RIAA: Cyberlockers Should Filter Proactively

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What do you think the odds are that BitTorrent sites and cyberlockers will start proactively filtering pirated material on their own?

“One of the principal problems with the use of take down notices for BitTorrent indexing sites is that the same infringing material can easily be, and usually is, very quickly reposted to the site,” RIAA writes. “As a result, copyright owners are forced into an endless ‘cat and mouse’ game, which requires considerable resources to be devoted to chasing infringing content, only for that same infringing content to continually reappear. For that reason, BitTorrent site operators should take proactive measures to stop indexing torrents.”
 
So it can be like youtube, and delete a video of my two cats playing with their new tree because I had the TV on in the background and it picked up part of a movie soundtrack.
 
Yeah they should totally spend a lot of time and money putting that system in place. Users will have to spend an extra 10 seconds selecting the encrypted password option in 7zip.
 
Lemme guess, at their own expense, right? Get real.

It's worse than that.

If they don't filter proactively and follow the "safe harbor" practices of the DCMA, the RIAA (and any other copyright holder) has to show that the cyberlockers willfully encouraged (there is a real legal term for this, but IANAL) copyright infringement in order to shut them down.

If they do filter proactively (giving up any claim to "common carrier" status), the RIAA can simply hammer them for every copyright infringing transmission that occurs (and think of some of the bittorrent judgments).

"Common carrier" laws need to be taken out and enforced. We wouldn't need any network neutrality laws if the internet didn't have any magical special cases to the common carrier principles.

And yes. It would be better if the RIAA simply proactively jumped in a fire.
 
Everyone on the planet works for the RIAA after all, right?
 
"YOU SHOULD FILTER COPYRIGHTED CONTENT ON YOUR SITES!"
"You do realize we get literally almost tens of thousands of torrents added daily right? How would we screen them all?"
"PUT UP A SYSTEM THAT PREVENTS PEOPLE FROM UPLOADING COPYRIGHTED CONTENT!"
"How would we do this? Users would simply rename files and lock the contents with passwords, they could put up say, Wreck it Ralph on the site, stick it in a passworded 7zip file with a password and call the torrent Smash it Sam. The system wouldn't catch it"
"OK THEN, HIRE WORKERS TO POLICE THE SITE!!!"
"That requires money, money we don't have. Our site funds itself and works for itself, why should we spend money to help you? Are you going to give us money to help police these sites?"
"FUCK NO, FUCK SPENDING MONEY, EXCUSE ME I HAVE TO GO THREATEN ANOTHER HUNDRED THOUSAND PEOPLE WITH BULLSHIT BLACKMAIL LETTERS SAYING I'M GOING TO TAKE THEM ALL TO COURT FOR STEALING CONTENT, BUT I REALLY JUST WANT THEM TO GIVE ME MONEY FOR FREE AND FUCK BE DAMNED THE LEGAL SYSTEM!"
 
For that reason, BitTorrent site operators should take proactive measures to stop indexing torrents."

If that is the direct quote, he basically just said that indexing sites should stop indexing (aka, shutdown). Lol.
 
I find it hard to defend a site whose primary revenue comes from hosting or assisting the transfer of copyrighted material in an illegal manner, but it's equally impossible to condone the behavior and tactics of the RIAA. I'm not going to support something just because it pisses of the RIAA, that only helps them self-delude about their lawful position even further. I'll stick to the trials and the legislation, where the real battles are, and try to ignore these smokescreens and cage-rattlings that have marked the frontier of controversial and dying policy for centuries.
 
What I don't quite get is the fact that 99% of the copyrighted material that ends up as torrents were originally obtained through Usenet, yet we never hear about the MPAA or RIAA trying to do something about it. Is it too difficult given the nature of news server propagation, or does Usenet exist in some legal "gray area" that makes it difficult to police?

Just wonderin'.
 
From what I see is that RIAA/MPAA is more interested in going for those that download the files and make them settle than going for those that create and release the content (which is a huge lawsuit and really no settlement). They are going for the easy kills that keep on paying than the big ones that pay once (well, they usually CAN'T pay).
 
They should simply request that all the necessary funds be provided from moneys the **AA's have extorted from old ladies and little girls.
 
FIlter out RIAA affliated artists. Then this stops being an issue. I mean people buying RIAA affliated artists...
 
What I don't quite get is the fact that 99% of the copyrighted material that ends up as torrents were originally obtained through Usenet, yet we never hear about the MPAA or RIAA trying to do something about it. Is it too difficult given the nature of news server propagation, or does Usenet exist in some legal "gray area" that makes it difficult to police?

Just wonderin'.

They've been hitting Usenet hard with dmca notices. Some files, if being aggressively protected, get deleted within less than hour.

There was an article that said they have an automated system to generate a DMCA notice to the Usenet providers when certain sites (nzbmatrix, etc) receive a file.
 
What I don't quite get is the fact that 99% of the copyrighted material that ends up as torrents were originally obtained through Usenet, yet we never hear about the MPAA or RIAA trying to do something about it. Is it too difficult given the nature of news server propagation, or does Usenet exist in some legal "gray area" that makes it difficult to police?

Just wonderin'.

I don't know where you got that misinformation from or if you spontaneously pulled it out of your ass, but torrent site shares and Usenet posts come from the same place, topsites.
 
What I don't quite get is the fact that 99% of the copyrighted material that ends up as torrents were originally obtained through Usenet, yet we never hear about the MPAA or RIAA trying to do something about it. Is it too difficult given the nature of news server propagation, or does Usenet exist in some legal "gray area" that makes it difficult to police?

Just wonderin'.

I read an interesting article recently that the MPAA is starting to. One top tier provider has given into their bots, which automatically upload a nzb of any partial matches to titles, claim it as copywrite. The files are automatically taken down within minutes, without any verification. Quite an abuse of dmca if you ask me.
 
Back
Top