Official Llano Benches

I agree with this, however there will always be a market for this type of system. On the idle power consumption side of things, look at the anandtech article on Llano, and look at the power gating portion. Power gating allows the entire CPU, GPU, APU whatever you want to call it, to be completely turned off when idle.

The power levels surprised me, amd is now at or better than parity with current intel sandy bridge models, especially at idle.

As far as the cpu goes, I think I would prefer allocation amd is using in the future for my purposes on more portable notebooks. I liken cpu performance to car speed and torque.

the fusion apu cpu has a top speed of 150 mph - 0-60 in 6s
the intel SB cpu has a top speed of 450 mph - 0-60 in 3.5s


In order to run the normal types of browsing programs smoothly and fluidly you need to go faster than say, 40 mph - they all meet and exceed that bar. Performance in things like excel are handled well by both, though again there will be a bit less latency with the SB chip, there is little to no HARD cap on typical performance that either one of these chips can do in cpu performance.

150 top speed
450 top speed

most people need to go at most like 80 to run things smoothly - we are past the point of diminishing returns for ever increasing intel raw cpu performance on typical types of program usage to the point where an intel chip with a top speed of 1800 mph could very well show little to no perceptible difference in real world use.


The graphics is an area where there is a clear hard cap for anyone who might want to play a game. And so increasing the ceiling of performance there at certain price points would net much better real world quality of usage improvements. Or so the argument should go.

Some people want the car that tops out at 450, I am fine with the car that tops out at 150, but has a nicer stereo system and better connectivity to access the gadgets I want to access. Absolute top speed is not my master, being able to handle a wider variety of tasks reasonably well is.

Jack of all trades, master of none vs an Ace of some and a deuce in others.



Now for people who get real world benefits for having max cpu speed, then intel will always be the better option in the near future, as they don't care as much about other performance amenities at certain price levels, their more myopic performance concerns tilt towards intels design focus and strength.


llano will do ok I hope, if for no other reason to get them to have enough resources to release trinity faster. While I do think stars is adequate, it is still dated, and they do need the faster chips in the mobile space on the x86 side. But the % layout is fine in my view, if they kept their more modern bulldozer cores and allotted the same % to x86 and graphics, that would be perfect.
 
Anand has updated his desktop preview benchmarks with DDR3-1866, and the performance is a lot closer to the 5570 than with DDR3 1333.

http://www.anandtech.com/show/4448/amd-llano-desktop-performance-preview/3

It's still not an easy fix because DDR3 1866 costs twice as much as 1333 modules, and very few laptop OEMs are willing to stock high-performance memory. There is no easy fix for the bandwidth situation, but at least this memory controller is more capable than the one on the Phenom II.
 
I'm waiting for the [H] review with squiggly line graphs comparing various on-chip GPU / memory controller overclocks using DDR3 2133+ and cooling which can only be described as overpowered.

Just because it'd be interesting to see an enthusiast push the platform to its limits and share their experiences... rather than the "meh" attitude that is currently prevailing.
 
IGP than compares to a GT220 in gaming performance != hard
ancient K10 core != hard

lulz, I mean meh

Kyle seems to be hosting a BD event next month though.
 
I'm waiting for the [H] review with squiggly line graphs comparing various on-chip GPU / memory controller overclocks using DDR3 2133+ and cooling which can only be described as overpowered.

Just because it'd be interesting to see an enthusiast push the platform to its limits and share their experiences... rather than the "meh" attitude that is currently prevailing.
IGP than compares to a GT220 in gaming performance != hard
ancient K10 core != hard

lulz, I mean meh

Kyle seems to be hosting a BD event next month though.

Why don't you take a look at the sticky posted at the top of this forum. [H] review is inbound any minute now.
 
It looks like Kyle is reviewing the reference mobile platform, like the other reviews. I don't think there will be any overclocking.
 
let's see the $350 llano a6 laptop.

there needs to be a better replacement for the current n660/HD4250 combo, with massively better battery life, or else it's Fail.
 
That's based on the assumption that GPU performance matters above all else, which isn't what seems to matter most for computers sales. Price is the top factor and battery life is way up there for laptops. Intel makes lower price point chips to address the lower end segments of the markets. I do see the raising of the floor for graphics performance on low end systems as a good thing, don't get me wrong. However, most users won't care about it.

GPU performance is certainly important to gamers, but not all computer buyers are gamers. The timing of high performance IGP releases isn't really optimal as it was in the past and AMD's emphasis on OpenCL and GPGPU is a symptom of that. The gaming market is shifting away from demanding PC specs, although old school games aren't going away any time soon. Some people were/are happy with HD4xxx level IGPs and HD Graphics 2000/3000. The 400SP Llano would be appealing to more of the low end in that way, but it is not the exclusive option that would work for many users.

Llano does seem to have many factors in favor for it, and performance while not exciting, is in the "more than good enough" range for many users. But it's also not the only product that could apply that label.

I don't think Intel will lower prices of existing chips any faster than it usually does, but will release new models instead. There do seem to be a couple of new OEM/tray products coming in weeks to counter Llano on the desktop: i3-2125/2130 (3.3/3.4GHz models) for under $140, and both are using HD Graphics 3000 which had not been available in the i3 series before. That IMO will force down Llano pricing from $170, and not touch i5/i7 pricing (a new i7 is also coming soon, so the 2500/2600 models should get a typical price drop or be discontinued).

Anyways, other than blind loyalists recommending systems, when someone is asked what similarly priced models are better for "general usage", it will be hard for an unbiased person to recommend Llano over SB for CPU performance at many price points. It's not that Llano has no chance, but there is limited gains to be had from low end gaming graphics included with it (A8-3500M gets 25fps in JC2, 1366x768 low settings... yeah massive appeal to gamers :p). Gamers are still going to prefer a discrete GPU.

Price wars have been very unfavorable to AMD in the past, and maybe you can explain who would be hurt more when it's Intel's 149mm^2 SB w/HD Graphics 3000 competing against a 228mm^2 Llano (dual core, quad core, 160SP, 240SP, 400SP... all the same die size) with hideously poor yields (so bad that AMD earlier this year switched to paying for good die instead of wafers). ;)


That's simply no longer true, mate.

First; Windows 7 uses GPU acceleration, Microsoft Office uses GPU acceleration, all current web browsers use GPU acceleration. Only a few things don't use GPU acceleration, and that's older applications, FLASH, and whatever terrible bloatware your manufacturer installs. Youtube's HD videos are GPU accelerated (h.264 codec). FLASH 10 does have GPU acceleration, although it's admittedly buggy...

As time goes by, more and more software applications will take advantage of the GPU. Denying that fact is plain stupid.

As for me, I'm not interested in Notebooks or Netbooks. I'm more interested smaller mobile devices.
 
These chips will be a huge boon to me in selling boxes to customers. None of them want mega processing, they only (in reality) need a 2GHz dual core for raw computing power and the built in GPU will be plenty to play and HD movie stuff, Farmville or the Sims for the daughter at a reasonable rate.

The fact its an AMD chip too means the saving from going AMD rather than Intel will allow the install (as I do now with my budget boxes) a 60GB SSD.

Going AMD rather than Intel means I can fit an SSD which is a far more noticable 'upgrade'. An Intel spec box doesnt fit in the budget. Plus the lower end AMD boards usually have more features than the lower specced Intel ones.

An AMD box with a Athlon II 3GHZ chip and a OCZ 60GB SSD has far more wow factor for the average customer than a Intel i3 box with a standard HDD in it.

Low power CPUs and SSDs are the future for average folks. The gamers and benchmark junkies can stick to Intel. The rest of the world will happily go in another direction.
 
Low power CPUs and SSDs are the future for average folks. The gamers and benchmark junkies can stick to Intel. The rest of the world will happily go in another direction.

That is, unless they get distracted by those shiny Intel Inside stickers and creative advertisement :p
 
Zarathustra[H];1037390107 said:
That is, unless they get distracted by those shiny Intel Inside stickers and creative advertisement :p

Well thats the other bizzare oddity with AMD isnt it.

Why dont they advertise?

People only say they want a Intel CPU when they go in the PC shop because they've only heard of Intel. Here in the UK if you watch a night of TV on the commercial channels you'll hear the Intel jingle at least three times.

So when they are looking for a PC or laptop they buy the intel one as "AMD? They cant be right can they? Intel are the ones that make processors surely? You know, like on the TV last night!"

I dont think advertising on TV would be a bad thing for AMD. After all only one other company is doing it. Most folks have shown they can handle more than one car, phone, TV or washing machine manufacturer when deciding on purchases.

Time for AMD to get a new Marketing Dept maybe?
 
Well thats the other bizzare oddity with AMD isnt it.

Why dont they advertise?

People only say they want a Intel CPU when they go in the PC shop because they've only heard of Intel. Here in the UK if you watch a night of TV on the commercial channels you'll hear the Intel jingle at least three times.

So when they are looking for a PC or laptop they buy the intel one as "AMD? They cant be right can they? Intel are the ones that make processors surely? You know, like on the TV last night!"

I dont think advertising on TV would be a bad thing for AMD. After all only one other company is doing it. Most folks have shown they can handle more than one car, phone, TV or washing machine manufacturer when deciding on purchases.

Time for AMD to get a new Marketing Dept maybe?

Couldn't agree more. This IMHO has been one of AMD's biggest failings.

When they were on top (performance wise), they never marketed themselves as such to the general consumer. This likely resulted in revenue loss, that could have been reinvested in more aggressive R&D to challenge Intel more on the performance front.

Unlike Intel, they don't have the massive resources to pursue a saturation TV ad campaign, where everyone recognizes their jingle. They will have to be more innovative in their advertising approach going after the return on investment of ads. Continuing to completely ignore end consumers in their advertising is probably not a good idea though.
 
Well thats the other bizzare oddity with AMD isnt it.

Why dont they advertise?

People only say they want a Intel CPU when they go in the PC shop because they've only heard of Intel. Here in the UK if you watch a night of TV on the commercial channels you'll hear the Intel jingle at least three times.

So when they are looking for a PC or laptop they buy the intel one as "AMD? They cant be right can they? Intel are the ones that make processors surely? You know, like on the TV last night!"

I dont think advertising on TV would be a bad thing for AMD. After all only one other company is doing it. Most folks have shown they can handle more than one car, phone, TV or washing machine manufacturer when deciding on purchases.

Time for AMD to get a new Marketing Dept maybe?

I think you underestimate the difference in capital between Intel and AMD. AMD had to sell its fab business to survive few years ago. Meanwhile Intel is at 80%+ market share in all its markets. Intel is also 10 times the size of AMD.

Intel makes more money selling Itanium than AMD sells Opterons. The disparity is huge.
 
Low power CPUs and SSDs are the future for average folks. The gamers and benchmark junkies can stick to Intel.
Funny statement. Intel, one of the top 5 NAND flash manufacturers in the world with lots of capacity to meet demand growth, also makes SSDs. And just a few weeks ago, Intel explained the strategy to lower average TDP across its range of CPUs to "around 15W". Do you see how Intel benefits more from both situations you describe?

ARM may start encroaching on x86's low end. That's not only going to put a dent into growth into new markets, but may cause AMD and Intel to struggle to hold onto existing share of traditional x86 segments.

Intel hopes future SoCs can compete in both performance and power (which it very well may), but I doubt it can match the flexibility of ARM's configurations or low cost ($10 Atom rebates are a sign that it costs too much vs $10-$20 dual core Cortex A9 chips). AMD is nowhere near a SoC's integration, package size or low enough power with Bobcat processors. Even the constantly in the future "sub-1W CPU core" Bobcat isn't low power enough to compete in handhelds.

The rise of iOS, Android, and if it takes off, Windows 8 for ARM, are going to make the PC landscape much different than what we see today. TBH, what we currently have is a mess and I won't miss it much.
 
I think you underestimate the difference in capital between Intel and AMD. AMD had to sell its fab business to survive few years ago. Meanwhile Intel is at 80%+ market share in all its markets. Intel is also 10 times the size of AMD.

Intel makes more money selling Itanium than AMD sells Opterons. The disparity is huge.

Agreed, and unless they do something about it, the trend is just going to continue in that direction.

They need the average Joes on the street to be familiar with them in order to drive OEM sales. Thats where the money is. We enthusiasts are not enough to keep them afloat. In fact, we are a depressingly tiny fraction of their sales.

Joe Blow walks in off the street into a Best Buy and wants to buy a laptop. He sees a machine with a familiar Intel Inside logo on it. he may even remember the jingle from TV. Then he sees some laptop with a sticker on it with a three letter abbreviation he has never heard of before. Which one do you think he's going to buy?
 
Zarathustra[H];1037390589 said:
Agreed, and unless they do something about it, the trend is just going to continue in that direction.

They need the average Joes on the street to be familiar with them in order to drive OEM sales. Thats where the money is. We enthusiasts are not enough to keep them afloat. In fact, we are a depressingly tiny fraction of their sales.

Joe Blow walks in off the street into a Best Buy and wants to buy a laptop. He sees a machine with a familiar Intel Inside logo on it. he may even remember the jingle from TV. Then he sees some laptop with a sticker on it with a three letter abbreviation he has never heard of before. Which one do you think he's going to buy?
One thing that may help AMD is that a lot of the cheaper systems between $300 and $500 are AMD powered, usually Athlon II x2 on a (crappy) GeForce 6150 m/b. Isn't it amazing that board mfgs STILL have a ton of GF6100/6150 chipsets laying around?
 
Oh man that chip is a beast, its almost as fast as my four year old Q6600. Oh wait...
 
AMD Trinity APU is supposedly 50% faster than Llano.

http://www.tgdaily.com/hardware-features/56626-amd-showcases-trinity-at-fusion-developer-summit

Senior AMD VP Rick Bergman said:
Trinity is based on our [enhanced] x86 bulldozer core. We tested the silicon a few weeks ago in our labs and confirmed a 50% performance increase.

Trinity is based on Bulldozer, and is on the same 32nm process. Does this means that the number of GPU stream processors is likely the same as Llano, especially due to size and thermal constraints? Did they leave the L3 out on the Trinity to save space, meaning more of the performance increase came from the architecture rather than more cache? Since Llano and Trinity seem to be poised to be released within a year of each other, does that mean the GPU won't be more advanced either?

I really wish I knew the context of that statement. Was the Llano he was comparing using DDR3-1866? We already know that using 1866 over 1333 yields a 20% increase in performance.

What I really want to know is how the Bulldozer cpu in Trinity is affecting everything. Assuming the GPU used doesn't change much due to size and thermal constraints there is a possibility that the Bulldozer cpu itself in Trinity accounted for 30 - 50% performance increase over the K10.5 architecture in the Llano.

Sorry, but I can't help but speculate on this piece of info. At the very least, a Trinity based laptop is going to kick ass in the mid and low end.
 
I think folks are underestimating the financial situation at AMD with regards to whether or not they could mount a decent TV (or any) marketing strategy.

At the end of the day they are a multi-billion dollar corporation, they have many creditors that are keenm for them to carry on, more debt than your competitor isnt a bad thing as the banks are not so much your lender as your business partner.

The cost of TV advertising has dropped dramatically and I'm sure a corporation the size of AMD could put aside a $x million dollar budget to create a grpahic and jingle that the PC stores can tack onto an ad like they do with the Intel one.

Or do some ads like MS did with proce difference and Apple. Just some brand awareness.

At the end of the day AMD are not as poor as some seem to think. It's not like they are working out of a 20 square foot industrial unit in Burbank.

They have the power, do they have the will?

I'd like to see someone like Kyle interview the marketing guy for AMD and ask him just exactly what he does for his wages.
 
AMD fanbois trying to talk me out of Sandy Bridge... Thank god I didn't listen. What an utter disappointment.
 
AMD fanbois trying to talk me out of Sandy Bridge... Thank god I didn't listen. What an utter disappointment.

Newb, this is a small CPU compaired to Sandy Bridge and it competes against Atom which it just slaughtered.
 
Newb, this is a small CPU compaired to Sandy Bridge and it competes against Atom which it just slaughtered.

A netbook CPU on the desktop? Why is this even a desktop CPU? Because of the onchip graphics which are barely decent? You gotta be kidding me with this shit. Just buy a damn GPU.

I still don't hold out hope for Bulldozer.
 
Newb, this is a small CPU compaired to Sandy Bridge and it competes against Atom which it just slaughtered.
This whole sub-convo confuses me. Llano thread, then Bobcat mention? :p

BTW...
Llano with 400SP IGP is 226mm^2 (no L3 cache)
SB 4c w/12EU IGP & 6MB L3 is 216mm^2 (ex. i7 2600 or i5 2500)
SB 2c w/12EU IGP & 3MB L3 is 149mm^2 (i3 2130)
SB 2c w/6EU IGP & 3MB L3 is 131mm^2 (i3 2100)

The top quad core A8 Llano will compete in CPU performance against cut down dual core SB models, likely an i3 model. A4 will compete against gimped SB Pentium G processors in CPU performance. There's no contest in GPU performance though. The flood of benchmarks yesterday shows Llano's 400SP IGP is 50-100% faster than 12EU HD Graphics 3000 and 3x faster or better than 6EU HD Graphics 2000.
 
i don't think now is the time to buy. both amd and intel can do better.
with AMD claiming 50% performance boost in trinity, why even bother with Llano. Just hold on to your current laptop for another year. You won't die.

if amd can bring along a low watt bulldozer, and intel can bring better graphics and power gating, then it's on.

i want the best of both worlds. I don't want to choose either or.

my ideal laptop is a $400 SB with decent igp graphics.
 
This whole sub-convo confuses me. Llano thread, then Bobcat mention? :p

BTW...
Llano with 400SP IGP is 226mm^2 (no L3 cache)
SB 4c w/12EU IGP & 6MB L3 is 216mm^2 (ex. i7 2600 or i5 2500)
SB 2c w/12EU IGP & 3MB L3 is 149mm^2 (i3 2130)
SB 2c w/6EU IGP & 3MB L3 is 131mm^2 (i3 2100)

The top quad core A8 Llano will compete in CPU performance against cut down dual core SB models, likely an i3 model. A4 will compete against gimped SB Pentium G processors in CPU performance. There's no contest in GPU performance though. The flood of benchmarks yesterday shows Llano's 400SP IGP is 50-100% faster than 12EU HD Graphics 3000 and 3x faster or better than 6EU HD Graphics 2000.

His point still stands. Llano is a small CPU compared to Sandy Bridge (APU wise they are about equal in size). Sandy Bridge requires an additional GPU to play games decently while Llano doesn't. Since Llano actually packs a beefy GPU (reason for the die size).

Also you don't know how big 2c Llano is.
 
i don't think now is the time to buy. both amd and intel can do better.
with AMD claiming 50% performance boost in trinity, why even bother with Llano. Just hold on to your current laptop for another year. You won't die.

if amd can bring along a low watt bulldozer, and intel can bring better graphics and power gating, then it's on.

i want the best of both worlds. I don't want to choose either or.

my ideal laptop is a $400 SB with decent igp graphics.

Because $400 including everything but the OS buys you a nice quick m-ITX gaming/HTPC system that uses less then 150w. Almost thinking of getting one just for the summer so I don't have to power up my 600w of usage desktop for non FPS games and keep my room from heating up to 80F.
 
His point still stands. Llano is a small CPU compared to Sandy Bridge (APU wise they are about equal in size). Sandy Bridge requires an additional GPU to play games decently while Llano doesn't. Since Llano actually packs a beefy GPU (reason for the die size).

Also you don't know how big 2c Llano is.

There has been speculation of a 2c llano die, but currently 2c llanos are cut down 4c llanos. IOW, only one llano die is being manufacture at the time.

Okay, it's not speculation. It's mentioned on anandtech's review.
AMD is building two distinct versions of Llano, although only one will be available at launch.
 
anand reckons 758m transistors, which should give us a pretty good idea when contrasted against the known dimensions of 4C Llano.
 
i don't think now is the time to buy. both amd and intel can do better.
with AMD claiming 50% performance boost in trinity, why even bother with Llano. Just hold on to your current laptop for another year. You won't die.

if amd can bring along a low watt bulldozer, and intel can bring better graphics and power gating, then it's on.

i want the best of both worlds. I don't want to choose either or.

my ideal laptop is a $400 SB with decent igp graphics.

Wow, waiting a year and you'll get better tech for the same or less money? What an original idea!

:rolleyes:
 
Back
Top