Which MMO?

Justin Cider

Weaksauce
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
67
I was wondering which of the current MMO games is the most fun.I would like to start to get into MMOs and I don't want to waste time and money on a crap one.I used to play D&D online and found it fun but it got a little boring after a while.I did try WoW for a bit although I liked it I found it got repetitive real quick,maybe it has changed since the expansions I don't know.I have been considering looking at Warhammer Online and AoC and I was wondering what peoples' opinions about them are.If you guys and girls could help me pick between WoW,Warhammer and AoC it would be appreciated.

Thanks in advance
 
City of Heroes is fun, but I don't know if someone can play that game for longer than a year.
 
ive tried a lot and always came back to wow...since the expansions there is a lot of other things to do to keep you occupied and when you need a break from quest grinding
 
Unless you have friends playing with you, I would just try several trials and make your own opinions. Personally for me I am just burned out on MMOs and never make it through the first free month without getting bored.
 
Don't waste your time on an MMO. They require so much time to get anywhere in the game, you have to treat it like a full time job to get anywhere.
 
I was wondering which of the current MMO games is the most fun.I would like to start to get into MMOs and I don't want to waste time and money on a crap one.I used to play D&D online and found it fun but it got a little boring after a while.I did try WoW for a bit although I liked it I found it got repetitive real quick,maybe it has changed since the expansions I don't know.I have been considering looking at Warhammer Online and AoC and I was wondering what peoples' opinions about them are.If you guys and girls could help me pick between WoW,Warhammer and AoC it would be appreciated.

Thanks in advance

What did you like and not like about WoW? Its hard just to recommend something with this little to go on. Heck Lord of the Rings online might be something you like too.
 
What did you like and not like about WoW? Its hard just to recommend something with this little to go on. Heck Lord of the Rings online might be something you like too.

I found it to be very repetitive,mind you I tried it when it first came out and it seemed that the quests were pretty linear.I mean just seemed that I was killing the same monsters over and over the same way,maybe has to do with the way I played.I don't know really
 
I found it to be very repetitive,mind you I tried it when it first came out and it seemed that the quests were pretty linear.I mean just seemed that I was killing the same monsters over and over the same way,maybe has to do with the way I played.I don't know really

Unfortunately, that's the nature of MMOs. Leveling and progressing will be linear and you'll find quests to be the same with slight differences: kill x of this critter, report to y person, collect z plants, etc. Even when looking at it from a PVP perspective, you'll probably be using the same spells during battle. Doesn't sound like a MMO is for you.
 
I found it to be very repetitive,mind you I tried it when it first came out and it seemed that the quests were pretty linear.I mean just seemed that I was killing the same monsters over and over the same way,maybe has to do with the way I played.I don't know really

Well if you just want to kill other players instead, then check out WAR. All MMOs are one type of grind or another. At least in WAR you can do the standard "Kick 7 chickens then return for reward" style of quests when you want, or just go kill other players in scenarios or open RVR and get XP + gear through that.
 
City of Heroes is fun, but I don't know if someone can play that game for longer than a year.

They can, but God knows how. I think the content gets incredibly boring after about the second or third time doing it, and there is no endgame at all.

But then again I don't see how anybody plays any MMO for longer than a few months straight.
 
The problems with a lot of mmos is the downtime. I dont mean server downtime either. A lot of time is spent doing simply nothing. Waiting to get enough people in your party to go to a dungeon, oops someone left your party, and now you have to wait to fill his slot.

Mmos arent games that you can just drop in and out of like an online fps.
 
Don't waste your time on an MMO. They require so much time to get anywhere in the game, you have to treat it like a full time job to get anywhere.

No thats just BAD MMO's like WoW where the system is based of grinding for rewards both in giving you gear but access to better content.

In a good MMO like Warhammer online, you can do all the games different types of content from the very second you make a character.

People have been conditioned to think like this because too many MMOs follow WoWs business model which is to make people grind for long periods of time in order to keep them subbed longer, opposed to a smarter way of doing it by making the game fun to play and desireable.
 
I was wondering which of the current MMO games is the most fun.I would like to start to get into MMOs and I don't want to waste time and money on a crap one.I used to play D&D online and found it fun but it got a little boring after a while.I did try WoW for a bit although I liked it I found it got repetitive real quick,maybe it has changed since the expansions I don't know.I have been considering looking at Warhammer Online and AoC and I was wondering what peoples' opinions about them are.If you guys and girls could help me pick between WoW,Warhammer and AoC it would be appreciated.

Thanks in advance

IIRC, MMO stands for massive multiplayer online, so if your asking what game you should play thats massive, and multiplayer online, I'd say Team Fortress 2 or World in Conflict (if your into RTS game you owe it to yourself to give this game a shot), but it sounds like your looking for an RPG:

WoW is flawed in that you dont really get a feeling for the real core gameplay (raids/battlegrounds/arena) aspects until you've put at least 48 hrs of played in game time into it. So in that sense, you really gotta hit level 70 before you can make an accurate judgement of what wow is like.

but in terms of free games, give ragnarok a try. Its very basic but the hundreds of different servers and thus different server configs mean your likly to find one that's just right. (ps if you do play ragnarok, make a monk/champion. Asura strike kicks ass).
 
No thats just BAD MMO's like WoW where the system is based of grinding for rewards both in giving you gear but access to better content.

In a good MMO like Warhammer online, you can do all the games different types of content from the very second you make a character.

People have been conditioned to think like this because too many MMOs follow WoWs business model which is to make people grind for long periods of time in order to keep them subbed longer, opposed to a smarter way of doing it by making the game fun to play and desireable.

What? Doesn't warhammer have tiers? And don't people just grind out XP in whatever is the most optimal battleground (no I don't care if they don't like it called that - that is what it is) for doing so?

Not saying he wouldn't like Warhammer or that the game sucks, but pretending it is somehow totally different than other MMOs is just silly. Just like those dumb "we don't let things rely on the random number generator! You get rewarded for what you do!" group quest things. Looks like they just put a rng on quests too if you ask me, you can still put the most in on the board and lose.

But yes, if you mainly want to PvP, I would check out Warhammer. Just don't pretend it is something it isn't.
 
GO Warhammer all the other mmo's fail in comparison. Just make sure you get on a higher population server.
 
Play single player RPGs instead. You get much better story, more meaningful character progression, more in depth gameplay and all in MUCH, MUCH less time.
 
Play single player RPGs instead. You get much better story, more meaningful character progression, more in depth gameplay and all in MUCH, MUCH less time.

ill have to say i agree with him... get a good driven RPG and play the hell out of it.

The witcher is great for that
 
Hate repeating myself but look into Darkfall Online.

It's supposed to release after beta ends in Dec. No levels to grind. No class restrictions. Twitch based combat. Full loot pvp with no safe zones.
 
I found WAR to be more of a grind than WoW. Personally, I like WoW a lot more. When I first started WoW it took me a good year before I was bored of it. I keep coming back for about 4 months at a time with a month or two break in between. I got bored of WAR in two weeks. YMMV.
 
Play with friends. Then you can do stupid shit, useless shit, annoying shit, any kind of shit and it is still somewhat entertaining.
 
Play with friends. Then you can do stupid shit, useless shit, annoying shit, any kind of shit and it is still somewhat entertaining.

Amen to this.

Also, not all MMO games are "grinding for gear" based.

City of Heroes certainly isn't. I beat the drum for this game a lot but it's because it doesn't follow the WoW standard of being gear based and the costume creator is bar none the best in the business.

And City of Heroes is just plain fun, for me anyway. There are plenty of people who hated it just like there are plenty of people who hated Crysis.

In addition the community is much, MUCH more mature, friendly and accomodating to new players than some MMO's I have played. If you happen to post a question in the official forums you won't get a steady stream of vitriol but rather helpful answers.
 
What? Doesn't warhammer have tiers? And don't people just grind out XP in whatever is the most optimal battleground (no I don't care if they don't like it called that - that is what it is) for doing so?

Not saying he wouldn't like Warhammer or that the game sucks, but pretending it is somehow totally different than other MMOs is just silly. Just like those dumb "we don't let things rely on the random number generator! You get rewarded for what you do!" group quest things. Looks like they just put a rng on quests too if you ask me, you can still put the most in on the board and lose.

But yes, if you mainly want to PvP, I would check out Warhammer. Just don't pretend it is something it isn't.

Warhammer has tiers but higher tiers don't have much different content from the low tiers, people just have more spells and abilities by then, and in general the focus shifts more towards PvP activities like more RvR and bigger RvR.

There are some things you need to level to get access to, Im not sure when the first dungeon is, but it's not available straight away, but RvR, scenarios, PQ's, PvE, you can jump into them all straight away at the start.

Some people do "grind" in as much as they find the best way to gain exp and keep doing that to reach level 40 as fast as possible, but there's no inherent benefit of doing so, in fact due to lower numbers of population being a high level at the moment, it means theres less RvR in higher levels for the moment.

Just because some people chose to grind, doesn't mean you have to grind, theres a very distinct difference. If you disagree then please give an example of why you HAVE to grind.

Theres other MMOs that have similar design, games like planetside allowed you access to most of the content at the start of the game but you could only access certain weapons/features at once, the more you played the more features you could unlock at once but there was very little that long term players could have that new players couldn't have after 30 mins of play.

I found WAR to be more of a grind than WoW. Personally, I like WoW a lot more. When I first started WoW it took me a good year before I was bored of it. I keep coming back for about 4 months at a time with a month or two break in between. I got bored of WAR in two weeks. YMMV.

What may I ask where you grinding for exactly, it sounds like you HAD to grind for something, im wondering what that is?
 
What may I ask where you grinding for exactly, it sounds like you HAD to grind for something, im wondering what that is?

Well, the quests in WAR were just as shallow as WoW's, in my opinion. I didn't feel any different doing them than I did when doing WoW's. Still felt like a "quest grind" or whatever the heck you wanna call it. In Tier 3 when the quests started running a bit dry, you pretty much have to do scenarios. I thought scenarios were boring and got old quick, just my opinion. PQs are lame, too. Cool in theory, but they're just a way to mask rep grinds.

WAR and WoW both have the same thing in common... they're MMOs! That's the nature of the beast. I'm not saying one is superior or inferior, just people parade around saying WAR is soooo much better and levelling is actually fun! etc. It's the same thing, doing a quest over and over again. Just do whichever you like more, GL HF DD.
 
Well i think you're wrong, I think WAR is more acccessible because you can play a lot of the content straight away, and it's more varied. I see no reason to grind for higher levels other than that what you're used to doing in WoW and can't help it.

Im been leveling quite fast and am level 32 now, I dont consider anything I've done as grinding, everytime I log in a try a bit of everything, SC, RvR, PvE and PQ's, it keeps it varied and I dont get bored of any one thing.

I think maybe a lot of it is your mindset.
 
I think maybe a lot of it is your mindset.

This. And people have a different idea of what grinding is so that changes this up...

In WAR you can do three fairly different things for XP and gear. So you can either do the RVR (3+ RVR levels per tier), PQs with friends, or grind out some quests. And you get the choice of doing PQ and quests in 3 completely different areas depending on if you play Order or Destruction. So sure, maybe you are just making a decision between collecting 15 skulls or 15 branches going between the zones, however at least you get that choice.

In WoW when BC came out here is what everyone did.

1) Do the same collection of quests everyone else is doing in Hellfire Pennisula. When you have done almost all the quests, proceed to Zangarmarsh.
2) Do the same collection of quests everyone else is doing in Zangarmarsh. When you have done almost all the quests, proceed to Nagrand.
3) Do the same collection of quests everyone else is doing in Nagrand. When you have done almost all the quests, proceed to Terokar.

Or maybe it was Terokar before Nagrand, but really WoW is as linear of a grind as you can get...
 
EVE Online, of course. All the other MMO's on the market are for little kids. :p

/puts on flame retardant suit
 
This. And people have a different idea of what grinding is so that changes this up...

In WAR you can do three fairly different things for XP and gear. So you can either do the RVR (3+ RVR levels per tier), PQs with friends, or grind out some quests. And you get the choice of doing PQ and quests in 3 completely different areas depending on if you play Order or Destruction. So sure, maybe you are just making a decision between collecting 15 skulls or 15 branches going between the zones, however at least you get that choice.

In WoW when BC came out here is what everyone did.

1) Do the same collection of quests everyone else is doing in Hellfire Pennisula. When you have done almost all the quests, proceed to Zangarmarsh.
2) Do the same collection of quests everyone else is doing in Zangarmarsh. When you have done almost all the quests, proceed to Nagrand.
3) Do the same collection of quests everyone else is doing in Nagrand. When you have done almost all the quests, proceed to Terokar.

Or maybe it was Terokar before Nagrand, but really WoW is as linear of a grind as you can get...

Eh, my point was that they are almost exactly the same. One just has more of a PvE focus and the other PvP. You list 'RVR (3+ RVR levels per tier), PQs with friends, or grind out some quests', not really any different from instances in WoW, group quests, and solo grinding.

Stating it to be extremely linear is also somewhat misleading. For the most part yes everyone does a lot of the same content, but there is variation. I have done over 1k quests according to the new achievement thing, but I haven't come close to doing all the ones in outland let alone the old world. I could have ended up in plenty of different places doing plenty of different things and still arrived at the level cap. You can also pick between the two and mix things up. Since I was leveling as a prot Warrior and lots of people wanted instances, I actually ended up questing in Hellfire, Nagrand, and then Netherstorm on the way to 70. I didn't even see the other zones until I went back and did quests there for gold / just for the fun of doing them at 70. The rest of my XP came from running instances and a few group quests.

Again, not saying one is flawed, but I just keep seeing people pointing this stuff out like it is totally different. Looks almost exactly the same to me. One PvP focused and one PvE focused, but still largely traditional MMOs. Nothing wrong with that either, different things for different people.
 
Don't waste your time on an MMO. They require so much time to get anywhere in the game, you have to treat it like a full time job to get anywhere.
So true but they are still fun to play.
I wish I had the time to try new MMOs but I don't even have time these days to even play normal games.

To the OP, not sure if you tried Guild Wars. If you have not its a nice game and no monthly fees is always good.
 
So true but they are still fun to play.
I wish I had the time to try new MMOs but I don't even have time these days to even play normal games.

To the OP, not sure if you tried Guild Wars. If you have not its a nice game and no monthly fees is always good.

MMO's aren't time sinks unless you let them be time sinks.

Any game can be consuming but only if you let them.

Its the person, not the game, that determines how much time is dedicated.
 
As resident AoC pundit of doom for that game, I'm telling you don't bother.

I'm willing to fire you off a trial key if you feel like downloading a double-digit gigabytes game install. And Jesus Christ, I just looked at my install folder for the game, it's at 30gb+

Also I'd have to find my box, gotta be around here somewhere...
 
I am waiting to see how Mortal Online comes along. Yes, it is going to be a long wait.
 
Only one I am waiting for is Knight Old Republic and Star Trek MMO. I have played all the major ones and have yet to get a complete level character. I always get bored or just feel why am I playing this and quit. My favorite's were City of Heroes and LOTRO I loved cities hero creation and lotro had the best lore and massive enviroments making you feel you are in a realy universe.
 
Warhammer is great. WoW was boring after you leveled up, and AoC just plain sucked.
 
I find Final Fantasy XI to be pretty awesome, been playing it for a few years now. Sure it is pretty old compared to most of the other suggestions, but it does have quite a bit of story missions (~6 story lines). The story missions can get quite challenging and the story/cutscenes are pretty good. There are always people leveling low level characters so you shouldn't have any problems finding groups either (FFXI is heavily party based, extremely difficult to do anything worthwhile solo). At endgame, there is quite a bit of available content to keep you busy. Though be warned, FFXI seems to take a lot more of a time investment to get anywhere than other MMOs.
 
This is turning into quite the debate,I see strengths in almost every reply.I don't know,all the different opinions is seems to be making this harder than I thought.Thanks to everyone keep 'em coming
 
To be honest if you really thought wow was repetetive your shouldnt be looking for an MMO. Youll just be wasting your money.
 
To be honest if you really thought wow was repetetive your shouldnt be looking for an MMO. Youll just be wasting your money.

When you add in PVP it completely changes the landscape though. It forces people to be aware of what they are doing in PVE for they might be killed by some random dude at any time.
 
I'm going to go with an other MMO; Vanguard. Yes, it had a horrible launch but in the past 2 years the game has been greatly enhanced, most of the bugs and performance issue are gone, It has a large non instanced world, fun classes and a great community. It has a free 14 day trial, I would give it a shot.
 
Back
Top