What Touchscreen Surfaces Were Made For

yea i think RTS games tend to work very well for touchscreens if they have all the commands on the screen so you dont have to use a keyboard
 
yea i think RTS games tend to work very well for touchscreens if they have all the commands on the screen so you dont have to use a keyboard

QFT, the guy seems to handle the screen pretty fast, faster than pointing and clicking with a mouse... and it works pretty well too...
 
no thanks, apart from looking really silly, it looks like it's just not very practical.
 
Looks pretty cool. I can see that video helping sell some touchscreen tables. :)
 
i'm not soldon it for RTS,

i can see touchscreen gaming to be very slow and cumbersome. Its hard to think thatyou can be just as quick and precise with a touchscreen. For view control, sure touch screening is awesome but for practicality of use in this case i don't think so.

Now for Flight Sims, Racing Sims etc.. , couple TrackIR with Touchscreen gaming and lookout!!!
 
According to Vid xbox 360 and ps3.

I'd like to to see it running with Natal, since getting your hands in the way of the screen and on top of it is still a No No for me.
 
A really slow RTS that doesn't require many actions per minute would be fine on it. Also a turn based or pausable real time strategy game would be ok, such as the total war series.
 
Ok I think anyone can agree they can navigate the map and issue commands way faster then that using a mouse. Poor implementation here, but yes it is great for RTS. I would have an adjustable navigational map overlay you can tap to instantly go to the action instead of silly scrolling over a mile of map. The key in RTS is to be able to issue complex commands very quickly.

I *still* say use a large high resolution variable pressure multitouchpad that sildes out from under the keyboard. It would show overlays where your fingers are located on the screen. Would cost way less, would stop fingerprints, your mongoloid arms and hands won't be blocking the view of the screen, you wouldn't have to stare downwards at a table either. The downside to this idea is you won't develop those muscles from waving your arms around for hours on end.
 
I don't know, it looks like a real pain to use in the video.

Might be cool in theory, but I think the technology has a long way to go.
 
Well, now we can see the need for all this hardware - a 6 core Core I7 (with Hyperthreading), 12+ GB RAM, multiple graphics cards.

And of course this is early implementation stuff, so it will be both rough around the edges but also just hinting at the eventual capability once this is mature.
 
Nice, except I can do all of that with a mouse and keyboard twice as fast and not have to buy stock in windex.

Sorry, for gaming touchscreens are a gimmick.
 
...umm i thought they were made for pr0n :D
 
I don't play many RTS games, but that implementation just looks amazing. I want one of those, too bad they are probably too expensive right now.
 
Now for Flight Sims, Racing Sims etc.. , couple TrackIR with Touchscreen gaming and lookout!!!

No exactly HOTAS, but the occasional "real" button press would be nice.

... your mongoloid arms and hands won't be blocking the view of the screen...

This. Through that whole demo I kept thinking "Get out of the way, I want to see what's going on!"
 
Touch screens are NOT a gimmick. The interfaces just aren't quite there yet for gaming. This looks promising, though. All the haters need to get an imagination.
 
As already said, RTS games would probably work well with touchscreens, if they haven't a really fast gameplay. I think it would still take a long time before touchsreens get widely used in this way, also this would probably be ridiculously expensive and still needs to be improved. Though I still would prefer a mouse.
 
Well if I ever have to come up with a way to burn $15,000 really quick -- this would certainly be on the list of options!
 
Wow, you guys are idiots. Not only does this game look terribly gimmicky, but you are falling for a stupid and crappy touch screen demenstration. Who cares if it looks slightly cool. Hell the videos of the guy playing starcraft on a touch screen looked cool, yet its not practical or fun to constantly putting in so much effort to move units around.

I bet this game will get less than an 80%~ and most of the reviews will say "it had good concepts, but was implemented poorly" or "that it looks fun to play, but isn't because of the limited way the game was designed."

PS. I will bump this thread when I am right. Also if I am wrong, please someone else bump it to prove how ignorant I was.
 
Touch screens are NOT a gimmick. The interfaces just aren't quite there yet for gaming. This looks promising, though. All the haters need to get an imagination.

Uh yea they are for gaming bud, sorry to burst your bubble. In gaming especially competitive games like RTS (Which are all fast paced, not like Turn based), speed is everything. Something like this looks cool but that is about it. Having your hands spread out all over the place is vastly inferior to a high speed mouse and a hand full of well designed hotkeys. The touch screen offers 1:1 movement, in other words you have to move your arms/hands the distance you want to move your units. A highly sensitive mouse however offers far more in that I can set the dpi extremely high and scroll the entire screen with extremely small movements and adjust that sensitivity at the touch of a button. So that puts the touch screen at an insurmountable disadvantage when it comes to gaming.

Sure they look cool, but at the end of the day the person using the touch screen is going to be at a huge disadvantage and just get the crap kicked out of them time and time again. Much like mouse and keyboard pilots in dog fighting games get the crap kicked out of them religiously by those who use a joystick. One interface is just flatly superior if all other things are equal.
 
I have a few comments that I don't think anyone else has posted so far:

1.) That guy gets paid to play that all day? :cool:
2.) Imagine how much ZAGG's InvisibleShield screeen protector is going to cost to protect that screeen. :eek:
3.) I bet the Japanese are working on a virtual girlfriend "game" that can be used on a large touchscreen like that. :eek:
 
Uh yea they are for gaming bud, sorry to burst your bubble. In gaming especially competitive games like RTS (Which are all fast paced, not like Turn based), speed is everything. Something like this looks cool but that is about it. Having your hands spread out all over the place is vastly inferior to a high speed mouse and a hand full of well designed hotkeys. The touch screen offers 1:1 movement, in other words you have to move your arms/hands the distance you want to move your units. A highly sensitive mouse however offers far more in that I can set the dpi extremely high and scroll the entire screen with extremely small movements and adjust that sensitivity at the touch of a button. So that puts the touch screen at an insurmountable disadvantage when it comes to gaming.

Sure they look cool, but at the end of the day the person using the touch screen is going to be at a huge disadvantage and just get the crap kicked out of them time and time again. Much like mouse and keyboard pilots in dog fighting games get the crap kicked out of them religiously by those who use a joystick. One interface is just flatly superior if all other things are equal.

If we were talking about dropping a touch screen on top of Starcraft, you'd be absolutely correct. But nobody is talking about playing Starcraft with a touch screen. Starcraft was designed for a keyboard, so to say a touch screen wouldn't work well with "current" competitive RTS games is pretty banal "bud".

Touchscreens bring the interface and the visualization together and that gives designers options. Yes, you have to move your hands around the screen, but how far, and how selection is done is completely up to the designer, we're no longer restricted by our hardware and that is HUGE, for any genre. It brings down a wall and if you think, as adoption of these devices grows, that designers won't find ingenious ways to take advantage of this to gaming's benefit, you're at best myopic and at worst a moron.
 
If we were talking about dropping a touch screen on top of Starcraft, you'd be absolutely correct. But nobody is talking about playing Starcraft with a touch screen. Starcraft was designed for a keyboard, so to say a touch screen wouldn't work well with "current" competitive RTS games is pretty banal "bud".

Touchscreens bring the interface and the visualization together and that gives designers options. Yes, you have to move your hands around the screen, but how far, and how selection is done is completely up to the designer, we're no longer restricted by our hardware and that is HUGE, for any genre. It brings down a wall and if you think, as adoption of these devices grows, that designers won't find ingenious ways to take advantage of this to gaming's benefit, you're at best myopic and at worst a moron.

Sorry you don't seem to understand basic physics here. 1:1 movement will Never be equal to an interface that offers 2:1 movement or better. It doesn't matter what nifty little innovations they add into touchscreens, you are still limited to the area you are touching. This is a hard fast rule, not some debatable point. Having to move your arms 1 real foot vs twitching your wrist will never be superior no matter how many ingenious innovations they add into the touchscreen. So before you go and start hurling insults at someone, get a better understanding of the material you are debating before you end up looking like a fool again. Also while you are at it, learn something about the dynamics of competitive gaming vs single player as that is an entirely different world that you clearly don't understand.

From a work perspective touchscreens are a fantastic innovation. From a gaming perspective they are a gimmick pure and simple. The only genre they "might" not be a disadvantage are Turn based strategies, however they still won't be superior to a mouse and keyboard.
 
"Cool", yes.
"Functional?" I don't know.

I still don't see everyone sitting around their little touchscreen tables moving their hands around a screen for an hour or more playing a game. Keeping your hands still and letting just your fingers rapidly hit buttons is still more efficient.
And what about multiplayer?


Touchscreens IMO are still a fad.

They work great for kiosks and stuff, but for actual devices in the business/home I don't see them working out very well. I think we could see something more along the lines of Natal take affect before touchscreens would.
 
Sorry you don't seem to understand basic physics here. 1:1 movement will Never be equal to an interface that offers 2:1 movement or better. It doesn't matter what nifty little innovations they add into touchscreens, you are still limited to the area you are touching. This is a hard fast rule, not some debatable point. Having to move your arms 1 real foot vs twitching your wrist will never be superior no matter how many ingenious innovations they add into the touchscreen. So before you go and start hurling insults at someone, get a better understanding of the material you are debating before you end up looking like a fool again. Also while you are at it, learn something about the dynamics of competitive gaming vs single player as that is an entirely different world that you clearly don't understand.

From a work perspective touchscreens are a fantastic innovation. From a gaming perspective they are a gimmick pure and simple. The only genre they "might" not be a disadvantage are Turn based strategies, however they still won't be superior to a mouse and keyboard.
Haha, first of all, I do play competitive RTS including Starcraft, CoH, and Supcom. There is no reason touch screens have to be 1:1. Your condescension is pretty pathetic for someone whose actually not managed to make a point yet. 1:1 would be a point, except for the fact it's not actually a limitation. The neat thing about touch screens is they can be ANY interface that is required at the time, which leads to more context sensitive interfaces.
 
I thought this was going to be a demo of some kind of porn game....perhaps this says more about me being a man-slut more than anything :p
 
Yes, you have to move your hands around the screen, but how far, and how selection is done is completely up to the designer

Just highlighting that I addressed 1:1 in my first post while I was making a fool of myself and not knowing my source material.
 
Haha, first of all, I do play competitive RTS including Starcraft, CoH, and Supcom. There is no reason touch screens have to be 1:1. Your condescension is pretty pathetic for someone whose actually not managed to make a point yet. 1:1 would be a point, except for the fact it's not actually a limitation. The neat thing about touch screens is they can be ANY interface that is required at the time, which leads to more context sensitive interfaces.

I have made a point, you haven't. You are confused at best delusional at worst. If you actually played competitive RTS as you claim you would know that moving your arms all over a large screen has no chance of being superior to a high speed mouse and keyboard ever. That statement is almost as silly as saying a touchpad is superior to a mouse because a touchscreen is essentially a big touchpad nothing more. The screen reacts to where you are touching, not where you aren't. Nothing is going to change that.

Once again since you fail at comprehension, Touchscreens for gaming are gimmicks.
 
You're obviously not getting what I'm saying. It can be a touchpad, keyboard, 1:1 surface, or gesture device. It could be a touchpad at a 1:5 ratio if you wanted it to be, and it doesn't have to just select physical objects on-screen at all times. Quit repeating yourself and forcing me to, thanks.
 
The point is really, really simple: adaptability and options lead to innovation in interface design. The possibilities are there for gaming and I have been playing RTS games for a long while now. They're my favorite genre by far. Touch screens do provide adaptability and they might just surprise you. If you feel the need to write another condescending diatribe about how mouse and keyboard will prevail and touchscreens are useless I'll feel obligated not to respond to you.
 
Back
Top