Should we be buying TN panel LCDs?

desertjedi

Weaksauce
Joined
Feb 29, 2008
Messages
69
I'm looking for some input/discussion on the wisdom of buying and using a TN-panel LCD.

Without realizing it until a few weeks ago, the only LCD I've ever used at home had a 19" MVA-panel. GTG response time was 8ms but I game a lot and only noticed a little afterglow in GRAW - when I jerked the mouse fast. But I also spend about 5-10 hours a week doing some serious photo editing for my online store products.

In my ignorance, I recently bought a Samsung 22" TN-panel LCD. At the time I didn't know about 6-bit color. I had 'CMO' panel problems and returned it but I did use it for a day. My non-CMO-related impressions were:

- backlighting is extremely "harsh"
- whites were not pure and bold
- LCD brightness was too strong

That's all subjective and vague language but it's the best I can come up with. The end result was that doing intensive work with the LCD led to bad eyestrain. Compared to previous MVA-panel LCD, it was kind of like using an old TV as a computer monitor.

Just looking at the main screen of Outlook Express showing all my e-mails, I could tell something wasn't right and it bothered my eyes a little.

I returned the Samsung and got a Viewsonic 22" TN-panel LCD. The three "negative" points I bulleted above were repeated in the new LCD.

By this point, I'd been schooled by the people on this forum and advised to get a non-TN panel.

I tracked down a 20" MVA-panel LCD from Planar that I was able to test for a short time (workplace had one). I can not come up with words to describe how phenomenal this display was compared to my prior two TNs. Photos were stunning in detail and clarity. Text was a pleasure to read and very easy on the eyes. Being a 20" 16x12 res LCD, the dot pitch was a bit better at .255 accounting for some of the improvement.

That LCD costs only $100-120 more than a 22" inch TN-panel LCD.

One of my friends has never used anything but TN-panels. Right now he has two 22" TN panels side by side and he says they look great. Then again he uses Dells which seem to have a really good rep. Has MaximumPC ever picked anything other than a DEll LCD as their preferred choice?

Maybe some of this comes down to what people are used to using. But part of me says that we're buying cheap ($250-300US) consumer-level products for the most important part of our rigs - the part our eyes have to look at.

Are the majority of people satisfied using TN panels? Are the weaknesses of TN panels exacerbated when increasing the screen size to 22"?
 
Personally...I could NEVER buy a TN lcd panel. Picture quality completely sucks compared to MVA/PVA or S-IPS.

I think TN panels are 'OK' for your typical non-enthusiast pc user. I reccomend them to family members and they are all thrilled with them.

The two biggest problems I have with TN panels are viewing angles and color reproduction. Viewing angles on TN panels are horrible. You only have to move a few degrees off direct center and colors start changing, you lose contrast...its a mess. I can't hardly even browse digital pictures because they always look different depending on how I am sitting...and don't even think about even light photo editing!

Anyways...personal opinion, but I hate TN panels. I will never own one. Although I think they are a good option for a typical, light pc user.
 
Personally...I could NEVER buy a TN lcd panel. Picture quality completely sucks compared to MVA/PVA or S-IPS.

I think TN panels are 'OK' for your typical non-enthusiast pc user. I reccomend them to family members and they are all thrilled with them.

The two biggest problems I have with TN panels are viewing angles and color reproduction. Viewing angles on TN panels are horrible. You only have to move a few degrees off direct center and colors start changing, you lose contrast...its a mess. I can't hardly even browse digital pictures because they always look different depending on how I am sitting...and don't even think about even light photo editing!

Anyways...personal opinion, but I hate TN panels. I will never own one. Although I think they are a good option for a typical, light pc user.


I agree; except I just would not reccomend them to anyone period. I guess if you are a gamer on a low budget.

A good display will last you through several comps, so buy a good one. It is the most important piece of your system in my opinion.

Best of luck

Dave
 
TN panels are great for gamers and office use only IMO. fast response times for the gamers and the 'i dont care how it looks, i just want to see something' attitude of the ppl that work in cubicles and look at word documents all day.

i would never buy one myself but they have their uses.

also, personally i cant stand dell stuff. monitors included.
 
That is only partially correct. In the horizontal direction contrast drops faster on MVA/PVA panels than on TN panels. VA panels actually lose contrast faster than any other technology.

The only panels that don't have this issue are IPS.
See PVA compared to IPS here(scroll down to image quality pic showing gamma shift):
http://monitortest.blogspot.com/

For the record I prefer TN to VA, precisely because the horizontal gamma/shift contrast loss is so bad on VA panels,that I can't stand using them. It was unknown to me when I purchased my first LCD, a PVA (I even ended up with second PVA) that I eventually replaced with a TN panel.

MVA Left, TN Right.
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=38&mo1=96&p1=979&ma2=36&mo2=224&p2=2104&ph=8

Now
MVA Left, IPS Right.
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=38&mo1=96&p1=979&ma2=52&mo2=149&p2=1606&ph=8

Notice VA loses contrast in every direction.
TN keeps it in the Horizontal, loses it above, and goes dark below.
IPS keeps contast in every direction. By far the most stable technology to work with.

Frankly TN hate is overblown. I only recomend TN and IPS. TN for general usage, IPS for high quality.

VA I don't recommend. I don't see the point for paying more to get a different set of problems that IMO are overall worse than TN.
 
That is only partially correct. In the horizontal direction contrast drops faster on MVA/PVA panels than on TN panels. VA panels actually lose contrast faster than any other technology.

The only panels that don't have this issue are IPS.
See PVA compared to IPS here(scroll down to image quality pic showing gamma shift):
http://monitortest.blogspot.com/

For the record I prefer TN to VA, precisely because the horizontal gamma/shift contrast loss is so bad on VA panels,that I can't stand using them. It was unknown to me when I purchased my first LCD, a PVA (I even ended up with second PVA) that I eventually replaced with a TN panel.

MVA Left, TN Right.
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=38&mo1=96&p1=979&ma2=36&mo2=224&p2=2104&ph=8

Now
MVA Left, IPS Right.
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=38&mo1=96&p1=979&ma2=52&mo2=149&p2=1606&ph=8

Notice VA loses contrast in every direction.
TN keeps it in the Horizontal, loses it above, and goes dark below.
IPS keeps contast in every direction. By far the most stable technology to work with.

Frankly TN hate is overblown. I only recomend TN and IPS. TN for general usage, IPS for high quality.

VA I don't recommend. I don't see the point for paying more to get a different set of problems that IMO are overall worse than TN.

Your comparison is flawed, because Acer tends to suck.

Here check this out: http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=36&mo1=332&p1=3107&ma2=36&mo2=224&p2=2104&ph=8

Oops; now the Samsung 245T smokes the 226BW.

It depends on the vendor and the model. In general TNs are the worst, but not in all cases.

Samsungs S-PVA pannels are used in many high end LCDs, their only major issue is input lag, which only matters to gamers.

I really do not like TN pannels, but I will admit the 28 inch HannsG looks pretty good for the price.

Best of luck

Dave
 
Your comparison is flawed, because Acer tends to suck.

Oops; now the Samsung 245T smokes the 226BW.

What do you mean smokes? It is essentially the same from the top and from the sides TN vs VA, it is only from below where you get the telltale TN darkening where you can tell them apart. Sure this picture reduces the VA effect, but this is more about the picture taken, they could be a bit more rigorous getting consistent results. Acer has nothing to do with it, it is the panel inside and everyone uses the same panels. They didn't make the panel. VA panels wash out. All of them. So unless you are talking about the view from UNDER your desk, TN doesn't have worse viewing angles as so many claim without verifying.

Revisit the Dell review I linked. Same panel in the Dell as the Samsung 245T you think is great and it washes out and destroys contrast completely. Scroll down to picture of two guys with brick building behind. Now that is poor viewing angle. I guarantee a TN wouldn't be that bad.

http://monitortest.blogspot.com/

The Reference Panel BTW is an IPS. Compared to which both VA and TN suffer viewing angle problems. Though TN has more issues in the vertical. In the horizontal TN is at least as good (Better in practice than VA).
 
Look at the rest of this page. You are the only person that has any interest in TN pannels. Look at what pannel types are used by Eizo and NEC or the more expensive Dell and Samsungs. Absolutely none of them are TN and many of them are PVA. It is pretty well established that in general terms the pecking order is IPS, PVA, and TN. You can find exceptions to this, but they are few and far between. I will not wast any time quoting specs, because most of them are BS anyways, but the one thing you really can't ignore is that TN are 6 bit color as compared to 8 bit in both IPS and PVA. I have seen PVA pannels that look pretty bad but, not as bad as the worst of the TNs.

I am not in love with any LCD tech. I think they all stink for what they cost. I own two Sony GDM-F520s one old and one new in the box. I use a Dell 2407WFP A03 for text related computing and it is good but by no measn great. I plan to upgrade to a NEC H-IPS pannel if they ever get their 30 incher out the door.

If you like TN junk; good for you. You can save a lot of money. As I stated above I will not recommend TN to anyone, because most if not all of them are unusable in my opinion.

Best of luck

Dave
 
Look at the rest of this page. You are the only person that has any interest in TN pannels.
Dave


Yes, why trust your own eyes when you can rely on the knee jerk opinions of the masses instead. The pictures you provided yourself illustrate one of the two main complaints is largely bogus. Aside from the viewing angle from below TN is at least equal to VA (I contend TN is better, but more easily identified with the dark from below test, so people look from below to "confirm" bad viewing angle).

I started out my LCD quest by reading reviews and believe the concensus PVA/IPS were good TN was junk. So I went out and bought a PVA which quickly had me questioning this "accepted wisdom".

I am VERY picky, put a panel in front of me and I can quickly tell you which type it is from the viewing angle behaviors, but you really can't tell from color, which is the other supposed fault. That is much more dependent on backlight and calibration than on monitor technology. 6bit is not the whole story. FRC does a very good job. Back to your comparison of the PVA vs TN samsung. Flip it over to the color comparison:

http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=36&mo1=332&p1=3107&ma2=36&mo2=224&p2=2104&ph=6

The TN panel is more accurate both out of the box and after calibration. How can that be with crappy 6 bit color?

People should actually look at the specific monitor in question and stop relying on historical hand me down info from 5 years ago. TN monitors today deliver very good color and viewing angles at least compared to the other compromise VA.

BTW I am not lucky at all. I find IPS and only IPS is suitable for color imaging work. By far the most expensive panel type. I can just barely tolerate TN and can't tolerate VA. So my choices are limited for decent quality monitor.
 
Well; we will just to agree to disagree. My observations of TN pannels are not based on any thing other than first hand experience. I work on a lot of other peoples hardware. Usually helping them out with software, or network issues. I have never owned a TN pannel, but when other people got new systems especially in Dell packaged systems, I smelled a rat. I checked into it and what do you know they are TN.

I really do not see how you can try and defend the color, color shift, or contrast ratio on TN pannels, but to each his own. I think you must have had a bad experience with a VA pannel and decided they all suck which is not the case. It varies dramatically by vendor and model.

Like I said if you are happy with your TN pannel, good for you.

Best of luck

Dave
 
Snowdog, you keep saying TN only has a bad viewing angle from the bottom, but that's not the whole story. It only takes a single side with a viewing angle problem to ruin the whole monitor. For example, on larger TNs if your eyes are not always perfectly aligned with the top edge of the screen, the image will be screwed. You drop your eyes down a few inches to the middle of the screen and the top becomes darker. And while it is possible to get good colors on a TN with calibration, the colors will only be good from the exact viewing angle you calibrated it from and at the exact position on the monitor where the calibration program was displayed. I've tried calibrating TNs before and it's a nightmare. You get everything perfect, and then you drag the calibration window up a couple inches or move your head a couple inches and it looks totally uncalibrated.

A VA panel will not allow you to view the screen from any angle like an IPS will, but it will at least allow you to move up and down or left and right by a foot or so without noticing any shift. Also, a properly calibrated VA panel will not have black crush and details will not be lost in dark scenes.

Finally, another problem with TNs that's less common on other panel types is backlight bleed. TNs are VERY susceptible to backlight bleed and nearly all of them have some, if not a lot.
 
Where were we discussing contrast ratios? We were talking about color and viewing angle, both of which I demonstrated are objectively as good if not better than VA. If TN didn't turn dark from below, almost no one could tell the difference from VA.

BTW the whole 6bit this is very murky:
http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/articles/6bit_8bit.htm

I am no huge fan of TN (I wish TN and VA would disappear), but in choosing the lesser of evils on the low end, I believe TN has a better set of tradeoffs.

TN:
pros: Less expensive, Less ghosting, Less lag, dramatically less horizontal gamma/tone shift
Cons: vertical viewing angle issue (pale from above, dark from below), some have 6bit+frc color (that in pracitce has almost no negative effect).

VA:
Pros: vertical viewing angle not as bad as TN, native 8bit color
Cons: Worse horizontal gamma/tone shift, most ghosting, highest lags, price premium over TN, many overdirve artifiacts attempting to deal with slowest B-W response time.

I have owned both (actually two different VA screens). The major issue I had with all 3, was viewing angles related, They are annoying on TN, intolerable on my VA.

Of the two VAs I owned the second improved on input lag and ghost (which were both horrendous on the first) but even the second was clearly worse than my TN.

If you want to pay more money for bigger lags, and big horizontal gamma shifts, be my guest. But I think most people should actually compare them first. Soon it won't matter, It is getting harder to find a non TN screen in the lower end anyway.
 
Only used TN panels. Don't have the $ for anything more.

Ignorance is bliss. :D
 
Yes, why trust your own eyes when you can rely on the knee jerk opinions of the masses instead. The pictures you provided yourself illustrate one of the two main complaints is largely bogus. Aside from the viewing angle from below TN is at least equal to VA (I contend TN is better, but more easily identified with the dark from below test, so people look from below to "confirm" bad viewing angle).

The 160 degrees advertised by the manufacturer are a sham and do not reflect reality at all:
Whilst the horizontal contrast viewed from the side can just about be deemed good, colour changes due to the viewing angle can be seen vertically from practically every seating position. A monocoloured grey desktop background appears darker at the upper edge and brighter at the lower edge of the screen.

http://proadviser.de/en/monitore/review/2007/review-samsung-226bw-part11.html
Although LG advertises generous viewing angles on the homepage, the L227WT is no different to other TN panel models in this regard. Especially the 170 degrees vertical viewing angle advertised belongs to the realms of fantasy, far from reality. As soon as you move your head out of the normal working position by rising or lowering it by a few centimetres, the brightness and colours at the top and bottom edges already start to change.
http://proadviser.de/en/monitore/review/2008/review-lg-l227wt-part7.html

While S-PVA Eizo gets very good as grade, previously only achieved by IPS panels.
http://proadviser.de/en/monitore/review/2008/review-eizo-s2231w-part9.html


FRC does a very good job. Back to your comparison of the PVA vs TN samsung. Flip it over to the color comparison:
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=36&mo1=332&p1=3107&ma2=36&mo2=224&p2=2104&ph=6
The TN panel is more accurate both out of the box and after calibration. How can that be with crappy 6 bit color?
That's comparing native sRGB monitor to wide gamut monitor.
And calibration checks only small number of selected colours, so it won't be hard to optimize dithering of those colours if they're not available from palette of 262k real colours.
 
A VA panel will not allow you to view the screen from any angle like an IPS will, but it will at least allow you to move up and down or left and right by a foot or so without noticing any shift. Also, a properly calibrated VA panel will not have black crush and details will not be lost in dark scenes.

I would never suggest a TN (nor VA)screen for imaging or other critical viewing work. I agree that the vertical angle is the worse of the technologies. But your characterization of VA horizontal angles is mistaken. You cannot callibrate away the tone/gamma shift on PVA screen. If you calibrate the center of the screen gamma to actually see all the details, then the sides will be very washed out, and this is sitting perfectly centered on screen. Contrast will drop and tones will lighten on the sides. You can't calibrate that away, it is a physical fuction of crystal layout in VA.

Here is crop (Left side and center) from a screen shot of my own VA screen before I sold it at a loss, just to be rid of it. Note this shot was taken at normal viewing distance (2.5 feet), centered straight on to the screen. Again note. This is not an angle shot. It is straight on, centered. Now tell me when editing an image which gamma is correct? Do you move your head around to find the right gamma? All the same issues you describe for TN are present, only instead of up down, it is side to side. Oh and lest anyone claim VA is better now. Check that Dell 2408 review link and go down to the image quality sections and have a gander at those two guys in front of the brick building.

65452628.TGQ59HS0.pvaToneShift.jpg
 
Where were we discussing contrast ratios? We were talking about color and viewing angle, both of which I demonstrated are objectively as good if not better than VA. If TN didn't turn dark from below, almost no one could tell the difference from VA.

BTW the whole 6bit this is very murky:
http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/articles/6bit_8bit.htm

I am no huge fan of TN (I wish TN and VA would disappear), but in choosing the lesser of evils on the low end, I believe TN has a better set of tradeoffs.

TN:
pros: Less expensive, Less ghosting, Less lag, dramatically less horizontal gamma/tone shift
Cons: vertical viewing angle issue (pale from above, dark from below), some have 6bit+frc color (that in pracitce has almost no negative effect).

VA:
Pros: vertical viewing angle not as bad as TN, native 8bit color
Cons: Worse horizontal gamma/tone shift, most ghosting, highest lags, price premium over TN, many overdirve artifiacts attempting to deal with slowest B-W response time.

I have owned both (actually two different VA screens). The major issue I had with all 3, was viewing angles related, They are annoying on TN, intolerable on my VA.

Of the two VAs I owned the second improved on input lag and ghost (which were both horrendous on the first) but even the second was clearly worse than my TN.

If you want to pay more money for bigger lags, and big horizontal gamma shifts, be my guest. But I think most people should actually compare them first. Soon it won't matter, It is getting harder to find a non TN screen in the lower end anyway.

NAME the monitors you owned, its funny that you can so adamantly argue with these "mystery monitors" yet never give us the model number.

Also anyone who is seriously listening to snowdog, STOP, please, look at this link:
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=88&mo1=249&p1=2366&ma2=36&mo2=245&p2=2334&ph=8

S-PVA vs a TN-film panel, the difference is night and day, there is no contest. Please dont go buying a TN film panel expecting it to be the same as an S-PVA, it isnt.
 
You're the only person I've ever heard saying TNs have better viewing angles than VA. :rolleyes:

As for the pros and cons you listed... my Gateway FHD2400 (TN) has much worse horizontal viewing angles than my LG L246WP (P-MVA). On the LG there's just a little gamma shift, but on the Gateway everything turns a brownish tint from the side, not to mention the vertical viewing angle problems. Also, I can't see any input lag or ghosting on the LG compared to the FHD2400 right next to it. As for overdrive artifacts, I've never seen any on the two P-MVA panels I own.

That means the only thing better about the Gateway is the price (and I like the glossy screen because it improves contrast, but that has nothing to do with the panel)..... Oh wait, never mind. I got the LG for $300 and the Gateway for $600.
 
I would never suggest a TN (nor VA)screen for imaging or other critical viewing work. I agree that the vertical angle is the worse of the technologies. But your characterization of VA horizontal angles is mistaken. You cannot callibrate away the tone/gamma shift on PVA screen. If you calibrate the center of the screen gamma to actually see all the details, then the sides will be very washed out, and this is sitting perfectly centered on screen. Contrast will drop and tones will lighten on the sides. You can't calibrate that away, it is a physical fuction of crystal layout in VA.

Here is crop (Left side and center) from a screen shot of my own VA screen before I sold it at a loss, just to be rid of it. Note this shot was taken at normal viewing distance (2.5 feet), centered straight on to the screen. Again note. This is not an angle shot. It is straight on, centered. Now tell me when editing an image which gamma is correct? Do you move your head around to find the right gamma? All the same issues you describe for TN are present, only instead of up down, it is side to side. Oh and lest anyone claim VA is better now. Check that Dell 2408 review link and go down to the image quality sections and have a gander at those two guys in front of the brick building.

If my face is a foot away from the screen, then yes, I can see the gamma shift on the sides. However, while I don't know what kind of monitor you had, I know that if I'm 2-3 feet away from my monitor then I can't see any shift at all from the left to the right. Maybe you had a crappy VA monitor or it wasn't properly calibrated.
 
I just bought teh benq g2400w tn panel. I was expecting A LOT worse angle viewing problems from this TN b/c that is what everyone blabs about. The only viewing angle that I can see as a problem is up adn down...from side to side there basically isn't any. I'm very happy with the display...it looks so much better then the samsung 245bw!
 
Only in the horizontal direction. For example. Leaving out up and down. Do you see a pattern:

67386274.bYbv23lc.angles.jpg

Yes the MVA look like shit, the TN look like shit, the S-PVA and S-IPS look close if not the same.

How about you just keep throwing PVA and MVA underneath the same blanket statement of "VA" though, that really does a service to those who are trying to learn about monitors.
 
Yes the MVA look like shit, the TN look like shit, the S-PVA and S-IPS look close if not the same.

How about you just keep throwing PVA and MVA underneath the same blanket statement of "VA" though, that really does a service to those who are trying to learn about monitors.

Thanks; I was wondering about that, because I have not seen an MVA pannel, so I really did not know how they stacked up.

Dave
 
Yes the MVA look like shit, the TN look like shit, the S-PVA and S-IPS look close if not the same.

How about you just keep throwing PVA and MVA underneath the same blanket statement of "VA" though, that really does a service to those who are trying to learn about monitors.

Yeah, thats right. S-PVA (Dell 2407-HC) is just like IPS (NEC 2490)::rolleyes:
http://monitortest.blogspot.com/

94078579.vVUI2Xea.desperado12xn1.jpg
 
Yes the MVA look like shit, the TN look like shit, the S-PVA and S-IPS look close if not the same.

How about you just keep throwing PVA and MVA underneath the same blanket statement of "VA" though, that really does a service to those who are trying to learn about monitors.


Actually, I have both a S-PVA and P-MVA, the latter is a far superior panel. Samsung PVAs give a yellow tinge to their gamma shift and older ones like my 2407wfp has pathetic blacks. The only difference between the two is that I can put my finger on is... um well nothing really.. It depends on when they were made as it changes panel from panel.
 
Actually, I have both a S-PVA and P-MVA, the latter is a far superior panel. Samsung PVAs give a yellow tinge to their gamma shift and older ones like my 2407wfp has pathetic blacks. The only difference between the two is that I can put my finger on is... um well nothing really.. It depends on when they were made as it changes panel from panel.

OK; and how do either of you VA pannels compare to TN pannels?

Dave
 
Why do people try to justify their purchases by telling everyone else that their inferior product "blows away more expensive monitors".. Just admit you bought a cheaper display, or that you are content with it. There is no competition between a TN panel and a P-MVA or an S-PVA or better yet S-IPS panels. TN is bottom of the rung when comparing quality displays of both types.

Before you flip out, I've owned a very good TN(FHD2400) and a very good S-IPS(2007WFP) and I have a nice P-MVA coming sunday :) (245WP-BN)

If you are content with TN panels, by all means buy them. Some of us are more sensitive to viewing angles and colour reproduction than others. Personally, I loved the FHD2400, but the vertical viewing angle annoyed the heck out of me, then back light bleed sealed the deal when I had 50% or more of teh screen bleeding horrendously. I love my 2007WFP, I'd be content with a 24" version of it, alas that doesn't exist! If you are content with a TN then by all means buy TNs, but don't direct others to believe that S-PVA and P-MVA panels are inferior. Put in your post that is your OPINION, which is subjective, not objective as you so succinctly decided to employ for fact.

Personally, I'm waiting for a 30" H-IPS or LED to come down into my price range .. for now the 24" LG will do :)
 
I'm using a Viewsonic VP930b which is an MVA panel and I'm not really seeing the negative factors mentioned in this thread. When I move to the sides, I get a slight yellow tinge and gamma reduction but nothing I'm concerned about. I tried to see if the my LCD was as bad as that Dell 24"-er mentioned in that monitor.blogspot article but it was nothing like it.

As a matter of fact, I kept moving and moving my head to make the angle drastic but the only thing I accomplished was falling out of my chair and flat on my ass. :p

Without getting too technical, I'm really impressed with the consistency of lighting on this MVA panel and in comparison, the TN panels I've used have looked like "butt".

I have another MVA-panel LCD on its way from Newegg...the Planar PL2010M.
 
I'll tell you why,

It's like the car market: Toyota Corollas and Honda Civics are good cars for really good prices and they will always have a big market world wide. So using this analogy, do not every think TN panels will ever go away, but 24 should be the absolute limit, not 25.5, 27, and 27.5!

TN panels are cheap, but past 24" they are simply a problem. Even the BenQ G2400W with it's newer TN and better viewing angles is at the limit of usable size. It's easy to find a good viewing angle with it, because it has a lot less color shift than others, and with my eyes between top and centre of the monitor screen, colour shift is minimal.

BUT, I slouch and rise in my chair a hell of a lot more than I shift left to right, and the colour shift on the BenQ is far more sensitive and severe (vertically) than even my Westinghouse L2410NM which is one of the worst VA panels I've seen for horiz. colour shifting.

Alternatively, my BenQ FP241VW has an A-MVA panel that doesn't shift easily at all horizontally.

So VA is very comfy for a 24" panel, whereas TN is at the limit.

IPS panels are the best (IMHO) for their combination of attributes, both for display quality and acuity, as well as superior viewing angles. And realistically, S and H-IPS are reported to be on average $30.00 more than TNs. I'd be willing to pay that, and I'd tell every friend I have to pay that for their eyes.

But I have to disagree with you Snowdog, I wouldn't recommend a TN panel more than 22" to anyone generally, with the BenQ G2400W the exception. But I agree that I would never recommend a TN for colour sensitive work either.

I base this on the fact that I have five screens in the house: one TN, two VAs and two S-IPS panels. G2400w, FP241VW, L2410NM, Dell 2005FPW, LG 37LB5D TV (S-IPS).


So yes, we should buy them, but not at larger sizes.

10e
 
I have a Samsung 245BW right now and I bought it because I got a good deal on it and I play a lot of FPS games and input lag was an issue for me with MVA/PVA panels. I'm waiting for a DoubleSight 26-inch IPS to come this Thursday and if I keep it then I will sell the Samsung. Before the Samsung I had two LG 19-inch TN panels. Frankly, the TN panel on the Samsung has better colors than the LG but the LG seemed to have better viewing angles, maybe because it was a smaller monitor. I don't like how on TN panels just moving a couple degrees vertically makes a big difference in how you see the brightness of colors. I don't do photo-editing and web design professionally but I do it as a side job and after a while the TN panel's caveats become a burden on design.
 
Back
Top