P55 overclockers...check your sockets

My i5 mobo is on the way and I have a virgin proc. I'll do the same picture and post it on Monday.
 
I also have an i5 mobo and virgin proc on the way, and will post before and afters.

Also, what deff said.
 
An XS member was saying how Biostar may have an "updated Foxconn socket" - but that guy never really substantiated it with anything. When did you buy the Maximus? I'm asking since it isn't part of the more advertised "P7P55D lineup" and may actually substantiate that guy's claim about an updated socket.

I'm wondering if those numbers on the socket backplate indicate anything. Of course I could be grasping at straws.

It was ordered on 9/28 from eWiz.
 
I have machines from both AMD and Intel (home and work) and I can tell you that removing the pins was a nice advancement. Have you ever bent a pin or got heat sink compound on one?
 
Good Lord I dodged the bullet :D

For the records eVGA FTW from NewEgg (Purchase Date: 9/30/2009 3:45:12 PM)

lotesftw.png
 
I'd like to know what Kyle and/or [H]ardOCP's thoughts on this issue are. Surely they see many more CPU/motherboard combos than we do. I realize that they might not want to comment without full knowledge, but even a "we are actively looking into it" would be nice.
 
I checked my EVGA P55 FTW and all pins are making perfect contact :) My P7P55D Pro had too many that were questionable.
 
I just wish one of you had a decent camera that could take a picture worth looking at....
 
Sand the pins flat. Easy fix :D

Another issue to think about would be the mounting pressure of the HSF. Over-tightening in this particular case might not be such a bad idea after all.
 
Haha. Use macro mode. :p

And ideally well lit with no flash. But the pics have been good enough to see the dots, so no biggie. Though if others are going to do before and afters, I'd like to see the chips from the same positions in both pics. In the before/after pics earlier, the after was taken with the chip 180 degrees from the before, so you can't compare as easily.

I just got a P55-GD80 today and, sigh, it's a Foxconn. But the info is still a little sketchy for the non-extreme OC, so I'm not going to worry about it. I'll be putting it together next week so I'll try to do some before and after pics too of the i7 860 I'll be using.
 
My line of thinking is that there is no free lunch. Costs were cut, and the differences are definitely felt. Now I feel silly for not spending the extra $40 on a x58 mobo, $40 on cpu, and $30 on 6GB kit. $110 for peace of mind isn't much when you consider I'll be using this for 1.5-2 years. If you work for a living, $110 over 1-2 years is NOTHING.

That is still no excuse. You spend less money, fine, you miss out on performance, but by no means should it mean that you also miss out on reliability. As its been said many times, its a risk for overclockers, but it is also a potential risk over the long run for normal users, I guess we'll find out in a couple years. Either way, shoddy workmanship on something as fundamental as the CPU/motherboard interface shouldn't even begin to be an issue, even with cheaper sockets.

It would be unacceptable for a $50 Athlon, let alone a $300 i7 860.
 
One of the big selling factors on the new intel chips is the OVERCLOCKING ability, and the performance increases created by it. Take that away and they lose that edge. Previously I always used AMD but the newer intel chips are pulling numbers no one can argue with, I sure hope the manufacturers are paying attention to whats going on.

Was really looking forward to the attractive pricing in the p55 line too =/
 
Well, I can definitely say that this really is just a 1156 problem.


Here is a pic of my 1156 I posted earlier

Here is a pic of my 950 that was from in a FoxConn 1366 connector.

Notice a difference? :eek:

Just wanted to confirm people are not looking at the little pin holes on the pads as contact points right? If you are then the 1336 has the same problem. I see at least 10 pads with no pin marks on them and multiple pads with 2 pin marks. I also don't see any other light contact marks. Am I missing something here? They look the same.
 
Below are links to pics of my i5 750 out of the box and then again after being firmly seated in my motherboard for a few minutes. Motherboard is a Gigabyte GA-P55M-UD2 with a Foxconn socket.

Straight out of the box, never seated in motherboard

After being seated and locked in motherboard for a few minutes

I feel like maybe I'm missing something? The before and after pics look more or less identical.

There's too much light reflection on the pads to see the faint contact marks as you can see on my pic. Try taking the pic at an angle.
 
What should I do about the Asus P7P55D I have on the way?

Should I use it or not? I will be near a Microcenter next week. Should I see if they will let me open some Evga boxes and check what socket it has?

:(
 
Just wanted to confirm people are not looking at the little pin holes on the pads as contact points right? If you are then the 1336 has the same problem. I see at least 10 pads with no pin marks on them and multiple pads with 2 pin marks. I also don't see any other light contact marks. Am I missing something here? They look the same.

Holy crap, this turned into a long rant. :D lathode, even though this started out as a response to you, it derailed and is not at all directed at you. :eek:

This is where a lot of the confusion is coming from. All the pins are contacting weather or not they make a dimple in the contact pad. This is why there isn't any stability issues. As I said before if there was no contact none of these computers would boot because the interfaces with the memory and GPUs would be totally hosed.

Think of in terms of electrical cords. Plug a space heater into one of those skinny brown extension cords. What happens? The cord heats up because it is too small of a gauge. Now apply that idea to the CPU pins. When the pin make one of those dimples or holes in the contact pad, there is a much larger surface area that is making contact than if it is lightly connected. As others and myself have said before, this isn't an issue for signaling since their current is at such a small amount.

This brings us to the VCC and other power connections. When people do the massive overclocks and pump the voltage up they end up with a lot more current going across the pins. This is pushing the pins with a light connection to their breaking point. In the case of my 1366 cpu, that is OK since the vast majority of the connections have a more secure connection and can take over. However because of the large amount of pins in the 1156 cpu with a light connection it is causing a cascade event melting down the pins and trashing the socket.

That is why this is a extreme overclocking warning only right now.

So why are we concerned? I'll go back to the extension cord example again. Sure the extension cord gets warm, but it works fine so whats the big deal? Over time the extra heat and current will degrade the cord and given time the cord will eventually fail. Many of us hand down computers or resell them to others on the forum. For example, my brother, his wife, my parents and my aunt are all using computers that I gave them. All hand me downs. Most of those computers are 5-6+ years old. (My aunts is a P3 800 that I paid almost a grand for in college :eek:) What we want to know and be reassured about is weather or not this is within spec and that these sockets will still be running in that long of time period.

Its way, way, way too early to make any choices based on this information. As this news spreads (I've seen it in a ton of places now) Intel, FoxConn, Kyle, will all probably eventually release statements about this. We can't expect this to happen overnight. The only thing people should be doing is backing off of huge overclocks for now, maybe delaying a purchase a couple of weeks, or choosing a board manufacture that doesn't use the FoxConn connector.
 
What should I do about the Asus P7P55D I have on the way?

Should I use it or not? I will be near a Microcenter next week. Should I see if they will let me open some Evga boxes and check what socket it has?

:(

Yeah I'd definitely check out MC. I've never actually asked an associate to open a box, but you wouldn't need to open the anti-static bag. The backplate on a LOTES is very obvious (look at Clunk's DFI review). So yeah, MSI or eVGA are 50/50 in terms of chance, so check those out.
 
The point I was making is that the author of the Anandtech article was stating that the pin marks on the pads were contact points from the Foxconn socket which they aren't. I was also pointing out from the picture I took of my 860 after being installed in a Foxconn socket it shows scuff marks in the middle of the pads. This was being pointed out in the Anandtech article of the 870 installed in a LOTES socket. I understand light contact causing the pins to heat up. That is also from 160+ watts going to the CPU, not something that would happen from stock-high overclocks (atleast I think 3.6-3.8 would be high). Another thing people over at XS were talking about is the fact there are less VCC pads on the 1156 socket than the 1366 socket, yet at extreme overclocks both 1156 & 1336 are pulling the same power so that may be causing the pins to burn out as well, the power not being distributed over enough contacts.
 
Yeah I'd definitely check out MC. I've never actually asked an associate to open a box, but you wouldn't need to open the anti-static bag. The backplate on a LOTES is very obvious (look at Clunk's DFI review). So yeah, MSI or eVGA are 50/50 in terms of chance, so check those out.

Only problem is that EVGA is the only company that shrink-wraps their boxes. I just picked up a EVGA FTW at the MN Microcenter and noticed that.

BTW the EVGA FTW is on sale right now. :cool::cool:

Picked up a second 860 for $229 and an EVGA FTW for $219.
 
Only problem is that EVGA is the only company that shrink-wraps their boxes. I just picked up a EVGA FTW at the MN Microcenter and noticed that.

BTW the EVGA FTW is on sale right now. :cool::cool:

Wonder what Microcenter's return policy is. I could buy an Evga P55, go out to the car open it, and walk back in to return it if need be.

Meh, it looks like 15% restocking fee.
 
Does it need to be an Evga P55 FTW, or will a regular P55 have the LOTES socket?
 
Good going lathode.

I just took my i5 out of its P55m-UD2 (Foxconn socket) and can easily see the contact point scruffs. As in your photo, they're visible in the middle of every pad.

The little pin hole indentations have absolutely nothing to do with the socket type--the processors arrive that way from the factory.

I enjoy Anandtech, but this is sloppy, damaging journalism. They need to retract or modify their article, and they need to do it soon.
 
Good going lathode.

I just took my i5 out of its P55m-UD2 (Foxconn socket) and can easily see the contact point scruffs. As in your photo, they're visible in the middle of every pad.

The little pin hole indentations have absolutely nothing to do with the socket type--the processors arrive that way from the factory.

I enjoy Anandtech, but this is sloppy, damaging journalism. They need to retract or modify their article, and they need to do it soon.

I just reread all of lathode's posts. He may be on to something. It is clear the pin prick indentations are there from the factory.

It does appear that the motherboard socket leaves longer dash looking indentations. Those are evident on every pad.
 
Even so...until I see burnt sockets from the LOTES camp as well, I'm still very wary of this.

*cue LOTES socket users to get their LN2/DI setup going lol.
 
This. For example when you buy an EVGA LE version of a board instead of the FTW to save money, you expect things to be cut; but everything that is left needs to work.

Actually I bought a P55 LE from MC and it has the coveted LOTES socket.
See EVGA P55 forums for this, so far the majority of us got LOTES.
 
I always thought that socket looked a bit cheezy, it looked to me like they skimped on an important bit of metal just to save 2 cents or so, and that tab under screw thing just does not look very repeatable.
 
ya the evga p55 ftw i posted on newegg shows LOTES but on evga site shows FOXCONN

I didn't pull my CPU, but I checked my socket cover and it is a LOTES. Glad I went with eVGA. ;)
Does it need to be an Evga P55 FTW, or will a regular P55 have the LOTES socket?

BTW, mine is NOT a FTW. It is one step below... http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...055&Tpk=EVGA P55 SLI Mainboard 132-LF-E655-KR



Also, to all the guys who are worried.....even if I had bought one with the FC socket...I would STILL just keep it. MOST if not ALL manufacturers have decent warranties on their products and really how many out here are gonna be doing EXTREME OC? I think it is something to take into consideration when purchasing a 1156 mobo, but to NOT buy ANYTHING due to this isolated issue? PFFTTTTT! Mountain outta a molehill.
 
will be interesting to check what intel themselves use, they have used many foxconn parts before, even some of their boards are made by foxconn.

They are quite anal about making their intel branded boards last for years without any trouble. (although you cant overclock most of them the power pins are there for a reason)
 
will be interesting to check what intel themselves use, they have used many foxconn parts before, even some of their boards are made by foxconn.

They are quite anal about making their intel branded boards last for years without any trouble. (although you cant overclock most of them the power pins are there for a reason)

The Intel boards have the Foxconn sockets.
 
Back
Top