Studies Show Piracy is Now Mainstream

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Torrentfreak has an article that talks about how recent studies from Canada and Spain indicate that file-sharing software users that download movies and music is up to almost 50% of all respondents. Maybe all the heavy-handed DRM schemes and copyright-violator witch hunts isn’t working as well as the industry had hoped.

The results of these two reports clearly show that public opinion is changing in favor of P2P users. So how did this happen? Could it be that the Internet has changed the way we interact with digital media? Unlike 10 years ago, people are now used to unlimited access to all kinds of information, much of it thanks to Google. The Internet allows people to access an unlimited library of information, and at an increasing rate people demand the same experience for TV, music and other forms of digital information, as the studies show.
 
Sociologists have known about this for a while. The culture of file sharing that has developed over the last several years has meant that now downloading music, movies, and games illegally is just as common as buying them - even expected, in the case of music, as I simply can't keep up with some of my friends due to my refusal to pirate most things (I do make an exception for professional-grade software that I absolutely cannot afford, would never buy, and would never use professionally, such as audio production stuff). Piracy is mainstream - even if it's not done with torrents, it exists on YouTube, over instant messaging services, forums, RapidShare, you name it. My highly religious relatives even have a film collection made up of dozens of high-quality DVD rips, none of which were purchased. It's not viewed as wrong, or immoral by most. Capitalism is centred around acquisition of products and things, and it encourages getting the best deals whenever possible - what better deal is there than free? Since the victims of the crime are invisible, piracy isn't considered criminal.
 
I see it as more along the analogy of "the forbidden fruit".

That which is forbidden is most desirable.

All these heavy handed tactics and saying "No you can't do that" seems to make people more inclined to do it anyway.

:cool:
 
I forgot to mention one thing.

There's this whole notion of "freedom of information" on the Internet, the idea being that every bit of information should be accessible to everyone - no privileging, no fees, etc. The huge problem with this is that supporters of piracy and file sharing often take "information" to include all intellectual property and creative content, not just information. For them, music, movies, television, games, etc. should all be free because they quality as "information". This is a weak and pathetic justification at best, but it shows just how perceptions of creative works have changed in recent years amongst many people.

Of course, I'd like to see these people actually producing this intellectual property, because if they wanted to make a living creating and selling it, and cared about what they were producing, then they sure as hell wouldn't be calling it "information".
 
I forgot to mention one thing.

There's this whole notion of "freedom of information" on the Internet, the idea being that every bit of information should be accessible to everyone - no privileging, no fees, etc. The huge problem with this is that supporters of piracy and file sharing often take "information" to include all intellectual property and creative content, not just information. For them, music, movies, television, games, etc. should all be free because they quality as "information". This is a weak and pathetic justification at best, but it shows just how perceptions of creative works have changed in recent years amongst many people.

Of course, I'd like to see these people actually producing this intellectual property, because if they wanted to make a living creating and selling it, and cared about what they were producing, then they sure as hell wouldn't be calling it "information".


come to think about it, our definition of the word "steal" has changed over the years. Because today software pirates steal just a sequence of zeros and ones
 
Software, movie, and music piracy is as tangible as saying taking a picture of someone or something as stealing them. You do not have any effect on the original, you can copy something a million times yet the original is unharmed and the copy is untraceable and undecernable from the original...

This form of piracy is nothing new, I remember back in the 1980's that nearly all larger "boomboxes" had two tape decks specifically for making duplicates of tapes. This was piracy yet no one cared, why should they care if you copy a dvd or cd?
 
This was piracy yet no one cared, why should they care if you copy a dvd or cd?

because some people realized that their wallets were getting thinner because of this, and well they didn't like it
 
I forgot to mention one thing.

There's this whole notion of "freedom of information" on the Internet, the idea being that every bit of information should be accessible to everyone - no privileging, no fees, etc. The huge problem with this is that supporters of piracy and file sharing often take "information" to include all intellectual property and creative content, not just information. For them, music, movies, television, games, etc. should all be free because they quality as "information". This is a weak and pathetic justification at best, but it shows just how perceptions of creative works have changed in recent years amongst many people.

Of course, I'd like to see these people actually producing this intellectual property, because if they wanted to make a living creating and selling it, and cared about what they were producing, then they sure as hell wouldn't be calling it "information".

piracy is not criminal, you never actually steal anything...

also i do believe all information is free. I'm a musician, i make my money from doing shows and selling t-shirts...fuck it take my music for free.... if i see you at the show then thats what matters, and even if you don't pay for merch or shows, if you dig the music you pass it on and sooner or later it gets into the hands of someone who will pay.

see if works both ways
 
piracy is not criminal, you never actually steal anything...

also i do believe all information is free. I'm a musician, i make my money from doing shows and selling t-shirts...fuck it take my music for free.... if i see you at the show then thats what matters, and even if you don't pay for merch or shows, if you dig the music you pass it on and sooner or later it gets into the hands of someone who will pay.

see if works both ways

I think in the end is just greed, greed from the people who has lots of money and control all that stuff and they see that they could make even more money if the people who gets piracy stuff would pay them up, and they want that money
 
because some people realized that their wallets were getting thinner because of this, and well they didn't like it

I meant the people not the Studio's.

To steal is to take the original, to make a forgery is to make a copy of the original. The MPAA and RIAA are going after people for the wrong thing in the first place.
Secondly I know of no one who has and I know I have never paid for a copy of any movie, software, or song that was made via "illegal" means. How can they justify suing for anything more then the face value of a cd/dvd.. etc.

I only brows the torrent sites for audio books, I do this for two fold reasons, one most of the audio books I want have been out of production for many years or they were only released in tape format. Either way they are not avaliable to me a willing customer so I will find my alternate means to acquire what I want.
Before you yell "burn him" I have legally purchased hundreds of audio books in my life, I would of gladly purchased the ones I pirated if I could of found them in a format useful to me.
 
And when content rakers can't make money they'll just stop. Can't pirate what doesn't exist.
 
I'd say free information for everyone!
but as long as some people are profiting from it, they are gonna bitch about it

Secondly I know of no one who has and I know I have never paid for a copy of any movie, software, or song that was made via "illegal" means. How can they justify suing for anything more then the face value of a cd/dvd.. etc.

well I know a lot!! :D
I currently live in Peru, a very nice country in South America, and over here almost 80% of software comes from piracy. Software comes here very expensive, not only because the software is already expensive but because of the taxes here, very pricy, so you get a higher price tag than on the US for example.

You could get here almost any software you want, if you wanna but the Adobe Suite with all the Adobe programs, around 4 dvds i think, you could get it here for around 5 bucks!!! with crack included!!!
The authorities know about this, but they really don't do anything about it, i mean they raid those places sometimes, but in the end they just come back, they can't do anything about, people just can't afford the expensive software!! they save money for years just to be able to buy a 400 dollar PC and the think of having to expend more than 100 bucks for an OS is crazy for them, and well i don't blame them :(
 
And when content rakers can't make money they'll just stop. Can't pirate what doesn't exist.

Oh no, the content makers will take their ball and go home. The newest of the corpratocracies bullshit, "let's go Gault!" We live in a capitalist society, so if EA doesn't want to make games anymore I'm sure there are fifty or so other studios who want all that business. Let them cry like babies and quit their jobs. My brother can take one of them since Lexicon just laid him off.
 
Oh no, the content makers will take their ball and go home. The newest of the corpratocracies bullshit, "let's go Gault!" We live in a capitalist society, so if EA doesn't want to make games anymore I'm sure there are fifty or so other studios who want all that business. Let them cry like babies and quit their jobs. My brother can take one of them since Lexicon just laid him off.

If people steal EA's stuff, why wouldn't they steal your brothers stuff? Piracy would tend to hurt the little guy even more I would think. Surely your brother isn't going to make games if he can't make a living doing it.
 
Money became intangible with the advent of credit cards and people started treating it as an unlimited asset and racked up debt. The same eventually happened with software and other digitized stuff like music and movies.

However, digital money has been treated differently than digital software, movies and music. Most pirates don't see consequences while those that rack up debt cause major disruptions in their lives. Or better yet, for those of you that try and justify piracy as harmless, try making copies of your digital money and inflate your bank account. Just don't come crying to me when you're in a 6x10 cell and have a pounding sensation in your ass.
 
Piracy is not "stealing", nor is it speeding, drunk driving or assault. It is and has always been "copyright infringement". Nothing more, nothing less. You can never be charged with theft by downloading stuff from the Internet.

The copyright industry has always been about artificially extracting value from something that is in theory worthless since supply is unlimited. Those who benefit from this have been against all technical innovations from the printing press to the cassette recorder to the mp3 player and the Internet. In Sweden in the late 70's they were actually against recorded disco music and wanted to create a special tax for any club that played it. The reasoning was that if disco music caught on, people would never listen to artists live again which would severely impact the industry which relies on concerts for much of its revenue.
While other industries like the auto industry have had to face the reality, the music and movie industries are kept alive by means of artificial respiration instead of being forced to adapt like everyone else.

The music and movie industry acted too late. If they had started with their scare tactics in 1999, while at the same time opening online stores that offered legal downloads at reasonable prices, without DRM, they might have been able to stop it. Now it's like an avalanche or a runaway train..there's just no way to stop it.
 
It's too bad almost none of you speak Swedish because this is just a perfect parallel to what's happening now.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdjcSGo1hJg

This is an actual clip from the Swedish news some time in 1979 and they're talking about this "disco tax". It's pure comedy.

If you skip to 1:50, they're talking to someone representing the musicians association, and here's what he's saying, roughly

"Today, public usage of recorded music is entirely free. You can listen to music anywhere, in stores, elevators, you can listen at sports arenas, and we have Discothèques and everything. This does not give the performing muscian any money at all even though he's the one who after all is performing. We can not accept that".
 
Piracy is not "stealing", nor is it speeding, drunk driving or assault. It is and has always been "copyright infringement". Nothing more, nothing less. You can never be charged with theft by downloading stuff from the Internet.

The copyright industry has always been about artificially extracting value from something that is in theory worthless since supply is unlimited. Those who benefit from this have been against all technical innovations from the printing press to the cassette recorder to the mp3 player and the Internet. In Sweden in the late 70's they were actually against recorded disco music and wanted to create a special tax for any club that played it. The reasoning was that if disco music caught on, people would never listen to artists live again which would severely impact the industry which relies on concerts for much of its revenue.
While other industries like the auto industry have had to face the reality, the music and movie industries are kept alive by means of artificial respiration instead of being forced to adapt like everyone else.

The music and movie industry acted too late. If they had started with their scare tactics in 1999, while at the same time opening online stores that offered legal downloads at reasonable prices, without DRM, they might have been able to stop it. Now it's like an avalanche or a runaway train..there's just no way to stop it.

qft
 
There are definitely ways to practically stop piracy, but they'd be a bitter pill. They are: 1) charge people for bandwidth 2) only publish games for systems that are completely locked down with DRM and other protections.

As far as the ethics and mentality of game copyright infringers, it would also help if they were in the same community as the game developers, so they can see what the effects are. Right now, game development and piracy are two isolated communities and neither one understands the other.

I think in order to assure its investors a profit, game companies will need to push something like this through, otherwise it's just a high risk proposition.
 
No offense to you, but why not pirate your friends things. If you make the exception for professional-grade software, you're just as guilty of "copyright infringement" as the next person. You either pirate nothing, or you might as well pirate everything. You're either guilty or innocent.

Sociologists have known about this for a while. The culture of file sharing that has developed over the last several years has meant that now downloading music, movies, and games illegally is just as common as buying them - even expected, in the case of music, as I simply can't keep up with some of my friends due to my refusal to pirate most things (I do make an exception for professional-grade software that I absolutely cannot afford, would never buy, and would never use professionally, such as audio production stuff). Piracy is mainstream - even if it's not done with torrents, it exists on YouTube, over instant messaging services, forums, RapidShare, you name it. My highly religious relatives even have a film collection made up of dozens of high-quality DVD rips, none of which were purchased. It's not viewed as wrong, or immoral by most. Capitalism is centred around acquisition of products and things, and it encourages getting the best deals whenever possible - what better deal is there than free? Since the victims of the crime are invisible, piracy isn't considered criminal.
 
No offense to you, but why not pirate your friends things. If you make the exception for professional-grade software, you're just as guilty of "copyright infringement" as the next person. You either pirate nothing, or you might as well pirate everything. You're either guilty or innocent.
This is something that I've had to struggle with, but the fact of the matter is that as a recreational musician making bedroom recordings, there is really no free software that can do a good job. I'm simply not in a position to spend literally tens of thousands of dollars on this stuff. Either I pirate this stuff (and grudgingly) or I give up my hobby - in this situation, there is nothing lost, and the only thing gained is my own enjoyment. I've made my choice, and it was not as easy as you'd think to make. Certainly, I think such a circumstance differs from what I usually do see. Yes, I know people do pirate stuff that they would never buy, and in spades - but the same people that do this also choose to pirate literally everything, whether they can afford it or not. It's fast and convenient for them, and frankly they don't give a flying fuck about the people producing the content in the first place.

The argument that "file sharing is not stealing" really does rub me the wrong way, because while it is applicable in some cases, it certainly is not applicable in others. On the one hand, if I lend the copy of my favourite game to my friend, then no harm is done. Both people can enjoy the game, but not at the same time, and there is greater incentive to buy a second copy. However, when I make a copy for him and keep the original, that's where the real problem arises - in effect the result is more or less the same, but at the same time now there is no incentive to actually buy a second copy of the thing. I have just ruined a potential sale, and that is money the original content creator will never see for his/her/its efforts.

What is particularly different about this situation if I decide to break into a store and steal a physical disc, or take one from the factory even, before it has been shipped out to a store? Again, the end is the same but I don't think most people would agree the means justify it - and it is purely the result of the inclusion of a physical product, a few cents' worth of plastic. All other losses are the same.

I don't think we appreciate artists and craftsmen in our contemporary society nearly enough. There is this sense that this stuff just exists - it's magic, in that we don't see where it comes from, and we assume that it will always be there. I don't know if charging money for intellectual is the "right" thing to do, but that seems to be how it works, and unless we restructure society such that artists are free to generate their works and still live well, but then that raises the question of what an artist is. Is an artist a painter? A programmer? A corporation? A farmer? In some respect, all producers of products are artists, but we don't recognise their works as part of any sort of canon. Again, the solution seems to be the move towards some sort of socialist or communist system - but fat chance of that happening, much less working out properly.
 
(more DRM || more expensive || more restriction) == more Piracy


this is how it work....

I remember how games were cost back in old days, like 20-29 bucks with no DRM/Restriction etc..

now they rise up the price to 49 dollar and start restricting the installation time and install some shitty crap like secuROM that disable your CD-ROM reading and writing CD, which is seriously retarded...
 
Of course, I'd like to see these people actually producing this intellectual property, because if they wanted to make a living creating and selling it, and cared about what they were producing, then they sure as hell wouldn't be calling it "information".

"infotainment" anyone?
 
(more DRM || more expensive || more restriction) == more Piracy


this is how it work....

I remember how games were cost back in old days, like 20-29 bucks with no DRM/Restriction etc..

now they rise up the price to 49 dollar and start restricting the installation time and install some shitty crap like secuROM that disable your CD-ROM reading and writing CD, which is seriously retarded...
It's nowhere near that simple:

When games were thirty dollars and had no DRM, fast Internet connections were not widely available.

Computer games used to be a niche market and were confined to a specific subset of individuals; nowadays there are far more people gaming, with far more diverse demographics (i.e. the nerd stereotype is much less relevant than it was 15-20 years ago).

Computer games used to be cheaper because of the effects inflation and because their development costs were much, much lower; profit margins, even with price increases, are actually lower than they used to be, and only around 10% of games actually make money over the initial investment.

DRM does not necessarily increase piracy rates. Studies suggest that around 1% of gamers have DRM impact their purchasing decisions. An informal study by Koroush Ghazi revealed that the number one determinant of a game's piracy rates is the game's popularity, not what DRM is included (for example, Call of Duty 4 and Fallout 3 both have minimal DRM, and both are amongst the top-selling and top-pirated games on the PC).

The fact of the matter is, the people who actually sit around talking about DRM make up a tiny, almost insignificant portion of the gaming market as a whole. Have you ever been at a Best Buy or GameStop and talked to someone at random there? Chances are they don't follow the industry, they don't know what DRM is, they don't read reviews - they just want a game they can buy and have fun with, regardless of the politics around it. This is the average gamer, the type that accounts for over 99% of the sales. Us nerds debating this shit on the Internet? Guess what, even if your favourite forum has 10,000 people, that's nothing next to the hundreds of millions of gamers out there.
 
Us computer enthusiasts ;)
It's funny how certain levels of geekiness have become socially acceptable or even preferable, especially in females (male gaze and all that), but at the end of the day if you're building water-cooled computers with blinking neon LEDs and RAID setups, you're still a nerd. In fact, if you start calling yourself a "computer enthusiast", you'll probably just get people calling you a nerd even more.
 
This is something that I've had to struggle with, but the fact of the matter is that as a recreational musician making bedroom recordings, there is really no free software that can do a good job. I'm simply not in a position to spend literally tens of thousands of dollars on this stuff. Either I pirate this stuff (and grudgingly) or I give up my hobby - in this situation, there is nothing lost, and the only thing gained is my own enjoyment. I've made my choice, and it was not as easy as you'd think to make. Certainly, I think such a circumstance differs from what I usually do see. Yes, I know people do pirate stuff that they would never buy, and in spades - but the same people that do this also choose to pirate literally everything, whether they can afford it or not. It's fast and convenient for them, and frankly they don't give a flying fuck about the people producing the content in the first place.

All you've said is that YOUR hobby is more important than paying for software. OTHER people's hobby might be listening to music or playing video games and therefore by your own test of "right and wrong." They should feel entitled to download whatever they want (grudgingly of course) as long as it fits in their hobby and as long as they cannot afford to pay for it.

The argument that "file sharing is not stealing" really does rub me the wrong way, because while it is applicable in some cases, it certainly is not applicable in others. On the one hand, if I lend the copy of my favourite game to my friend, then no harm is done. Both people can enjoy the game, but not at the same time, and there is greater incentive to buy a second copy. However, when I make a copy for him and keep the original, that's where the real problem arises - in effect the result is more or less the same, but at the same time now there is no incentive to actually buy a second copy of the thing. I have just ruined a potential sale, and that is money the original content creator will never see for his/her/its efforts.

What is particularly different about this situation if I decide to break into a store and steal a physical disc, or take one from the factory even, before it has been shipped out to a store? Again, the end is the same but I don't think most people would agree the means justify it - and it is purely the result of the inclusion of a physical product, a few cents' worth of plastic. All other losses are the same.

While yes, the losses are the same, they are defined legally as being very different crimes. Until the law states otherwise, what you think is unfortunately irrelevant.

I don't think we appreciate artists and craftsmen in our contemporary society nearly enough. There is this sense that this stuff just exists - it's magic, in that we don't see where it comes from, and we assume that it will always be there. I don't know if charging money for intellectual is the "right" thing to do, but that seems to be how it works, and unless we restructure society such that artists are free to generate their works and still live well, but then that raises the question of what an artist is. Is an artist a painter? A programmer? A corporation? A farmer? In some respect, all producers of products are artists, but we don't recognise their works as part of any sort of canon. Again, the solution seems to be the move towards some sort of socialist or communist system - but fat chance of that happening, much less working out properly.

Socialism and Communism doesn't work. It never has. Capitalism works because it recognizes basic tendencies in humanity and applies them to an economic system. It's not always pretty and doesn't necessarily demonstrate the best humanity has to offer, but it works. The last time I checked the best artists are well rewarded for their crafts whether that be musicians, authors, or software programmers (I don't think U2, J.K. Rowling, or Bill Gates are hurting for money).
 
All you've said is that YOUR hobby is more important than paying for software. OTHER people's hobby might be listening to music or playing video games and therefore by your own test of "right and wrong." They should feel entitled to download whatever they want (grudgingly of course) as long as it fits in their hobby and as long as they cannot afford to pay for it.
The difference here is that this audio production software can often cost literally tens of thousands of dollars (albeit no individual program is that expensive, to my knowledge), whereas computer games are relatively inexpensive. Furthermore, I would not buy this software even if I couldn't pirate it, period. Games, music, movies, etc. are far less expensive and even people who are not doing well economically can afford them - a game is the price of a few days' worth of food, so unless you're making minimum wage and straining to pay even the most basic of expenses, buying a game or CD once in a while shouldn't be a problem.

The fact is, if you can afford a gaming-quality computer, you can afford to buy games for it. If you can afford a high-capacity digital media player to store all your music, then you can afford to buy that music, either by download or on CD (I much prefer CDs for their higher quality and the fact that they are actual physical objects, but whatever floats your boat). If you can't afford to buy everything you want, then control yourself and make smart purchasing decisions. There are plenty of free or inexpensive sources of entertainment, too - MySpace, YouTube (though the legality of that is questionable), television, radio, online Flash titles, free-to-play MMOs, indie games, etc. The best I can say of something like free audio production software is that it doesn't melt your computer.

For the record, I do not regularly pirate anything. I have not downloaded music illegally (except in very rare cases, like to compare my CD rip to another copy while checking for errors in my own) in about four years, and I have not downloaded a game in about two years, unless that game is pretty much impossible to find anywhere or the original company that made it is now defunct

While yes, the losses are the same, they are defined legally as being very different crimes. Until the law states otherwise, what you think is unfortunately irrelevant.
Sure, but that doesn't mean that laws can't be changed.

Socialism and Communism doesn't work. It never has. Capitalism works because it recognizes basic tendencies in humanity and applies them to an economic system. It's not always pretty and doesn't necessarily demonstrate the best humanity has to offer, but it works. The last time I checked the best artists are well rewarded for their crafts whether that be musicians, authors, or software programmers (I don't think U2, J.K. Rowling, or Bill Gates are hurting for money).
The fact that you lump Rowling and Bono into examples of the "best artists" capitalism has to offer severely damages your argument, in my opinion. :p
 
I don't pirate to much stuff anymore, but I tend to look more selectively at what I do.

What I mean is the RIAA and MPAA just seem to rub me the wrong way. Not to mention years of years of 1 to 2 song CD's and the rest being crap. This makes it easy to pirate.

I don't pirate gaames, mainly because I don't have time nor want to make time to play games.

And lastly Microsoft, sorry but to me, those pig fuckers are fair game as long as they are in business.
 
The difference here is that this audio production software can often cost literally tens of thousands of dollars (albeit no individual program is that expensive, to my knowledge), whereas computer games are relatively inexpensive. Furthermore, I would not buy this software even if I couldn't pirate it, period. Games, music, movies, etc. are far less expensive and even people who are not doing well economically can afford them - a game is the price of a few days' worth of food, so unless you're making minimum wage and straining to pay even the most basic of expenses, buying a game or CD once in a while shouldn't be a problem.

The fact is, if you can afford a gaming-quality computer, you can afford to buy games for it. If you can afford a high-capacity digital media player to store all your music, then you can afford to buy that music, either by download or on CD (I much prefer CDs for their higher quality and the fact that they are actual physical objects, but whatever floats your boat). If you can't afford to buy everything you want, then control yourself and make smart purchasing decisions. There are plenty of free or inexpensive sources of entertainment, too - MySpace, YouTube (though the legality of that is questionable), television, radio, online Flash titles, free-to-play MMOs, indie games, etc. The best I can say of something like free audio production software is that it doesn't melt your computer.

For the record, I do not regularly pirate anything. I have not downloaded music illegally (except in very rare cases, like to compare my CD rip to another copy while checking for errors in my own) in about four years, and I have not downloaded a game in about two years, unless that game is pretty much impossible to find anywhere or the original company that made it is now defunct

I'm not picking on you necessarily. But your whole argument hinges on price. Since the price is higher, you deem it acceptable. In fact, one could argue that you are doing more damage because the higher price means a significantly decreased volume of sales, especially in a niche market like that. You are just sounding like you are trying to rationalize it to yourself. You're a software pirate. If you're arrested and accused in court of "copyright infringement," the argument that I didn't have the money to pay for it and it was a hobby of mine isn't going to get you anywhere. I'm sure you've dealt with these issues and determined that the benefit of using the software illegally outweighs the risk of getting caught. I would just caution you to resist the urge to (seemingly from my point of view) throw the book at the other guys (music and games) while being just as guilty as they are. You appear to be hypocritical. Not picking on you. Just pointing out what seems obvious.

Sure, but that doesn't mean that laws can't be changed.
Yes, laws can be changed, and perhaps even should be to reflect the changing times.

The fact that you lump Rowling and Bono into examples of the "best artists" capitalism has to offer severely damages your argument, in my opinion. :p

I don't know about "best," but certainly we would agree they are among the "best paid" for their works. ;)
 
It's nowhere near that simple:

When games were thirty dollars and had no DRM, fast Internet connections were not widely available.

Computer games used to be a niche market and were confined to a specific subset of individuals; nowadays there are far more people gaming, with far more diverse demographics (i.e. the nerd stereotype is much less relevant than it was 15-20 years ago).

Computer games used to be cheaper because of the effects inflation and because their development costs were much, much lower; profit margins, even with price increases, are actually lower than they used to be, and only around 10% of games actually make money over the initial investment.

DRM does not necessarily increase piracy rates. Studies suggest that around 1% of gamers have DRM impact their purchasing decisions. An informal study by Koroush Ghazi revealed that the number one determinant of a game's piracy rates is the game's popularity, not what DRM is included (for example, Call of Duty 4 and Fallout 3 both have minimal DRM, and both are amongst the top-selling and top-pirated games on the PC).

The fact of the matter is, the people who actually sit around talking about DRM make up a tiny, almost insignificant portion of the gaming market as a whole. Have you ever been at a Best Buy or GameStop and talked to someone at random there? Chances are they don't follow the industry, they don't know what DRM is, they don't read reviews - they just want a game they can buy and have fun with, regardless of the politics around it. This is the average gamer, the type that accounts for over 99% of the sales. Us nerds debating this shit on the Internet? Guess what, even if your favourite forum has 10,000 people, that's nothing next to the hundreds of millions of gamers out there.

It's not quite complicate like think..

from the people that I know of, and from what I am seeing around...

game price does a huge impact on game selling.

simply look at how games were 20 dollar off in bestbuy using the rewardzone, huge amount of people jump in and buy those game in a cheap price.

and look at how UT3 came lately with low price also, doesn't the sales boost up tremendously?

then take a look at a game that sell at 49 dollar in market, such as CoD4 like you stated..
the price is high, not many people can afford a game in their hand with the amount of money they got, especially to people who is under 20 or people who doesn't have a job.

How does DRM/secuROM impact the customer's choice, this question doesn't seem to be that hard to be answer, and it is not just 1% of people who get effected.

From the people that I have seen and people on this forum, most of the got effected in a lot of way, 3 times installation limit is not a choice for a game to be purchase at 50 dollar, and in order to play the game, you have to sacrifice your DVD-ROM's CD Writing ability due to secuROM disable the function.

How does bandwidth have anything to do with pirating?
I have to say it does have a little impact but not much.

back in the old days the internet still not quite as popular, but pirate is still massive, not through downloading but through selling bootleg...

like all-in-one game pack etc..... which is far more worse than current situation..

The whole piracy problem is not as hard as it is....
It is farm more simple than any of you could think of...

And the main cause of this, is the Price/Restriction ....
 
I notice with analog(physical) stuff its like private property but once something is digital it becomes public property practically. The sense of stealing or ripping someone off when its digital isn't there as much with digital media. I think its a revolution with p2p file sharing. Music artists will make money by doing shows like everyone did before recording came along. Movies will make money by making better movies and placing ads some place. I think eventually we'll get a service with ads on the side with all entertainment for free. People aren't rich these days either. They charge so much for movies and stuff that its rediculous. Why cant they sell games for 5-15 bux instead of 60 or 50. They'll sell 10x more if they lowered the price. Its like a gas station near your house, the gas station a few cents cheaper gets 100x more customers than the one on the other corner selling it a few more cents higher. They are so greedy they are getting less in reality. They don't realize if they lowered the price more they would sell more and it would make up the difference and then some. P2p will never die. You can't suppress a group of people and get away with it. It never works out like that. The people change the market, not the market.
 
I don't mind paying for quality games with a good multiplayer. I pay $15 a month to play WoW and I buy pretty much every game Valve puts out, like HL2, TF2, etc. Why?

1) multiplayer, that won't work if I pirate
2) I know they'll be good before I even buy them, so I'm not debating if it's going to be a waste of my money or not
 
My opinion only...

How could "they" avoid this? By leaving it alone. For a very long time, file sharing was limited to IRC and FTP (in a broad sense) for more "upper echelon" nerds.

Then along comes Kazaa and greatly simplifies filesharing, and brings P2P mainstream. RIAA / Sony / Lars decides that due to saggy audio sales, who's fault could it be?? CERTAINLY not audio management whose "shake and bake" pop bands complete with bright sparkley colors to entrance the masses? Definitely not the cost of an average CD, what only contains the 1 or 2 hit wonders that desired people to get the CD in the first place. Combine that with the FM overplay of "hit singles", and sooner or later things would come to a head.

The masses (starting with college students due to bandwidth probably) figured out that they could only get the songs they liked vs. a whole CD of shit complete with corn nibblets. Combine that with the TV play of the makers of Kazaa (hell, it made it all the way to the movie "The Italian Job".) and away the trend goes. The drama from the demise of Kazaa was the final nail in the proverbial coffin of traditional media.

Greed.. the eternal corporate model. Move forward 5 years, and just now (over the past year) have media moguls figured out that allowing individuals to download the songs they like, at more sensible prices will actually work vs. the end-user to pay 13+ dollars for a CD of steaming excrement for only 1 or two tracks that are maybe worth something. They missed the boat, and nothing they do will make that ship turn around. They took something that was viral, and due to their perceived legal momentum moved P2P to the masses.

You reap what you sow. By no means am I advocating P2P, but I ABSOLUTELY understand it, and encourage it. Hell, download it, if you like it, buy it. Get the funds back to the band who actually (OMG) deserve it. Not some cleatus in a suit.

Need any more encouragement... Thanks Sweden / RIAA for exposing even more to TPB. I think thats why TPB acts the way they do. All its doing is encouraging the failure of the current media business model. They may win against TPB, but all they have done is encourage the usage of torrents, and basically held the hand to educate others in how to download media.
 
It's funny how certain levels of geekiness have become socially acceptable or even preferable, especially in females (male gaze and all that), but at the end of the day if you're building water-cooled computers with blinking neon LEDs and RAID setups, you're still a nerd. In fact, if you start calling yourself a "computer enthusiast", you'll probably just get people calling you a nerd even more.

hahaha!!
you are right!! we are just a bunch of NERDS!!1 and proud to be one :D
 
The difference here is that this audio production software can often cost literally tens of thousands of dollars (albeit no individual program is that expensive, to my knowledge), whereas computer games are relatively inexpensive. Furthermore, I would not buy this software even if I couldn't pirate it, period. Games, music, movies, etc. are far less expensive and even people who are not doing well economically can afford them - a game is the price of a few days' worth of food, so unless you're making minimum wage and straining to pay even the most basic of expenses, buying a game or CD once in a while shouldn't be a problem.

Pure crap designed to fit your needs. I'm sure music and games are out of reach to some teenagers that are not working too. We all turn things around to fit our own needs and desires. It's why people speed and complain about cops speeding, it's why some don't mind taking a few pens from work, and it's why even here there is so much contradictory info regarding piracy. This story is posted almost as a win for the P2Pers, yet talk anything piracy in the game forum and the post is locked. You cannhead over to the OS forum and find out about ways to use a key with a different version of an OS than you paid for, or for software that you "can't find the install disc" for, etc.

This is the way society is. Make excuses for your behavior. Have you ever heard someone not state they pirate something, but only because something else? No. Make an excuse for what you do. I'm not saying a hate piracry or love it or that there's even anything wrong with it, but I'm saying people who post and excuse for doing it and then blame others for doing basically the same thing are FULL OF CRAP!!!
 
I think file sharing may have just become mainstream in recent years but piracy itself has long became mainstream before file sharing did. Only difference being that back then, people have to actually pay for pirated materials too, just at a lower cost.

Even during the Sega Megadrive system days, there was alot of pirated cartages that contains 3 games or sometimes even more. And pirated movies comes in those huge VHS cassettes :p
 
Back
Top