Switching from iPhone to Android: Beware First Impressions

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
TechCrunch has an article about the author switching from an iPhone to a Droid and warns about how first impressions are often misleading. The author definitely makes some solid points & it’s something to consider when you’re reading all of the comparison articles (like the one below) that are starting to hit the web regarding the Nexus One.

Imagine if you took a longtime Windows user and sat them in front of a Mac for a couple days. They’d probably complain about superficial things like the change in mouse acceleration and the “unintuitive” button placement (the Close button is on the opposite side of the window). It’s not until a week or two after you start using a Mac as your primary computer that you overcome these issues and begin to fully grasp some of the benefits it offers. No, it may not be for you, but there’s really no way you can tell for sure without taking the plunge and using one as your primary computer. It’s the same way with Android.
 
Longtime iphone users are biased? Say it ain't so!

I wonder if it's even possible to find someone in the tech community who HASN'T used an iphone to do an unbiased review of the droid or nexus.
 
As far as iPhone users are concerned, there will never be a phone superior to an iPhone. Apple could choose not to update the iPhone in any way for the next 5 years and iPhone users will still claim their phone is superior to any current offerings.:rolleyes:
 
I find it depressing that someone gets paid to write an article about something that should be common sense. Although being a Droid user I would love to convert my friend who is an iPhone evangelist...
 
I wish people would stop comparing things to the iPhone and just be happy for a good alternative

Everyone compares stuff to the most common or best in category. It's our nature to try and gauge value.

Though I agree, people are comparisons are too specific. These are 2 devices made by 2 companies. They will be different.

I have a droid, and think the iphone is a good phone for some and revolutionized the smartphone industry.

I also had a blackberry... which also has its merits.

I think android is a greate smartphone OS... my only complaints are small and easily fixable.
 
Love my Droid (other than the "cloud" obsession; there are a lot of applications that I'd love to see working in tandem with, or as a direct extension to, my desktop or other techs like ODB-II) but I can see iPhone users being thrown when first using Android. On the iPhone, Apple sets everything up for you and tells you how you are going to use it while Android acts more like a traditional OS and merely provides a platform for other apps to run on. That and Apple's crappy development support drove me away from the iPhone, but I can understand the attraction for those who like the default configuration and application selection of the iPhone.

I think that Google would do well to create something like a set of configuration wizards aimed toward walking users through some of the common steps like selecting notifications and syncing accounts. Reduce the barrier to entry while leaving the options intact.
 
I appreciate the perspective he takes. I think everyone needs to be this one with any tech.
You get used to certain things and new things can seem unfamiliar and therefore not as good at first until it grows on you.
 
I've never used an iPhone (ATT service sucks where I live), and picked up the Droid. I have used BB and WimMo before and I like Android better. It's intuitive enough to figure things out. Didn't seem any more difficult than Blackberry.
 
Longtime iphone users are biased? Say it ain't so!

I wonder if it's even possible to find someone in the tech community who HASN'T used an iphone to do an unbiased review of the droid or nexus.

That goes for any smart phones for the most part. I was a decade-long Blackberry user from the bulking black and white unit (I forget the model) all the way up to the 9000 Bold. My boss convinced me to try my current iPhone 3Gs and I hated it for a couple weeks. I'm deaf, so texting and emailing is a must for me and getting used to the touchscreen keyboard was a very frustrating experience.

I can do it in my sleep now, and I love the iPhone. It's a neat little device.

I'd imagine I would go through similar experience switching to a Droid phone.
 
Speaking as an iPhone to Droid convert I can safely say I don't miss my iPhone one bit. Honestly my Droid has been more problem free then my iPhone 3G ever was. Not to mention the lack of dropped phone calls, better 3G speeds, and cheaper plan.
 
I want something other then this iPhone, but you have to admit they really aren't trying very hard. Bad 3G that doesn't work with AT&T anyways (locked into contract) and not as responsive touch screen that lags multi touch. Not to mention how I'm I going to listen to my audio books and watch my digital copies of my movies on the go. That last part I can live without.
 
I wonder if it's even possible to find someone in the tech community who HASN'T used an iphone to do an unbiased review of the droid or nexus.
Why would iPhone ownership necessarily imply bias? It's pretty easy to just boil phones down to what features each supports and how they're set up as far as the GUI is concerned. Good working knowledge of a wide array of phones is what's going to give a reviewer the ability to really hone in on the pros and cons of each platform, and that's what people are going to want: how does this phone compare to that one; how do these iPhone competitors compare to the iPhone; how does the iPhone compare to the Blackberry; etc.

You give me two weeks with any phone and I'll give you an unbiased review of it. It isn't impossible. It isn't even particularly difficult.

Bad 3G that doesn't work with AT&T anyways (locked into contract) and not as responsive touch screen that lags multi touch.
AT&T's set to start offering Android phones fairly soon. I'm not certain of which models.

Not to mention how I'm I going to listen to my audio books and watch my digital copies of my movies on the go. That last part I can live without.
Android phones are great for that. Particularly the Moto Droid and the Nexus One, which can play back greater-than-DVD resolution video. They're both expandable with SDHC-ready slots, so you can really load up on video and audio quality assuming you have the budget for SDHC cards.
 
Android phones are great for that. Particularly the Moto Droid and the Nexus One, which can play back greater-than-DVD resolution video. They're both expandable with SDHC-ready slots, so you can really load up on video and audio quality assuming you have the budget for SDHC cards.

I second that. Use mine for videos/podcasts/music/audiobooks every day. Droid screen beats the snot out of iPhone 3G.
 
Yeah, but I can't watch iTunes format movies, not sure about iTunes format audio books.
 
Going from an iPhone to Droid. I can relate to the article. The iPhone is great device. The phone on it has always sucked and the interface isn't as customizable or responsive. But it does give a user a total experiance. It has quite a bit of polish on it like a lot of Apple stuff. To be honest the Droid feel exactly like what it is. Linux! You have to actively go out and track down everything you want this to do. And there are usually 5 different ways to achieve the same end result and none of them feel smooth and seamless. Syncing to your PC is anything but simple and enjoyable. and the fact that I need to run everything through google as if its some central repository for all of my information I would normall keep on a PC is irritating. Maybe I don't get the whole "cloud" thing. I'm too old I suppose.

That being said I still prefer clean crisp sounding phone calls that don't drop and web connection everywhere i go. When i have a problem CS takes care of it fairly quickly. That's refreshing after the cornholing i got with ATT. not too mention I actually like my droid and hope that eventually the wrinkles will get ironed out.
 
. . .To be honest the Droid feel exactly like what it is. Linux! You have to actively go out and track down everything you want this to do. And there are usually 5 different ways to achieve the same end result and none of them feel smooth and seamless. Syncing to your PC is anything but simple and enjoyable. and the fact that I need to run everything through google as if its some central repository for all of my information I would normall keep on a PC is irritating. Maybe I don't get the whole "cloud" thing. I'm too old I suppose.

And there lies the rub. . . The iPhone is SO EASY. A friend of mine's mother (who is 70+) uses it to facebook with her grandkids. There is nothing on the market the is easier than an iPhone for the masses. The iPhone brought non smartphone people to a smartphone.

Is this not a PC vs Mac debate? Sure a PC can do more but it is not as "easy."

Part of my job is cell phone deployment and generally speaking people are indifferent about their Windows Mobile phones, they like their blackberries and they LOVE their iPhones. I would imagine that android would be a kin to a blackberry (as we have not used them as their support for exchange is lacking).

Remember we are [H]! We are not average.
 
And there lies the rub. . . The iPhone is SO EASY. A friend of mine's mother (who is 70+) uses it to facebook with her grandkids. There is nothing on the market the is easier than an iPhone for the masses. The iPhone brought non smartphone people to a smartphone.

Is this not a PC vs Mac debate? Sure a PC can do more but it is not as "easy."

Part of my job is cell phone deployment and generally speaking people are indifferent about their Windows Mobile phones, they like their blackberries and they LOVE their iPhones. I would imagine that android would be a kin to a blackberry (as we have not used them as their support for exchange is lacking).

Remember we are [H]! We are not average.

Agreed, same reason I am wondering about the impact of the iSlate. It should be a very simple device to use if it uses the same kind of OS as the iPhone.
 
I'm waiting for another generation before I touch Droid-- even though its 2.0 it still feels 1.0 in a lot of ways. I'm on a Palm Pre and kind of over it due to sluggishness, but yet haven't been able to pull myself away from the multitasking it can do -- I hate the "one at a time" app approach on iPhone, having to hit Home button and exiting the app. Things still feel bleeding edge right now on pretty much everything right now, in another 1-2 years hopefully we'll have gear with lightning fast response times that also multi-task and can hold a decent charge. I like the idea of a Google phone as well (Nexus One) but the videos I've seen still make Android "feel" like a beta O/S.
 
And there lies the rub. . . The iPhone is SO EASY.

yep, I agree, I have an iPhone (2g) and a G1 both on T-Mobile and for "normal" use (phone/text/email/web) I find myself using the iPhone 90% of the time, the G1 has major advantages like 3G, console access, a lot of utilities I use (and Google SkyMap AWESOME APP) but half the time the phone is asking me if I want to "Wait or Force Quit"... its just a more frustrating experience... of course nothing compares to the frustration of years of WinMo phones
 
Back
Top