The PC Is Not Dead

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Take it from a game developer, the PC is not dead. I have no comment on that other thing he said about mobile platforms. ;)

Well the article title says it all: PC is not dead and mobile is sh*t. Of course I make a certain type of game and the market is more geared up to sell PC copies of those, and indies releasing PC games on Steam certainly find they can do pretty well on there too compared to other platforms. Other developers are having great success on mobile - good for them. But I would urge caution in the mobile market. It's HUGELY over-saturated and hard to get noticed. I got my existing games ported to mobile as a low-risk approach, but there are teams of developers out there spending 6-12 months on mobile games and I personally think that's a recipe for disaster in most cases.
 
The mobile market is very hard to make money on. Only 20% of developers make any profit on their games, and of those maybe a quarter of them make enough to fund new projects.

And really, most games don't have good enough controls to really be good on phones. The best are simple games, like flash style games, strategy and tower defense games, and to a much lesser degree action games. The controls aren't very manageable on a touch screen phone, and games that don't require a lot of loading are best, since these games are expected to be playable while you're waiting for something.

That being said, I would so pay for FTL to be released on Android. I love that game on PC.

As for PC games, I think they're actually on the forefront of something big: Indie games. They're huge right now, and a lot of great ideas are being developed at the moment. With funding from kickstarter and the low barrier to entry, Independantly published games are really taking off in a way that's a lot more difficult to do on the consoles. Compare the Xbox Live Indie games to PC indie games (Baby Maker 2 vs. FTL or Amnesia the Dark Descent) and you see that not only are the PC indie games of higher quality, but the freedom of the PC interface makes it much easier to seperate the bullshit from the real games.

AAA games may not be doing quite so well on the PC, being treated like an afterthought, but let's be honest, AAA games aren't so good on average anyways. Free to Play games are starting to really shine on PC. I'm a lot more likely to play Mechwarrior Online or Hawken before I'd try playing Assassin's Creed 3. Maybe it's not such a big loss afterall...
 
I liken the mobile market to the video game market of the early 1980s. Lots of titles, little quality control, and diverse platforms.

In other words, beware.
 
He's wrong. It's dead. This morning I poked it a few times with a stick to make sure it wasn't going to move around by itself before I put it in the dumpster.
 
I liken the mobile market to the video game market of the early 1980s. Lots of titles, little quality control, and diverse platforms.

In other words, beware.

The mobile gaming market and PC/console gaming market just aren't the same thing though there is overlap. The most successful mobile game last year was Angry Birds Start Wars. The most successful console game was CoD Black Ops 2, not sure that the most successful PC game was last year, but it was probably much closer to CoD than Angry Birds.
 
The mobile gaming market and PC/console gaming market just aren't the same thing though there is overlap. The most successful mobile game last year was Angry Birds Start Wars. The most successful console game was CoD Black Ops 2, not sure that the most successful PC game was last year, but it was probably much closer to CoD than Angry Birds.

I think Stilleto was comparing the current mobile market to the equivalent video game market 30 years ago ... the video game market in the 1980s was the wild wild west ... so is the mobile market today ... probably not that bad an analogy ;)
 
Mobile games are so hard to sift through... SO much garbage. Someone told me about this pretty good "RTS" game for phones called Dinosaur wars.

Yeah... RTS... it's more like taking the worst aspects of Farmville and Pokemon and putting them together. Farmville like resource building where you occasionally choose to watch a Pokemon battle you have no actual control over. Ratings on the market are good, it was even on a top 10 list somewhere, but the game is total garbage. Someone is pumping up ratings or paying people to get on lists of "good" games.

Mobile is like trying 10 games to find one that is worth playing for more than 10 minutes.

I understand the issue though. People expect them for free. And with so much total garbage out there, who can blame them for not wanting to pay anything up-front?
 
The mobile gaming market and PC/console gaming market just aren't the same thing though there is overlap. The most successful mobile game last year was Angry Birds Start Wars. The most successful console game was CoD Black Ops 2, not sure that the most successful PC game was last year, but it was probably much closer to CoD than Angry Birds.

Read what I said again. Particularly the "early 1980s" part. I know...there were no tablets back then, so you might be confused.
 
Read what I said again. Particularly the "early 1980s" part. I know...there were no tablets back then, so you might be confused.

Sorry, I should have said that I agree with you and I thought what I said reinforced your point.
 
When the damn content for the ipad is created on a crappy ipad, then the PC will be dead... until then STFU.

How many gens of stupid shit have come and gone, all of their software and design being created on desktop machines, then became obsolete and useless, while the PC platform their were created on rolls on into the future?
 
The mobile gaming market and PC/console gaming market just aren't the same thing though there is overlap. The most successful mobile game last year was Angry Birds Start Wars. The most successful console game was CoD Black Ops 2, not sure that the most successful PC game was last year, but it was probably much closer to CoD than Angry Birds.

Is Angry Birds "Start Wars" the one where you fling birds at Steve Ballmer until he puts the start menu back in Windows?
 
Over saturation will kill the mobile market if it isn't careful with its own development. Much like over saturation of cheap , easy to develop games from Atari and other platforms of the late 70's - early 80's almost murdered the video gaming industry entirely.

PC gaming I think is currently hitting a peak. I don't see that peak dropping anytime soon but it will as it should.

Just take one look at all the junk games on the mobile market that are just copies of other junk mobile games. Hundreds of thousands of games and most are utter crap.
 

Not at all... AAA studios are complaining, but their budgets have gone to the cosmos and they're thus finding it hard to recoup their investments. It's not really a shocker. Small studios and indies are finding it much easier, and doing quite well lately on the PC market. This has been an accelerating trend for several years now.

As far as the mobile market, it is very saturated... you need to market just as much as make a good game/app now to actually sell well, barring a lucky viral hit. However, the reward is definitely there still. The problem is, many devs simply don't get that making a good game or app isn't enough anymore.
 
Here's hoping it's true, but sadly the market goes by what the majority of people want, not "extreme users" which we are considered, and pro gamers are considered. Most people are content surfing facebook or playing farmville on a phone or tablet and could not care less about FPS or other games or applications that use a keyboard and mouse. Autocad? Photoshop? Coding? What's that? Nobody does that anymore. (point of view of the majority of people).

The PC will become more and more niche and very few manufacturers will make components. Intel already pulled out of making motherboards. This is only the beginning. It's sad, but it's what's happening. I wish I was wrong.
 
The PC will become more and more niche and very few manufacturers will make components. Intel already pulled out of making motherboards. This is only the beginning. It's sad, but it's what's happening. I wish I was wrong.

While there will be more phones and tablets sold, desktop PCs will still sell in the many millions of units for years and years to come, there's always a market for speed and power. As for Intel getting out of motherboards, I'm surprised that haven't done that much sooner. I really wouldn't worry until they stop making discrete CPUs.

I don't know why so many PC enthusiasts fret mobile devices, it's not a zero sum game. I do get that with other choices less focus is on the PC but at the end of the again, millions and millions across the planet are going to want and need the power and capability of the PC for work and play and they are going be willing to pay more than $200 for it and the games and software don't have to be 99 cents.
 
PC is dead? Hardly. Name one mobile app company that's picked up that much crowd funding money with nothing to show but a teaser vid and some fictional backstory. PC exclusive title.

Name one tablet that can do a high-res Eyefinity/Surround setup with 60+ FPS. Did I hear crickets?

Name one tablet that can, as someone else mentioned, be used effectively to develop for its own platform. Yeah, way to rock that Visual Studio on that iPad. Oh, was that Maya you were running on your Android?

I'll reiterate what I've said in the past. Everything has its place. Mobile devices are tools of convenience on the go. Powerhouse workstations are for development and crunching. Desktop gaming PC's are for the enthusiasts. If you're not an enthusiast then get off the [H]. You do not belong here. :cool:
 
Name one tablet that can, as someone else mentioned, be used effectively to develop for its own platform. Yeah, way to rock that Visual Studio on that iPad. Oh, was that Maya you were running on your Android?

Core tablets can run Visual Studio pretty well. Tablets really are just a form factor and there's considerable difference in the power of the low end and high end.
 
Name one tablet that can, as someone else mentioned, be used effectively to develop for its own platform. Yeah, way to rock that Visual Studio on that iPad. Oh, was that Maya you were running on your Android?

Core tablets can run Visual Studio pretty well. Tablets really are just a form factor and there's considerable difference in the power of the low end and high end.
 
As long as the components are available, I will always build my own. It doesn't have to be an Intel board. I like Intel boards, but an Intel processor with an ASUS board has always worked quite well for me. I've payed anywhere from $550 to $2000 per machine over the years (depending on purpose). It has never been about what's popular. It's always been about what's inside me to have. It's the ability to see the code behind the screen....knowing 'why' something happens and being able to control it, manipulate it, use it. It's the passion to learn and the need to know. I'm not above using parts from other machines to get something else up and running. But it's more than just making it work, it's making it work right. It's more than just what games can be played but without the enjoyment of even having a computer, it's all for not. The idea is to get better, stronger, faster while also keeping that passion (that driving force) alive and actually enjoying the end result.

Tablets and smartphones represent lesser devices that are under the control of someone else. With these things, you have to follow their rules (whatever rules they might have). It's a setup for failure while limiting the potential of the end users' ability. With these things, your using someone else's system while becoming subject to their whims. Personal growth gets stifled.

I know that there are very few people out there that see things the way I do. It's why I came here to begin with. A hope that I can find people that not only understand but can share in a deep heart felt passion for technology. I'm not on the hunt for the most gadgets to keep up with the Jones's. For me, it's alot more than just playing the game....it's living the game (from the inside). Kinda like looking at the Matrix encoded.
 
AAA studios are complaining
really? i thought the AAA studios were doing fairly well.

as far as i know, it's the AA studios that are going bankrupt. in fact, just a few days ago, thq got put on the chopping block.
 
Tablets and smartphones represent lesser devices that are under the control of someone else.

woah, hang on, could you expand on that please? i thought android (and palm os) is just a modified version of linux.

what do you mean that it is under the control of someone else?
 
One additional factor that was mentioned in the Feb issue of Maximum PC is the difference in revenue associated with the mobile market vs PC market ... although the processors for smartphones and tablets sold twice as many units as those for the PC form factor (laptops, desktops) the revenue from sales was one fifth as much (mobile sold 750 million units for 6.2 billion in revenue vs the 300 million units sold for PCs but with 31 billion in revenue) ... those numbers more than anything else will encourage companies to keep the PC alive and kicking for the near and long term future ;)
 
Another thread like this? I'll never give up a desktop or laptop over a tablet. My wife has a Nook Color, but I always find myself using the laptop, even if I'm on the couch.
 
woah, hang on, could you expand on that please? i thought android (and palm os) is just a modified version of linux.

what do you mean that it is under the control of someone else?

What difference does it make if it's Linux?

Sure, there are plenty of things you can do with this equipment. But it's not like you can do ANYTHING. It's more than just the technical ability of it to do it. There is always the "mother may I?" factor with this stuff. I've seen the ridiculousness of paying for access to things like fart sound "apps" that used to be free downloadable .wav files. It's this whole "apps" thing that makes me crazy when all it comes down to is another means of controlling what you do and how you do it. Now, if I want a donkey porn app on my iphone...I should have every right (as an adult) to have that without 'getting permission from Apple' first. I should never have to go through a service provider for anything more than a connection. I should have full access to turn things off .... AT MY DISCRETION.
 
really? i thought the AAA studios were doing fairly well.

as far as i know, it's the AA studios that are going bankrupt. in fact, just a few days ago, thq got put on the chopping block.

By "AAA" I meant large studios. Semantics, honestly, there...
 
The market it changing. There is still plenty of room for PC levels of power and ability, and plenty of demand for such. The large amount of sales of smaller devices has been filling the void that a new kind of device fills. Repeat sales are currently from large improvements in the end product. That will eventually subside. Many folks are "adding" devices to their device collections, not tossing one out the door in favor of the smaller ones.
 
really? i thought the AAA studios were doing fairly well.

as far as i know, it's the AA studios that are going bankrupt. in fact, just a few days ago, thq got put on the chopping block.

THQ signed its own death warrant years ago. It killed its-self with that dumb ass tablet. It dropped way too much money on franchises like Homeland.

THQ is not really a good example.
 
Core tablets can run Visual Studio pretty well. Tablets really are just a form factor and there's considerable difference in the power of the low end and high end.

But can it run both Visual Studio and Maya at the same time on multiple displays? :p
 
But can it run both Visual Studio and Maya at the same time on multiple displays? :p

That is the key here. I don't care how powerful phones and tablets are or will get, the lack of multiple display is the big killer for me. I see them as portable accessories but not replacements for computers.
 
But can it run both Visual Studio and Maya at the same time on multiple displays? :p

All Windows 8 tablets support external displays, even the Clover Trails. While Clover Trails wouldn't have the horsepower to run VS and Maya simultaneously on different screens, there Core tablets that should be able to handle this.
 
Everytime I see the "PC is dead" stories it kind of worries me. I mean I am using a PC at the time, so perhaps maybe i'm gone as well...:eek:
 
Mobile games are so hard to sift through... SO much garbage.
Mobile is like trying 10 games to find one that is worth playing for more than 10 minutes.

I understand the issue though. People expect them for free. And with so much total garbage out there, who can blame them for not wanting to pay anything up-front?

True. I think there's an attitude problem though....like "this game doesn't have to be good" because we're all casual gamers who don't care because we only play mobile games while standing in line 5 min at the bank.

F2P sucked games downhill too. I'd rather pay more money upfront for a good game, than get a handicapped game unless I give it a constant money flow. I initially liked the whole idea, but it's sucking now.
 
BTW: I use a tablet every day, but I also use my PC every day.....and there's no way in hell my PC could get replaced by my tablet.

So there. :p
 
True. I think there's an attitude problem though....like "this game doesn't have to be good" because we're all casual gamers who don't care because we only play mobile games while standing in line 5 min at the bank.

F2P sucked games downhill too. I'd rather pay more money upfront for a good game, than get a handicapped game unless I give it a constant money flow. I initially liked the whole idea, but it's sucking now.

I think some gaming genres are better represented in mobile than others ... I would actually like to see older software titles from the 90's adapted for mobile. Some of the better iPad games I have played:

Wasteland - a Cthulhu Mythos style turn based strategy game ... no where near the depth of a PC game but still very well done (probably more a niche product though)

Highborn - nice turn based strategy game from a couple of years back ... still very engaging

Elder Sign - based on the board based card game I think. Another Cthulhu Mythos game ... very very challenging for the hard maps

I would love to see a game like Diablo 2 or the original HoMM adapted for tablets ... I would think that would be a big hit :cool:
 
One additional factor that was mentioned in the Feb issue of Maximum PC is the difference in revenue associated with the mobile market vs PC market ... although the processors for smartphones and tablets sold twice as many units as those for the PC form factor (laptops, desktops) the revenue from sales was one fifth as much (mobile sold 750 million units for 6.2 billion in revenue vs the 300 million units sold for PCs but with 31 billion in revenue) ... those numbers more than anything else will encourage companies to keep the PC alive and kicking for the near and long term future ;)

Winner winner chicken dinner. Smartest thing said in this thread.
 
Back
Top