why did AMD lie?

j1979

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 29, 2007
Messages
291
i have not had a intel chip since my 286. and have always got AMD, Cyrix etc. and for the last 8 years only AMD.

But why did AMD say that Barcelona would beat clovertown by 40% in FPU apps when they clearly knew the performance of both chips?
 
They didn't say when it would beat cloverton did they?

Check out the benchies and you will see that the barcelona scales much better than Intel processors.

Once the speed ramps up.. it may well beat the Intel chips by that much.. we shall see.

Also.. we need to wait for the desktop systems that won't be crippled by the slower RAM.. not to mention the BIOSes on those test boards probably aren't very mature yet.
 
"We expect across a wide variety of workloads for Barcelona to outperform Clovertown by 40 percent," Randy Allen said. The quad-core chip also will outperform AMD's current dual-core Opterons on "floating point" mathematical calculations by a factor of 3.6 at the same clock rate

http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9584_22-6152645.html
 
i have not had a intel chip since my 286. and have always got AMD, Cyrix etc. and for the last 8 years only AMD.

But why did AMD say that Barcelona would beat clovertown by 40% in FPU apps when they clearly knew the performance of both chips?

Can you give proof of this lie?
 
Can you give proof of this lie?
I think he is referring to the claims made by AMD late last year, which they subsequently rescinded. I also remember reading similar such claims as recently as 2Q of this year.
 
It's their company culture.

When guys like Henri Richard can say "We don't do paper launches" with a straight face, you know not to trust their claims.
 
They are a company with share holders, every company does it. Some better then others.

People are just way to tied up rumors and speculation, it isnt like AMD slept with your wife and then told you that she performed 30% better then your sister.
 
i have not had a intel chip since my 286. and have always got AMD, Cyrix etc. and for the last 8 years only AMD.

But why did AMD say that Barcelona would beat clovertown by 40% in FPU apps when they clearly knew the performance of both chips?
Could there be a more flamebait thread title? :p

amd-specfp-rate2006-4p-servers.jpg


The 2.5Ghz parts are going through validations right now.
 
Could there be a more flamebait thread title? :p

amd-specfp-rate2006-4p-servers.jpg


The 2.5Ghz parts are going through validations right now.

by the way, that says 4p, doesn't that mean 4 processors? or just 4 cores? if its 4 processors then I Can see for sure that barc would dominate =p
 
AMD had to lie. It's a delay tactic with the hope they can get the clock speeds up ASAP. With their close ally IBM and biggest Opteron vendor HP not shipping any Barcelona systems (@ 1.9GHz and 2.0GHz) until mid-November, things are getting desperate in Sunnyvale.
 
And of course Intel never li…….er…….exaggerates either.

Like where are all the over 3.0 gig product we were PROMISED over a year ago. But wait, there is more, a new chip, smaller process, smaller core and…….oh…….yeah…..barely made it over 3.0 Gigs and still runs hot.

And let us not forget the little issue of heat that Intel hasn’t been able to overcome, although perhaps that was a company goal. Notice you can’t buy a decent new case without at least a half dozen 120 mm fans these days. What did the case companies know that we were never told?

A quick glimpse into the future (putting on tinfoil cap) ..Millions of carbon nano tubes laid out in a perfect grid work within the core itself. Each tube gets a nano pump which pumps nano fluid to a nano central heat exchanger portion of the core where a nano three stage phase cooler will cool the entire chip internally. As a consumer all you will need to provide is the new PSU with a separate 75 AMP 12 Volt rail to power the thing.

Hey, what’s a little flame bait with out a bit of humor?:rolleyes::D


 
by the way, that says 4p, doesn't that mean 4 processors? or just 4 cores? if its 4 processors then I Can see for sure that barc would dominate =p
Right, 4 processors, 16 cores. I'd personally like to see more 4P benchmarks, but I suppose they will show up soon.

Only on a forum would one see this amount of anti-AMD fanaticism :D I do wonder why so many E6400/E6600 owners are posting in these threads though...

2360/8360 are going to be SE parts and have 120W TDP. So it runs a little hotter than standard parts, no surprise there. I'm unsure whether the target release date has been made public yet (other than just Q4), so I will just say that we are pushing it out as soon as possible.
 
Only on a forum would one see this amount of anti-AMD fanaticism I do wonder why so many E6400/E6600 owners are posting in these threads though...


Its becouse they were the underdogs for so long. If Intel didnt have such big pockets they would have been really hurting through the whole p4 thing. The c2d is a nice chip for sure. I think AMD did pretty good with really a patch job. When the clockspeeds get going i think it will be the better chip all around and this is jmo. Thing is i dont remember ever seeing this kinda crap go on in the Intel forums when AMD was on top like it is here. I have been comeing to the H since it was just a new web sight only about 2 months old on a daily basis and its just seems the forums have gone down hill so much from back in the day with this kinda crap from all the kids just getting into computers these days. I never posted much but hell i may as well get a beer buzz going and fight back as i dont see them leaving to make the forums a quality place anytime soon.
 
Right, 4 processors, 16 cores. I'd personally like to see more 4P benchmarks, but I suppose they will show up soon.

Only on a forum would one see this amount of anti-AMD fanaticism :D I do wonder why so many E6400/E6600 owners are posting in these threads though...

2360/8360 are going to be SE parts and have 120W TDP. So it runs a little hotter than standard parts, no surprise there. I'm unsure whether the target release date has been made public yet (other than just Q4), so I will just say that we are pushing it out as soon as possible.

That is normal. I am an AMD fan, and I've been around since before the K6. Every single launch we get the same thing. The best advice I can give is to "stand you ground" In the end once the architecture takes the lead (like it always does) they will fade into the shadows, and you wont hear from them for a good long while.
 
That is normal. I am an AMD fan, and I've been around since before the K6. Every single launch we get the same thing. The best advice I can give is to "stand you ground" In the end once the architecture takes the lead (like it always does) they will fade into the shadows, and you wont hear from them for a good long while.
No worries, it doesn't affect how I do my job. Having been on both sides, I can say that the view from the inside is drastically different than the view from the outside, especially the one from the extremely vocal minority on an enthusiast site such as this. On the inside, there is no chaos, no doom, no mass hysteria, just hardwork. Nearly a decade ago, I was awed and inspired by AMD's ability to innovate and overcome against impossible odds that set me on the path I am on today. I have not lost sight of that.
 
They are a company with share holders, every company does it. Some better then others.

People are just way to tied up rumors and speculation, it isnt like AMD slept with your wife and then told you that she performed 30% better then your sister.

ROFLMAO. That's hilarious. :D

The sad part though is that it's true, we all sometimes get taken up by the hype, and when something fails to deliver we get dissapointed. Barcelona is about where I expected it to be. Winning some, losing some, trading blows with the current crop of Conroe based products. AMD needs to ramp things up and get the ball rolling to stay competitive.
 
btw even Opterons 64(k8) cores were faster then core 2 xeons(core 2) in 4p were they not?
Up until last week, Intel's only MP chips (4S) were based on Netburst. :p So yes, Intel's 4S chips were far behind Opteron, but no, they were not Core 2. Sun and other manufacturers announced 4S Tigerton servers (some even allow you to order) but they're not available for delivery yet.

What's interesting though is that even with crummy Netburst chips, Intel held on to 50% of the 4S and higher x86 marketshare.
 
What's interesting though is that even with crummy Netburst chips, Intel held on to 50% of the 4S and higher x86 marketshare.
That is resultant from their long-standing history in the server space and their highly loyal customer base, which AMD always had a difficult time breaking into (understandably so).
 
Only on a forum would one see this amount of anti-AMD fanaticism :D I do wonder why so many E6400/E6600 owners are posting in these threads though...
I have a 165 and a 3200+, along with two other C2Ds folding. Just cuz I sig the best doesn't mean I'm only going to buy Intel. I would buy a AMD quad if it was worth it. With three boards ready for Q6600s and two 939 rigs the best option is obvious. You are right, I should just stop posting here.
 
I for one was never really impressed by the Core2Duo systems (the ones from system builders like Dell and IBM)... sure they were a lot faster then the P4 systems...

But... I had more than a couple people who had AMD based systems(servers) from system builders (Dell.. hint hint).. and they LOVED how fast the AMD systems were.... I actually had a guy that I was doing work for go on and on about how he was amazed at how fast the AMD server he just got was.

This was after Core2Duo was out...

The system response time of the AMD systems is still faster than the Core2Duo systems due to the way better memeory architechture...

Sure they may win in benchmarks and game FPS.. but for response times.. AMD still wins.

The Intel systems.. .even when loaded with a clean install of Windows just seems kinda sluggish when compared to a nice AMD based system... remember I am talking response times here.. not actual appliation performance once the application is opened.. unless the program is very memory intensive that is.
 
The Intel systems.. .even when loaded with a clean install of Windows just seems kinda sluggish when compared to a nice AMD based system... remember I am talking response times here..
I have a sugar based cure for whatever ails you, in convenient tablet form. :p You really, really can't be serious.
 
How many years did Intel insist that MHz was the sole determinate of processor performance?
I don't know. If they did it as often as you imply, could you furnish us with an example or three?

I think it was implied, sort of like using PR numbers in 2007. :p
 
I don't know. If they did it as often as you imply, could you furnish us with an example or three?

I think it was implied, sort of like using PR numbers in 2007. :p

I'm sorry, were you living under a rock during the Netburst years? I'm not going to take the time to dig up old Intel PR to satisfy your ignorance.
 
I for one was never really impressed by the Core2Duo systems (the ones from system builders like Dell and IBM)... sure they were a lot faster then the P4 systems...

But... I had more than a couple people who had AMD based systems(servers) from system builders (Dell.. hint hint).. and they LOVED how fast the AMD systems were.... I actually had a guy that I was doing work for go on and on about how he was amazed at how fast the AMD server he just got was.

This was after Core2Duo was out...

The system response time of the AMD systems is still faster than the Core2Duo systems due to the way better memeory architechture...

Sure they may win in benchmarks and game FPS.. but for response times.. AMD still wins.

The Intel systems.. .even when loaded with a clean install of Windows just seems kinda sluggish when compared to a nice AMD based system... remember I am talking response times here.. not actual appliation performance once the application is opened.. unless the program is very memory intensive that is.

I tend to agree, but at the moment while working the Folding at home project intel does have a distinct advantage. On the other hand, read below;)

I have a sugar based cure for whatever ails you, in convenient tablet form. :p You really, really can't be serious.

Having a nice mix of both AMD X-2s C2D and a Q6600, I can tell you he is not kidding.

Perhaps you have heard of DreamWorks, a little company that does CGI and massive amounts of rendering.

Welp. Back in 2005, after previewing the newest C2D from the nice Intel folk and also after doing extensive testing guess what? They decided to go ALL AMD. Not only AMD but off the shelf product, same as we buy.

Now you are asking yourself why, are they dumb or something? Nope, not at all. What they did find was if they wrote their own in house code optimized for each produce AMD clearly had the better architecture. All the Sun Work Stations were tossed, as were the Intel products but they did concede to keep a MAC here and there to keep some artistes happy.

In my mind we are all hobbled to some degree by generic code made to run on anything X86 capable. One of the things I found very interesting, the Vista code has a crap load of AMD optimizations written right in, just search the registry for AMD and Vista itself for AMD and you will be shocked how much MS put into the effort.

Could /Should AMD have moved a bit faster, of course, but right now they are taking core server business from Intel and our needs as enthusiasts will have to take a back seat for a while.;)




 
How many years did Intel insist that MHz was the sole determinate of processor performance?

Uh, zero.

It actually sounds like you were the one living under a rock. If Intel insisted that "MHz was the sole determinate of processor performance," then the Celeron would have sold like hotcakes.

A 2.8 GHz processor is faster than a 2.4 GHz one from the same family. Until very recently, Intel never acknowledged the existence of AMD and their microarchitecture. They didn't need to "insist" on MHz.
 
It actually sounds like you were the one living under a rock. If Intel insisted that "MHz was the sole determinate of processor performance," then the Celeron would have sold like hotcakes.

They didn't need to "insist" on MHz.
I believe what Rabid Badger implied was Intel's NetBurst architecture was originally designed to clock at very high speeds for its era. Hence, the P4's 20+ stage pipeline, and witnessed by the highest clockspeeds ever achieved by a X86 processor. Despite the fact that Intel may never have actually adopted a specific slogan or advertised "Gigahertz is King," it nevertheless engineered its products in that general direction, and marketed them thus.

I distinctly remember reading some articles severely criticizing Intel for granting unlimited sway to its accountants for 'designing' their then new line of processors, instead of its very own engineers. The overall message being that Intel was far more concerned about achieving high clockspeeds at all costs, which ultimately incurred them the cost of the performance crown towards the end of that era (especially per watt), and gave the impetus towards their Core architecture.
 
I believe what Rabid Badger implied was Intel's NetBurst architecture was originally designed to clock at very high speeds for its era. Hence, the P4's 20+ stage pipeline, and witnessed by the highest clockspeeds ever achieved by a X86 processor. Despite the fact that Intel may never have actually adopted a specific slogan or advertised "Gigahertz is King," it nevertheless engineered its products in that general direction, and marketed them thus.

I distinctly remember reading some articles severely criticizing Intel for granting unlimited sway to its accountants for 'designing' their then new line of processors, instead of its very own engineers. The overall message being that Intel was far more concerned about achieving high clockspeeds at all costs, which ultimately incurred them the cost of the performance crown towards the end of that era (especially per watt), and gave the impetus towards their Core architecture.


I can remember Anand posting about Intel from that perspective years ago,and he(as are you and badger) was quite right,it was implied through thier ads strongly...
 
Tech industry is all lies.

Take a look at Hard Driver MTBFs. If you go by the traditional meaning of this, HD's should last about 20 years on average. Dig a little deeper and you find out that is the failure rate if you replace the drive every two years...

LCD displays. 178 degree viewing angle?? Seriously did anything even think about what that means. That means viewing your monitor square on from the side. I had one of these and sitting perfectly centered and moved my head an inch the contrast would washout.

Wait for reviews. Check things out before you buy it, because you can't trust any manufacturer to honestly represent their products.
 
SPECfp_rate2006 is not a wide variety of workloads as promised by Randy Allen.

Shh! AMD doesn't want you to know that SPECfp is the only test they are 40% ahead in! :p

And before you flame me: you know it's the truth. AMD loves to harp SPECfp because it gets extremely bandwidth bottlenecked scaling past two cores, and it's the only test that their useless wadzoos of memory bandwidth and "native" quad-core BS actually help in. All the tests in real applications so far (SQL, 3Dsmax, etc.) have indicated that the extreme bandwidth and "native" garbage don't make much of any difference in the real world.
 
Every major company out there is run by lawyers and marketing, and its their job to lie as effectively and subtly as possible whenever needed to promote more sales. Its not just the tech industry, its nearly EVERY major company. Its wrong and its a sad commentary on how business is run today but its the norm, not the exception.

The problem is it works. Lies, damn lies, and statistics are being used all the time to bait consumers into believing whatever they have now isn't worth keeping and they should run to the store and get the newest item immediately. Hey, this is an enthusiast forum, we all want to have the biggest and baddest (enter computer components here) so we fall for this stuff as much as anyone.

We even lie to ourselves! How many posts have you read that someone comments about the massive performance jump they have seen when upgrading from a Pent 2.4 to a 2.8 or a e6400 to a e6600, or a x2 4200 to a x2 4800? Sure, there is a small improvement, but the person who paid $xxx amount of money to do a small upgrade WANTS to believe it made a big difference. He (or she) wants to feel they are a happier more complete human being because they spent the money and upgraded.

Bottom line is.. they all lie and it works because we want to believe it!
 
Every major company out there is run by lawyers and marketing, and its their job to lie as effectively and subtly as possible whenever needed to promote more sales. Its not just the tech industry, its nearly EVERY major company. Its wrong and its a sad commentary on how business is run today but its the norm, not the exception.

The problem is it works. Lies, damn lies, and statistics are being used all the time to bait consumers into believing whatever they have now isn't worth keeping and they should run to the store and get the newest item immediately. Hey, this is an enthusiast forum, we all want to have the biggest and baddest (enter computer components here) so we fall for this stuff as much as anyone.

We even lie to ourselves! How many posts have you read that someone comments about the massive performance jump they have seen when upgrading from a Pent 2.4 to a 2.8 or a e6400 to a e6600, or a x2 4200 to a x2 4800? Sure, there is a small improvement, but the person who paid $xxx amount of money to do a small upgrade WANTS to believe it made a big difference. He (or she) wants to feel they are a happier more complete human being because they spent the money and upgraded.

Bottom line is.. they all lie and it works because we want to believe it!

I would have to disagree with the fact that it is wrong, a company will always try to present their products in the most optimistic light as possible. This is not wrong at all, it is up to us consumer to be knowledgable buyers, you can't expect the people making and selling the products to give anything buy the best perspective, as evidenced very few ,this goes for people in general are willing to make themselves look bad intentionally.
 
Back
Top