Ultra X3 600W thoughts

misho

n00b
Joined
Sep 16, 2009
Messages
52
Hey guys, so i am building a pc, its running:
E8400, (gonna OC this around (4.0 - 4.3Ghz)
2x1GB 1066 Mhz ram
Gigabyte EP45-UD3P
GTX280
1 DVDRW drive,
1x36GB RAptor drive
and MAYBE a 500GB drive.

Question: Is the Ultra X3 600W gonna be enough for this setup, + the overclock on the CPU?

Thanks!
 
The psu will be fine since your system won't be drawing over 400watt.
 
The X3 600W isn't a great PSU, but if you already have it, it'll be enough.
The New Ultra X4 600W is available now!!!!

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4558897&CatId=1483

Review
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ww2Tk1gg0Pw


The internals are better in this version with lifetime warranty.
That is not a review. The guy had no idea what he was talking about, and didn't do any testing with it at all. Although the internals of the X4 600W are probably better than the X3, I doubt they're anything to get excited about either judging from the performance of the other X4 models that have already been reviewed around the net.
 
The X3 600W isn't a great PSU, but if you already have it, it'll be enough.

That is not a review. The guy had no idea what he was talking about, and didn't do any testing with it at all. Although the internals of the X4 600W are probably better than the X3, I doubt they're anything to get excited about either judging from the performance of the other X4 models that have already been reviewed around the net.

Really? SMH
 
Well alright, gonna get the X3 then, a guy selling it for $60 CAD, not a bad deal.
I thought i will draw more than 400W with the CPU overclocked, but i guess i was wrong.

Thanks
 
Well if you don't have it already, I wouldn't recommend that you buy it. Spend a little more and get a quality PSU that'll last you.
 
you don't think its gonna last ?



It's not a great quality PSU, sure it'll be enough to power your system, but if you don't have it already might as well buy something better quality.

I am not sure about the pricing in CAD so I'll leave that to someone who does :)
 
you don't think its gonna last ?
Not really. We all thought you had the PSU on hand. Since you don't, don't buy it. It'll be a stupid purchase.

Also, out of the parts you listed, which ones do you already have? If you don't have any of those parts, you really should rethink that build.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Out of all the parts, i got the E8400, GTX 280, 2GB of ram, and the 36GB raptor.

What i need to get is the PSU, mobo (which will be the gigabyte UD3P cuz its the best p45 for OCing.

Edit: Well if its that bad.. imma have to go with Corsair

Either HX520, HX620, TX650 or VX550 need to get a good deal (BTW im buying used ONLY as its cheaper. i dont want brand new)
 
Last edited:
i dunno, the 520 seems low wattage, but it has better amps, :S which one if i had to chose out of those 2, the 550VX or HX520?
 
i dunno, the 520 seems low wattage, but it has better amps, :S which one if i had to chose out of those 2, the 550VX or HX520?
The HX520 is overall a better PSU, although both are excellent. Either one would be plenty for your needs.
 
If you are worried the 520/550 is too low then go with the 650/620. 520/550 from a quality vendor like corsair is plenty for a single gpu / dualcore.
 
Don't do it to yourself, get a different PSU.
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2008/01/09/ultra_x3_600w_power_supply/9
The Bottom Line


The X3 600w incorporates all the benefits found in the X3 line of power supplies in a more midrange product than previous X3's we have reviewed. While the X3 600w features very good DC output quality, good 120v efficiency, a low noise profile, very good transient load response, and good voltage regulation the unit suffers from the same short coming as the X-Pro 600w in that it cannot do its full labeled output at 45c. If this unit were being marketed as the “X3 480w” it would be an outstanding product from our perspective but as it is today the X3 600w is an overstretched unit in our particular testing environment. Even that considered, the X3 600w is well overpriced for the 450w – 500w PSU category.



One Step Forward, Two Steps Back?

Editor’s Note: It is sad to see Ultra somewhat repairing their reputation over the last year with fine high end power supplies, and then bring back a unit that is not suitable for the enthusiast user. And certainly, that is exactly the target market of the Ultra X3 brand. This is the same “600 watt” power supply we reviewed last March that gave the same lacking performance. Why is Ultra upgrading this unit to “X3” status and not upgrading the internals? Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Seeing product marketing like this certainly makes me question the entire brand.
 
i dunno, the 520 seems low wattage, but it has better amps, :S which one if i had to chose out of those 2, the 550VX or HX520?


You really don't understand amps vs. watts, do you?

You're considering an Ultra X3 600W, which puts out only 432W or 36A on the +12V rail and dissing the Corsair HX520 which puts out 480W or 40A on its +12V rail?

That Ultra cannot compete in any way with the Corsair. And the only reason the Ultra is "rated" at a higher wattage output is simply from its +3.3V/+5V rails being more heavily powered, which is rather useless given almost all power these days in modern computers is drawn from the +12V rail.....gone are the days when cpus drew their power from the +5V rail.
 
You also might want to think about the future of your build. If you're gonna be upgrading parts or starting a new build, why not get a PSU with higher wattage so you could reuse it?
 
Ahh what i thought is that the 3.3/5V rails are all the same AMPS on every PSU, so thats why i thought the 600W is better.
 
Hey guys, how about a Cooler Master RS550-PCARA3-US 550Watt PSU

Is that a good one? any thoughts on it?
 
Thats waaaaaay too much.

I got a deal, either a HX620 for $80 CAD(local deal) or a TX750 for $90CAD (local deal as well)

no shipping/taxes.

Which one should i go for? HX620 or TX750?
 
The 750TX will provide more headroom for future upgrades. The 620HX has modular cables and is of better quality.

You can figure it out for yourself from there.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Hey guys, how about a Cooler Master RS550-PCARA3-US 550Watt PSU

Is that a good one? any thoughts on it?
Not great.
Thats waaaaaay too much.

I got a deal, either a HX620 for $80 CAD(local deal) or a TX750 for $90CAD (local deal as well)

no shipping/taxes.

Which one should i go for? HX620 or TX750?
With your system, I'd go with the HX620. It's overall a better PSU than the TX750, and you don't need the extra 130W.
 
Yeah i was leaning more towards the HX620 as well.

Even with future upgrades i am not going to go SLI/crossfire because lets not forget, its an HTPC case after all. too much heat, gonna keep it single GPU and the HX620 is enough..

Googling i found some stuff on the HX620 fire issues? DOes it cause fires??
lol
 
Theres nothing wrong with the Current Ultra PSUs. The older X2 and others were crap, but the X3 and newer X4 are very nice PSUs and the X3 has gotten great reviews fromt he [H]. I am currently running a X3 1000watt and love it, I would definatly get another.

Most people that are bashing Ultra have no personal experience and have not been in the loop and are refering to the older PSUs from Ultra.
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2007/08/24/ultra_x3_1600w_power_supply/ GOLD award!
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2007/04/23/ultra_x3_1000w/ Silver Award
 
Of course Ultra still sells the the crap along with the decent stuff. Thermaltake and Coolermaster do it as well.
 
Theres nothing wrong with the Current Ultra PSUs. The older X2 and others were crap, but the X3 and newer X4 are very nice PSUs and the X3 has gotten great reviews fromt he [H]. I am currently running a X3 1000watt and love it, I would definatly get another.

Most people that are bashing Ultra have no personal experience and have not been in the loop and are refering to the older PSUs from Ultra.
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2007/08/24/ultra_x3_1600w_power_supply/ GOLD award!
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2007/04/23/ultra_x3_1000w/ Silver Award
Maybe you should actually read the review for the 600W X3 that this thread is about: http://www.hardocp.com/article/2008/01/09/ultra_x3_600w_power_supply/

Not exactly gold-worthy.
 
Maybe you should actually read the review for the 600W X3 that this thread is about: http://www.hardocp.com/article/2008/01/09/ultra_x3_600w_power_supply/

Not exactly gold-worthy.

Well, I got to agree after reading some more reviews of the X4 series. Both the 600 and the 1200 have not done well in reviews as well as the X3 600.
Sure is a shame that Ultra cant pull it together for very long, they had great units with the X3 1000 and X3 1600, other than that they have done poorly.
 
Back
Top