it handles specific roles. While I am a fan of unified environments to a point, there is a line where it ceases being efficient and becomes less so. I feel that the push to unify the windows environment across multiple hardware platforms is actually a step in the wrong direction. It opens up the door to larger scale problems that can now affect multiple devices instead of being isolated and slows down how quickly problems can be responded too.

Now don't get me wrong, I would love a windows environment where my Outlook calendars, tasks, and other productivity are all synced across my laptop, desktop and phone. I have this currently, but it requires a number of third party applications in order to achieve this. While it works most of the time, it can be difficult to get things working smoothly all the time. Now given that I am a tech and even I have trouble keeping this stuff working flawlessly, I can only feel sympathy for the average user. To be fair this likely won't change for me as I tend to root and mod my phone, just saying.

As much as I hate to admit it, I feel that apple is going to come out on top by not unifying iOS and that MS is making a major mistake. This has a lot of potential to make windows far too cumbersome and far too inflexible when responding to threats/problems.

Apple has a major mobile OS and a Desktop/Laptop OS people think they are trying to merge.

MS has... a major Desktop/Laptop OS they are merely trying to add more touch functionality to, in order to better support a long time, poorly supported, Windows niche: tablets. And MS is trying to do it in a way to drag people away from buying another iPad/Android tablet.

They aren't "merging" anything. WP7 is just that.... Windows Phone 7. It will stay a phone OS, and is not slated to ever become a tablet OS or a desktop OS.
 
With hardware accelerating constantly however, there should be less and less you can't do on a tablet or tablet type computer, at least in regards to the average user. So less compromise will have to be made in the OS, etc. I think a unified platform is a great idea, and could cause it all to blow up much as Windows originally allowed the PC to flourish.
 
As much as I hate to admit it, I feel that apple is going to come out on top by not unifying iOS and that MS is making a major mistake. This has a lot of potential to make windows far too cumbersome and far too inflexible when responding to threats/problems.

Engineering non-trivial systems is all about the management of complexity, not the avoidance of it. While some will debate the awkwardness of fusing Metro with the desktop Windows 8 will be the most flexible OS ever created. Multiple form factors, CPUs, chipsets, input devices, development tools, etc. while retaining nearly 100% backwards compatibility with it's predecessor is frankly an amazing feat of software engineering that no one has ever attempted at this level with a product of unparalleled and historic success.

But of course there's enormous risk here at many levels and I think that that's why so many want Microsoft to succeed here because it will force other major players out of their comfort zone and challenge them to take more risk. Windows 8 is indeed being forced as a result of the iPad ad to a lesser extent Android slates.
 
I agree with what heat is saying. MS is trying to make a much larger ecosystem than has ever been seen before. If they get it pretty right on the first pass, it will make a huge difference (especially in the business community).
 
Let us not forget that, for all the accusations of copying, intellectual piracy, etc., Microsoft has some brilliant engineers at their disposal. I find it hard to believe they'll screw up a launch of this magnitude, and the concept - sharing layers of an OS across multiple devices that have customizable front ends - is very compelling.

Instead of a monolithic "Windows OS" there will snippets of code and programs on devices that can communicate to the main "hub" - probably a PC or perhaps a phone in the future. I imagine Microsoft wants a world where your phone buzzes when your toast is done, or you can play games on any computer by sticking your phone (which has your saved games) into any dock that can connect with your cloud data.

You can criticize Microsoft all you want, but you can't deny that they have some absolutely brilliant people. I eagerly await Windows 8, and I hope it isn't a colossal failure. Done correctly, it could set a new bar for their competitors, which increases competition and empowers consumers in the long run.
 
Engineering non-trivial systems is all about the management of complexity, not the avoidance of it. While some will debate the awkwardness of fusing Metro with the desktop Windows 8 will be the most flexible OS ever created. Multiple form factors, CPUs, chipsets, input devices, development tools, etc. while retaining nearly 100% backwards compatibility with it's predecessor is frankly an amazing feat of software engineering that no one has ever attempted at this level with a product of unparalleled and historic success.

But of course there's enormous risk here at many levels and I think that that's why so many want Microsoft to succeed here because it will force other major players out of their comfort zone and challenge them to take more risk. Windows 8 is indeed being forced as a result of the iPad ad to a lesser extent Android slates.

I am well aware of that, it does not however change the reality that the more complex something is the more points of failure there are. The fact that no one has ever attempted a product at this level with any amount of success should be your first indication that this has massive potential to fail badly. Unfortunately in the software world, things of this magnitude tend to just simply fail.

Let us not forget that, for all the accusations of copying, intellectual piracy, etc., Microsoft has some brilliant engineers at their disposal. I find it hard to believe they'll screw up a launch of this magnitude, and the concept - sharing layers of an OS across multiple devices that have customizable front ends - is very compelling.

Instead of a monolithic "Windows OS" there will snippets of code and programs on devices that can communicate to the main "hub" - probably a PC or perhaps a phone in the future. I imagine Microsoft wants a world where your phone buzzes when your toast is done, or you can play games on any computer by sticking your phone (which has your saved games) into any dock that can connect with your cloud data.

You can criticize Microsoft all you want, but you can't deny that they have some absolutely brilliant people. I eagerly await Windows 8, and I hope it isn't a colossal failure. Done correctly, it could set a new bar for their competitors, which increases competition and empowers consumers in the long run.

You find it hard to believe they will screw up a launch of this magnitude? Your memory is short...I can name off a laundry list of things MS has tried to create to "revolutionize" how things are done that they completely flopped the launch.

You are correct though, Done correctly this has the potential to change the game. However there is a huge chance this will be a colossal failure, and if it is, it also could be a serious game changer.

Don't get me wrong, I hope it succeeds (well outside the terrible metro ui, just default that off on desktop/laptops and I will be happy). As an It professional a truly unified environment would be a dream. However the very real risks make me very skeptical.
 
You find it hard to believe they will screw up a launch of this magnitude? Your memory is short...I can name off a laundry list of things MS has tried to create to "revolutionize" how things are done that they completely flopped the launch.

You are correct though, Done correctly this has the potential to change the game. However there is a huge chance this will be a colossal failure, and if it is, it also could be a serious game changer.

Don't get me wrong, I hope it succeeds (well outside the terrible metro ui, just default that off on desktop/laptops and I will be happy). As an It professional a truly unified environment would be a dream. However the very real risks make me very skeptical.

The reason I believe it has good odds of success have nothing to do with their past history, but with hardware today. Everything is in place for true integration to begin. From phones to tablets, the hardware is finally capable of keeping up with the features demanded by consumers. Microsoft has to know this and that the stakes are higher than they've ever been given the decline of personal computers and rise of phones/tablets.

You seem like a natural pessimist, which is fine. You may even be right. But I'm looking at what they've done and I'm not yet seeing the telltale signs of failure such as delays, excuses, lowering of expectations, etc. Instead, there's functioning software that actually works pretty well (Metro UI opinions notwithstanding) with plenty of time for improvement. And to clarify, my memory is very long. :)
 
I am well aware of that, it does not however change the reality that the more complex something is the more points of failure there are.

Well you could make the same argument comparing DOS and Windows 7 and it wouldn't really make any sense in reality.

The fact that no one has ever attempted a product at this level with any amount of success should be your first indication that this has massive potential to fail badly. Unfortunately in the software world, things of this magnitude tend to just simply fail.

Sure its a difficult undertaking but few organizations have Microsoft's software development expertise. And sure, Microsoft is behind the game here, they needed to do something besides slap a phone OS on an ARM device like Apple and Google and call it a tablet.
 
In short, Windows 8 is Microsoft's big answer to that broadening landscape: a product that can power nearly all machines, with an interface that can adapt along the way. That right there is one of the biggest differences between Microsoft's vision of computing and Apple's, which created a separate OS to power its portables, while keeping the desktop OS for its Intel-based machines.

Oh, so Win8 is like Linux then.
 
As long as Windows 8 has an option to go back to a gui similar to previous windows version, it's a good idea for microsoft make a single OS that powers everything.
 
I am going to be honest, this article is actually one of the major reasons I am not liking the direction of win8. I have been involved in the software development side of industry for the better part of 10 years, that experience has taught me that the more things you try to do with a single piece of software, the worse it handles specific roles. While I am a fan of unified environments to a point, there is a line where it ceases being efficient and becomes less so. I feel that the push to unify the windows environment across multiple hardware platforms is actually a step in the wrong direction. It opens up the door to larger scale problems that can now affect multiple devices instead of being isolated and slows down how quickly problems can be responded too.

Now don't get me wrong, I would love a windows environment where my Outlook calendars, tasks, and other productivity are all synced across my laptop, desktop and phone. I have this currently, but it requires a number of third party applications in order to achieve this. While it works most of the time, it can be difficult to get things working smoothly all the time. Now given that I am a tech and even I have trouble keeping this stuff working flawlessly, I can only feel sympathy for the average user. To be fair this likely won't change for me as I tend to root and mod my phone, just saying.

As much as I hate to admit it, I feel that apple is going to come out on top by not unifying iOS and that MS is making a major mistake. This has a lot of potential to make windows far too cumbersome and far too inflexible when responding to threats/problems.

I have to disagree. Isn't one of Window's strongest selling point in its decades of existence that you can build a computer with any hardware to complement it and Windows will work on it? That there are drivers available anywhere for Windows? One can argue that AMD and Intels are two different processors despite both sharing x86 core. Microsoft has no problems supporting both - in addition to their 64-bit counterparts. What's another processor?
 
I would love to see any production Linux distro do half of what I can do with just this Developer preview of Windows 8 on my EP121.

I'm going against the quote I pasted. I was jokingly referring to the fact that Linux is also very platform-independent. I wasn't talking about the functionality of Linux.
 
A lot of people are bashing Windows 8 on the Dev Build Edition, especially with the Metro UI, what about all of the features that are coming out with Windows 8 for a desktop, environment such as Hyper-V (yes can be achieved with 3rd party software, but makes it easier and cheaper), XBL integration, Native USB 3.0 support, native class compliant driver support for mobile broadband dongles, Devices equipped with an NFC chip, and countless other good stuff to come with it.
 
I'm going against the quote I pasted. I was jokingly referring to the fact that Linux is also very platform-independent. I wasn't talking about the functionality of Linux.

My bad, fair enough about Linux running on multiple platforms.
 
A lot of people are bashing Windows 8 on the Dev Build Edition, especially with the Metro UI, what about all of the features that are coming out with Windows 8 for a desktop, environment such as Hyper-V (yes can be achieved with 3rd party software, but makes it easier and cheaper), XBL integration, Native USB 3.0 support, native class compliant driver support for mobile broadband dongles, Devices equipped with an NFC chip, and countless other good stuff to come with it.

One on the coolest things that you have to have multiple Windows 8 instances running to see is the profile syncing, witnessed it last night when I installed Win 8 on a desktop and saw my browser favorites sync up and the wallpaper change on my EP121 when I changed it on the desktop machine.
 
One on the coolest things that you have to have multiple Windows 8 instances running to see is the profile syncing, witnessed it last night when I installed Win 8 on a desktop and saw my browser favorites sync up and the wallpaper change on my EP121 when I changed it on the desktop machine.

Windows 8 is going to be like the WP7 mango update, hundreds of changes but only a few the normal end user will really notice. :D

I also haven't gotten windows 8 installed yet so haven't gotten to play with it much.
 
I got the Windows 8 Developer version installed last night on my primary rig and just jumped right in and USED it as my primary OS all night.

Here's the amazing thing... it worked. EVERYTHING worked.

ATI Video drivers, Realtek Audio drivers...
Ventrilo.
Steam.
Copied 140GB of steam folder from my win7 hard disk and it took it fine.
Fired up Bad Company 2 and it ran perfect.

The new Metro interface, which pretty much means "the way the Start button works" is your primary difference. It's the crossover point between the desktop and the app world.

No big problem. This OS has some very interesting potential. My only real gripe so far is wanting a few more right click context options, especially as it relates to creating taskbar and desktop shortcuts. Other than that using it is pretty straightforward.
 
Mac OS X and the iOS are slowly becoming one (AKA "a product that can power nearly all machines, with an interface that can adapt along the way.").

I really think that's where this argument fails. So Microsoft isn't being a copycat because they are doing the same thing as Apple or at least in a timeline slightly behind Apple?
 
Mac OS X and the iOS are slowly becoming one (AKA "a product that can power nearly all machines, with an interface that can adapt along the way.").

I really think that's where this argument fails. So Microsoft isn't being a copycat because they are doing the same thing as Apple or at least in a timeline slightly behind Apple?

What Apple has done thus far with Lion and unifying iOS and OS X is nothing but a sugar pill compared to Windows 8. An app launcher that looks like iOS, full screen apps and some gestures, that's about it. Can't run iOS on OS X natively or vice versa, and OS X has never been supported officially with screen based pen and touch devices.
 
Copying apple? Far from it... if Apple is so diverse and good, why doesn't everyone talk about it like so? Because it fails in many aspects. Especially price.... that's why it will never be popular. overpriced.

back to the topic, Win8.... it will be able to run on the crap phones, as well as crappy computers. yet its still going to appeal to the techy people finally?

I am anxious to see this new Windows, being a techy person hearing the updates.... but I do NOT have high hopes yet.
 
I would love to see any production Linux distro do half of what I can do with just this Developer preview of Windows 8 on my EP121.

You're seriously trying to say your "developer preview" of Windows8 can do more than Linux? I hate to even dignify your statement with a response...
 
You're seriously trying to say your "developer preview" of Windows8 can do more than Linux? I hate to even dignify your statement with a response...

LOL... wake me when Windows finally gets a real shell. MS seems to have fixed almost everything except that fucking frankenstein that they call a command prompt.

I haven't been able to install the preview yet. Did they finally implement virtual desktops? I don't care who they copy. Just add it already.
 
You're seriously trying to say your "developer preview" of Windows8 can do more than Linux? I hate to even dignify your statement with a response...

The only thing that's not working at all my EP121 are games, so in that respect its equal with Linux. However every desktop app works, and all but a couple drivers. On my desktop Windows 8 install EVERYTHING works this far including the games I've tried. So in terms of what can actually run, saying thins Dev Preview is more functional than Linux is hype.
 
An app launcher that looks like iOS, full screen apps and some gestures, that's about it.

You just don't get the gestures. I say this as a person that wishes Microsoft would copy gestures from Lion, and the gestures in Lion are currently incomplete.

Wake me when gestures are ingrained into Windows and hardware agnostic.
 
You just don't get the gestures. I say this as a person that wishes Microsoft would copy gestures from Lion, and the gestures in Lion are currently incomplete.

Wake me when gestures are ingrained into Windows and hardware agnostic.

Well there are no touch screen Macs so the point about hardware agnosticism is a little odd from my point of view. I probably use gestures as much as the average OS X user as I use them all the time on my Windows tablets, including pen gestures. In fact one thing I don't like about this developer preview is that the flicking gestures don't work with touch anymore as they probably cause issues with the Metro gestures.

Gestures that I use daily in Windows 7 on my touch screens:

Directional Flicks which are customizable and can be assigned key strokes
Two finger tap
Successive finger tap, tapping one finger and then another while keeping the first finger pressed
Pinch zoom
Tap and hold

One pen side there's

scratch out
join
split

So gestures are critical to effectively using even a Windows 7 tablet. I get gestures plenty. I was just saying that some were added to Lion, not that they aren't important but certainly not nearly enough to make Lion a tablet OS.
 
Well there are no touch screen Macs so the point about hardware agnosticism is a little odd from my point of view.

The iPad and iPhone are effectively their testbed and probably should be considered touchscreen Macs. Porting features from the iPad (for better or worse) to OS X has already begun.

Furthermore, laptops greatly outnumber tablets. MS can shout about gestures for tablets, but who cares when there are a gazillion laptop users compared to tablets. I laugh when people talk about the synaptics gesture suite or using hacked drivers to enable gestures on trackpads. It's all shit and won't see mass acceptance until MS implements it across the board.

I hope it happens in Windows 8. We'll see.
 
The iPad and iPhone are effectively their testbed and probably should be considered touchscreen Macs. Porting features from the iPad (for better or worse) to OS X has already begun.

Sure Mac track pads are great, personally I don't like any track pads including Macs but then I don't use Macs enough to have an informed opinion.

Microsoft has a lot of fish to fry with Windows 8. Support for touch, keyboards, mice/track pads and pens all while making touch and pointing devices interoperable while not making any of the hardware. While getting better multi-touch support for track pads would be great just getting all of this to work well and fairly coherently is a great deal more important multi-touch track pad support.

I guess Windows' multi-touch track pad support will improve when iOS gets official pointing device support or OS X gets pen support.
 
iOS copycat?

Who came up with that ?

Besides, iOS works good as an interface.

The interface in the dev preview looks like it was designed by Mattel and is total shit.
 
Roll on windows 9 when the crap from this one gets sorted out. Even after playing around with the preview, there is still nothing compelling or interesting yet about this release for users without tablet junk. Which is 95% of people. It's all a load of minor background stuff which is hard sell to most people. Then a junky optional GUI which just doesn't look nice.

XBL integration

I'm annoyed about that. I hate that shitty service that idiots pay for, because they can't think for themselves nor look at things objectively (hey dudes, lets pay for a P2P service where you already pay for the connection, games and hardware, thats free everyelsewhere because, hell, why not! It haz avatars! :eek:). This is just a rebranded continuation of GFWL. It's a kick in the face for PC gaming, and if they are serious about PC games they should abort this now. Nobody wants GFWL whatever the hell they call it. Then again the masses are generally morons.
 
Microsoft has a lot of fish to fry with Windows 8. Support for touch, keyboards, mice/track pads and pens all while making touch and pointing devices interoperable while not making any of the hardware. While getting better multi-touch support for track pads would be great just getting all of this to work well and fairly coherently is a great deal more important multi-touch track pad support.

If MS was serious about gesture/trackpad support it would be supported on the millions of devices currently in use. Not tablets where their market is miniscule.

I guess Windows' multi-touch track pad support will improve when iOS gets official pointing device support or OS X gets pen support.

Then Win multi-touch track pad support will never improve.
 
Back
Top