The Official DOOM 3 [H]ardware Guide thread.

burningrave101 said:
I hope your refering to the Athlon 64 because the Pentium 4 beats the Athlon XP in gaming.

The P4 "C" does beat the AXP but then again the AXP was rated to up against the P4 "B" :/ and even then the AXP does a pretty good job against the p4 c in gaming.

And Mike id say the 3200XP is about even if not a little (very little) better than a p4 "c" 3.0Ghz processor as far as performance goes. At least thats what it looks like form most benchmarks from back a year ago.
 
Looks like the sweet spot is:

AMD Athlon64 300+
NVIDIA Geforce FX 6800 GT

Doom3 @ 1024x768 HQ


(which is exactly the system I'm trying to get :D )
 
Unit=0 said:
Because they feel the Athlon XP 3000 can run at high settings.. while the 3.0C P4 runs at medium quality.

What other reason do you need?

Well i dont have an ATI 9800 pro so i'm not worried :p. It could of been a driver issue or the fact it performed better on another motherboard with a different chipset or all kinds of things.

The P4 3.0c with a 6800GT outperformed the AXP 3200+ with a 6800GT though. Only by 1/10 of a fps but still beat it lol.

And here are some recent AXP vs P4 benchmarks at Tech Report. The 3.0c even beats the Athlon XP Mobile running at 2.4Ghz.

http://techreport.com/reviews/2004q1/athlonxp-m-2500/index.x?pg=4
 
Looks like must have 6800 Ultra and change my ATI if only I have the money I'll get an A64 system.

Excellent Guide Kyle!

Do you get paid doing tthis guide?? hehehe
 
AAHHH Nooooo, please kyle or anyone else,

I have a Geforce3. You guys totally forgot to bench it but listed it like crazy?!!?

Can you please go back and see what the benches were, just incase you forgot to add them to the website when you were puting it up?

Please man i need to know how good it does, compared to the G4mx. How much beter does it do? I only seen a picture of it thats it.
 
What I'd like to know is which cards would be best to play both Doom 3 and Half Life 2. I'm about to spend a lot of money on either an X800 Pro (flash it to an XT) or a 6800nu and I want to make sure I get the best gaming experience I can from both games. Id Software has apparently spent a lot of time to get D3 working great on either ATI or nVidia, but has Valve? Does Valve usually tend to lean towards one maker or are they awesome like id? I know there's no real answer as to which is better for both games, but I'd like to hear some ideas so I don't end up kicking myself when HL2 comes out.
 
I'm not sure.. and I'd like to know as well. But if I were to take history into perspective, Valve did a great job with the original HL to play well on a mediocre system. I hope HL2 will be the same.
 
I guess the real question is when will we get our Half Life 2 guide, so we can compare hardware configs to buy? :)

But really, guys, take note of what this article is talking about: you shouldn't be trying to max out framerate or resolution, you should be trying to max out the image quality.

Good games should be created as an experience, with character and atmosphere, not just a few whizbang effects. And that's what we should worry about when we buy gaming hardware, not "he gets more FPS than me b/c my hardware is obsolete but "i'm getting the best possible IQ for the money"
 
This has relieved a lot of my fears...

AMD 1.2/tyan kt133a/512mb pc133/5200u ... at least my HD is fast and the broadband faster. Ghetto I know, but I just lost a matched stick of RAM during a power spike a couple weeks ago, and my tuition reimbursement won't happen till the end of Sept for a new mobo/proc/mem upgrade =(

I think it should be minimally playable and has become my top choice for next game. Time for Halo to get the boot me thinks - and yes, I get decent enough fps on Halo.

Thanks a lot for the great and nearly complete review(gf3's would have been nice to include since my sis and her bf have the ti's) =) Keep up the great work.
 
Any official word on how a Radeon 9700Pro will pull through? I"m assuming acceptable and somewhere inbetween the 9600-9800 series but it would be nice to see some figures or atleast some official word. :confused:
 
burningrave101 said:
Well i dont have an ATI 9800 pro so i'm not worried :p. It could of been a driver issue or the fact it performed better on another motherboard with a different chipset or all kinds of things.

The P4 3.0c with a 6800GT outperformed the AXP 3200+ with a 6800GT though. Only by 1/10 of a fps but still beat it lol.

And here are some recent AXP vs P4 benchmarks at Tech Report. The 3.0c even beats the Athlon XP Mobile running at 2.4Ghz.

http://techreport.com/reviews/2004q1/athlonxp-m-2500/index.x?pg=4

Hey, don't try to make sense of it. :p

It just is because that's the way Kyle and Brent agreed upon. If that isn't like the 11th commandment or something I dunno what is.
 
I know the editors didn't really think that a newer card would exist in an older machine, but here I am with that exact issue.

Currently system specs are:

AMD Athlon XP 2400+
A7V333 Mainboard
1 GB PC-333 DDR-SDRAM
ATI Radeon 9800 XT

Nothing is overclocked (except the built in overclock in the Catalyst drivers is enabled)
No real expensive extra cooling in the case except for 3 extra case fans (makes it a bit loud, but hey)

I am *hoping* the extra muscle from the video card would let me play 1024x768 HQ, but I am suspecting I may either have to drop to 800x600 HQ or do 1024x768 MQ.

Also, I am running a dual monitor setup (one CRT and 1 flat panel) - unfortunately I have no real concept of whether or not that would entail a serious performance hit. I can always disable the second monitor for playing if need be, but just curious if you guys feel that would be a real issue or not.

Never been a real performance freak, though I do like having nice performance in my systems when I buy them.

The video card was purchased for Halflife 2 just when it was "supposed to be released" then the code theft happened (sigh).

Thoughts? (thanks in advance)
 
FryLock said:
What I'd like to know is which cards would be best to play both Doom 3 and Half Life 2. I'm about to spend a lot of money on either an X800 Pro (flash it to an XT) or a 6800nu and I want to make sure I get the best gaming experience I can from both games. Id Software has apparently spent a lot of time to get D3 working great on either ATI or nVidia, but has Valve? Does Valve usually tend to lean towards one maker or are they awesome like id? I know there's no real answer as to which is better for both games, but I'd like to hear some ideas so I don't end up kicking myself when HL2 comes out.

You'll have to buy an X800Pro VIVO to be able to even think about flashing it to an XT. They cost around $450 i believe. And why are you looking at a 6800nu in comparison? Buy a 6800GT which will easily overclock to Ultra speeds and will be faster in DOOM 3 and will give you great performance in Half Life 2 as well. HL2 will even have SM 3.0 support for the 6800's.

If you know anything about Valve then you know they optimize their games to run very well on low end systems. Look at the original Half Life for example.

VeVildUdE said:
Looks like must have 6800 Ultra and change my ATI if only I have the money I'll get an A64 system.

You dont need an A64 system. The processor you have now is more then fast enough. The majority of PC games are GPU intensive. Very few are truly CPU intensive. At 1600x1200 w/ AF enabled in DOOM 3 the P4 is going to perform as well as the A64.

In Hards benches the A64 3500+ only scored .7 fps faster then the Pentium 4 3.0c. They were both using a 6800GT and running 1600x1200 w/ 8xAF.

The only time having an A64 is going to really matter is if your playing a really CPU intensive game or if you get kicks out of sitting and playing at 800x600 lol. And if your playing at 800x600 your fps is going to be so high it wont matter because once your fps breaks the refresh rate of your monitor its useless.
 
One thing that did bug me looking at the guide wasn't as much ATI's overall FPS, but more or less the fact that ATI had so many more dips and valleys in their FPS The overall number seemed to be comparable to the 6800, but the lower frames per second seemed seemed to occur more often on the ATI hardware than on the Nvidia hardware.

I also don't see new drivers making much of a difference, as ATI tends to make smart hardware with drivers that just work. Nvidia on the other hand makes dumb hardware that relies on drivers to improve performance, so we can only assume that these figures will only improve on Nvidia's side once the developers have more time with the 6800.
 
Tim said:
I also don't see new drivers making much of a difference, as ATI tends to make smart hardware with drivers that just work. Nvidia on the other hand makes dumb hardware that relies on drivers to improve performance, so we can only assume that these figures will only improve on Nvidia's side once the developers have more time with the 6800.

Well the 6800's are definitely not dumb hardware :p.

I'll agree that the 5800u was a flop and a half though lol.

And nVidia hasn't even began to optimize their drivers for the 6800's yet. Their still pretty much running with beta's. ATI's X800XT PE is running off mature drivers that are highly optimized. If you turn off Tri and AF ops for the 6800's they lose very little performance. AF ops even come OFF by default now. This just shows that nVidia hasn't needed to optimize very much to have a card that runs as fast as the X800's.

I've heard several people say that nVidia is working on better optimizations to be included in the 62.xx series drivers. People are already getting nice Far Cry performance boosts from the 62.xx series drivers that have been leaked recently.
 
MadSkills said:
But really, guys, take note of what this article is talking about: you shouldn't be trying to max out framerate or resolution, you should be trying to max out the image quality.

Good games should be created as an experience, with character and atmosphere, not just a few whizbang effects. And that's what we should worry about when we buy gaming hardware, not "he gets more FPS than me b/c my hardware is obsolete but "i'm getting the best possible IQ for the money"

In my opinion framerate and resolution are the key part of gaming (unless you're playing Pitfall). You're right in some ways, there's different types of gamers, but I happen to be a multiplayer FPS gamer, so I need high frames and res to be able to stay alive as long as I can. Image quality doesn't really factor in much when I'm trying to run backwards up a spiral staircase while fending off 2 guys with lightning guns, I need frames to see where I'm going.
I think that's one of the points they were trying to make with the "Real-world Gaming Experience" charts that they made. They indicated that there were differences in image quality at a few places between the manufacturers, but they didn't notice anything when they were playing.
 
Nice guide. But still, you guys haven't described how it feels to play Doom 3 in Matrox's Surround Gaming. That must be mind blowing. Even more then whatever better FPS can give. Please include a little Parhelia.
 
burningrave101 said:
Well the 6800's are definitely not dumb hardware :p.

I'll agree that the 5800u was a flop and a half though lol.

And nVidia hasn't even began to optimize their drivers for the 6800's yet. Their still pretty much running with beta's. ATI's X800XT PE is running off mature drivers that are highly optimized. If you turn off Tri and AF ops for the 6800's they lose very little performance. AF ops even come OFF by default now. This just shows that nVidia hasn't needed to optimize very much to have a card that runs as fast as the X800's.

I've heard several people say that nVidia is working on better optimizations to be included in the 62.xx series drivers. People are already getting nice Far Cry performance boosts from the 62.xx series drivers that have been leaked recently.

What I meant by "dumb" is that the hardware is never optimized in the way that ATI's hardware is. It's more of a pure brute force method of computingwith the drivers to optimize performance, while ATI relies on the hardware itself to be fast and optimized and the drivers to just implement it.
 
Mike Ryna said:
not to be a prick cuz i know how much went in to this and how great you guys are for doing this but STILL we have not gotten an answer as to why the p4 3.0ghz with 9800pro 128mb is suggested at medium 1024 while the athon xp 3200 is recommended at high...

this deserves at least some explanation :D

I have the 2.8ghz of that p4 with the same card and 1gb pc3200 so that test is very relevant to me. JW why not high? This q has been asked since at least page 6 I think.

your 2.8 should oc to 3.5 or so with decent cooling maybe more...boom...high settings..
 
22killer said:
AAHHH Nooooo, please kyle or anyone else,

I have a Geforce3. You guys totally forgot to bench it but listed it like crazy?!!?

Can you please go back and see what the benches were, just incase you forgot to add them to the website when you were puting it up?

Please man i need to know how good it does, compared to the G4mx. How much beter does it do? I only seen a picture of it thats it.

Please I need to know before saturday. Certain reasons.
 
How delicate is the balance between the CPU and video requirements? Granted I am in dire need of a complete overhaul, but I have a GF4Ti4200 (slightly better than min., although on an agp1x mobo) and a 1ghz tbird (less than min.) with 384mb of ram. Will this be playable?
 
I'd upgrade the mobo + cpu.. you can do that for about $100 if you are a smart buyer.

Pricewatch: AMD XP 2400+ $57 KT333 mobo for $37

And I forget if you have SDRAM or DDR.. but if you need DDR, it's another $47 for 512mb of PC2100
 
First, thanks so much for all the hard work and the detailed write up.

I'm working with a 1.4GHZ Athlon machine with an ATI 9600 128MB card with 600+ RAM. IDo you guys think the 1.4 as opposed to the 1.5GHZ will prevent me from playing? This seems like a silly question, but I'm just wondering if it's worth my while to buy the game.

Thanks in advance for your time!
 
apc said:
How delicate is the balance between the CPU and video requirements? Granted I am in dire need of a complete overhaul, but I have a GF4Ti4200 (slightly better than min., although on an agp1x mobo) and a 1ghz tbird (less than min.) with 384mb of ram. Will this be playable?
if the page about the min specs show that the minium machine cant even run it @ 30 avg fps, then i doubt yours will be playable. the fact that your mobo is agp 1x will hurt
 
callon said:
First, thanks so much for all the hard work and the detailed write up.

I'm working with a 1.4GHZ Athlon machine with an ATI 9600 128MB card with 600+ RAM. IDo you guys think the 1.4 as opposed to the 1.5GHZ will prevent me from playing? This seems like a silly question, but I'm just wondering if it's worth my while to buy the game.

Thanks in advance for your time!
that 100mhz difference wont hurt you at all because the two things that really matter you have higher than min spec: video card and mem. your video card will help you out alot. your system should do fine.
 
sorry if this was asked a few pages back
but i dont see a difference between the high and ultra high shots

can this difference can be observed better while playing the game?
 
Aztlan said:
sorry if this was asked a few pages back
but i dont see a difference between the high and ultra high shots

can this difference can be observed better while playing the game?
the answer to that is no, they said in the article u will probably not see any difference because of the rapid gameplay. where it came into play was mainly the fat monster's stomach and floor which clearly had more lighting and effects applied to it. They also said u will see signficicant greater graphics at higher resolutions then lower rather then bumping up the quality.
 
Aztlan said:
sorry if this was asked a few pages back
but i dont see a difference between the high and ultra high shots

can this difference can be observed better while playing the game?
there really is much difference, you cant really notice it while you are playing but in the screenshoot provided, ultra had more detail on the guy's belly than high. from what i saw and [h] said, not really much a difference at all.
 
In ultra mode specular and diffuse maps arent compressed. These maps deal with how the lighting appears on the texture. To see a difference you must know what to look for, specular lighting is the "shine" while diffuse lighting is what most consider lighting =)

http://www.beyond3d.com/articles/vs/lighting-specular-sphere.gif here's a picture that gives you the idea.

Since these are not compressed they are capable of having greater detail. The screenshots, however, are compressed jpegs. So its hard to tell from what we know; my guess is that unless you have a high attention to detail you wouldnt be able to tell a difference.
 
Need I say more Hardocp is simply the best. Top in my fav list.
! question though How come you recommend Radeon 9800 pro on high settings when it drops to 6 fps in minimum. Also would the game behave diffrent in the highest mode of difficulty?

And I am planning to buy an A64 newcastle proccy Socket 754, with Radeon 9800 pro how will the game run on that will it be similar to 3000+ barton? Also can you suggest me a board which will help me to oc the proccy ( I am proably out of topic here, kindly ignore me if thats the case)
 
This guide was the best I have ever seen. It is a true testiment to all of us, that they spent all that time testing for our benefits. I was going to buy new hardware for a game, and cancelled them all after seeing this guide.

They have spent a great deal of time responding to our questions. I can think of 3 other works for the [H]:

[H]onorable
[H]onest
[H]ardworking

This is why I spend 90% of my webbrowsing on this site.

Thanks for this great no wait "FUCKING AWESOME" Guide.
 
OM - HardOCP on IGN.com - well done. All that "hard work" you did is really paying off :D
 
thanks Qwertyman and avatar_of_might, Lord of Shadows for the explanation

I better read the article
but tiresome from 1 1/2 hour of being stuck in traffic doesnt allow you to :(
 
I read the guide and i was wondering why there is no benchmark for the ati radeon cards with the Athlon 64 3000. I have a similar setup and would really like to know how they perform with that processor.

I have
a64 3200
x800 xt pe
1 gig of corsair 3200LL memory
 
Hello all !! its been a long time since i have been in the hardware scene a very long time at that... however i have a weird setup and with the announcement of DOOM 3 i want to know if i may be able to play it ... i use my computer for my work but i want to try doom 3 hehee so because of what i do for a living it explains my system specs.

if anyone has any idea how doom 3 would run please let me know because im not sure how my video card would work!! thanks so much!

system specs.
Windows xp Pro
Intel Dual Xeon's @ 2.2ghz
1 GB RAM
nVidia Quadro 4 900 XGL 128 megs of ram
120 gb 7200 rpm
Creative Labs Audigy 2 ZS
 
Back
Top