why did AMD lie?

Up until last week, Intel's only MP chips (4S) were based on Netburst. :p So yes, Intel's 4S chips were far behind Opteron, but no, they were not Core 2. Sun and other manufacturers announced 4S Tigerton servers (some even allow you to order) but they're not available for delivery yet.

What's interesting though is that even with crummy Netburst chips, Intel held on to 50% of the 4S and higher x86 marketshare.

actually I was referring to 2 quad core Xeons vs 4 Dual Core Opterons, which were tested on anand i think? and the AMDs did very well since the bottleneck of the FSB becomes appearent at >4 core
 
actually I was referring to 2 quad core Xeons vs 4 Dual Core Opterons, which were tested on anand i think? and the AMDs did very well since the bottleneck of the FSB becomes appearent at >4 core
I think I remember reading that article a while back and the Opterons did fare well...

http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/intel/showdoc.aspx?i=2897&p=11


AMD Quad Opteron Platform


Advantages:
Still the best performing FP platform: highest rendering performance
Scales better than comparable Intel platform

Cons:
Expensive 8xx(x) CPUs and expensive platform (motherboard)
(Slightly) lower integer performance than E5345
Lower performance/Watt than Xeon E5345
___________________________________

Intel Dual Xeon Platform / Clovertown

Advantages:
Quad socket performance...
...For very low dual socket price in CRM, SAP, Financial analyses and Java server
Excellent rendering performance at high resolutions (>=720p)
In some cases, a simple upgrade for Xeon 51xx.

Cons:
Mediocre scaling in many applications
Slightly higher power consumption but little or no performance gain compared to Xeon 5160 in flow modeling,
3D rendering (lower resolutions), structural simulation, MySQL and TPC.


Here's a more recent article: http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/intel/showdoc.aspx?i=2957&p=3
 
I would have to disagree with the fact that it is wrong, a company will always try to present their products in the most optimistic light as possible. This is not wrong at all, it is up to us consumer to be knowledgable buyers, you can't expect the people making and selling the products to give anything buy the best perspective, as evidenced very few ,this goes for people in general are willing to make themselves look bad intentionally.

Your absolutely right about companies representing their products in the best possible light, and it seems like AMD was doing just that. It's not actually a lie... but it certainly wasn't the truth either. But I was actually directing my comments at the title of the OP's post. But many companies are better at misdirection than they are producing a product or service. They can make more money by deceiving their customers (share holders, workers, etc) than they can by investing in research and development. While AMD isn't known for going to that extreme, it certainly shouldn't be surprising that they use a little misdirection to sell some more product.

Plus I woke up extra jaded this morning! :D
 
i have not had a intel chip since my 286. and have always got AMD, Cyrix etc. and for the last 8 years only AMD.

But why did AMD say that Barcelona would beat clovertown by 40% in FPU apps when they clearly knew the performance of both chips?

It has to do with the marketting department. AMD's marketting guys like to lie, and have almost always done so, except with the A64 when they didn't have to.
 

I was looking more along the lines of absolute values in references to the competition. I have already seen these but I didn't consider them since they were compared to AMD's own processors.

Edit: though it is interesting that the SpecFP and SpecInt scaling results are about the same I calculated a 185.4% in comparison for SpecFP. This is very nice considering your double the number of cores and extracting and 85% gain give or take.
 
I am sure that Barcelona's performance will increase once it's "drivers" are more mature.

>_>

<_<
 
Hmm.

I thought this was the AMD section.

The AMD section is for discussing all things AMD, not just all good things AMD. ;) False marketing claims is a serious issue that bears some discussion, and this forum is certainly the right place for it.
 
I have been comeing to the H since it was just a new web sight only about 2 months old on a daily basis and its just seems the forums have gone down hill so much from back in the day with this kinda crap from all the kids just getting into computers these days.

Exactly. Back in the day, bans would be handed out for some of the crap and threadcapping that gets posted nowdays. It seems the only things you are allowed to discuss around here anymore are nVidia GPU's and Intel CPU's. Start a thread on an AMD CPU or GPU and its threadcapped within the first 10 replies.
 
They are a company with share holders, every company does it. Some better then others.

People are just way to tied up rumors and speculation, it isnt like AMD slept with your wife and then told you that she performed 30% better then your sister.

this had me rolling around for a while..

but everytime i look at the benchmarks that have been floating around i come to a different conclusion.

broadly speaking clock for clock i have them down as about 5% behind intel, who agrees?

but even though barcelona is not what id hoped and the fact that i think AMD lied to everyone i will probably still get a phenom when its out.
 
this had me rolling around for a while..

but everytime i look at the benchmarks that have been floating around i come to a different conclusion.

broadly speaking clock for clock i have them down as about 5% behind intel, who agrees?

but even though barcelona is not what id hoped and the fact that i think AMD lied to everyone i will probably still get a phenom when its out.

wha? from reading the review twice, I'd say they are 5% above clock that takes into consideration that they are faster in some and slower in others =p
 
but even though barcelona is not what id hoped and the fact that i think AMD lied to everyone i will probably still get a phenom when its out.



If its real world performance is as good as a S775 45nm quad @ the 300~ mark come say...Febuary,then yes,I too will grab one and build a gaming/encoding system around it,as long as it does at least the latter,and oc like a mofo.

Wonder if it it will.... ? :D
 
Back
Top