The Official DOOM 3 [H]ardware Guide thread.

theelviscerator said:
and a 3.0 can be overclocked to near 4 ghz grasshopper...
[sarcasm]
And Intels says they're their having trouble getting near 4ghz.
[/sarcasm]

I wonder why though if some of their chips already can get close to that (of course I've only seen some phase change setups do it ;) )
 
see sig below.....do you think if i went with the BFG 6800GT OC that i could get 1920X1080 <HDTV BABY> resolution with no AA and 8X AF at a decent framerate with the system below?

DASHlT
 
theelviscerator said:
...the people in these forums may not realize how elite our systems really are compared to joe schmo at home....who doesnt belong to say Hardocp, overclockers.com..etc.......

Excellent point. In fact I would venture to guess that the average casual gamer doesn't post to forums, and probably hasn't even heard of [H]ard|OCP (no offense guys). The average casual gamer typically relies on people like us, the gaming enthusiasts, to pass on the information. You all know who I'm talking about. That friend, or co-worker, or relative who is always asking you what is the best game, or what is the best video card. That is the average casual gamer. We, the readers and especially the frequent posters here, are the 2nd tier if you will, of gaming and hardware information. We are the ones who voraciously read, then test and tweak, until we know the real deal inside and out. Then we pass the information on to others. Think about how many buying decisions for other people you've influenced. That said, when you keep company like this, you do have to pull yourself in now and again and remember that not only do most people *not* upgrade their systems every 6 months, but that they don't want to either. Most casual gamers want their PC to be an appliance, like an Xbox or PS2. A device that stays static for years, yet is still capable of playing the latest games. With that in mind, the comment from the EBGames guy about Doom3 being beyond the capabilities of his average customer makes sense.
 
theelviscerator said:
I was talking to someone at my local EBgames about the release date for doom3 {like you WILL have this on the 3rd right}, I mentioned it was going to be a HUGE title you know and he said,,,

I dont think so, most of the customers here cant meet the minimum requirements. avg pc is 1.2 of my customers...

I was kinda shocked to hear that...food for thought...

the people in these forums may not realize how elite our systems really are compared to joe schmo at home....who doesnt belong to say Hardocp, overclockers.com..etc.......

You are forgetting about Xbox...

Think of how huge Halo was and it was limited to just the Xbox for it's peak selling time. When you increase the number of platforms the game can be played on, you're going to increase your target audience. Lots of people have Xboxes now. (heck, they even out sold PS2 a month or so ago) So, the average Joe may not have an uber PC, but lots of average Joes have Xboxes.
 
superpata said:
paraiso36 u are crazy!! an amd 64 3000 is faster than any p4 3.2 in games.. and if u are talking about new games even a 3.4 extreme edition will fall behind the 3000 lol!
u can compare a p4 with an axp but not with an a64 when u talk about gaming performance.


ps: ant newcastle amd 64 3000 can be clocked to 2,3 ghz with stock cooling easily, wich is = to +- 3500+ :D just look at the overclock they did with the 3000 :p


Am I mad???? If you carefully read my review I said that the intended rivals for a P4 3.2 are AMD 64 3200 or 3400...I also stated that from benchmarks AMD 64 beats P4 3.2 more than marginally talking about games!!..Maybe I disnt post clear but I dont know if AMD 64 3000 is faster than P4 3.2 but from benchmarks I have read they are very equal ( sometimes wins P4 other AMD 64 3000..see http://www6.tomshardware.com/cpu/20040318/athlon-fx53-18.html).What is wrong with what I have stated?...So we both are crazy..because we both agree about it...So no problem I see....

The problem about the the tests result is between an AMD Xp 3200 and P4 3.0. I recalc IT ISNT AN AMD 64, ONLY AMD XP and in that conditions I state that P4 3.0 es better than Xp 3200 in almost all test...so I dont understand the tests result considering that AMD XP is even only with 512 MB Ram...About AMD 64 they are out of the fight...Thanks ;)
 
parasio i posted a separate post about this that is waiting replies because the discussion in this thread is too varied and our issue loses view time quickly
 
CrimandEvil said:
[sarcasm]
And Intels says they're their having trouble getting near 4ghz.
[/sarcasm]

I wonder why though if some of their chips already can get close to that (of course I've only seen some phase change setups do it ;) )


this chip would probably do it on water but i dont care for the hassle of wcooling...

intel wants a chip that can run 4 gig on air with a stock hsf in a hot room and a crappy case...all about stability i guess.
 
ZaDar said:
I know the editors didn't really think that a newer card would exist in an older machine, but here I am with that exact issue.

Currently system specs are:

AMD Athlon XP 2400+
A7V333 Mainboard
1 GB PC-333 DDR-SDRAM
ATI Radeon 9800 XT

Nothing is overclocked (except the built in overclock in the Catalyst drivers is enabled)
No real expensive extra cooling in the case except for 3 extra case fans (makes it a bit loud, but hey)

I am *hoping* the extra muscle from the video card would let me play 1024x768 HQ, but I am suspecting I may either have to drop to 800x600 HQ or do 1024x768 MQ.

Also, I am running a dual monitor setup (one CRT and 1 flat panel) - unfortunately I have no real concept of whether or not that would entail a serious performance hit. I can always disable the second monitor for playing if need be, but just curious if you guys feel that would be a real issue or not.

Never been a real performance freak, though I do like having nice performance in my systems when I buy them.

The video card was purchased for Halflife 2 just when it was "supposed to be released" then the code theft happened (sigh).

Thoughts? (thanks in advance)

Sorry for the shameless bump.... I posted late last night and it's now over 150 posts later =/

I've been trying to guess at what I could do based on the report, and I just don't really have a feel for how much of an impact processor has over graphics card. The report says that a AMD 3200 with the 9800 XT can do 1024x768 HQ, but there is no XT on the 2500+ -- I even have a slight step down from that with only a 2400+. I have plenty of memory though so I'm hoping that will help some... Im hoping for 1024x768 HQ, and just at a guess I think I'd get a nicer experience doing 800x600 HQ than I would 1024x768 MQ, but wouldn't mind if anyone would comment on which would be a better play experience.

Overall, I must say Im impressed with the guide, hats off to the writers!
 
Go for 800x600 HQ, I think it's possible. You really shoulc upgrade your MB and memory to something alittle more current.
 
bruninggrave - thanks for those benchmarks, wow ATi loosing in Far Cry? Not by much but still, before they were winning, now loosing. Plus 6800 has extra/better IQ options for far cry etc...

wow even in UT2004, Nvidia is that bit ahead, I wonder if they have better image quality?
 
i agree with u paradise, p4 should have high quality to, especialy in this game, since it seems the bottleneck are the cards and i have seen some charts where a much faster cpu outperforms the other by just 2 or 3 fps:D. Anyway those bench u showed me are mostly synthetic, 3d mark is based, mostly, in the card power and aquamark uses ht but not 64 bit instuctions. if u see normal gaming benchmark u will notice how a64 are much faster, again i agree with u when it comes to axp performance.(its indeed slower or equal to p4 3000 in gaming performance)
 
Hey guys, great article on Doom 3 hardware. How do you think this system will do in Doom 3?:

ASUS P4P800 Deluxe (i865PE/ICH5R, DDR400)
Intel Pentium 4 ("C") Northwood HT at 2859MHz (OC from 2600MHz)
2xCorsair "Value Select" SDRAM-DDR 256MB (512MB in dual-channel mode)
Latencies: 2.5-4-4-8 (could probably go lower)
Speed: DDR400/PC3200​
(soon) BFGTech GeForce 6800 GT OC 256 MB GDDR3
Core Clock: 370MHz (vs. 350MHz standard)
Memory Clock: 1000MHz (effective)
555 million vertices/sec setup
32.0GB/second memory bandwidth​
RAID 0 (2xWestern Digital 40GB) <-- will be my Doom 3 install drive
On-board 5.1 surround sound with SoundMAX
Logitech headphones and Creative 5.1 speakers
Antec 300W Power Supply (has been perfectly adequate so far, with an ATI Radeon 9500 Pro)
Windows XP Professional

Also, I plugged my system into a Kill-a-Watt watt meter, and I found out that with an ATI Radeon 9500 Pro and all of the above specs, I was only using about 180W while in a Quake 3 timedemo. With a GF6800 GT, let's say that it uses 40 more watts... so about 220W total on an Antec 300W (69% efficiency). I don't know much about electricity; Do you think 300W is enough power for the GeForce 6800 GT at minimum (factoring in the efficiency and stuff)?; I'll be practically broke after buying a $500 video card. I would really rather spend the money on some cheap half-gig of RAM, seeing that I will be spending at least $100 for a quality power supply with Active PFC and support for SATA/PCI Express (future-proof).

One more thing: does anyone know how much a GeForce 6800 GT or Ultra with 512MB of memory would cost?

P.S. By the way, I have about $700 to spend on the upgrade. Any recommendations would be awesome.

Thanks a ton,
xtknight
 
Blad3 said:
bruninggrave - thanks for those benchmarks, wow ATi loosing in Far Cry? Not by much but still, before they were winning, now loosing. Plus 6800 has extra/better IQ options for far cry etc...

wow even in UT2004, Nvidia is that bit ahead, I wonder if they have better image quality?


funny i can still outrun 6800 gts in sm3.0 using 1.1 patch and default shaders...on my pro...
 
ZaDar said:
Sorry for the shameless bump.... I posted late last night and it's now over 150 posts later =/

I've been trying to guess at what I could do based on the report, and I just don't really have a feel for how much of an impact processor has over graphics card. The report says that a AMD 3200 with the 9800 XT can do 1024x768 HQ, but there is no XT on the 2500+ -- I even have a slight step down from that with only a 2400+. I have plenty of memory though so I'm hoping that will help some... Im hoping for 1024x768 HQ, and just at a guess I think I'd get a nicer experience doing 800x600 HQ than I would 1024x768 MQ, but wouldn't mind if anyone would comment on which would be a better play experience.

Overall, I must say Im impressed with the guide, hats off to the writers!

Naw, you can probably go for 1024x768 HQ. Just look at the minimal difference of the 9800xt scores on an xp3200 and Athlon64-FX53:

http://www2.hardocp.com/1090787143TO62AMOEWX_7_8_l.gif
http://www2.hardocp.com/1090787143TO62AMOEWX_17_7_l.gif

Considering the cpu difference between those two, I can't imagine there being a lot of difference going from a xp2400 to a xp3200 on a 9800 series card.

Hell, the faster system even gets lower fps, due to some margin of error. Your xp2400 will probably get 2-3fps less *at most*, if at all.
 
Blad3 said:
...and the fact that it probably won't catch up for nvidia with doom3 for a while and that it could even be better in HL2 than ATI and that I'll be going with nvidia if this happens. SO will many other's...


Agreed. I'm not married to ATI, and frankly, bang for the buck is solidly with nVidia right now. If you would have told me 6 months ago that I would be considering a 6800nu, I would have thought you were crazy. The doom 3 results show that nVidia is much stronger in OGL, and this is important to me because I'm running linux on 2 of my systems. ATI rocks in DirectX, and the 9600 is a fine card, but linux support is not one of their strong points. This isn't an issue for those content to use only Microsoft products, but I'm not one of those people anymore. At this juncture I am about as likely to use internet explorer as I am to advise someone to set up an IIS server :eek:

the X800 is just too freaking expensive. That, and the fact that it is slower in Doom,despite ithe high pricetag is going to influence a lot of the ATI crowd to come back to the nvidia fold. $283 shipped from Newegg for a 6800 is just too sweet in my mind to pass up. It seems ignorant to spend 599 on an x800.
 
Guess I will have to stick with my old system for now.
I would like to wait until nVidia issues a 512 Meg card. If DOOM 3, Half Life 2, STALKER and other future games are going to benefit from more video RAM I figure I may as well do it right the first time. With any luck they will have a card out in 3 months or so.

¸,ø¤º°`°º¤ø,¸¸,ø¤º°º¤ø,¸¸,ø¤º°º¤ø,¸
AMD 2500 Barton (OC @ 2.0 GHz)
MSI K7N2-ILSR (non Delta)
512 MB of Corsair XMS 3200LL
WD Raptor Hard Drive
ATI Brand 9700 Pro
Cooler Master ATCS case
Koolance Exos Water Cooled
CPU-300-H06
GPU-180-V06
GPU-180-H06
InnovaKonvekt-o-Matic MAXI Passive Radiator (Silver)
 
Charon_Sin said:
Guess I will have to stick with my old system for now.
I would like to wait until nVidia issues a 512 Meg card. If DOOM 3, Half Life 2, STALKER and other future games are going to benefit from more video RAM I figure I may as well do it right the first time. With any luck they will have a card out in 3 months or so.

¸,ø¤º°`°º¤ø,¸¸,ø¤º°º¤ø,¸¸,ø¤º°º¤ø,¸
AMD 2500 Barton (OC @ 2.0 GHz)
MSI K7N2-ILSR (non Delta)
512 MB of Corsair XMS 3200LL
WD Raptor Hard Drive
ATI Brand 9700 Pro
Cooler Master ATCS case
Koolance Exos Water Cooled
CPU-300-H06
GPU-180-V06
GPU-180-H06
InnovaKonvekt-o-Matic MAXI Passive Radiator (Silver)

If you've got $700 you might get a 512mb card. GDDR yields as they are, it's gonna be a long time.

No reason for it, doom3 @ high is 99% of ultra.
 
All... just thought I should share my excitment about this (probably) the game of the year. I quickly ordered doom3 last week, and i put together a relatively cheap / midrange system after i read the doom3 related [h]ard-ticles :cool: ...

P4 Prescott 2.4A stock OC 3202MHz
Asus P4P800-E Deluxe
Creative T7700 7.1 set
2 x 512MB DDR400 Dual Channel
2 x 40GB ATA133 7200rpm 8MB buffer RAID 0 stripe set
Radeon 9200SE 128MB AGP8X
Antec Sonata case with 380W PS

Whole setup about $1000 CAD

As all of you can see the weakest link is probably my R9200SE... What do you think I can do in Doom3 with this system?

I am trying my best to find a 6800 GT 256MB AGP here (Vancouver, Canada) I am having no luck locating anyone who has them in stock.

=== I FOUND MSI 6800 GT 256MB AGP8X for $600 CAD IN STOCK ===

Joe
 
geediu said:
All... just thought I should share my excitment about this (probably) the game of the year. I quickly ordered doom3 last week, and i put together a relatively cheap / midrange system after i read the doom3 related [h]ard-ticles :cool: ...

P4 Prescott 2.4A stock OC 3202MHz
Asus P4P800-E Deluxe
Creative T7700 7.1 set
2 x 512MB DDR400 Dual Channel
2 x 40GB ATA133 7200rpm 8MB buffer RAID 0 stripe set
Radeon 9200SE 128MB AGP8X
Antec Sonata case with 380W PS

Whole setup about $1000 CAD

As all of you can see the weakest link is probably my R9200SE... What do you think I can do in Doom3 with this system?

I am trying my best to find a 6800 GT 256MB AGP here (Vancouver, Canada) I am having no luck locating anyone who has them in stock.

Joe

I was thinking that was a pretty decent computer until I got to the Radeon 9200SE.

That card is bad...it has a 64bit interface and isn't DX9 (if I remember correctly).

It would have been much better to spend an additional $20 on a Geforce 5200 with a 128bit interface and DX9 capabilities (although I just would have saved money and gone with a 9600/5700 or greater video card).
 
geediu said:
All... just thought I should share my excitment about this (probably) the game of the year. I quickly ordered doom3 last week, and i put together a relatively cheap / midrange system after i read the doom3 related [h]ard-ticles :cool: ...

P4 Prescott 2.4A stock OC 3202MHz
Asus P4P800-E Deluxe
Creative T7700 7.1 set
2 x 512MB DDR400 Dual Channel
2 x 40GB ATA133 7200rpm 8MB buffer RAID 0 stripe set
Radeon 9200SE 128MB AGP8X
Antec Sonata case with 380W PS

Whole setup about $1000 CAD

As all of you can see the weakest link is probably my R9200SE... What do you think I can do in Doom3 with this system?

I am trying my best to find a 6800 GT 256MB AGP here (Vancouver, Canada) I am having no luck locating anyone who has them in stock.

Joe

800x600 low?
 
Nothing to do with hardware, but I can't wait for someone to remake Doom 2 on the D3 engine. Maybe even a Wolf3D mod? That'll be awesome.
Also I noticed in the screenshots that the space marine is without helmet in D3. It's just not the same!
 
lol, that's because a helmet was a hell of a lot easier to render in Doom2 than a human face was :p
 
FryLock said:
Nothing to do with hardware, but I can't wait for someone to remake Doom 2 on the D3 engine. Maybe even a Wolf3D mod? That'll be awesome.
Also I noticed in the screenshots that the space marine is without helmet in D3. It's just not the same!

nah.. i wanna see hexen above all. ....

also, it will most likely apear that we will be able to seen carrying a different weapon at times!
 
Is anyone going to play DOOM 3 using Omega drivers, or DNA drivers, etc? Let us know how those drivers performed after your testing is done.
 
In the guide they mentioned that an AMD Athlon XP 1800+ will run Doom3 fine but i wondered, since im the owner of one, what i could expect from it.... even with a dx 9 card like the radeon 9700 pro that i have.?

i was hoping for 800x600 with medium details after reading the tests but im not sure.
 
Qwestman said:
Is anyone going to play DOOM 3 using Omega drivers, or DNA drivers, etc? Let us know how those drivers performed after your testing is done.

After hearing about omega drivers I decided to see what they were about. After getting a virus through a popup and then reading they were just tweaked nvidia drivers, I decided omega is about as noob as you can get.
 
moky said:
In the guide they mentioned that an AMD Athlon XP 1800+ will run Doom3 fine but i wondered, since im the owner of one, what i could expect from it.... even with a dx 9 card like the radeon 9700 pro that i have.?

i was hoping for 800x600 with medium details after reading the tests but im not sure.


im wondering if my 2400+ 1 gig of ddr 2700 wiht a 9800pro 128mb 256bit will run ok too ? i just ordered the 9800 getting it on aug 3


is anybody else going to take off work for doom 3 too ? ;)
 
superpata said:
i agree with u paradise, p4 should have high quality to, especialy in this game, since it seems the bottleneck are the cards and i have seen some charts where a much faster cpu outperforms the other by just 2 or 3 fps:D. Anyway those bench u showed me are mostly synthetic, 3d mark is based, mostly, in the card power and aquamark uses ht but not 64 bit instuctions. if u see normal gaming benchmark u will notice how a64 are much faster, again i agree with u when it comes to axp performance.(its indeed slower or equal to p4 3000 in gaming performance)


Ok Quarrels settled...I agree about AMD 64 :) ..intel has a great job to do...
 
Finally through 31 pages of reading. Took some hours. Conclusion, don't ask if your system will play Doom with your specific settings. Look towards the benched systems instead.

Thumbs up to the [H]Crew for being the first to supply us with quality benchmarks.
Though, I have to ask why no Apples to Oranges comparison, with the diffferent platforms all at the same settings. In addition a test of Medium vs. High Quality. It would be nice to have an idea of the performance delta between the two. Not trying to be mr. Complaint here.

I look forward to playing the game, but the thought of investing huge sums of money towards a new graphics card makes me dizzy.
A system upgrade of NF7-S+XP-M 2400 can be done for less than half the price of a 6800GT, makes your system quite up to date, and and the old motherboard and processor can recoup half the upgrade costs.
 
Using ddr2/i925 seems to affect some of the cards strangely. Generally when ddr2 is used it causes an improvement for the x800xt card while causing a slowdown for the 6800 cards, the best example being for the 6800 gt on a p4 3.6:

ddr1/i915:
http://www2.hardocp.com/1090787143TO62AMOEWX_11_2_l.gif

ddr2/i925:
http://www2.hardocp.com/1090787143TO62AMOEWX_14_2_l.gif

and the x800xt on the same systems:

ddr1/i915:
http://www2.hardocp.com/1090787143TO62AMOEWX_11_3_l.gif

ddr2/i925:
http://www2.hardocp.com/1090787143TO62AMOEWX_14_3_l.gif

so my question is, am i missing something obvious or is there some sort of weird conflict/optimisation at work? oh and I think at ddr2 the XT gets its heighest IQ/FR of any system tested, this seems odd...

Oh yeah thanks for the hardware guide, lots of info, being a greedy bastard I would have liked more but given the time limits it was great. btw im thinking i'll be able to get 800*600 at MQ on my athlon 1.33, 512 pc2700 and ti4200 64mb, i was hoping to get 10*7 but i am thinking even 8*6 might be unrealistic :confused:
 
What The Wall Street Journal is to the financial world, HardOCP.com is the same for the PC enthusiast/gamer.

I am just floored by all of the work and results that have been produced. You have prepared thousands of gamers for this Special event..

Plus all of this is free

Now to upgrade :D

Thank you again!

davidj
 
I am sorry if this question or a similar one has already been asked, but I found it tough to try and read through 32 pages of replies. In one test a P4 3.0GHz syestem with 1 GB of RAM and a BFG Geforce 6800nu was used, and the average fps was ~52 at 1600 x 1200 high quality with noAA and 8xAF. Would similar performance be expectable at 1024 x 768 high quality with 2x or 4x AA and 8xAF? I ask this because I have a P4 2.66GHz, 1 gig 2700 RAM, and a Leadtek Geforce 6800nu, but my monitor is only 15 inches. Thanks.
 
bf9 said:
I am sorry if this question or a similar one has already been asked, but I found it tough to try and read through 32 pages of replies. In one test a P4 3.0GHz syestem with 1 GB of RAM and a BFG Geforce 6800nu was used, and the average fps was ~52 at 1600 x 1200 high quality with noAA and 8xAF. Would similar performance be expectable at 1024 x 768 high quality with 2x or 4x AA and 8xAF? I ask this because I have a P4 2.66GHz, 1 gig 2700 RAM, and a Leadtek Geforce 6800nu, but my monitor is only 15 inches. Thanks.

u have a nice system minus the monitor ouchie.:p

oh btw, 1028x res on medium doesnt sound too bad for me. P4 2.8c@3.2, Abit IC7 mobo, 2x512mb ram, and ATI 9800pro 128mb. sounding by the review on hardware required i think i'll be satisfied for now. i guess its a wait and see when i get the game. :D
 
Back
Top