Student Sues For $1M Over Missing Xbox

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This news items isn’t so much about the fact that this kid sued the airline over his missing Xbox, it is the ridiculous amount he sued for ($1 million). Then again, after reading the arrogant response from the airline…you kinda hope he gets the money.

"We haven't been apprised of any lawsuit yet, but regardless of the figure in the complaint, there are federal loss limits applicable to all airlines on their liability for lost luggage and belongings, which are currently set at $3,300 per bag," Valerie Wunder, a US Airways spokesperson, said in an e-mail. "Further, our publicly available baggage policies specifically exclude liability for electronics checked in luggage."
 
I hope he gets the max, some one stole that shit on the airline or the security team.
 
I hope he gets his stuff back. Nothing more, nothing less.

I hope the airline gets a whopping fine and the person that stole it is prosecuted....simply because the airline hides behind federal regulations and they act like they have no control over what happens to your bags...the same bags they charge an extra $15 - $20 each now.
 
"Further, our publicly available baggage policies specifically exclude liability for electronics checked in luggage."

And this would be why I can bet everyone that is reading this that has ever taken a peice of electronics onto a plane has TAKEN IT CARRY-ON.

I hope the kid gets his xbox back - no doubt he has lots of saved games on there, and i'm not siding with the airlines - i'm simply looking (and remembering the last time I was on a plane) and seeing they are not liable.

I guess it must have been his first time on a plane - have you ever seen how those guys handle your luggage? If its anything but clothes, I hope you have it bubble wrapped! Wait a sec... I think I would bubble wrap my pure pwnage tshirt.
 
Heh.... the only time I've ever had baggage "missing" was when I was traveling with my little sister and they "lost" her bag.

The airline said they couldn't find the bag. They gave me a number to call for an update and over two days went by and each time I called, they said they had no information available.

After I left them a very blunt and not very nice message about them never having any information available and wanting to know what was going on, the bag was delivered to our front door the next morning at about 5am.

The bag had been at the airport the whole time. Luckily nothing was missing.
 
There fault all the way around.

They guy should have locked his bag. He shouldn't have checked in through luggage, but as a carry on. I travel a lot and my $2000 laptop never leaves my eyesight.

Furthermore $3000 for the loss of the console (a new 360 is $250 + the supposed upgrades) and another $25000 (or a $1 Million lump sum) for emotional distress? Oh Please, That's just an attempt to bilk the airline. If he thinks speaking to 5 customer service reps is earth-shattering emotional experience wait until he has to talk to the IRS or some other government agency.

The airline response was arrogant, but they are probably legally right. What this guy should do is go to small claims court, sue for the $1000 (which he will probably get) and fly with another airline.
 
I think it is bullshit that they can have clauses like that. I think they should be 100% liable for any and all items I give them. I can understand that they are moving a crap load of bags a minute and that a bag might get lost every now and then. However this bull shit that the handlers can still your laptop or game consoles out of your bag and they claim they are not at fault is very much bull shit in my opinion.
 
Few years back, my sister had a CD wallet loaded with CDs and her portable CD player. This was before mp3 players were popular. She had those in a bag they forced her to check in, "Don't worry, nothing will happen to it." We land, all the CDs and player are missing, where they responsible? Of course not, I forget what excuse they used. No idea how CDs magically disappear during that course if their people didn't do it.
 
I always carry electronics and jewelry as carry-on, it's quite common sense. It's not only the lost bag or equipment, it's also getting a potentially torn/smashed/mashed bag back.

You are crazy if you believe you have some right because you can pack electronics in check-in and expect it to be perfect when you get to your destination. Secondly, airlines does offer package services for these types of things with coverage options.

I am not siding with the airlines, but to expect a million or even 3k or heck even anything for an xbox (electronic) device is insane.

Like mmarsh said, go to small claims, sue for the maximum lost luggage value and be done with it.
 
Airlines: "Further, our publicly available baggage policies specifically exclude liability for electronics checked in luggage."

What it doesn't say is, "...because we know our employees are going to steal that shit."
 
Airlines: "Further, our publicly available baggage policies specifically exclude liability for electronics checked in luggage."

What it doesn't say is, "...because we know our employees are going to steal that shit."

Or the airport bag transport, or the taxi driver, or the concierge baggage handler, or the hotel bag checkin attendant, or the customs agent, or the...... etc. You can't hold an airline responsible solely because of so many hands that touches your bags out of the airlines control.

While the airline should be responsible, whats to prevent you from saying "oh, I had an xbox in there, it's gone now". When they first covered electronics, this was one of the biggest scams known to the airline baggage industry.
 
You are crazy if you believe you have some right because you can pack electronics in check-in and expect it to be perfect when you get to your destination.

Pretty much.
If it's breakable and you're putting it in your luggage, you are taking a risk. Airlines aren't a carrier service (UPS/Fed/etc). Yeah, they should get in trouble if they go out of their way and completely manhandle your stuff; however, if it gets lost or broken through no abuse, then the airlines shouldn't be at fault.

I've traveled from Illinois to Alaska over 8 times in the last year, and I take my xbox in my luggage everytime, knowing full well I might not see it ever again on the other side. If you can't take that risk, then don't do it. You'll live without your electronics for those X days.
 
can't lock your bag or they WILL destroy it to get it open. Something about smuggling terrorists or something.

The TSA uses bolt cutters and breaks just about every lock they find when they have a suspicious bag or it's selected for a random check (which seems pretty much every locked bag). I believe that there is a note on the check in counter saying that locks will be cut or something the last time I flew.
 
I never check a bag...of course this has led to being questioned. Why are you buying a 1 way from phx to albuquerque 20 min before the flight with cash and not checking a bag? Ummm, cause I wanted a last minute vacation to hike the Sandia Peaks? That wasn't a good enough excuse.

United sent my gf's bags to japan when she went to the Virgin Islands...she got them back the last day of her vacation.
 
I never check a bag...of course this has led to being questioned. Why are you buying a 1 way from phx to albuquerque 20 min before the flight with cash and not checking a bag? Ummm, cause I wanted a last minute vacation to hike the Sandia Peaks? That wasn't a good enough excuse.

United sent my gf's bags to japan when she went to the Virgin Islands...she got them back the last day of her vacation.

Been there. Fortunately there was this spandex clad woman in high heels wearing a top that covered almost nothing that was in the same line as me. So I got to look at that during the wait.
 
"Further, our publicly available baggage policies specifically exclude liability for electronics checked in luggage."

And this would be why I can bet everyone that is reading this that has ever taken a peice of electronics onto a plane has TAKEN IT CARRY-ON.

I hope the kid gets his xbox back - no doubt he has lots of saved games on there, and i'm not siding with the airlines - i'm simply looking (and remembering the last time I was on a plane) and seeing they are not liable.

I guess it must have been his first time on a plane - have you ever seen how those guys handle your luggage? If its anything but clothes, I hope you have it bubble wrapped! Wait a sec... I think I would bubble wrap my pure pwnage tshirt.

catch 22... i flew with electronics...refused to check them and took them as carryon...they saw wires in my bag and decided on "further screening"...needless to say i went on a tirade about violation of rights and a few other choice words... i missed my flight and am probably on a list somewhere.

i hope he gets blood.
 
The TSA uses bolt cutters and breaks just about every lock they find when they have a suspicious bag or it's selected for a random check (which seems pretty much every locked bag). I believe that there is a note on the check in counter saying that locks will be cut or something the last time I flew.

yeah those cocksuckers wrecked my gf's modded pc case when she moved here, apparently the fucking apes didn't understand thumb screws
 
"Further, our publicly available baggage policies specifically exclude liability for electronics checked in luggage."

And this would be why I can bet everyone that is reading this that has ever taken a peice of electronics onto a plane has TAKEN IT CARRY-ON.

I guess it must have been his first time on a plane - have you ever seen how those guys handle your luggage? If its anything but clothes, I hope you have it bubble wrapped! Wait a sec... I think I would bubble wrap my pure pwnage tshirt.

I do a LOT of business travel. On more than one occasion, on a tight connection, I've been the last guy on and had a bulk head seat. When that happens, all the overheads are full and there is no under-seat space. At that point, all your stuff is getting checked. My sister had her laptop broken this way (last on, bulkhead seat) - one of the other passengers actually witnessed the luggage handlers drop her laptop bag off the top of their cart.

Did the airline own up to the problem and provide a mutually agreeable solution? I think you know the answer.

Granted, I could just hang around in the terminal waiting for another flight in order to protect my carry-on luggage rather than take the last seat in a full flight, but it seems a little ridiculous. I also think, in the current economy, it might be easy to replace problem luggage handlers.
 
Our luggage has locks that can be opened by TSA without cutters.

I had some of these, but (surprise, surprise) TSA cut them off - apparently no one told them that they have some secret master key.
 
thanks to this kid getting his $1 mil airplane ticket prices will go up 75%
 
I had some of these, but (surprise, surprise) TSA cut them off - apparently no one told them that they have some secret master key.

same, i had a bunch of equipment in a pelican case destroyed, i dont even know how they managed, but instead of just opening the TSA lock, they cut it off, but not by cutting the lock, no, by cutting up the pelican case, and then i can only presume they ran the case over with a 747 and a garbage truck becuase it looked like it had been through a nuclear war when i got it back

i hate TSA/airlines etc they all are so apathetic i wish they would all just go out of business and start from scratch
 
I do a LOT of business travel. On more than one occasion, on a tight connection, I've been the last guy on and had a bulk head seat. When that happens, all the overheads are full and there is no under-seat space. At that point, all your stuff is getting checked. My sister had her laptop broken this way (last on, bulkhead seat) - one of the other passengers actually witnessed the luggage handlers drop her laptop bag off the top of their cart.

Did the airline own up to the problem and provide a mutually agreeable solution? I think you know the answer.

Granted, I could just hang around in the terminal waiting for another flight in order to protect my carry-on luggage rather than take the last seat in a full flight, but it seems a little ridiculous. I also think, in the current economy, it might be easy to replace problem luggage handlers.

I hate your circumstances, especially when the other passengers carry on large items and screw you out of space. However, for laptops, you always have under the seat or at your feet.
 
Furthermore $3000 for the loss of the console (a new 360 is $250 + the supposed upgrades) and another $25000 (or a $1 Million lump sum) for emotional distress? Oh Please, That's just an attempt to bilk the airline.

While this *is* a ridiculous amount given what happened, the point is to maybe make them think twice before pulling shit like this again. I think that's the idea behind it legally, anyway.
 
I hate your circumstances, especially when the other passengers carry on large items and screw you out of space. However, for laptops, you always have under the seat or at your feet.

He just said there was no under-seat space, and they won't let you keep things free-floating at your feet.

On another note (since I can't edit my other post), I hope the kid gets it, simply because it seems like airlines typically do everything they can to screw you. They charge ridiculous prices in the first place, and then on top of "not being liable" for your checked baggage, they charge you $50+ to check more than one anyway! Greedy, greedy companies.
 
He just said there was no under-seat space, and they won't let you keep things free-floating at your feet.

On another note (since I can't edit my other post), I hope the kid gets it, simply because it seems like airlines typically do everything they can to screw you. They charge ridiculous prices in the first place, and then on top of "not being liable" for your checked baggage, they charge you $50+ to check more than one anyway! Greedy, greedy companies.

There is always space somewhere. Most people don't know that if you have a laptop bag, you can fit it under the seat below you (unless of course the person behind you is using it). You can also wedge it behind your legs, most of the time they don't notice :p

Creativity :)
 
i hate TSA/airlines etc they all are so apathetic i wish they would all just go out of business and start from scratch
TSA isn't a business, it's a government agency :D Your taxdollars at work.
 
After the person that's helping you check your bags does so, the responsibility for your bags gets handed off to *airport* baggage handling. The airline doesn't have dedicated ground support, the airport supplies hardware and personnel for baggage handling. Then you have plane changes at a different airport if you have to catch another plane. It gets even screwier if you're changing carriers mid trip.

I'm not saying that this shouldn't be made right by the airline, I'm saying that it's *a lot* more complicated than it looks like on first blush.
 
There is always space somewhere. Most people don't know that if you have a laptop bag, you can fit it under the seat below you (unless of course the person behind you is using it). You can also wedge it behind your legs, most of the time they don't notice :p

Creativity :)

Well, I think the idea here is that you have no seat in front of you because you're at a bulkhead, and the seat underneath you is used. Technically, putting it behind your legs is against regulations, too, but since (as I mentioned before) they are crooks, I really don't have a problem with it. ;)
 
I haven't flown since 1994 but next time I do, just to make a point (that probably will be overlooked by all the screeners), I am going to wrap my luggage completely with a copy of the U. S. Constitution, so they have to literally tear apart that document to search my luggage.
 
yeah the TSA likes to "randomly" look through crap, went to Maui a couple years back and of our 3 pieces of luggage my girlfriends had the little notice inside that said the whole "this has been inspected at random, etc etc if something is missing it's not our fucking fault". Now there was only clothing in that bag, not even any hygiene products or anything, on the way back home, also got that same bag checked, AND there was a bra missing... fucking perverts.
 
I haven't flown since 1994 but next time I do, just to make a point (that probably will be overlooked by all the screeners), I am going to wrap my luggage completely with a copy of the U. S. Constitution, so they have to literally tear apart that document to search my luggage.

they will probably label you some kind of terrorist for having the constitution on you, i know they have arrested people for reading it out loud, and some police handbooks seriously mention that telltale signs of dissenters and homegrown terrorists are the mention or possession of the us constitution. no joke.
 
I don't understand some people. Airline travel is to allow you and your "clothing" to go from point A to point B. If you have something of value you take it as a carry on. If it is something large that you can't bring on the plane, you fucking ship it via UPS/USPS/FedEx etc.
 
I haven't flown since 1994 but next time I do, just to make a point (that probably will be overlooked by all the screeners), I am going to wrap my luggage completely with a copy of the U. S. Constitution, so they have to literally tear apart that document to search my luggage.

That would take some balls. In this day in age, I don't think you would get your luggage back :p
 
I don't understand some people. Airline travel is to allow you and your "clothing" to go from point A to point B. If you have something of value you take it as a carry on. If it is something large that you can't bring on the plane, you fucking ship it via UPS/USPS/FedEx etc.

You don't think that with all that money you're paying you should have the right not to get your shit stolen? Granted this has never happened to me but they lost my sister's luggage. I think she had a little jewelery in it.

And it is the baggage handlers fault! When they're loading it and unloading it it's the only time it leaves your sight. Not at the hotel, not in the taxicab. Customs only comes into play when you travel internationally.

It's time to prune these stealing baggage handlers and replace them with the 10million or so jobless people who would kill to have a job right now.
 
I think it is bullshit that they can have clauses like that. I think they should be 100% liable for any and all items I give them. I can understand that they are moving a crap load of bags a minute and that a bag might get lost every now and then. However this bull shit that the handlers can still your laptop or game consoles out of your bag and they claim they are not at fault is very much bull shit in my opinion.

Prove he actually had the xbox in there when he checked it in. That's why they have liability limits, or everyone would be claiming they had $100,000 in cash that was taken out of their bag. The fact that he is suing for so much money is a sign he is just tryin gto get a settlement on his baseless claim.
 
Back
Top