P55 overclockers...check your sockets

well i hope they find out about this and fix it sooner rather than later.
 
I'm not really sure if there's even a problem here.
This whole issue has me scared for my new 860.
Confirmed that the little intentions are from the factory.

That is all.
 
Raji earlier today on XS said:
The pin holes are from the Foxconn socket. The scuff marks likely when the CPU is first instered into the socket or direct from Intel.

Raji replying to a comment on his article tonight said:
yeah the pricks are from factory CPU's. The Foxconn head contact should leave a small scuff mark on every pad, but it does no seem this always happens due to incorrect loading.


So at first it was that not all pads had pin marks, now it's that all pads don't have scuff marks apparently. Can anyone with a lotes socket post a pic of your CPU? Curious to see how much more pressure there is on the scuff marks.
 
I'm not really sure if there's even a problem here.
This whole issue has me scared for my new 860.
Confirmed that the little intentions are from the factory.

That is all.

If you are worried about the Foxconn socket, go to FRY's
or Microcenter and get an eVGA or other 860 motherboard
where you believe it will be a different socket manufacturer.
Put on credit card, and insist on inspection before leaving the
store. Tell them you are not paying for a board with a Foxonn
socket, tell them it is a known issue.

Or take it home, inspect and return if it is a Foxconn.

As a consumer, you are entitled to reject an item of reported
poor quality.
 
So people that already have boards with Foxconn sockets... what are you going to do?

Will you keep running what you have, or order a new board?

It would cost me $90.50 to return the Asus P7P55D Pro for an Evga P55. $25.50 (15% restocking fee) + $25 (combo discount taken back) + $10 (ship board back) + $30 (cost difference between P7P55D Pro and P55) = $90.5
 
I'm going to keep on using my fast assed computer. I'll keep an eye on the forums for sure but until I see people having problems with processors that aren't pushed completely out of spec, I'm not going to worry about it. There's not much I can do about it anyway since I can't afford any of the boards with LOTES sockets and I'm not gonna sell off my shit and buy a Phenom II or a Core 2 Quad.
 
will be interesting to check what intel themselves use, they have used many foxconn parts before, even some of their boards are made by foxconn.

They are quite anal about making their intel branded boards last for years without any trouble. (although you cant overclock most of them the power pins are there for a reason)

many, if not most intel branded boards are manufactured by foxconn. others are manufactured by asus. you can be pretty sure they will have foxconn sockets.
 
So people that already have boards with Foxconn sockets... what are you going to do?

I'm convinced there's a problem, but I'm not convinced it's systemic.

Raju's evidence may have been wrong (the pin hole indentations), but his conclusion may still be right (some Foxconn sockets might provide insufficient contact).

The burn-out pictures are hard to ignore, but less than a dozen cases have been reported. Considering the ubiquity of the Foxconn parts, the number of failures is not very concerning.

These boards have been out for over a month; if the issue was widespread, the forums would have been overrun a long time ago.

Since my board is running fine, I have no intention of returning it. I'll continue running at 4.1Ghz. If my socket combusts, I'll report it here immediately. :cool:
 
Raji said:
Word is that Foxconn have changed the socket top plate in a revision to correct the problem. Not sure that it is trouble free now as someone in mainland China had a problem on the revised socket too. What I do know is that DFI, EVGA and MSI have moved production over to other socket vendors.

Raji said:
thats the part Lathode that is all under wraps. I've had two vendors come forwards and show me what Foxconn sent them. Foxconn claim the issue was identified in May and that Intel were due to revise their design to rectify. Apprently these were supposed to be sample sockets with the issue and all issues were supposed to be in house in some vendor labs. Since then there have been issues reported on what is supposed to be the revised Foxconn socket (or samples that have gone into the wild on retail boards), so I'm not sure what to believe at this point. What some of the vendors have seens themselves is not centric to an earlier model or revision of socket.

It would be nice to see more info on this from the manufacture or Intel, but if I'm going to go from this, well then I guess I will just have to wait and see. I don't see it as being enough of a problem to replace my board. Especially since there's not a better MATX than the GENE.
 
The top plate on the LOTES is slightly different looking, mainly the tabs that put pressure on the CPU have different indents. So if Foxconn is changing the top plate like Raju's source says then I wonder if people can request a new top plate and replace their own.

LOTES
lotes.jpg


Foxconn
foxconn.jpg
 
I'm convinced there's a problem, but I'm not convinced it's systemic.

Raju's evidence may have been wrong (the pin hole indentations), but his conclusion may still be right (some Foxconn sockets might provide insufficient contact).

The burn-out pictures are hard to ignore, but less than a dozen cases have been reported. Considering the ubiquity of the Foxconn parts, the number of failures is not very concerning.

These boards have been out for over a month; if the issue was widespread, the forums would have been overrun a long time ago.

Since my board is running fine, I have no intention of returning it. I'll continue running at 4.1Ghz. If my socket combusts, I'll report it here immediately. :cool:

+1 ..I've gone as high as 4.3ghz on mine for benching purposes and run 24/7 at 4ghz. No issues at all.. I've pulled my 860 out twice and I'm not having any issues, what-so-ever..

Gigabyte p55 ud4p
Intel Core i7 860
Prolimatech Megahalems Cooler

43ghz.jpg


p95.jpg
 
So people that already have boards with Foxconn sockets... what are you going to do?

Will you keep running what you have, or order a new board?

It would cost me $90.50 to return the Asus P7P55D Pro for an Evga P55. $25.50 (15% restocking fee) + $25 (combo discount taken back) + $10 (ship board back) + $30 (cost difference between P7P55D Pro and P55) = $90.5


Nothing. I am going to keep my existing DP55KG board, however when I purchased a new board yesterday, I bought an EVGA FTW board with a LOTES socket.

Actually that isn't true, I need to swap my DP55KG board for a mini-ATX one. Since there aren't any LOTES socketed boards that fit my needs for that, I am going to still buy a FoxConn socketed board.
 
I have a custom built i5 750 desktop with the Gigabyte GA-P55-UD3R motherboard that will be arriving to my home this week and I'm not planning to overclock the cpu. Let me get this straight, I won't have any burnt sockets because I not going to overclock the CPU.
 
I have a custom built i5 750 desktop with the Gigabyte GA-P55-UD3R motherboard that will be arriving to my home this week and I'm not planning to overclock the cpu. Let me get this straight, I won't have any burnt sockets because I not going to overclock the CPU.

If your not OCing you have nothing to worry about. If something failed you would be totally under warranty and I believe that board has a 3 year warranty on it and if its going to fail most likely its way before that and most likely it will have nothing to do with this particular issue.

Enjoy the comp and don't worry!
 
I suspect that the Foxconn sockets are still within Intel specs, just with much less headroom than the LOTES ones. Like previous posters have pointed out, LGA1156 only has about 175 power pins vs 250 for LGA1336, even though both platforms will draw similar amounts of wattage at high (4+ GHz) overclocks.
 
Well, EVGA just got themselves a sale since they aren't using all Foxconn sockets their higher end models, but rather a mix of Foxconn and LOTES. Their P55 motherboards were so off my radar until this mess came up; I was either going to get an Intel or MSI motherboard from Amazon. Yesterday I picked up an EVGA P55 FTW board at Fry's, just in case I got a Foxconn and needed to return it. Opened up the box, LOTES stamped on the CPU retaining clip, jackpot!

Either way, whoever made that call at EVGA did a good thing, I'm sure they're cashing in a little bit from this.
 
Hi

I just got new mobo Asrock P55 Pro today, It's foxconn :(, I haven't start new i5 build just yet.

Asrock just release new bios 1.80 with Add CPU Vcore over current protection. Thanks god:D

2pz0j0p.jpg


New i5 build on the table (unopened).

ziszuf.jpg


I can't find where to buy the LOTES brand ILM and Back Plate for Socket 1156 pix below

5d8q41.jpg


LOTES home page at http://cn.lotes.cc/product_info.php?id=3289#

I like to get one LOTES kits installation and remove Foxconn with 3 screws out then pop in new one with LOTES, sound pretty easy swap it.

Thanks,
phatbx133
 
Last edited:
I like to get one LOTES kits installation and remove Foxconn with 3 screws out then pop in new one with LOTES, sound pretty easy swap it.

I have not read the whole thread but if it were me I would not believe the retention mechanism is the problem more like the pins themselves.
 
I do not think that kit is available publicly, just to the manufacturers. I am sure that if the problem became more rampant, then Asus and others would issue a recall (you would hope) and allow end users to be able to get those kits in the mail or send their board in to have it fixed. Time will tell.
 
I honestly don't think you'll see any kind of recall unless it can be shown that it's harming non-OCed chips, because I'd think they could all fall back on the "hey, we warned you in the manual that you OC at your own risk".
 
I honestly don't think you'll see any kind of recall unless it can be shown that it's harming non-OCed chips, because I'd think they could all fall back on the "hey, we warned you in the manual that you OC at your own risk".

That is true. They do that to cover their ass. It makes them not liable for something the end user did.
 
Keeping my i5-750 at 4ghz. Can't be bothered to remove the mobo and heatsink to check it. Not really worried anyway. Will be interesting to see if there's an official announcement from Intel or mobo manufacturers though.
 
I have not read the whole thread but if it were me I would not believe the retention mechanism is the problem more like the pins themselves.

That's the big thing, the pins with the LOTES and Tyco sockets have larger heads than the Foxconn sockets do.
 
Are we sure it is just the socket?
- it makes me really glad i just got i7 920/s1336 or i would return the p55/i5 i was considering

Tom's hardware is reporting multiple defective motherboards from 3 different manufacturers and they are not LN2 or water cooled;

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html
(quoted in part)
Encouraged by a far-lower TDP rating on the new generation of Core i7 processors (95W, down from 130W), these companies probably designed LGA 1156-based models with a similar percentage of “overcapacity” as they’d used on LGA 1366 boards. But the fault doesn’t sit solely with each motherboard’s initial design team, as testing should have revealed the problem before the boards reached mass production or distribution.

Maybe a better question would be “what’s missing”? It seems that many of our previous-generation motherboards would shut off when overloaded, before anything was damaged. That’s called over-current protection, and it’s a feature apparently now reserved for high-end boards.

But did we push too hard? Remember that these settings were achieved using air cooling while keeping the CPU below its thermal-throttle threshold. Air-cooled overclocks certainly aren’t considered “extreme.” And for those wondering, the side of the VRM that burned in every case was the same side upon which the CPU fan was blowing strongly. This once again demonstrates that a voltage regulator should never be designed so that it can output more than its peak capacity.

Because three of the failures occurred at or below 1.40V, we have no knowledge of what to recommend as a “maximum safe” voltage for overclocking these three motherboard models. In the future, we’ll allow motherboard manufacturers to specify any lower “maximum” settings that may be required to preserve their products and will then duly arm readers with that information.

Update: ASRock confirmed that its P55 Pro was designed to handle a smaller power load, based on Intel's lower TDP for LGA 1156 processors, and has sent a BIOS its representatives claim will enable built-in over-current protection. To make sure that all three companies have an equal opportunity to address this issue, we have given them all two weeks to come up with a solution and will publish an article that addresses the new overclocking limitations.
 
apoppin - Did Tom's check for socket burn as well? Either way if it's related - it sucks. If it's not related, that's a second separate issue to worry about, and as low as 1.36Vcore. This is laughably bad - I'm almost expecting more and more bad news to come out.
 
apoppin - Did Tom's check for socket burn as well? Either way if it's related - it sucks. If it's not related, that's a second separate issue to worry about, and as low as 1.36Vcore. This is laughably bad - I'm almost expecting more and more bad news to come out.
i am not sure

Most of the forums and tech sites i have visited have not related the issues to each other. Tom's issues appears to be different - and more what regular end users can expect. IF ASRock limits the voltage with an "overcurrent protection", all of the overclocking will go to hell.

It does look serious. And perhaps a design flaw by Intel
:eek:
 
I am NOT surpised at all that this issue is only on the Foxconn sockets....

I refuse to buy any boards sold by Foxconn and cringe when I see people with OEM boxes since most OEM motherboards are made by Foxconn.

I did onsite repair for Dell and some for IBM over a 2 year period. The crappy quality of the Foxconn boards made me never ever want to buy an OEM box for any reason whatsoever.
 
I am NOT surpised at all that this issue is only on the Foxconn sockets....

I refuse to buy any boards sold by Foxconn and cringe when I see people with OEM boxes since most OEM motherboards are made by Foxconn.

I did onsite repair for Dell and some for IBM over a 2 year period. The crappy quality of the Foxconn boards made me never ever want to buy an OEM box for any reason whatsoever.
we don't know this for sure, do we? - Tom's HW appears to be reporting different issues with 3 different mobo manufacturers on AIR overclocking
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html

Doesn't Foxconn make most of the Intel sockets - including for Intel's own mobos?
:confused:
 
Yeah - brom42 was using a reference Intel P55 board if I recall correctly...looks like it's been changed to an eVGA board now though.
 
Are we sure it is just the socket?
- it makes me really glad i just got i7 920/s1336 or i would return the p55/i5 i was considering

Tom's hardware is reporting multiple defective motherboards from 3 different manufacturers and they are not LN2 or water cooled;

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html
(quoted in part)

That's something different. Those were cheap boards that couldn't handle the power. Tom even states ASRock told them the board was designed for lower power and so they made changes to the BIOS. Higher end boards do not have this issue.
 
They found that problem on Asrock's X58 Supercomputer, it's not related to the Foxconn P55 sockets.
huh? did you read the article?
:confused:

Tom's article is all about *multiple* P55 motherboards burning up with the CPU mildly overclocked on AIR cooling
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html

From these manufacturers:

ASRock
MSI
ECS

IF they all have Foxconn sockets, THEN it is the socket (probably)
- if not, it is possibly Intel's design issue - don't say it is because they are "budget" mobos, either. All *3* different manufacturers plus the ones Anandtech detailed.
:eek:
 
That's something different. Those were cheap boards that couldn't handle the power. Tom even states ASRock told them the board was designed for lower power and so they made changes to the BIOS. Higher end boards do not have this issue.

If it is truly "something different" from the socket then it is a design issue
- Intel's, not 3 different mobo manufacturers

Evidently, we have different issues plaguing p55 mobos
- ALL of these "value" mobos are designed for O/C'ing - and only now is ASRock limiting voltage (which will surely kill overclocking)


At this point, would you recommend that someone that overclocks buy any P55/i5 mobo - Now?
:confused:

And if one must buy a High-End mobo for i5, what advantage is there to buying it at all?
-- i7 for me
(i got i7 920 last week)
 
we don't know this for sure, do we? - Tom's HW appears to be reporting different issues with 3 different mobo manufacturers on AIR overclocking
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html

Doesn't Foxconn make most of the Intel sockets - including for Intel's own mobos?
:confused:

Yep.. and the P55 boards that are reportedly having these issues have the Foxconn sockets, while the ones with a different brand socket don't seem to behaving this issue.

Great electrical connections are what you want.. mediocre ones are going to cause problems like this.

With the way sockets are made nowdays (no pins on the CPU) it is even more important for the manufacturers to make sure that they are making a very good product as all that makes sure that it makes contact is pressure.

The old pin type sockets clamped onto the CPU pins and I very much doubt that any socket built like that would ever experience anything remotely similiar to this.
 
huh? did you read the article?
:confused:

Tom's article is all about *multiple* P55 motherboards burning up with the CPU mildly overclocked on AIR cooling
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html

From these manufacturers:

ASRock
MSI
ECS

IF they all have Foxconn sockets, THEN it is the socket (probably)
- if not, it is possibly Intel's design issue - don't say it is because they are "budget" mobos, either. All *3* different manufacturers plus the ones Anandtech detailed.
:eek:

The article is about the power regulation on P55 motherboards burning up, a problem which has been seen before on an X58 motherboard. So yes it is a problem on multiple low-end P55 motherboards, but is not confined to P55 or even low end boards. It is also a separate issue from Foxconn 1156 sockets, and is vendor or BIOS specific, not socket-specific.
 
The article is about the power regulation on P55 motherboards burning up, a problem which has been seen before on an X58 motherboard. So yes it is a problem on multiple low-end P55 motherboards, but is not confined to P55 or even low end boards. It is also a separate issue from Foxconn 1156 sockets, and is vendor or BIOS specific, not socket-specific.

Let me put it another way . . . Not having good contact between the pins and pads will certainly stress the CPU and the motherboard. The parts of the chip where excess power is being drawn may suffer electromigration issues that may cause failure of that part of the chip's power plane at some point as it tries to compensate for the poor contacts. With that failure, the motherboard is also possibly going to have current flowing in the wrong places.

i am not saying for sure that they are related - but i cannot see how poor socket contact can be simply dismissed as an additional factor besides poor over-current protection and cheap motherboards as part of THG's cause for failure. THG did not consider the sockets at all. Perhaps all 3 of these mobos use sockets from Foxconn(?). i don't believe we know for certain yet.

At any rate, now is not a good time to be buying a P55 mobo until this is sorted out, imo
 
Last edited:
So... should i save the >$150 and go i5 or spend an extra >$150 and go i7 this holiday season?
 
So... should i save the >$150 and go i5 or spend an extra >$150 and go i7 this holiday season?
Once they get this sorted out, you will be OK

The only criteria for me was running multi-GPU. i run 4870-X3 TriFire now and i need to be able to run two Fermi GTX F-100s in SLi without having to worry about 8x + 8x PCIe.

if i never planned on running CrossFire or SLi it would be a more difficult decision. i got i7 920 and will go for max OC.

Good luck with your decision!
 
Are we sure it is just the socket?
- it makes me really glad i just got i7 920/s1336 or i would return the p55/i5 i was considering

Tom's hardware is reporting multiple defective motherboards from 3 different manufacturers and they are not LN2 or water cooled;

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/budget-p55-motherboard,2436-15.html
(quoted in part)

those are all shit mainstream boards that aren't really meant for overclocking. it's not that surprising that they failed.
 
I was so close to pulling the trigger on the i5/p55 but decided to wait a day :eek:
Don't mind spending a little more for peace of mind.
 
Back
Top