P5Q Pro network adapter no longer detected

GJSNeptune

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Mar 31, 2004
Messages
12,372
I posted this in Networking & Security, but none of the 30ish people who've read it have responded, and I'm beginning to think it's more of a hardware issue. Before I thought it was a drivers conflict or something (hopefully, maybe it still is), but after Googling, it seems it's actually pretty common for the P5Q boards.

I have no idea what happened. I had just set up my new Asus VW266H monitor. I turned on my computer and loaded Firefox. I Googled for Dead Pixel Buddy, and suddenly I was getting error messages about not being able to load webpages. I went into Control Panel to repair the LAN, and still nothing. I rebooted a couple times. Now my LAN doesn't even show up under Network Connections. I've repaired and uninstalled/reinstalled the Atheros LAN drivers several times. I even tried the latest version. My Gigabit LAN is enabled in BIOS. Under Device Manager, only my 1394 network shows up under Network Adapters.

I did have uTorrent running at the time because it's set to start with Windows, but I've never had problems, and I only use it to download (legally) taped concerts in FLAC format. I highly doubt I downloaded something malevolent.

I'm using Windows XP 32-bit. I've had this rig going for about two and a half months now without issue. Now my network adapter is broken? I've Googled but haven't come up with anything beyond what I've tried.

The ethernet port has a mostly-solid yellow light. It'll flicker occasionally. I don't know enough to know about RJ45 ports, but I'm guessing the LED is independent of whether or not the adapter itself is working.

I've tried just about everything. I guess my onboard NIC died. I came across a Microsoft support page, and tried some things. After nothing worked, it told me I could use the CMD console to show hidden devices in the Device Manager. The Atheros network adapter was indeed faded out, and the Microsoft page told me to uninstall it. So I did. I rebooted, but Windows didn't detect it to add it again, so I can't even mess with LAN drivers because they don't detect the device.

Anyone have experience with Asus RMA, or should I buy a NIC?
 
Any thoughts about getting one of these? It's $30 with shipping as opposed to $36 shipped for the retail boxed version.
 
Try using a Linux LiveCD like Knoppix, Ubuntu, or Sabayon Linux to test the ethernet port. If none of those liveCDs can detect a working NIC, there's a good chance that the NIC is faulty. However do note that Linux doesn't support a few NICs out there. Dunno if the Asus P5Q Pro's NIC is one of them

NIC wise, I think that Intel GT NIC is decent.
 
I agree, if another OS cannot detect it, its probably faulty (RMA time).
 
I'll try a LiveCD. If I have to RMA, I might as well get a NIC instead due to shipping costs and, more importantly, having a working computer. I can still game. :cool:

What exactly can I do if a Linux LiveCD detects it? I've tried many troubleshooting procedures inside Windows and nothing works.
 
I had a similar issue on my older Asus P5GD2 board. Wien I overclocked the NIC would cough out on me. I noticed you're OC'in your E8400. Try running it back to stock speeds and see if this fixes it b/c my NIC would come back to life after stock speeds and a reboot from BIOS.
 
Hmm. I'll try it, but I don't think it'll work. I updated my BIOS after the NIC disappeared. I don't think I booted Windows without re-OCing though.

If that doesn't work, and since Linux is so weird with the Atheros adapter, I may just pop in my Windows 7 HDD and see what happens.
 
You have the P5Q Pro? I have the P5Q, same board with the difference of the PRO having Crossfire support. Not sure if we use the same BIOS or not but I flashed to 1611 dated 12/12/08. What BIOS version you running?
 
If its detected in linux, I suspect its a software issue. You could try a repair windows installation.

Its not worth to RMA because of non-working network adapter. NIC is just $7

Eh, depends on the owner I guess. Personally, I paid for a fully working motherboard, and I'll RMA to get one if its still under warranty. I have other systems to use in the meantime, so there would be no downtime for me, unlike the OP.
 
The NIC you have linked is PCI but if you want something to put in a PCI-E x 1 slot, I purchased these because they were recommened by a few forum members.

Two weeks ago they were 33.99.

There's no way I would RMA for a faulty NIC.

I figure I'll just keep using this Intel NIC over and over.
 
Eh, my thinking is if the NIC died, what else is wrong with board? How can you be sure nothing else is wrong with it? IMO, its safer to RMA while you can than proceed with a faulty board, but thats just me.

I presume it'd have faster speeds on PCI-E then?

For most things, not really. Though PCI is a shared bus, so if when transferring at gigabit speeds, PCI-E would be faster if anything else is on the PCI bus.
 
I'm not sure nothing else is wrong, but so far I haven't noticed anything.

I'd probably go PCI because my x1 ports are close to my video card, although the bottom-most x1 port looks to have room. Plus the PCI version is much cheaper.
 
Well I just did two things before I turned on my computer. I shut off the power supply for about thirty seconds. Then I turned on the computer and loaded default settings in the BIOS. Sure enough, once I got into Windows, my network adapter was detected and here I am.

Which has me very interested in what exactly caused the glitch. Since Windows could no longer detect my network adapter as long as my CPU was overclocked, I'm lead to believe that my overclock (though seemingly harmless for over two months) was causing the problem.

I guess I'll have to OC again, run some stress-test and stability apps, and also see if my network adapter disappears a second time. I really hope it's not my OC. I like 3.6. :D

Is there an app that's geared towards stressing the network that would indicate if my OC is causing issues?
 
I have fried a couple of network controllers on P35/P45 boards. They were MSI though, both were replaced. I started having network issues and then lost the entire adapter. Nothing helped, manufacturer replaced both. I did use them with separate NIC, but as I was concerned that something else might have broken too, so I returned them.

The P35 was broken because it couldn't recognize e4300 correctly and pci/fsb was locked even though it shouldn't have. Unintentional pci-bus overclocking fried the nic (I think this can fry it very easily with any board). So make sure oc does not affect pci bus speed.
 
Try using a Linux LiveCD like Knoppix, Ubuntu, or Sabayon Linux to test the ethernet port. If none of those liveCDs can detect a working NIC, there's a good chance that the NIC is faulty. However do note that Linux doesn't support a few NICs out there. Dunno if the Asus P5Q Pro's NIC is one of them

NIC wise, I think that Intel GT NIC is decent.

the Ubunto and Knoppix versions that I had didn't detect the nic in my P5Q Pro.
I thought my nic was bad from the get go since it didn't light up the connection light on my D-Link switch when the computer was turned on.
 
Back
Top