Why Chrome OS Will Fail, Big Time

if games use opengl, the port to linux is rather simple, and if its supported in linux, or chrome os, or macos its easy... very easy to port.

This would work ideally in an ideal world. But Frogger 3d is very different from COD MW2... :D

We already have Open architecture PCs, if we further that with open source graphics APIs, then I think that all the compromises will seriously yield us "Frogger 3D" like immersion. Granted, Frogger is fun and all, but it's nothing like blowing up baddies with machineguns and mortars.
 
If price was such a big issue then you wouldn't see Apple selling more computers than ever and making all this proft. What you can do with a mac can be done on a PC with a lower price (and maybe even more powerful hardware) yet there are enough people out there who are willing to pay money for a different type of experience

My point is not about Mac vs. PC, I'm saying it's not all about the price or being free otherwise a company like Apple who charges a premium would have failed already

Netbooks came out with Linux; manufactures realized that people are not interested in Linux and Microsoft realized that they either how to lower their licence fee or missing big. Microsoft lowered the price and manufactures didn't hesitate a second to let go of Linux and go Windows

And seriously the whole issue with fast bootup, with the sleep function in OSX and Windows 7 it takes seconds for the OS to boot up. Even if it takes 45 seconds as opposed to say 15, are we humans that addicted to Internet that 30 seconds of time passeed without surfing the web can be considered a downside? That's sad if it is true!

Google Chrome OS might be interesting for those tech bloggers or "cool" podcast makers, but in real word it offers no advantage over OSX or Windows

PS: 2010 will be the year of linux. How many times I've heard "This year will be the year of linux?"?
 
OpenGL is a mess, like most typical huge OS projects it takes them years to agree on any significant changes, if they come to an agreement at all. How is that better for the consumer?

Thats funny since OGL is controlled by a committee of big software companies(which MS was actually part of) and hardware companies . It was CAD (and to some extent still is) that drove development into CAD.

FOSS lot actually have little to no input into what extension's get added to OGL. FOSS are responsible for implementing the std the committee agree on (in the form of MESA).

YES OGL dev stalled at OGL-1.4 for a very long time (allowing DX9 to come along and exceed it) but this was downto SGI running out of money and couldn't commit to closing the spec to OGL-2.0.
Once the licence got sold OGL has progressed really rapidly (within a month of getting sold OGL-2.0 was finised).
ATM OGL-3.2 does what DX11 does (GFX wise), couple that with OCL and then OAL and you have DX11 match.

API is another thing, you either like it or hate it, a bit like the DX API (and MS insistance on Hungarian notation which is fugly)
 
One thing they missed...

will you ever be able to get Windows 7 legally for free?

Free is a very compelling thing...

Again...what part of Chrome OS is free? You can't download it and install it. The only way to get it is to BUY new hardware. That's not free in my book. Like heatlesssun said people will pay $300 versus $250 to get Windows over a Linux variant.
 
while at the same time being completely open source allowing for better programs, upgrades, and addons to the operating system..QUOTE]

This is the exact argument that the OSX proponents use and it's for the exact same reason. A SERIOUSLY limited hardware base. If it's that good and that stable, why not release it to the general PC community? Oh that's right, because it would DIAF if it had to account for all the different hardware configurations that PC users have.
 
but the one thing we can be guaranteed is that it will be a hell of a lot more stable then windows ever will be and can be..

Darn the no edit button... meant to quote this is my previous post.

This is the exact argument that the OSX proponents use and it's for the exact same reason. A SERIOUSLY limited hardware base. If it's that good and that stable, why not release it to the general PC community? Oh that's right, because it would DIAF if it had to account for all the different hardware configurations that PC users have.
 
Thats funny since OGL is controlled by a committee of big software companies(which MS was actually part of) and hardware companies . It was CAD (and to some extent still is) that drove development into CAD.

FOSS lot actually have little to no input into what extension's get added to OGL. FOSS are responsible for implementing the std the committee agree on (in the form of MESA).

YES OGL dev stalled at OGL-1.4 for a very long time (allowing DX9 to come along and exceed it) but this was downto SGI running out of money and couldn't commit to closing the spec to OGL-2.0.
Once the licence got sold OGL has progressed really rapidly (within a month of getting sold OGL-2.0 was finised).
ATM OGL-3.2 does what DX11 does (GFX wise), couple that with OCL and then OAL and you have DX11 match.

API is another thing, you either like it or hate it, a bit like the DX API (and MS insistance on Hungarian notation which is fugly)

You seem the only one who dislikes DirectX. OpenGL works in Windows, so why aren't developers using it instead to cover all platforms? Why shoot themselves in the foot and limit themselves to Windows and alienate Linux and Apple users?








Wait, don't tell me. Microsoft bribed/threatened/blackmailed/whatever developers being the evil company it is.
 
You seem the only one who dislikes DirectX. OpenGL works in Windows, so why aren't developers using it instead to cover all platforms? Why shoot themselves in the foot and limit themselves to Windows and alienate Linux and Apple users?








Wait, don't tell me. Microsoft bribed/threatened/blackmailed/whatever developers being the evil company it is.

Even Apple fanboys are not really cheering up the Chrome OS, and they'd cheer anything that competes with a Microsoft product
 
It may be OK in a dual boot situation if it boots in just a few seconds, but otherwise completely useless. They just keep trying to sell me cloud computing and I'm just not buying. I want my photos, music and documents in MY posession, not on some server where I have to find some sort of connection to the web to get them.
 
One thing they missed...

will you ever be able to get Windows 7 legally for free?

Free is a very compelling thing...

And it can be a very deceiving thing as well. Google is creating this "free" OS to sell advertising and their services without the need of a third party. There's nothing "free" about it.

Anyone who doesn't get that is just denying the truth of big business.
 
My main thing is that I still don't buy the whole netbook craze. On a fundamental level I don't agree with Chrome OS because it is geared towards that platform. For those sort of functions with an on-the-go type device I would rather have a Blackberry or iPhone, and for everything else there are proper notebooks.

But I dunno, I could be very very wrong. The sales numbers for netbooks, how it has allowed companies like Acer to eat into Dell's marketshare in a significant way, still kind of blows my mind. I could completely be missing the point here.
 
My main thing is that I still don't buy the whole netbook craze. On a fundamental level I don't agree with Chrome OS because it is geared towards that platform.


Netbook is more a moniker, than a description of functionality. These are still functional computers. I could own one of those, because they are useful without connectivity.

What Google is proposing is much less than netbook functionality.

I have zero interest in something that is basically useless when not cloud connected. It is the philosophy I have issue with, not the hardware.
 
My main thing is that I still don't buy the whole netbook craze. On a fundamental level I don't agree with Chrome OS because it is geared towards that platform. For those sort of functions with an on-the-go type device I would rather have a Blackberry or iPhone, and for everything else there are proper notebooks.

But I dunno, I could be very very wrong. The sales numbers for netbooks, how it has allowed companies like Acer to eat into Dell's marketshare in a significant way, still kind of blows my mind. I could completely be missing the point here.

I also dont buy into the netbook craze as i love my core2duo lappy and do not mind it's 4 hour battery life, but i do love what came out of the netbook idea - low cost, low energy, yet powerful HTPC specs, ala ION and Atom.

The whole netbook/Atom dealie also contributed into pushing Adobe into developing a better Flash version which had been long needed.

I'm sure netbooks also spawned and pushed other technology that had been slow coming to us, such as SSD and touchscreens (which tablet notebooks never suceeded in making users aware of).

So even though i'll never get a netbook, i'll always be grateful for what resulted from their existence.



Posted from mobile device
 
You seem the only one who dislikes DirectX. OpenGL works in Windows, so why aren't developers using it instead to cover all platforms? Why shoot themselves in the foot and limit themselves to Windows and alienate Linux and Apple users?

Three reasons:

1. Until recently, developing stuff in OpenGL has been a PITA. By my understanding the more recent versions of it have improved on that a lot, in addition to bringing it back to feature parity (or near to it) with DX11.

2. The bungling of the standard for a long time has made for a situation where GFX drivers tend to suck for it. This seems to be improving some too, with Nvidia, AMD, and Intel all working on or having released 3.2 drivers. Still a long way to go.

3. Companies have largely dismissed those user bases, which admittedly it was pretty easy to do when they accounted for about 2% of desktop users. Mac OSX has grown quite a bit lately and frankly, the reported install base for desktop Linux is well below what it likely is.

OpenGL isn't exactly going to regain the share that it lost on desktop software development anytime soon, but the trend is a positive one and indie devs at least are experiencing a good deal of success when they release Mac/Linux versions of their games. That gives me some hope for the future.
 
So yeah, I was trying out that VMWare image of ChromeOS. It's like...imagine running the Chrome web browser in Windows...

...and then imagine, if you will, taking out the whole "Windows" aspect of it. Yeah. It's like that. ChromeOS = not for me. At all.
 
My main thing is that I still don't buy the whole netbook craze. On a fundamental level I don't agree with Chrome OS because it is geared towards that platform. For those sort of functions with an on-the-go type device I would rather have a Blackberry or iPhone, and for everything else there are proper notebooks.

But I dunno, I could be very very wrong. The sales numbers for netbooks, how it has allowed companies like Acer to eat into Dell's marketshare in a significant way, still kind of blows my mind. I could completely be missing the point here.

I'm with you

Real Computer =

OSX, Windows are fully capable of doing everything. Even Linux (for those who want Linux no matter what) can get most of the stuff done

Portable Computing =

Laptops are more affordable than ever. Plus netbooks already do what customers need (and I dont like netbooks either, at least with the current level of performance) and there is no point in re-inventing the wheel

Everyday portability =

Smartphones are able to do the most basic functions including email and web. Granted they have a small screen but they are meant to portable in all situations

Google Chrome OS really has no target market except Google's preferred "everything cloud" platform. Instead of an OS, Google should make Chrome OS a suit and put it on every OS. That would be a far better option and also less expensive
 
Three reasons:

1. Until recently, developing stuff in OpenGL has been a PITA. By my understanding the more recent versions of it have improved on that a lot, in addition to bringing it back to feature parity (or near to it) with DX11.

2. The bungling of the standard for a long time has made for a situation where GFX drivers tend to suck for it. This seems to be improving some too, with Nvidia, AMD, and Intel all working on or having released 3.2 drivers. Still a long way to go.

3. Companies have largely dismissed those user bases, which admittedly it was pretty easy to do when they accounted for about 2% of desktop users. Mac OSX has grown quite a bit lately and frankly, the reported install base for desktop Linux is well below what it likely is.

OpenGL isn't exactly going to regain the share that it lost on desktop software development anytime soon, but the trend is a positive one and indie devs at least are experiencing a good deal of success when they release Mac/Linux versions of their games. That gives me some hope for the future.

What makes you think that Linux desktop users are undercounted? These numbers come from net usage primarily so I'm not sure why the number would be way off.

And even if the numbers for Linux are a little low and with increased Mac market share which has occurred only in the US for the most part the Mac has NEVER been a gaming platform and Linux users just aren't going to buy much software.

Everytime I say that desktop Linux users just aren't the software buying type of crowd I do hear people say I have that all wrong but I challenge the average Linux user to give me there annual software budget and compare it to mine. Including games and not including software for my mobile device I spend about $2500 on software almost EVERY year. Now that's a bit high for probably even a hardcore Windows user but people like simply don't exist in the desktop Linux world.
 
Steve why did you pick the worst written & least informative article on Chrome OS? There are litterely dozens of blogs/news/OpEds that are 100x better than the one you picked to be on the front page.
 
Google Chrome OS really has no target market except Google's preferred "everything cloud" platform. Instead of an OS, Google should make Chrome OS a suit and put it on every OS. That would be a far better option and also less expensive

Good point about smart phones. And the thing about the Google "everything cloud" is that with the Chrome OS its also "nothing but". This is a web appliance and if treated as such then it can find a home. But there are tons of web appliances out there already including smart phones.
 
Personally, I think its a great idea. Great for those that can't afford a Mac, but only use internet related services (email, web surfing, youtubing, chat, forums, blogging etc etc)

Also, would be nice to have this as option on my desktop because to be able to boot up into an OS is a chore for me at times JUST to check movie times or read that important email.
 
Well, if you have to log in each time you boot your machine, what do you do if you use a really strong password, of mixed upper/lower-case, numbers and stuff? It can be a real pain to type that in each time you boot up your machine.
 
One thing they missed...

will you ever be able to get Windows 7 legally for free?

Free is a very compelling thing...

I have a free pile of crap for you! WOW IT'S FREE IT MUST BE AWESOME! Wait a second... :rolleyes: .

Seriously... it's not free anyway, you're talking tons of time/money/resources porting apps, databases, re-training yourself and staff, etc. to switch to Linux, not to mention craploads of QA and testing. It is free insofar as the license, but it's not free.
 
Netbook is more a moniker, than a description of functionality. These are still functional computers. I could own one of those, because they are useful without connectivity.

What Google is proposing is much less than netbook functionality.

I have zero interest in something that is basically useless when not cloud connected. It is the philosophy I have issue with, not the hardware.

Good points.

One thing just occurred to me though: HTML5 provides building blocks that application authors can use to write apps that will work with or without an internet connection. I can only assume that this is one of the things that Chrome OS will be leaning heavily on. A computer that is only useful when plugged into the internet... isn't.
 
I mostly agree with his points. The success of ChromeOS has little to do with google, and more to do with people's willingness to live in cloud computing.

I for one, have no use for it, as with most people I know.

Sadly as much as I love google stuff (wave, gmail, voice), It's like backtrack, but a google editions. Built from Linux, and Suse to be more specific. If I want Linux, I'll use linux... not Chrome OS.
 
Personally, I think its a great idea. Great for those that can't afford a Mac, but only use internet related services (email, web surfing, youtubing, chat, forums, blogging etc etc)

Also, would be nice to have this as option on my desktop because to be able to boot up into an OS is a chore for me at times JUST to check movie times or read that important email.

Depends on how much it costs. You can get a Windows 7 laptop now for $300 that does all of this and a lot more. Sure, you don't have to worry about local malware but then you can't play a DVD either.

I think these things will have to be ULTRA cheap or even free for people to buy them in the consumer world. I could see businesses more interested in them than consumers.
 
Depends on how much it costs. You can get a Windows 7 laptop now for $300 that does all of this and a lot more. Sure, you don't have to worry about local malware but then you can't play a DVD either.

I think these things will have to be ULTRA cheap or even free for people to buy them in the consumer world. I could see businesses more interested in them than consumers.

But even then if they can't attach to group policy would businesses use it? They would have to adopt the cloud as well. I can see startups go this route at first but if they grow I just don't see them sticking with it once they need something more robust.
 
Here's a link to a much better and more informative article:
http://arstechnica.com/open-source/news/2009/11/chromeos-announcement.ars

Doesn't change the basic issue. Which is data in the net cloud vs on your device.

I think this is a clear limitation that most people don't want.

Also it is a more expensive choice. Storage is comparatively cheap compared to net bandwidth (especially wireless net bandwidth).

Living the cloud is fine for a Google Billionaire, but for people who work for a living, it is too spendthrift of a choice.
 
Doesn't change the basic issue. Which is data in the net cloud vs on your device.

I think this is a clear limitation that most people don't want.

Also it is a more expensive choice. Storage is comparatively cheap compared to net bandwidth (especially wireless net bandwidth).

Living the cloud is fine for a Google Billionaire, but for people who work for a living, it is too spendthrift of a choice.

Well it kind of looks like it will support external storage. So ala Apple AirBook you just bring your external storage with you. I personally just don't believe in having my data stored somewhere else. I just don't. That your life someone is hosting and I would much rather come up with my own storage solution that I can access when I need to.

There's nothing stopping me from creating my own cloud and storing my files there. Preferably in a place that I own.
 
google virtually failed everything other than the search engine, and the search engine is getting worse and worse
 
Google Chrome OS has the word "failure" all over it

The best they can hope to do is to enlist the help of Mac and Google tech friendly journalists (like Cnet or Wired) which happen to be over 95% of all the tech journalists nowadays to hype this thing up and push the "everything cloud" down everyone's throat

It's funny how they make such a big deal about the bootup time. Put Windows on a SSD (which Google Chrome OS requires) and boot times will be significantly faster compared to traditional HDDs (ignoring the fact that sleep mode exists in Windows 7)

I guess we'll see
 
I have a free pile of crap for you! WOW IT'S FREE IT MUST BE AWESOME! Wait a second... :rolleyes: .

Seriously... it's not free anyway, you're talking tons of time/money/resources porting apps, databases, re-training yourself and staff, etc. to switch to Linux, not to mention craploads of QA and testing. It is free insofar as the license, but it's not free.

Yeah, that's the price you pay for being a fucking idiot and not going with Linux OSes for a large network in the first place.
 
great for your average desktop consumer that does some quick web browsing and emailing, but corporate clients will look elsewhere. Google's ultimate goal in the end for all their products is to "borrow" your usage statistics and track what youdo. They are the ultimate "nice" big brother. Every search you make, every email you read is seen by google employees. They know what you are doing at all times and are logging it.
 
google virtually failed everything other than the search engine, and the search engine is getting worse and worse

Google Inc. (Public, NASDAQ:GOOG)
569.94

People who have and use real money tend to disagree.
 
Back
Top