paraiso36 said:This is specially for Mike Ryan
Good Day,
I was the one who started the doubt about the test results with an AMD Xp 3200 and P4 3.0 GHZ with the ATI 9800pro 128 MB..First I need to say that I appreciate Mike intention to ask the question again, because until now nobody has been able to answer it..As we are all fanatic of this gaming world and most of all arent expert on the subject, maybe there isnt a person here who knows the answer about why the AMD 3200 deserves a High Quality and P4 3.0 only Medium quality..May be the person (sorry I am writing with my IPAQ so it is difficult to browse other pages ) who answered that it was as it was...is right...But I dont want to offend but maybe this doubt is just because I always try to explain something that called greatly my attention. Someone answered Mike that if he knew about CPU architecture he would get the answer.Please I ask him to teach us with his knowledge, because by now I am at the starting point...A few days ago I bought my P4 3.2 GHZ CPU so I made lot of researchs about P4 3.0, 3.2 and the AMD rivals.From that I learnt,
1. AMD Xp 3200 isnt better than P4 3.0 in terms of performance. Overall is slighty behind it in all areas of tests including games.
2. Amd begin to hit Intel with his AMD 64...P4 3.0 races against AMD 64 3200 and sometimes AMD 64 3000. P4 3.2 races against AMD 64 3400 and sometimes AMD 64 3200..The race is very matched but I admit that in gaming AMD 64 wins and sometimes it isnt a marginal victory..On the other hand Intel P4 wins almost all the tests about video and audio processing.
From the points above I still have my doubts about the result of the test even more if you consider other factors,
1. First as I mention the AMD Xp 3200 isnt better than P4 3.0..If anyone can prove that it is better please tell me...But even suppose they are in a perfect draw,
2. AMD 3200 has only 512 MB of RAM and P4 3.0 1 GB.Yes I know someone can tell me that Doom 3 is not dependent of Ram, but I havent seen a single system runs better with 512 MB ran instead of 1 GB.
3. The result not only gives AMD Xp 3200 High Quality instead of medium one given to the P4 3.0..It also gives 8xAF to the AMD and NO AF to P4...
Really there is something strange about it...or something I dont understand..Maybe we will have to wait until the game is released but my doubt still exist and nobody has been able to give a explanatory answer..If the AMD were a 64 model I would understand it..but not with a XP..I think it is to much punisment to P4 3.0 and I want to understand it...Thanks again and specially to Mike because I still have the same doubt.
I have to wonder what benches you've based your CPU comparisons on. I pray to God it's not THG...