Space Station Trash Will Impact Earth

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Pieces of an ammonia tank that was jettisoned from the ISS are expected to impact the Earth after reentry, NASA says. Officials expect that pieces of the refrigerator-sized tank will survive reentry and will impact Sunday afternoon to evening, though the exact locations are unknown. Scary!

In a recent interview, NASA space station program manager Mike Suffredini said, "This has got a very low likelihood that anybody will be impacted by it. But still, it is a large object and pieces will enter and we just need to be cautious." NASA expects as many as 15 pieces of the tank to survive the intense heat of re-entry, ranging in size from about 1.4 ounces to nearly 40 pounds, according to MSNBC.
 
Scary. Let's start calculating the odds that any particular person would actually get hit by those falling objects.
 
When does sizes equates to weight? For the sake of calculating odds, I'll say the biggest junk will be 1x1 foot, smallest being 1x1 inches...

I'm now calculating odds.
 
196,937,400 sq miles

1 sq mile = 27878400 sq feet

total sq feet of earth surface (water/land) =5,490,299,612,160,000 sq feet

AVG SQ Footage of a person is about 2 from the top.

so the ratio of a person to the surface of earth is about eh 1 to 2,745,149,806,080,000 a percentage of eh... 3.642788447410719167217332716531e-16

And supposely the biggest object that may strike a person is at sq foot of 1, the above percentage is divided by two and that's the odds... QUITE SMALL...
 
Oh snap... I forgot to account in the 6.7 Billion people... Well, just multiply the last number to a factor of 6.7 billion and that's the accurate ODD... Somebody correct me if I'm mistaken.
 
Strap a small rocket motor on that trash and send it into a lunar orbit....we'll pick it up later :p
 
Am I the only one wondering why we're still throwing garbage into space?

I'd say it's inevitable that space tourism will happen, it's just a matter of 20 years from now before the price is decent that most folks can do it.

And wasn't it NASA that also said here awhile back there is way too much space junk?
 
Which was why they jettisoned back to earth rather than into orbit.
 
Strike that, looks like it was dropped last year and its orbit has just degraded. It does sound like a bad idea all around.
 
"they normally make sure these things will land in oceans or deserts..."

I agree, however I dont think this is something they ever intended on coming back down, thusw there would be no guidence for returning back to earth...oops! :eek:
 
I always want space junk to fall on or next to my house. Usually it contains some nice precious metals. Imagine a big chunk of platinum come barreling through your roof. :p *score* :p
 
"they normally make sure these things will land in oceans or deserts..."

I agree, however I dont think this is something they ever intended on coming back down, thusw there would be no guidence for returning back to earth...oops! :eek:

Thats the way it sounded to me. They expected the entire thing to burn up. Then after redoing their caculation now that it is ready to reenter found they were wrong and would end up wtih 12 chuncks that will not burn up.

This is why the should always assume the worse and assume a few small pieces won't burn up for anything they have comming back down to earth.






I like this line from the article ""If anybody found a piece of anything on the ground Monday morning, I would hope they wouldn't get too close to it," Suffredini said"

Who would't go look to see what the weird chunk of metal in their backyard is?
 
You can bet that NSA and the Air Force know exactly where its going to hit but that the information is classified. They track every single nut and bolt that's floating around up there in order to protect there spy satellites from hitting something when they move them from place to place.

Remember when the Comet hit Saturn, they knew exactly when it was to impact and also where, and its millions of miles away!:eek:
 
Scary, well the earth is covered ~70% with water and humans or even physical assets(buildings, cars) for damn sure don't occupy most of the remaining 30%. Then you have to figure a lot of it will burn up and break up upon reentry leaving a relatively small amount of material going at terminal velocity.

Based on all that, I think I'm more scared of slipping and breaking my neck when I get out of the shower.
 
Oh snap... I forgot to account in the 6.7 Billion people... Well, just multiply the last number to a factor of 6.7 billion and that's the accurate ODD... Somebody correct me if I'm mistaken.
Guessing the actual odds are actually smaller than that and much harder to calculate due to a number of reasons.

For example, we aren't evenly spaced over the earth.
 
Given the remote odds of this thing actually hitting a populated area (or land for that matter), you figure that any person it did hit would be one unlucky sumbitch. :D
 
You can bet that NSA and the Air Force know exactly where its going to hit but that the information is classified. They track every single nut and bolt that's floating around up there in order to protect there spy satellites from hitting something when they move them from place to place.

Remember when the Comet hit Saturn, they knew exactly when it was to impact and also where, and its millions of miles away!:eek:

Do you mean Shoemaker Levy hitting Jupiter? I don't remember a comet hitting Saturn.

Given the remote odds of this thing actually hitting a populated area (or land for that matter), you figure that any person it did hit would be one unlucky sumbitch. :D

I bet it's gonna be me. I'm havin' a bad day :(
 
This reminds me of The Simpsons..... When the cosmonauts' dinner smashed into Homer's car.
 
Scary, well the earth is covered ~70% with water and humans or even physical assets(buildings, cars) for damn sure don't occupy most of the remaining 30%. Then you have to figure a lot of it will burn up and break up upon reentry leaving a relatively small amount of material going at terminal velocity.

Based on all that, I think I'm more scared of slipping and breaking my neck when I get out of the shower.

NASA expects as many as 15 pieces of the tank to survive the intense heat of re-entry, ranging in size from about 1.4 ounces to nearly 40 pounds, according to MSNBC.

Thats the whole point of the article. It didn't all burn up (or wasn't at least suppose to) with there still being a little over a dozen parts that would hit somewhere. 1.4oz (depending on its shape) may not be that bad, although 40lbs would be.

Although as I don't think anyone expected to get hit.

Since we didn't hear any more about this I take it nobody or nothing got hit.
 
Tell that to the guy that gets the Brainectomy!

:)

196,937,400 sq miles

1 sq mile = 27878400 sq feet

total sq feet of earth surface (water/land) =5,490,299,612,160,000 sq feet

AVG SQ Footage of a person is about 2 from the top.

so the ratio of a person to the surface of earth is about eh 1 to 2,745,149,806,080,000 a percentage of eh... 3.642788447410719167217332716531e-16

And supposely the biggest object that may strike a person is at sq foot of 1, the above percentage is divided by two and that's the odds... QUITE SMALL...
 
Well, we could shoot it way out into space, but inevitably (might take 1000 years) some Alien Trucker in an intergalactic Trash-Truck the size of the moon will bring all our shit back to us, probably with a not-so-nice note from their government.

:)

Am I the only one wondering why we're still throwing garbage into space?

I'd say it's inevitable that space tourism will happen, it's just a matter of 20 years from now before the price is decent that most folks can do it.

And wasn't it NASA that also said here awhile back there is way too much space junk?
 
What scares me the most is all these idea's of shooting are garbage, junk, unwanted nuclear missles, etc... into the Sun so they will burn up. Problem solved.

I don't care how smart our scientists think they are. Does anyone else get a chill from the idea of farting around with the one thing that keeps the solar system alive?
 
They would incinerate before they even got anywhere near the surface of the sun...
 
Over 70% of the earths surface is covered in water ... the chances of this hitting a populated area are very low.
 
You can bet that NSA and the Air Force know exactly where its going to hit but that the information is classified. They track every single nut and bolt that's floating around up there in order to protect there spy satellites from hitting something when they move them from place to place.

Remember when the Comet hit Saturn, they knew exactly when it was to impact and also where, and its millions of miles away!:eek:

You mean Jupiter? Comet Levy Shoemaker?
 
So now that we don't have a interceptor missile to test under the auspices of "public safty" it's OK for it to crash into something.
 
We should launch a dozen guys or so into orbit and have them drill a nuclear warhead into the tank, clear the tank, then detonate the charge as to divide it into two pieces. Hopefully the blast of the warhead will push the two pieces completely past Earth.

...and no Aerosmith soundtrack.
 
Back
Top