desertjedi
Weaksauce
- Joined
- Feb 29, 2008
- Messages
- 69
I'm looking for some input/discussion on the wisdom of buying and using a TN-panel LCD.
Without realizing it until a few weeks ago, the only LCD I've ever used at home had a 19" MVA-panel. GTG response time was 8ms but I game a lot and only noticed a little afterglow in GRAW - when I jerked the mouse fast. But I also spend about 5-10 hours a week doing some serious photo editing for my online store products.
In my ignorance, I recently bought a Samsung 22" TN-panel LCD. At the time I didn't know about 6-bit color. I had 'CMO' panel problems and returned it but I did use it for a day. My non-CMO-related impressions were:
- backlighting is extremely "harsh"
- whites were not pure and bold
- LCD brightness was too strong
That's all subjective and vague language but it's the best I can come up with. The end result was that doing intensive work with the LCD led to bad eyestrain. Compared to previous MVA-panel LCD, it was kind of like using an old TV as a computer monitor.
Just looking at the main screen of Outlook Express showing all my e-mails, I could tell something wasn't right and it bothered my eyes a little.
I returned the Samsung and got a Viewsonic 22" TN-panel LCD. The three "negative" points I bulleted above were repeated in the new LCD.
By this point, I'd been schooled by the people on this forum and advised to get a non-TN panel.
I tracked down a 20" MVA-panel LCD from Planar that I was able to test for a short time (workplace had one). I can not come up with words to describe how phenomenal this display was compared to my prior two TNs. Photos were stunning in detail and clarity. Text was a pleasure to read and very easy on the eyes. Being a 20" 16x12 res LCD, the dot pitch was a bit better at .255 accounting for some of the improvement.
That LCD costs only $100-120 more than a 22" inch TN-panel LCD.
One of my friends has never used anything but TN-panels. Right now he has two 22" TN panels side by side and he says they look great. Then again he uses Dells which seem to have a really good rep. Has MaximumPC ever picked anything other than a DEll LCD as their preferred choice?
Maybe some of this comes down to what people are used to using. But part of me says that we're buying cheap ($250-300US) consumer-level products for the most important part of our rigs - the part our eyes have to look at.
Are the majority of people satisfied using TN panels? Are the weaknesses of TN panels exacerbated when increasing the screen size to 22"?
Without realizing it until a few weeks ago, the only LCD I've ever used at home had a 19" MVA-panel. GTG response time was 8ms but I game a lot and only noticed a little afterglow in GRAW - when I jerked the mouse fast. But I also spend about 5-10 hours a week doing some serious photo editing for my online store products.
In my ignorance, I recently bought a Samsung 22" TN-panel LCD. At the time I didn't know about 6-bit color. I had 'CMO' panel problems and returned it but I did use it for a day. My non-CMO-related impressions were:
- backlighting is extremely "harsh"
- whites were not pure and bold
- LCD brightness was too strong
That's all subjective and vague language but it's the best I can come up with. The end result was that doing intensive work with the LCD led to bad eyestrain. Compared to previous MVA-panel LCD, it was kind of like using an old TV as a computer monitor.
Just looking at the main screen of Outlook Express showing all my e-mails, I could tell something wasn't right and it bothered my eyes a little.
I returned the Samsung and got a Viewsonic 22" TN-panel LCD. The three "negative" points I bulleted above were repeated in the new LCD.
By this point, I'd been schooled by the people on this forum and advised to get a non-TN panel.
I tracked down a 20" MVA-panel LCD from Planar that I was able to test for a short time (workplace had one). I can not come up with words to describe how phenomenal this display was compared to my prior two TNs. Photos were stunning in detail and clarity. Text was a pleasure to read and very easy on the eyes. Being a 20" 16x12 res LCD, the dot pitch was a bit better at .255 accounting for some of the improvement.
That LCD costs only $100-120 more than a 22" inch TN-panel LCD.
One of my friends has never used anything but TN-panels. Right now he has two 22" TN panels side by side and he says they look great. Then again he uses Dells which seem to have a really good rep. Has MaximumPC ever picked anything other than a DEll LCD as their preferred choice?
Maybe some of this comes down to what people are used to using. But part of me says that we're buying cheap ($250-300US) consumer-level products for the most important part of our rigs - the part our eyes have to look at.
Are the majority of people satisfied using TN panels? Are the weaknesses of TN panels exacerbated when increasing the screen size to 22"?