Steam Civilization Weekend!

Alright, I will start off with who is the type for this game? I like rts's and fps's mostly and this one gets great reviews so is it worth $30 to take the plunge?
 
If you enjoy turn based strategy and more sit back and look at the big picture then yes, this is for you.

I have a hard time getting into them because I get discouraged playing them because I always fall behind.
 
This is turn based strategy. It's like crack.
 
I tried liking Civ 4 and this one. I don't know, I just can't really get into it. I think if things get disorderly and feel out of my control, I really lose interest because my brain starts to hurt.
 
Is the digital deluxe copy the best Civ 5 copy to have? Better than the regular steam and retail copies?
 
civ 4 > civ 5

This.

V messed up a lot of things IV had right, turned up the graphics just enough to make it require a half decent computer (as compared to needing no computing power required), and screwed up multiplayer. In fact the only thing they got right was using Nimoy again and even then I would have rather had Freedman's voice.

All my opinion but the hours and hours and hours I spent in IV with friends were much more fun than the one game we played on V.
 
All my opinion but the hours and hours and hours I spent in IV with friends were much more fun than the one game we played on V.

Unbelieveable. You mean to say you actually enjoyed having out of sync errors after about an hour of gameplay, and then every other turn after that regardless of how many times your friends rejoined?

I've put a good amount of time into both games, and while I could take either one for single player, I can only recall ONE Civ 4 game that we played through that did not end up with an "out of sync" message - despite identical game files and a myriad of different computer systems, in addition to all of the other steps people had suggested to prevent it.

At least Civ V does not give us this sort of crap.
 
How is single player civ5? I don't have any friends who like to get down on turn based stategy games. Bunch of philistines.
 
Been waiting for this to go on sale! Picked it up with the map packs. Excited!
 
CIV4 > CIV5 indeed, and 30 bucks is still not cheap enough for me to purchase CIV5. The damn thing was so riddled with bugs and bad design on release it will never be forgiven by many CIV4 players.

I have never had ONE out of sync multiplayer game of CIV4 but I have never actually managed to complete ONE game of CIV5, single or multi, without crashing, save corruption, or performance so abysmal you'd think you were playing Quake on a 286.
 
I was hoping for the sale to extend to the Civ 5 DLC. :(

As was I. :/ To the guy who was asking if this game is worth it, absolutely. You'll lose hours, even days, of your life to this game. And that's just single player. If you LAN it up with your friends this game can be even more awesome. And it's fun to cheat in single player and play God. Civ 4 was cool but that 20+ unit stack bullshit was out of hand. Civ 5 aboloshes it and removes tech trading (you can only work together on techs).

tl;dr: this is very much worth it.
 
Last edited:
How is single player civ5? I don't have any friends who like to get down on turn based stategy games. Bunch of philistines.

If you enjoy empire/city builders than you should try out Civ 5. Steam has a demo so you can take it out for a test drive if you have doubts.

It's a fun game with a lot of replayability. However, just don't expect it to be perfect, it still has a lot of flaws that might put some people off.

The biggest drawback is combat AI, it's too easy to exploit. I never played Civ 4 but I find the new 1 unit per tile rule in Civ 5 to make for some excellent combat. Just wish the computer would put up more of a fight. One unit per tile turns it into a board game like Panzer General for those that like that style of gameplay.

I haven't played in several months but here are some tips,

Pay close attention to your empire happiness, the best way to get more happiness is to trade other AI's for goods you don't have.

Don't make too large of an Army or you'll go bankrupt.

Unless the city is of strategic importance to you it's often better to make a conquered city your puppet than to take it over outright. You'll take a big happiness hit for each conquered city which can make fast conquest troublesome.

Social policies are important, there are several that will improve your happiness and lessen your upkeep costs.

Video review

http://angryjoeshow.com/?s=civilization+5&search.x=0&search.y=0
 
Watching "let's play" on youtube, it looks more like sleeping pills than crack, maybe addicting but not very exciting

You don't play strategy games to get excited. Is chess exciting? Axis and Allies? How about Risk? Ever hear anyone say, "Man, I'm gonna do 3 lines of coke, drink 8 cups of coffee, and FUCKING PLAY RISK ALL NIGHT LONG!!!"
 
You don't play strategy games to get excited. Is chess exciting? Axis and Allies? How about Risk? Ever hear anyone say, "Man, I'm gonna do 3 lines of coke, drink 8 cups of coffee, and FUCKING PLAY RISK ALL NIGHT LONG!!!"

And yet, that's what ends up happening.
 
Watching "let's play" on youtube, it looks more like sleeping pills than crack, maybe addicting but not very exciting

Let me get this straight. You're watching someone play a turn-based strategy game on YouTube and judging it by that alone?
 
CIV4 > CIV5 indeed, and 30 bucks is still not cheap enough for me to purchase CIV5. The damn thing was so riddled with bugs and bad design on release it will never be forgiven by many CIV4 players.

I have never had ONE out of sync multiplayer game of CIV4 but I have never actually managed to complete ONE game of CIV5, single or multi, without crashing, save corruption, or performance so abysmal you'd think you were playing Quake on a 286.

Words of rebuttal right out of my mouth.
 
Let me get this straight. You're watching someone play a turn-based strategy game on YouTube and judging it by that alone?

I can't think of a better way besides playing than watching someone play... so ya.

Really I just said that to hopefully hear some defense, it's hard not to be interested in this game reading the reviews... but I'm just not sure the game type is for me. If I did get the game I would probably go for 4, just to make sure I am interested in this game type, and if I have fun then maybe get 5 when it goes down in price.

Can someone familiar with both games compare 4 vs 5. Also, do both games offer a simple online multiplayer solution?
 
I can't think of a better way besides playing than watching someone play... so ya.

Really I just said that to hopefully hear some defense, it's hard not to be interested in this game reading the reviews... but I'm just not sure the game type is for me. If I did get the game I would probably go for 4, just to make sure I am interested in this game type, and if I have fun then maybe get 5 when it goes down in price.

Can someone familiar with both games compare 4 vs 5. Also, do both games offer a simple online multiplayer solution?

Just play the Civ 5 demo on steam and you'll be able to judge for yourself. The demo won't show flaws that may show up late game but it'll give you an introduction to the Civ series. I will say this, Firaxis is still supporting the game and they're releasing patches every month. This statement was released this week.

http://forums.2kgames.com/showthread.php?104604-February-Patch-Notes!

With future patches we’ll continue to iterate through Civ V systems and fine tune the balance of each one. So far we’ve already identified combat, multiplayer, late-game policies, wonders and civilization-unique bonuses as additional areas that will benefit from this sort of attention. And as this journey progresses we promise to keep an ear to the ground for other areas the Civilization community may want us to address. Continued collaboration between community, our gameplay testers, and the development team will be nothing but a win for Civ V.
 
Last edited:
So you think I should skip civ IV all together if I like the demo of civ V? Because I hear a lot of civ IV is better...

that statement by firaxis does sound promising.
 
So you think I should skip civ IV all together if I like the demo of civ V? Because I hear a lot of civ IV is better...

that statement by firaxis does sound promising.

Since you never played Civ before starting with Civ 5 is just fine. Despite what people say there are several improvements with Civ 5.

1. Graphics, no contest Civ 5 looks much better than Civ 4. The graphics in Civ 5 are great and really help pull you into the game.

2. Hex vs. squares. Civ 5 uses a hex map vs. the squares of Civ 4. Most people who play on hex maps never look back.

3. Combat, one unit per tile in Civ 5 vs. unlimited stacks of doom in Civ 4. In Civ 4 you could have your whole army in one giant stack and just run around destroying everything with it. In Civ 5, you can only have one unit per hex, so you'll have to move and fight with your army laid out on the map. Do you prefer to have each individual unit fight and attack or just have giant stacks auto resolve the battle for you?

4. Civ 4 may have deeper gameplay than Civ 5 but since you never played 4 it doesn't matter. It will have enough gameplay to keep you occupied and having fun.
 
Watching "let's play" on youtube, it looks more like sleeping pills than crack, maybe addicting but not very exciting

If you've never played the game, you probably don't realize that you have 20-30 medium-term goals in mind that have to be addressed every turn. That's why it's like crack, there's so much stuff you want to make happen over the next 10-100 turns and every turn more stuff pops up that you want to do.
 
Been a big fan of Civ games since Civ II, I've been holding out for a decent price drop on V, for $30 I think I'll get it. At least I know what I'm doing this weekend, haha!
 
Unbelieveable. You mean to say you actually enjoyed having out of sync errors after about an hour of gameplay, and then every other turn after that regardless of how many times your friends rejoined?

I've put a good amount of time into both games, and while I could take either one for single player, I can only recall ONE Civ 4 game that we played through that did not end up with an "out of sync" message - despite identical game files and a myriad of different computer systems, in addition to all of the other steps people had suggested to prevent it.

At least Civ V does not give us this sort of crap.

u cant even play a multiplayer game in civ V not with any sort of enjoyment anyways
 
This statement was released this week.

With future patches we’ll continue to iterate through Civ V systems and fine tune the balance of each one. So far we’ve already identified combat, multiplayer, late-game policies, wonders and civilization-unique bonuses as additional areas that will benefit from this sort of attention. And as this journey progresses we promise to keep an ear to the ground for other areas the Civilization community may want us to address. Continued collaboration between community, our gameplay testers, and the development team will be nothing but a win for Civ V.

So, basically 6 months after launch they've identified that the entire game is still broken and could use improvement? Not a big surprise to those of us who got suckered on the release date.

I don't play Civ5 much any more because as one person on the Civ Fanatics forums stated, Civ 5 is the first civ game where the objective is to not build things. I was highly anticipating Civ5 because of 1 unit per tile and the added strategy it would bring. However, the game was such a step back in all other areas that it has not been really enjoyable.

Thanks to the disappointment that is Civ5 I've spent the time learning how to be a better Civ4 player.

$30 bucks is worth it if you absolutely MUST have Civ5. Otherwise, I'd wait for the first expansion or another sale. Anything to give the developers more time to massage the game and make it better.
 
seems obvious they are gonna wait on a expansion for any real changes or additions of things they should had already.

This will be the last full patch before expansion annuncement I bet. They will have a Expansion for holiday season I'm guessing
 
u cant even play a multiplayer game in civ V not with any sort of enjoyment anyways

I've had several enjoyable games in Civ V, without crashes, errors, slowdowns or problems of any sort. The only problem we seem to have is when the game drags on too long and someone gets bored and wants to play something else. It happens. At least we're able to get this far - while your experience may have been different, for us Civ IV has consistently produced out of sync errors after 100 turns of gameplay or so. This essentially ends the game for us, because while we can rejoin to clear the out of sync issue, it happens again in 1-2 turns, which means that most of the players are spending more time reconnecting to the game than playing.

Among the other improvements that Civ V brings that have been previously mentioned, I see no reason why I'd want to pick up Civ IV if I had multiplayer in mind. Singleplayer perhaps. It's a steal at that price. However, due to the previously mentioned issues with Civ IV, we have taken up Civ V as our turn-based game of choice at montly LANs and are much happier for it.
 
@ $30? For civ 5? Are you kidding me? This is a no-brainer.

Don't listen to the naysayers. Some people are just never satisfied.
 
Is save game corruption still a big issue? (bloating file size until the game refuses to continue a save game)

Looks like a good game, but that issue is the deal breaker for me, unacceptable.


Y.
 
Is save game corruption still a big issue? (bloating file size until the game refuses to continue a save game)

Looks like a good game, but that issue is the deal breaker for me, unacceptable.


Y.

I never had issues with file bloat. Haven't read much about it either, should be fine.
 
Is save game corruption still a big issue? (bloating file size until the game refuses to continue a save game)

Looks like a good game, but that issue is the deal breaker for me, unacceptable.

I've never once had save game file corruptions, and I bought the game the day it was released. Every save I have, and there a lot of them, range from early in game to very late in game (with huge maps too).

Since you never played Civ before starting with Civ 5 is just fine. Despite what people say there are several improvements with Civ 5.

1. Graphics, no contest Civ 5 looks much better than Civ 4. The graphics in Civ 5 are great and really help pull you into the game.

2. Hex vs. squares. Civ 5 uses a hex map vs. the squares of Civ 4. Most people who play on hex maps never look back.

3. Combat, one unit per tile in Civ 5 vs. unlimited stacks of doom in Civ 4. In Civ 4 you could have your whole army in one giant stack and just run around destroying everything with it. In Civ 5, you can only have one unit per hex, so you'll have to move and fight with your army laid out on the map. Do you prefer to have each individual unit fight and attack or just have giant stacks auto resolve the battle for you?

4. Civ 4 may have deeper gameplay than Civ 5 but since you never played 4 it doesn't matter. It will have enough gameplay to keep you occupied and having fun.

+1

Civ 4 was great, but Civ 5 easily replaces it. There are a lot of aspects that the nay-sayers aren't telling you about Civ 4 that were absolutely awful. Stacks and stacks of units (trust me, it's much worse than it sounds), lousy AI, AI trading tech among each other like it was candy (so all the AI would be around the same level all the time), out of sync errors in multiplayer games (even on LAN), the list goes on. Civ 5 has none of these issues. It was completely rebuild from the ground up in just about every aspect. And it supports DX9 or DX10/11.
 
I haven't owned every version but I'm a fan of the Civilization series. How can you not want to play Civ 5 if you enjoyed Civ 4? There's always going to be things you like from the older game that doesn't make it to the new game if the older game is considered near perfect.
 
Grabbed Civ IV for that price...will definitely wait for a better deal on Civ V though.
 
I havent complained about civ5 vs civ4 in awhile so I figure I'll chime in a vote for civ4 being the better game a terrific value at this price. civ5 is less enjoyable than civ4 to me. I went back to civ4 two weeks after I bought civ5 (release day purchase). the game was just boring unless you were at war. the game is designed to keep you from expanding very much or building too much (units or buildings) and sure it was kinda pretty but it wasnt ground breakingly beautiful or anything...diplomacy was pretty much useless too. I havent played it since all the patches have been released though...
 
Back
Top