SM2.0b being phased out?

Tigerblade said:
Haven't seen any shots no, shitty firewall at work will block em too :mad:

To be honest this game really holds no interest to me, it's the principle......

Altho, I *thought* the x800 line could *do* HDR?

it's the whole FP blending deal...HDR on the x800s looks like kiddy stuff compared to OpenEXR...but OpenEXR is not beyond reproach...it's slow and not compatible with AA...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
To the topic at hand...yeah 2.0b was only temporary...I don't even think it's really an official dx version...

It's really in the DX Spec. It officially exists.
 
Brent_Justice said:
They didn't "cutt off" anyone. The game runs fine on those cards. It uses SM 1.1 mode and the only thing it lacks visual quality speaking is Soft Shadows, HDR (cause no ATI cards have FP 16 frame buffer blending) and Parallax Mapping.

I musn't be putting my point across well enough. It isn't just x800 series I'm talking about. The game will only run in all it's glory on the 6800 series....how many PS2.0 cards are out there compared to PS3.0 cards....that's my point.

So in essence they are 'cutting' alot of users off as these users cannot see the game in all its glory. Yes I'm not gonna dispute the fact it'll look shit hot maxed on PS1.4 BUT it's the case that only a relative handful of gamers across the world will be able to play it in it's 'true' form.

Hope that makes it clearer lol
 
Tigerblade said:
I musn't be putting my point across well enough. It isn't just x800 series I'm talking about. The game will only run in all it's glory on the 6800 series....how many PS2.0 cards are out there compared to PS3.0 cards....that's my point.

So in essence they are 'cutting' alot of users off as these users cannot see the game in all its glory. Yes I'm not gonna dispute the fact it'll look shit hot maxed on PS1.4 BUT it's the case that only a relative handful of gamers across the world will be able to play it in it's 'true' form.

Hope that makes it clearer lol

We all get precisely what you're saying...what you don't seem to get is...that there really isn't that much of a difference...and hardly anyone is going to notice...the game isn't chock full of ps2.0 shaders like HL2...it's just a dark game with soft shadows and HDR...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
We all get precisely what you're saying...what you don't seem to get is...that there really isn't that much of a difference...and hardly anyone is going to notice...the game isn't chock full of ps2.0 shaders like HL2...it's just a dark game with soft shadows and HDR...

Well if I could see a screen shot then I'd probably agree :D

Let's just hope the same isn't done on a shader intensive game.
 
2 Things you all need to keep in mind:

1.) The SM 3.0 mode in SC: Chaos Theory does not inherintely make the IQ better over SM 1.1 in the game.

The features that allow better IQ are HDR which requires FP 16 framebuffer blending, having nothing to do with SM 3.0. Parallax Mapping and Soft Shadows. Turn all of these features off and just compare SM 3.0 to SM 1.1 and the game looks the same.

2.) You all are forgetting the base support in Longhorn is WGF 1.0 which is DX9.0L supporting SM 2.0 and 3.0.
 
Brent_Justice said:
2 Things you all need to keep in mind:

1.) The SM 3.0 mode in SC: Chaos Theory does not inherintely make the IQ better over SM 1.1 in the game.

The features that allow better IQ are HDR which requires FP 16 framebuffer blending, having nothing to do with SM 3.0. Parallax Mapping and Soft Shadows. Turn all of these features off and just compare SM 3.0 to SM 1.1 and the game looks the same.

2.) You all are forgetting the base support in Longhorn is WGF 1.0 which is DX9.0L supporting SM 2.0 and 3.0.

...what does longhorn have to do with anything?
 
Brent_Justice said:
2 Things you all need to keep in mind:

1.) The SM 3.0 mode in SC: Chaos Theory does not inherintely make the IQ better over SM 1.1 in the game.

The features that allow better IQ are HDR which requires FP 16 framebuffer blending, having nothing to do with SM 3.0. Parallax Mapping and Soft Shadows. Turn all of these features off and just compare SM 3.0 to SM 1.1 and the game looks the same.

2.) You all are forgetting the base support in Longhorn is WGF 1.0 which is DX9.0L supporting SM 2.0 and 3.0.

I think I hear the fat lady singing :p

Fair enough, I will now be quiet ;)
 
Brent_Justice said:
Just showing that SM 2.0 isn't going anywhere as some people are fearing in this thread.
Brent, do you know if Unreal 3 will have SM2.0 support?
I heard minimum 6600...
 
I heard minimum 6600 to get sm3.0 support...
The engine movie demos say how sm2.0 and sm3.0 are the basis, but with sm3.0 acurate depth is rendered.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
haha...well I"m a card carrying member of the "NV crew" so let me take a stab at responding to that...

well...it's not quite that simple...the x800s and ps2.0b make up a very small minority of the cards out there and ATi is phasing ps2.0b out...so it will have less than a year lifespan...however...as you can see from Valve's own survey, FX cards make up at least 17% of their users (could be more due to people running in linux being listed as unknown which was another 7%)...and yet they dropped the partial precision path which would have greatly increased performance on those cards...and the fact that they had a marketing deal with ATi just made that whole situation look shady as hell..like Valve cared more about their advertising partners than their end-users...
Maybe they just couldn't get the effects they wanted with partail precission.

^eMpTy^ said:
yeah I read that right after I posted...thus my second post...personally...I'm not privy to the inner workings of their company or anything...but maybe they just couldn't get the effects they wanted with PS2.0? there are tons of logical reasons why they would do such a thing...maybe they had features that went beyond ps2.0 and stuff that could be done in ps1.4 and there was no need to write a ps2.0 codepath when they could just use 1.4 and then everything back to the geforce3 would work with it...

whatever the case...don't worry...I'm sure all those ps2.0 cards run ps1.4 just fine as well...
Don't you have a sinister tin foil hat theory that maybe the devoloper and nVidia are up to?
 
kcthebrewer said:
Brent, do you know if Unreal 3 will have SM2.0 support?
I heard minimum 6600...

http://www.beyondunreal.com/content/articles/95_1.php

BU: UT2004 required 5.5 gigs of hard drive space to install. This has got to be a strain a lot of people's systems. So you're talking 2048 x 2048 texture sets, what kind of system and memory is this next game going to take?

TS: Well, we are aiming at the kind of PC that we think will be mainstream in 2006. We will also be able to scale it down. Basically DirectX 9 cards will be minimum spec, so any DirectX 9 shipping today will be capable of running our game, but probably at reduced detail. If you only have a 256 meg video card you will be running the game one step down, whereas if you have a video card with a gig of memory then you'll be able to see the game at full detail.
 
Met-AL said:
Maybe they just couldn't get the effects they wanted with partail precission.

Don't you have a sinister tin foil hat theory that maybe the devoloper and nVidia are up to?

There is no difference between what you can do with partial precision and without, it's just a flag set in the code saying when FP16 is good enough and when it isn't.

No I think it's quite clear what they're up to, the developer wanted true HDR effects in their game...and nVidia was the only game in town since the x800s don't support FP16 blending...Valve is working on the same kind of HDR for the source engine as well...
 
'whereas if you have a video card with a gig of memory then you'll be able to see the game at full detail'

When is unreal 3 estimated for release?

Sod 512Mb cards.....
 
Blackhawk05 said:
Anyone care to tell me wtf a 'TWIMTBP Game' is?

The Way It's Meant To Be Played. Nvidia's branding of a game.

ATi's is 'Get in the game'....I think lol
 
Tigerblade said:
'whereas if you have a video card with a gig of memory then you'll be able to see the game at full detail'

When is unreal 3 estimated for release?

Sod 512Mb cards.....
Yeah with that sort of comment i think i might skip the R520/G70 gen ;)
 
^eMpTy^ said:
There is no difference between what you can do with partial precision and without, it's just a flag set in the code saying when FP16 is good enough and when it isn't.

No I think it's quite clear what they're up to, the developer wanted true HDR effects in their game...and nVidia was the only game in town since the x800s don't support FP16 blending...Valve is working on the same kind of HDR for the source engine as well...

I like the fact though that Valve is making a fallback to INT16 for HDR for cards that don't support FP16 blending. That way all cards can run with the highest quality HDR they are capable of rendering.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
There is no difference between what you can do with partial precision and without, it's just a flag set in the code saying when FP16 is good enough and when it isn't.

No I think it's quite clear what they're up to, the developer wanted true HDR effects in their game...and nVidia was the only game in town since the x800s don't support FP16 blending...Valve is working on the same kind of HDR for the source engine as well...

I apologize for my statements regarding the tinfoil crap.

I just get irritated everytime someone brings up the ATi/Valve conspiracy theory when we all know how poor DX9 performance was on the FX series of cards.
 
Tigerblade said:
'whereas if you have a video card with a gig of memory then you'll be able to see the game at full detail'

When is unreal 3 estimated for release?

Sod 512Mb cards.....

Well I don't know about Unreal 3 but UT 2007 sounds like it will be out towards the fall of 2006. It may be 2007 before we see Unreal 3, just a guess on my part.
 
Met-AL said:
I apologize for my statements regarding the tinfoil crap.

I just get irritated everytime someone brings up the ATi/Valve conspiracy theory when we all know how poor DX9 performance was on the FX series of cards.

haha...no problem...for the record...I totally have a tin-foil hat...and it says "DIE ATI DIE" on the side of it...

no...I'm not kidding...
 
Brent_Justice said:
Well I don't know about Unreal 3 but UT 2007 sounds like it will be out towards the fall of 2006. It may be 2007 before we see Unreal 3, just a guess on my part.

Is UT2k7 running the unreal 3 engine? Or a variant of it? I don't suppose there is much info about it.....

ut2k4 is a wicked game :D cannot wait for 2k7

Didn't think much of Pariah tho....too slow. Altho I digress.... ;)
 
^eMpTy^ said:
haha...no problem...for the record...I totally have a tin-foil hat...and it says "DIE ATI DIE" on the side of it...

no...I'm not kidding...

That's two comments I may have to sig of urs tonight ;)
 
kcthebrewer said:
Which good game other than HL2 and Painkiller isn't?

Painkiller is a TWIMTBP game

Read the thread. Beat to death with my reply :) but: SM2 isn't going anywhere.
As for Ubisoft not putting it in SP:CT is retarded. Simply added the code for SM2 would have more of a performance increase on a lot of videocards (Both ati and nvidia).
 
Geez, you leave the thread for a moment to play some HL2 (yes in ps1.4... no, not on an FX... on an actual 8500 :)), and the thread just explodes! :)

^eMpTy^ said:
There is no difference between what you can do with partial precision and without, it's just a flag set in the code saying when FP16 is good enough and when it isn't.

Well, in theory you can do the same. In practice the precision may be too low to properly perform certain effects... and then it might be better to redesign the shader entirely.

Other than that I'd like to point out that the DX specs force all devices to be completely backward compatible. Which means that all SM3.0+ cards will be supporting SM2.0b. This could mean that like ps1.4, SM2.0b will be popular among developers, despite the fact that there aren't that many 'true' ps1.4/SM2.0b devices out there.
Back when the Radeon 8500 was still high-end, there wasn't really any software with ps1.4 support either, but now many games support ps1.4 anyway. Possibly also because the 8500 is now mutated into budget-devices, and is quite popular with OEMs...
I suppose the X800s could have a second life as low-budget devices aswell, and then the same will happen with SM2.0b.

Apart from that, you don't really NEED FP16 blending for HDR. There are ways around it, some even with the full 24 bit accuracy.
But it seems that there's no game with HDR that uses such an approach.
 
Scali said:
Other than that I'd like to point out that the DX specs force all devices to be completely backward compatible. Which means that all SM3.0+ cards will be supporting SM2.0b. This could mean that like ps1.4, SM2.0b will be popular among developers, despite the fact that there aren't that many 'true' ps1.4/SM2.0b devices out there.
Back when the Radeon 8500 was still high-end, there wasn't really any software with ps1.4 support either, but now many games support ps1.4 anyway. Possibly also because the 8500 is now mutated into budget-devices, and is quite popular with OEMs...
I suppose the X800s could have a second life as low-budget devices aswell, and then the same will happen with SM2.0b.

Apart from that, you don't really NEED FP16 blending for HDR. There are ways around it, some even with the full 24 bit accuracy.
But it seems that there's no game with HDR that uses such an approach.

You kind of said something in a different way that I was going to say. You can see at some point x800 cards becoming the low end card. But there are also a LOT of the x800 family now. It's not just the original "2" anymore(x800 pro and x800XT) SM3 cards can handle SM2.B games because of backwards compatiblity and much like games not really fully use SM2 (and still really don't), SM2b is a "stepping stone" if you will. Kind of like how Riddick uses SM2++ (a or b) for softshadow support. There is one engine that has been announced to use SM2B too that hasn't been released yet and it's the Reality Engine (haunted house demo, blade of grass near coke can) Going home soon so don't really feel like searching :) I know it's been posted on the forums here a couple of times.
Although it might be called artifical Reality engine.
 
Netrat33 said:
Kind of like how Riddick uses SM2++ (a or b) for softshadow support.

Wrong, its an OpenGL game and the so-called SM2++ is just an OpenGL softshadow extention (ARB2 I think??). :p
 
Brent_Justice said:
I like the fact though that Valve is making a fallback to INT16 for HDR for cards that don't support FP16 blending. That way all cards can run with the highest quality HDR they are capable of rendering.


Kind of funny but people currently brag about Nvidia cards being more advanced. Unless it changes with the Geforce 7 or 8 series, i dont see this staying true for long. ATI seems to be very content on a 24/32FP while i assume Nvidia will continue with 16/32FP. Means in games under age from older DX may have an advantage under NV but anything that uses PS1.4+ i believe will revert Nvidia into 32FP while ATI can continue to do FP24 in all games except for those with PS3.0 enabled. Should be a performance advantage almost instantly and until the end of time on ATI cards. One thing im semi-curious about in terms of if Nvidia will address that.
 
FanATIc said:
Kind of funny but people currently brag about Nvidia cards being more advanced. Unless it changes with the Geforce 7 or 8 series, i dont see this staying true for long. ATI seems to be very content on a 24/32FP while i assume Nvidia will continue with 16/32FP. Means in games under age from older DX may have an advantage under NV but anything that uses PS1.4+ i believe will revert Nvidia into 32FP while ATI can continue to do FP24 in all games except for those with PS3.0 enabled. Should be a performance advantage almost instantly and until the end of time on ATI cards. One thing im semi-curious about in terms of if Nvidia will address that.

...huh?

I was under the impression that the 6800s did FP32 all the time unless told to do otherwise...and in that regard they keep up with the x800s very nicely...especially considering their clock disadvantage...I don't thing what you're saying really makes sense...any other opinions?
 
^eMpTy^ said:
...huh?

I was under the impression that the 6800s did FP32 all the time unless told to do otherwise...and in that regard they keep up with the x800s very nicely...especially considering their clock disadvantage...I don't thing what you're saying really makes sense...any other opinions?


haveing to do FP32 in a SM2.0 game vs ATI in FP24 actually makes the 6800 just a little slower.
 
Back
Top