Violent Games Increase Aggression For Extended Periods?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
You know, reading studies like this really pisses me off. Seriously, the more I obsess about the results of this study, the more aggressive I get! Oh noes!

Playing a violent video game can increase aggression, and when a player keeps thinking about the game, the potential for aggression can last for as long as 24 hours, according to a study in the current Social Psychological and Personality Science.
 
actually, playing an aggressive game is very relaxing...gets the mind off of other irritations
 
I wonder if this same thing happens for physical real world games involving aggression, like say football or basketball.
 
They must have been playing a particularly frustrating game, like mario brothers. That game will put me into a rage for hours after I try playing it because of the stupid controller lag, the jump spacing, and the fact that I can't get the stupid timing down to get through the first level.

easy games like WoW put me at ease because I can get things done and not feel overly frustrated.

now if only psychologists could actually understand that frustration leads to anger and aggression, then we'd actually get to the bottom of the issue here: badly programmed games.
 
They must have been playing a particularly frustrating game, like mario brothers. That game will put me into a rage for hours after I try playing it because of the stupid controller lag, the jump spacing, and the fact that I can't get the stupid timing down to get through the first level.

easy games like WoW put me at ease because I can get things done and not feel overly frustrated.

now if only psychologists could actually understand that frustration leads to anger and aggression, then we'd actually get to the bottom of the issue here: badly programmed games.
Read the full article. They controlled with non-aggressive games and the effect was only seen in males who ruminated over their gameplay (not in women nor in men who didn't think about the game).

By the way, the full journal article is available for free online:
http://spp.sagepub.com/content/early/2010/08/06/1948550610379506.full.pdf+html

In case you're wondering how they measure aggressiveness (emphasis mine):
On returning to the lab the following day, participants were
given 3 min to list what they thought about in the past 24 hr.
Next, they completed a competitive reaction time task with
an ostensible partner of the same sex in which the winner could
blast the loser with painful noise through headphones. The
noise levels ranged from 60 decibels (Level 1) to 105 decibels
(Level 10; about the same level as a fire alarm). A nonaggressive
no-noise option (Level 0) was also provided. The winner
could also determine the duration of the loser’s suffering by
controlling the noise duration. The ostensible partner set
random noise intensities and durations across the 25 trials.
Basically, within the ethical limits of the laboratory, participants
controlled a weapon that could be used to blast their partner
with painful noise. This is a well-validated laboratory
measure of aggression that has been used for decades (e.g.,
​

Giancola & Zeichner, 1995). A debriefing followed.
:D
 
Watching a sports game can increase aggression, and when a fan keeps thinking about the game, the potential for aggression can last for as long as 24 hours, according to a study in the current Social Psychological and Personality Science.

Fixed.
 
Guys, this doesn't mean just cause you play shooters you will become a violent criminal, so don't be defensive. It DOES mean it revs you up for a while and makes it easier to go off (mostly, not everybody). This is entirely consistent will previous research of the last 30 years. What we see, read, listen to affects us. There is a reason advertisers pay for commercials.
 
You're welcome to carry out that study. From the end of this one:

Declaration of Conflicting Interests
​
The authors declared that they had no conflicts of interests with respect to their authorship or the publication of this article.​


​
Funding
The authors declared that they received no financial support for their research and/or authorship of this article.​
​
 

Nah.

Engaging in any physical, mental, social, competitive, sexual, or entertaining activity can increase aggression, and when a someone keeps thinking about that activity, the potential for aggression can last for as long as 24 hours, according to a study in the current Social Psychological and Personality Science.

Now that's fixed. Humans are an agressive species.
 
Now that's fixed. Humans are an agressive [sic] species.
*Sigh*
Reading comprehension fail, unless you think Guitar Hero, Gran Turismo, and Shaun White Snowboarding are non-physical, non-mental, non-competitive, non-social, and non-entertaining...
 
I don't get angry anymore. Way I figure it, I'm playing a game to have fun, not to accomplish something. If I for some reason can't "accomplish" something in the game; no big deal. I don't even get agitated when someone TKs me.

The root problem is that there is a perception that gaming is about accomplishment. In-game achievements only reinforce that kind of mentality. Re-align your perception and quit playing games that are severely competitive and absurdly difficult and you'll find yourself as calm as a Hindu cow. Save the aggression for the shit that matters.
 
I am pretty damned certain there are a lot more things besides video games that increase aggression for extended periods of time.
 
I wonder if this same thing happens for physical real world games involving aggression, like say football or basketball.

they couldn't possibly because society and the television tells us that sports are social norms and we should all strive to be cool enough to play them...those people couldn't possibly have anything wrong with them

right.....right?
 
Fixed

Failing at the mating game can increase aggression, and when a guy keeps thinking about being spurned, the potential for aggression can last for as long as 24 WEEKS, according to a study in the current Social Psychological and Personality Science.

fucking moron studies
 
I think he means playing frustrating games (Camping) or games with broken mechanics (Spawn killing, etc). Has nothing to do with the voilence of the characters. You could camp the only 2-hour spawn for a purple daisey in pony adventures and still piss people off.
 
Read the full article. They controlled with non-aggressive games and the effect was only seen in males who ruminated over their gameplay (not in women nor in men who didn't think about the game).

If most people were given a weapon that allowed me to blast someone with painful noise and they couldn't get you, and there was no retaliation, most people would be spamming that button for the thrill of it
 
I am reminded of the study where they have a fake game show where the contestants would give the others increasingly lethal shocks and they would do it. To me it just shows that people will act out based on pressure and lack of consequences. Not quite the way the real world works.
 
If most people were given a weapon that allowed me to blast someone with painful noise and they couldn't get you, and there was no retaliation, most people would be spamming that button for the thrill of it

They do this already. It's called "car audio". They put huge speakers in cars with powerful amplifiers and drive around pounding crap out that annoys the bat snot out of the majority of people. THAT is rage-inducing, and what I would like to see done with these people I cannot post here as it would cause this message board to divide by zero.
 
They do this already. It's called "car audio". They put huge speakers in cars with powerful amplifiers and drive around pounding crap out that annoys the bat snot out of the majority of people. THAT is rage-inducing, and what I would like to see done with these people I cannot post here as it would cause this message board to divide by zero.

Hey those same people drive past my window at 5 in the morning when i'm getting through the last of a 6pack of cocaine mild/ DPZ before turning in for the day (I find it hard to sleep for some reason). Its a well known psychoaccoustical thing that anything over a certain loudness will give feelings of euphoria. Which is how they can stand listening to that junk. Unfortunately your too far away. Unfortunately you can still hear it.
 
If most people were given a weapon that allowed me to blast someone with painful noise and they couldn't get you, and there was no retaliation, most people would be spamming that button for the thrill of it
And yet, as the study shows, you'd be wrong.

You would be surprised at how well behaved people generally are when being observed.
 
And yet, as the study shows, you'd be wrong.

You would be surprised at how well behaved people generally are when being observed.

Apparently its only if you play for 20 minutes or more...and are a man.

Their methodology is screwy. But they did base it off a test group of...126 individual 19 year olds. Which would cover the chances that one group was more aggressive than the other. Also they were testing difficult games vs easier games, a better test would have been one game with violence removed and added. With this giant test group there is still too many variables to come to the wild conclusions that they blew this research grant on.

But yes, that is why we can't see god/aliens/the overseer. Otherwise it wouldn't be a test :D
 
Like when I rage quit on MW2.... my agression could last for days.

Rage quitting is for pussies. Real aggression is smashing your keyboard over handed into your desktop. I've broken keyboards, mice (I think I'm on my fourth G9X), remote controls, at least 8 (lost count at 8) xbox 360 controllers, snapped a PS2 controller in half, PS3 controllers, a pair of glasses, and even cell phones. Yeah, I need help.

It seems only games like COD do this to me. I get ass wooped in other games but it doesn't phase me.
 
Rage quitting is for pussies. Real aggression is smashing your keyboard over handed into your desktop. I've broken keyboards, mice (I think I'm on my fourth G9X), remote controls, at least 8 (lost count at 8) xbox 360 controllers, snapped a PS2 controller in half, PS3 controllers, a pair of glasses, and even cell phones.

Yeah, I need help. Will I go out and get it? Fuck no. That costs money I could be using towards replacing all the shit I break.

On a serious note...I've broken a ton of stuff.

It seems only games like COD do this to me. I get ass wooped in other games but it doesn't phase me.
 
Its a well known psychoaccoustical thing that anything over a certain loudness will give feelings of euphoria. Which is how they can stand listening to that junk. Unfortunately your too far away. Unfortunately you can still hear it.

To me, anything over a certain loudness causes my eardrums to hurt and makes me develop aggressive tendencies.
 
No wonder my wife has been being a bitch longer than usual.
 
Can someone do a study on aggression and other Psychological effects after watching major news broadcasts??? Why always Video Games?
 
To me, anything over a certain loudness causes my eardrums to hurt and makes me develop aggressive tendencies.

Depends on the loudness. The threshold of pain varies between 120 an 135dB depending on your sensitivity etc. But also remember that pain and being aggressive causes euphoria in people too because of the adreneline. Which is people like being scared and such. But the sound above a certain point and below the threshold of pain.
 
Can someone do a study on aggression and other Psychological effects after watching major news broadcasts??? Why always Video Games?

Same reason more people care about which beautiful and rich socialite is fucking which hot and rich soccer star more than things that actually matter.
 
easy games like WoW put me at ease because I can get things done and not feel overly frustrated.

Can easily be just as frustrating listening to 24 other people say why they think a raid is failing. I have seen some people get pretty heated on vent after a couple hours of wiping.

But leveling can be very easy going :)

There is of course the infamous Onyxia Wipe (aka 50 DKP MINUS!!!) that shows how much people can rage.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtvIYRrgZ04
 
I think this is just natural really for guys. There is something in us that makes us want to dominate. We can try and be "civilized" all we want, but something is going to trigger that natural tendancy.

I remember being pretty riled up the first time I saw movies like Fast and Furious (original) or 300. They are movies about addrenaline and guys can relate to that feeling.
 
I remember being pretty riled up the first time I saw movies like Fast and Furious (original) or 300. They are movies about addrenaline and guys can relate to that feeling.

I like what Sarah Silverman had to say about 300: "It's called '300' because on a scale of 1 to 10, that's its gay factor."

The Fast and the Furious even sounds like a gay porn title.
 
Back
Top