Today’s Bully is Apple

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
This should get you guys fired up. Newsweek has an article about how Apple is the big bully that Microsoft was ten years ago. Interesting stuff.

A former lieutenant of Steve Jobs's once told me something surprising about his ex-boss. "Steve is a monopolist at heart," he said. "He's just like Bill Gates. He just hasn't been as successful."
 
Not a surprise. IMO, Jobs would be more successful than MS if they licensed OSX for PCs. If people could choose between OSX and Vista, I think they'd choose Vista. Or at least the tech nerds they ask for advice would recommend it. Unless you play games or do AEC work (AutoCAD, etc), you really don't need Windows.
 
Err, choose OSX. Where's the edit button??

No, I think you had it right the first time. Given the choice between OSX and Vista, I would bet a vast majority of the people would buy Vista. If Apple had made their OS compete on PCs, say, 10 years ago, then maybe things would be different. But Apple already shot themselves in the foot - they aren't breaking into the PC market anytime soon.
 
A former lieutenant of Steve Jobs's once told me something surprising about his ex-boss. "Steve is a monopolist at heart," he said. "He's just like Bill Gates. He just hasn't been as successful.".

How would that be a surprise to anyone? Apple is the most monopolistic tech company in the world. They have a complete vertical solution. You buy their hardware to run their software. Period.

The only reason their attempted monopoly has avoided legal trouble is because of their relatively small market share.
 
Just becouse they dont know and buy into the hype and after the newness wears they would go back to windows. Windows is easer to learn imo and supports more apps and dx as most games or made for. Os x is nice but lacks way to much software support. You can also make it unbootable so easy lol.
 
No, I think you had it right the first time. Given the choice between OSX and Vista, I would bet a vast majority of the people would buy Vista. If Apple had made their OS compete on PCs, say, 10 years ago, then maybe things would be different. But Apple already shot themselves in the foot - they aren't breaking into the PC market anytime soon.

I don't think so.

In some perverse way likely totally unknown to us hardware enthusiasts, I'd say part of Apple's appeal is that you do get everything in one package. That plays into the "it just works" image that the company is trying to convey. I really don't see the point of pulling an MS on their operating system, which would probably totally go against what they're trying to market.
 
A former lieutenant of Steve Jobs's once told me something surprising about his ex-boss. "Steve is a monopolist at heart," he said. "He's just like Bill Gates. He just hasn't been as successful."

09/05/08 stock market close:

APPLE - $160.18/share

MS = $25.65/share

I'd say Steve's doing just fine as an aspiring monopolist, maybe even bett'n Bill.
 
How would that be a surprise to anyone? Apple is the most monopolistic tech company in the world. They have a complete vertical solution. You buy their hardware to run their software. Period.

The only reason their attempted monopoly has avoided legal trouble is because of their relatively small market share.

Exactly. Apple is in for a world of hurt in the near future I believe. Not because their computer market share is really gaining but because other aspects of the company are very successful.
 
No, I think you had it right the first time. Given the choice between OSX and Vista, I would bet a vast majority of the people would buy Vista. If Apple had made their OS compete on PCs, say, 10 years ago, then maybe things would be different. But Apple already shot themselves in the foot - they aren't breaking into the PC market anytime soon.

I agree completely. One of the reasons this hasn't happened is, as people have stated before, the "it just works" campaign. It simply wouldn't just work if they had to cater for tens of thousands of different hardware configurations. However, as you say, if they had opened it up ten years ago they would have a much larger OS market share now and hence I believe game and software makers would offer many more products on OSX. They have literally shut themselves out of a large portion of the market.
 
09/05/08 stock market close:

APPLE - $160.18/share

MS = $25.65/share

I'd say Steve's doing just fine as an aspiring monopolist, maybe even bett'n Bill.

you're forgetting how many times MS has done a stock split. wonder how many times apple has done that?

:rolleyes:
 
09/05/08 stock market close:

APPLE - $160.18/share

MS = $25.65/share

I'd say Steve's doing just fine as an aspiring monopolist, maybe even bett'n Bill.

I wish people on these forums would stop quoting stock price as evidence of... anything.
Without including a history of stock splits, they are meaningless as even a token measure of market success.

Try this instead:
http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=MSFT#chart3:symbol=msft;range=my;compare=aapl;indicator=volume;charttype=line;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=on;source=undefined

And then comment on the rise in AAPL vs. MSFT since 2003, if you must.
 
09/05/08 stock market close:

APPLE - $160.18/share

MS = $25.65/share

I'd say Steve's doing just fine as an aspiring monopolist, maybe even bett'n Bill.

Apple is doing just fine, but your stock quote is a bit misleading.

$141,218,372,140 Apple
$ 238,885,965,450 MS
Actual value of all outstanding shares. But that is misleading as well. A better indicator of success imho would be net profit over a certain time scale, and projected future profits, as well as net worth of the corporations, but I'll leave that to you to look up. Hint: Apple has a ways to go.

As far as catching up to Bill, well, when Apples OSes have an 80% plus market share and Steve starts flexing his monopoly muscles let me know. ;)


EVERY ceo, hell every capitalist, wants to be a monopolist. Steve is no different. He justs lacks the products, skill, luck, market conditions, and vision to get there at present. maybe next year? Who knows?
 
Windows has all the home and office computers.
Linux has all the servers.
Apple has everyone in Starbucks.
 
Apple has everyone in Starbucks.

and college students wanting to be in more debt rather than save several hundred on a damn laptop....i suppose that would fit into the starbucks thing though. nothin like expensive coffee and an overpriced laptop to make the parents/wallet/banks happy :p
 
Not a surprise. IMO, Jobs would be more successful than MS if they licensed OSX for PCs. If people could choose between OSX and Vista, I think they'd choose Vista. Or at least the tech nerds they ask for advice would recommend it. Unless you play games or do AEC work (AutoCAD, etc), you really don't need Windows.

Im willing to bet if they licensed their OS for PCs the first time they actually had to deal with shit like third party driver support like vista did when released it would sink like a fucking rock and ruin that company forever.

What thier doing is both the secret to thier success and what will always keep it far behind microsoft. Their damned if they do and damned if they dont.
 
Windows has all the home and office computers.
Linux has all the servers.
Apple has everyone in Starbucks.


Amen to that, and as long as they dont talk to me about how good apple is im fine.


and college students wanting to be in more debt rather than save several hundred on a damn laptop....i suppose that would fit into the starbucks thing though. nothin like expensive coffee and an overpriced laptop to make the parents/wallet/banks happy :p

Amen to that too.


When apple users come to my room and ask my why i have 4 computers, and that i should have bought a mac that can do everything i use 4 computers with it pisses me off, happend 3 times in the past year.

the worst part is when they say "buying 1 mac would be cheaper" when they dont even know the cost of hardware when you dont buy OEM... nor what i do with my stuff.

My stuffis actually quite cheap, the cost of: 2x little valley (atom based) boards, an m1330, and a homebuilt desktop < the cost of mac desktop at its cheapest configs.

even if it has 8 processors, 2GB of ram and an 2600xt? i'd gladly take my 3.7Ghz q6600 + 4gb + 8800GTX anyday. not to mention 2TB of storage.
 
Thing is macs dont do everything out of the box. Just like windows theres alot of stuff Apple wants you to buy in order to get. Just like a PC.
 
AGreed on the whole MAC/Apple "im better than you" attitude. Im fine with people choosing what they want, but dont try to shove it down my throat with an AT4, and get off your damn high horse. Fact is There isnt anything a Mac can do that a PC cant, and vice versa (except pretty much all aspects of gaming and some certain 64bit apps). They both have their pros and cons, and I know which one I like better (because I hate the other has no point here, I dont attack other people with elite BS just because they use a product I cant stand) If this was the norm, Paris Hilton would have commited suicide many moons ago from all the shit the world would give her :) (and I wouldnt miss her..)

I feel very strongly against apple, but I dont insult other people's intelegence or thro out BS "stats" and make crazy claims just because they wanted to buy their overpriced status Icon. If it makes you happy then fine, thats your right.
My best friend is a MAC FANATIC (extreme legion type nut, almost worships it lol ) and Im always letting him borrow my gamer rig so he can game, plus I think its photoshop 64 isnt supported on mac stuff and he cant upgrade his CPU to my Q66 (he does pic/video editing and needs my rig fo rthe big jobs) I dont try to force PC and windows down his throat, but he is always telling me how much better his 2 yr old non upgradable mac is, how windows is so bad and M$ is so evil to its customers, just over pricing on everything and leaving no options for the user, until he needs my computer once every few months...

I have nothing against Mac guys as people but they need to lay off this elite crap.

PS Ive had plenty of experience with Macs over the last 7-8 years, most disturbing of which is my damn iPhone, such a waste of money, but it had the biggest screen at the time, but the whole phone is SO SLOOWWWWW (not just the ancient internet), crashes more then Evil Kinevil did, and locks up on the hour, and battery life suxc (barley make a day with minimal use), edge and 3g models both (3 differant phones so far, each worse than the last). Google Maps is the only reason I keep it anymore (plus Id get raped by the contract..)
 
Apple is in for a rude awakening if their popularity continues to increase. As soon as the become large enough to look like an actual threat, all of the antitrust lawsuits will start. I wonder how well Apple will hold up to millions and millions of fines from the EU and government oversite in the US.

I can easily see the EU saying that it is illegal to tie OS X to hardware. That would be hilarious.
 
I don't think so.

In some perverse way likely totally unknown to us hardware enthusiasts, I'd say part of Apple's appeal is that you do get everything in one package. That plays into the "it just works" image that the company is trying to convey. I really don't see the point of pulling an MS on their operating system, which would probably totally go against what they're trying to market.

Yes, but if they sold their OS the the masses then that "just works" claim would evaporate and APPL would learn just how hard it is to ship an OS that runs on as many systems as Windows and Linux.
 
Not even close to ALL. I don't even think it is the largest percentage, but I would like to see some numbers.

http://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prUS21399008

Linux sold 13.4% of the market share vs. Windows 36.5%. I say sold because I remember reading a while back (can't find source anymore) about how many Windows servers were being reformatted and having Linux installed since there were discounts and such on the Windows servers but not the Linux ones. Not sure how credible that is, but there you go.

That said, of the major players (fortune 500 companies and popular web sites), Linux+Apache is dominating.
 
Not even close to ALL. I don't even think it is the largest percentage, but I would like to see some numbers.

http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Linux-and-Open-Source/Linux-Losing-Market-Share-to-Windows-Server/

http://www.geekpedia.com/news193_Linux-server-market-share-plummeting.html

Take it for what its worth. MSFT is super competitive in the server market.

People should not confuse MSFT server SKUs with retail SKUs. The server clients are hyper reliable, IT customers demand it and since competition from Linux variants is fierce MSFT works hard to maintain their edge.
 
Yeah Windows still holds the server market. Only thing Linux really has is some servers and nerds with dreams they can crush Microsoft without any software developer support because it's free.

Linux has much more than that. It is very much a major player in the server market. And there *is* developer support for Linux - its what companies like Novell, Redhat, and IBM provide.
 
I'm confused, where was Linux mentioned in the article :confused:

Sucks that there is not much of a way to confirm the credibility of the article, since the author has no bio or past articles in Newsweek. I'm sure he's known out there somewhere on the internet though....

However I don't doubt for a second that Jobs is going for a monopoly. But, with Apple's current strategies, he'll never get there.
 
Not even close to ALL. I don't even think it is the largest percentage, but I would like to see some numbers.

Yeah Windows still holds the server market. Only thing Linux really has is some servers and nerds with dreams they can crush Microsoft without any software developer support because it's free.
 
can really compare Apple net profit to MS, since you are comparing a software company to a hardwareone.

Now for a more direct share..

lets compare MS OS Sales to Apple OS sales... which i guess could be determined by taking every Apple computer sold and multiple $150 x that or the current cost of their OS's? ?

could also toss in Zune sales vs Ipod sales in that.... but most profit comes from the hardware.... cant compare a $300 @ most Vista Ultimate vs a $2000 Mac desktop cause it has the OS...
 
Yeah Windows still holds the server market. Only thing Linux really has is some servers and nerds with dreams they can crush Microsoft without any software developer support because it's free.

Like hell they do.

Linux webservers alone would likely outnumber all types of windows servers in existence.
 
And in ten years, just like Microsoft, they'll be the company nobody except the fanboys buy from.

Except that with Microsoft, it's not just the fanboys.
 
Get a way to find out, we can't exactly base server numbers on sales.

Not really, no way to know how many Win servers get reformatted and then have nix installed. But Nix is indeed a powerhouse in many server segments. Though what that has to do with Apple acting the ass, as usual, I don't know.
 
09/05/08 stock market close:

APPLE - $160.18/share

MS = $25.65/share

I'd say Steve's doing just fine as an aspiring monopolist, maybe even bett'n Bill.

Bill Gates could buy Apple outright with a phone call or two. One to his broker/mutual fund manager, the other to Warren Buffet.

I don't think Steve has that kind of pull... he dreams of it, but he ain't got it.
 
OMG is this news over 20 years out of date. LOL, I guess nobody remembers NeXT. Will we have to wait another 10 years for a Google appraisal? Does nobody in IT reporting have any knowledge beyond the last five years or so?

Hmmm. Nearly four years of n00b status. I guess credibility is based on how much crap you can turn out out in the shortest period of time? So, a bit like Microsoft, Google, Apple, etc :D
 
In some perverse way likely totally unknown to us hardware enthusiasts, I'd say part of Apple's appeal is that you do get everything in one package.
What, exactly, does Apple have bundled that Microsoft doesn't?
I'm not talking minor features (we could discuss those all day), but major features. For instance: Movie Maker, Media Player, etc


Windows has all the home and office computers.
Linux has all the servers.
Apple has everyone in Starbucks.
LMAO.

Mac users are the most ignorant stuck up people in the world.
Please, tell us how you feel ;)
But seriously, I do agree.

Thing is macs dont do everything out of the box. Just like windows theres alot of stuff Apple wants you to buy in order to get. Just like a PC.
Only difference- is there is more FREE software for Windows. You start adding in the costs of having to pay for software, service packs, all this extra crap on a Mac: tons more money.

Not even close to ALL. I don't even think it is the largest percentage, but I would like to see some numbers.
I don't think there is any way to measure it.
That said, a year or two back IW or NYT or something had an article on the Fortune 500 companies and Windows usage. It's about 50% Linux and 50% Windows, but there were growing numbers of them actually going over to IIS... Windows is a valid competitor in the Server market, but I'd agree Linux is more well known as a Server OS.


Apple is probably the biggest monopoly in the computer industry... It's just folks will ALWAYS hate #1.
 
As soon as a company can, they will become a bully.

It's one of the horrific cons of capitalism.

(please no marxist or socialist comments. can't anyone say one thing against capitalism without some of you morons out there replying back with such nonsense and inflammatory remarks? sometimes it feels like saying one bad thing about capitalism is like cursing out someone's mom.)
 
the irony is Apple could open up OSX to Dell/HP/Acer with ease...

just give a list of mobos, NiCs, wireless, sound that have drivers written and let them make "apple clones"

ask Nvidia/ATi to make drivers for all the newer cards

but why would apple want to give up the retarded/assine markup they are making on their desktop/notebook products and "upgrades"

google OSx86.. kinda eye openning
 
Back
Top