I'm going to go with an other MMO; Vanguard. Yes, it had a horrible launch but in the past 2 years the game has been greatly enhanced, most of the bugs and performance issue are gone, It has a large non instanced world, fun classes and a great community. It has a free 14 day trial, I would give it a shot.
I played vanguard at launch and played it again about 3 months ago and can tell you its barely any better than launch and the community is the smallest i have ever seen in any MMO. Everquest feels more populated than vanguard.
When you add in PVP it completely changes the landscape though. It forces people to be aware of what they are doing in PVE for they might be killed by some random dude at any time.
How is that any different than wow? Its funny how all the WAR fans are acting like WAR is the first game with good PVP like WAR didnt take 90% of thier PVP ideas directly from wow.