Path Uploads Your iPhone Address Book To Its Servers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What do you mean this app uploads my entire address book to its servers without my permission? Is that a feature or am I just holding it wrong?

I’m not insinuating that Path is doing something nefarious with my address book but I feel quite violated that my address book is being held remotely on a third-party service. I love Path as an iOS app and I think there are some brilliant people working on it, but this seems a little creepy. I wonder how many other iOS apps actually do the same.
 
There's some great discussion under the article... even "common industry practice" is mentioned. This can be massive, hope it's not swept under the carpet.
 
Hmm, giving away your personal info is the price of using these apps.

Well, I suppose at least the Android Market tells you the app you are about to download is taking your phone serial number, and using fine GPS to find you. On non-rooted phones anyways.

/shrug
 
Dammit, that post doesn't belong here.

Anyway, wasn't iPhone users saying something about how they don't have these problems because iOS has a closed market? What happened with that guys?
 
Don't see anything wrong with this, you buy an iPhone or an Android, you do so with the knowledge that an image of your entire phone is sitting on their servers (Apple are more than willing to hand over your phone image to authorities when asked).
 
Don't see anything wrong with this, you buy an iPhone or an Android, you do so with the knowledge that an image of your entire phone is sitting on their servers (Apple are more than willing to hand over your phone image to authorities when asked).
Any wonder why they want the landlines shut down. If I call someones cell using a 2way radio, using repeaters,would that dive me privacy OR ?.
 
Don't see anything wrong with this, you buy an iPhone or an Android, you do so with the knowledge that an image of your entire phone is sitting on their servers (Apple are more than willing to hand over your phone image to authorities when asked).

Actually, you can turn off the auto-backup on android devices :rolleyes:. Also, apps inform you upon install what permissions they will use.
 
If I call someones cell using a 2way radio, using repeaters,would that give me privacy OR ?

Would depend if the radio had a scrambler on it and both people where on the same scrambled channel. It would be hard to listen in real-time without having similar hardware set to similar settings. The conversation /w scrambling could be easily be recorded though and later decoded by any computer given enough time. So, no. Momentary privacy only. Eventually the government would know both what you said and who you said it to if they cared enough//wanted to.
 
Yes because no app maker would ever lie about that.

Well since you can't hide what permissions you use in Android they can't really lie about it. The permissions in Android are pretty explicit. :)

Dammit, that post doesn't belong here.

Anyway, wasn't iPhone users saying something about how they don't have these problems because iOS has a closed market? What happened with that guys?

The iCult will find some way to spin this to make it look like it's a good thing. Just you wait! ;)

There's always pluses and minuses to open systems vs closed systems. This is definitely one of the minuses of a closed system. You don't know what is happening behind the scenes and if anybody thinks Apple gives a shit they need their head examined.

That's one big plus for the openness of Android. You get to decide whether you want to take it up the tailpipe or not. With some custom ROM's (CyanogenMod) you can even revoke certain permissions from apps. Sometimes that causes Force Closes. For example the Facebook app Force Closes if you revoke the Location permission. Nowadays, if I want an app that badly but don't like the permissions, I revoke the permissions I don't care for and if it causes a Force Close the app gets uninstalled forever. It also helps that all apps I install can't access my data connection unless I allow them in the firewall I have installed. So that way I'm guaranteed protection for my data unless I explicitly allow it.
 
I am impressed by the fact there is a response by the head guy in the article's comment section. I am less impressed by his actual answer.

LBE for Android FTW. Look it up in the market. It's pretty awesome.
 
While they should communicate it better, just about any social app does this to match your contacts on their service. Facebook does it as well, just about anytime you load their app.
 
Glad I don't have an iPhone!

On Android, how do we override individual apps "permissions" - is there an easy app for that?

What I mean is: when you install an app and it says you have to give it permission to "x", "y" and "z" I want to go ahead and install it then say: but no, I'm blocking this app's acces to "y"...
 
Glad I don't have an iPhone!

On Android, how do we override individual apps "permissions" - is there an easy app for that?

What I mean is: when you install an app and it says you have to give it permission to "x", "y" and "z" I want to go ahead and install it then say: but no, I'm blocking this app's acces to "y"...

LBE Privacy Guard (though lately it's come under fire as a suspicious chinese app)
Permissions Denied
Privacy Blocker
PDroid (app+rom patch)

Not a permissions blocker but still useful:
DroidWall
 
Glad I don't have an iPhone!

On Android, how do we override individual apps "permissions" - is there an easy app for that?

What I mean is: when you install an app and it says you have to give it permission to "x", "y" and "z" I want to go ahead and install it then say: but no, I'm blocking this app's acces to "y"...

If you do that you may find that the app crashes, at least if it needs that access in order to function as designed.
 
I use path and don't mind that access. There is far more info I am posting on there that matters more to me than my address book. Has everyone here taken themselves out of the phone book too?

There is far more private info out in the wild that matters a lot more than this.
 
I use path and don't mind that access. There is far more info I am posting on there that matters more to me than my address book. Has everyone here taken themselves out of the phone book too?

There is far more private info out in the wild that matters a lot more than this.

Then he should have disclosed that he was going to do it, and you would remain as a customer because you don't mind.
 
Back
Top