Unequal size memory sticks - worth the performance hit?

Mark Larson

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 16, 2002
Messages
3,177
Is it worth the performance hit to have unequal size memory sticks in the system?

I have an Asus M3A78-EM with 4x1GB running in UnGanged mode. What would happen if I were to replace 1 slot with a 2GB stick for 5GB total?
 
No. It's not worth the effort at all tbh... You will get a highly unnoticable performance gain, and will have wasted some money. Might as well get 8gb imo.
 
If you do a lot of memory-intensive stuff with your PC and find yourself running out of RAM, you'll gain performance from adding the 2GB stick. Otherwise, you'll either take a hit or won't see any difference, in which case it won't be worth doing altogether.
 
A good benchmark is do whatever you normally do on your PC, and see if it feels faster or slower. In the end, that matters a hell of a lot more than any benchmark.
 
I was thinking of doing that same thing (I have 4gb DDR2 800 OCZ). I was gonna buy an extra 2 gb off brand ram to add to make 6gb but i herd it would either not work or be glitchy
 
I was thinking of doing that same thing (I have 4gb DDR2 800 OCZ). I was gonna buy an extra 2 gb off brand ram to add to make 6gb but i herd it would either not work or be glitchy
There's no reason why it wouldn't work.
 
An older chipset (such as the nForce 4 that is somewhat common among HP desktops), will support a maximum of 4 GB.
 
There's no reason why it wouldn't work.

its just that ive herd some motherboards dont like two diffrent name brands of ram at the same time and i would hate to spend the money and it doesnt work. i should just buy 4 more gigs of the same model of ram i have now
 
A good benchmark is do whatever you normally do on your PC, and see if it feels faster or slower. In the end, that matters a hell of a lot more than any benchmark.

I doubt I'll see any difference in what I usually do, and that's where a benchmark can come in handy. I actually bought the stick so I can have either 5GB + 3GB in both systems of mine or 4GB + 4GB with dual-channel in the newer one.
 
its just that ive herd some motherboards dont like two diffrent name brands of ram at the same time and i would hate to spend the money and it doesnt work. i should just buy 4 more gigs of the same model of ram i have now

You'd be surprised. I had 3 sticks of A-Data DDR2-800 (manuf 2008) in my system (1 was on RMA) and I put in an HP DDR2-667 (manuf 2007) in and it worked. Then I OC'ed that stick to DDR2-800 at regular voltage and memtest86+ passed with flying colors. :D
 
its just that ive herd some motherboards dont like two diffrent name brands of ram at the same time and i would hate to spend the money and it doesnt work. i should just buy 4 more gigs of the same model of ram i have now

As the guy above me said, you'd be surprised. As long as the memory works on the same CAS settings, etc. and at the same speed with the same voltage as the rest of the memory, you should be fine.
 
Well, I had been running 5GB in my Win7 x64 system since I made that post, and today I removed the 2GB stick.

Windows Performance Evaluation Results (Memory) with 5GB (all 4 slots filled): 7.4
Windows Performance Evaluation Results (Memory) with 3GB (only 3 slots filled): 5.5

I guess it does have a benefit.
 
Back
Top