NVIDIA Says Intel’s CPU Is “Dead”

That's a good point Pxc, but you know what it's like sometimes, you read it through, and it all looks good, then you read it again 15 mins later, and you spot a typo! lol

I think the decision is a bad one, sorry Kyle, and can only lead to more posts, which puts more strain on the server etc...
 
Show me!

My quad box is ready and I need a new GPU that is worth upgrading to.

 
Yet more smoke and mirrors and unadulterated bull from nVidia.
They need to get some competent mouthpieces already.
 
And all this is coming from a company that cant even make a stable chipset. Those are some bold claims.


....what unstable chipset? I'm under NDA (typical contract manufacturer crap), but I will say this: there are some very stable products made with their chipsets....and very fast products I might add.
 
To take down someone like Intel, you must have something really really good. Intel has so much money that even if Nvidia did succeed in coming out with something very good, Intel will eventually adapt to the situation. Sure it may take them a couple years like it took them to get Core 2 out, but eventually they will put out something to compete. I dont know, I just think its a bunch of marketing BS. Reminds me when AMD challenged Intel to some speed contest. Cant remember exactly what this challenge was, but in the end Intel won.
 
....what unstable chipset? I'm under NDA (typical contract manufacturer crap), but I will say this: there are some very stable products made with their chipsets....and very fast products I might add.

680i. See the "crapbox" thread in the Intel Motherboards forum. Even Dan_D chimed in on how crappy it was.
 
Kyle described it a few times that the choice was made on purpose. You can always use preview to check your post before submitting.

yeah but you can't add something 5 minutes later
 
Apparently everybody at nvidia is 14 years old. They probably think their userbase communicates like this everyday ... good lord. :eek:
 
Yep, I guess since games are becoming more GPU-limited no one will buy CPUs anymore.
 
I think what nV is trying to say is they believe the current idea of a CPU will become dead when CPUs and GPUs merge. Kind of like when 2D accelerators dissappeared when they became integrated into the 3D chips.

An Intel CPU with a 3D core vs. an nV GPU with x86 CUDA

I dunno. I think people would still percieve either one as a new kind of CPU lol
 
Honestly, I hope Nvidia can put up here, I will admit, I would like to see intel being taken down a serious step or two. Given that it is unlikely they will anytime soon, but with this statement, they are now competing against 3 major companies, if any one of those three can make a major stride (especially AMD) then intel will have a harder time. Honestly, though, I am a little sick of intel ATM and it wouldn't bug me to see larrabee flop.
 
yeah, if you are talking about high end, IMHA i would rather have an X3 phenom for 20 bucks more than the E4600 though, the low end core 2's are not doing too well, intel seriously needs to consider lowering the E4xxx series by a good 60 dollars!
 
Honestly, I hope Nvidia can put up here, I will admit, I would like to see intel being taken down a serious step or two. Given that it is unlikely they will anytime soon, but with this statement, they are now competing against 3 major companies, if any one of those three can make a major stride (especially AMD) then intel will have a harder time. Honestly, though, I am a little sick of intel ATM and it wouldn't bug me to see larrabee flop.

Why? Intel (unlike NVIDIA) has continued to improve their products and cut their prices despite little competition. As long as they keep doing that I'm happy.
 
I seriously doubt that Nvidia's cards are going to allow me to record more simultaneous tracks in protools.

Actually, some folks ARE using graphics processors to process audio, and the performance is phenominal. It won't add the ahrdware to get those channels into or out, but it could give you the punch to do a lot more processing on those streams.


hehehe, yea, ok, big pipe.......

HA! you may wake up soon and see how a 1,000 core Intel CPU will beat down anything you have to show...vaporware or otherwise.

ALso, you may be better served to see how you are going to compete against Intel having 50+ dedicated cores running graphics once again in software; sans any GPU at all.

Big Pipe indeed, put up or shut up.


The thing is, you start going to that many cores, and to make it fit and be efficient, you are probably going to wind up stepping on patents that belong to NVIDIA, AMD, or the cell processor consortium.

Not to mention to make that 1000 core beast useful, you have to advance compiler technology and development tools to make that seemless. Both areas where NVIDIA and the Cell consortium have been there first and own a lot of the technology. Not to mention any breakthroughs that make it easy to program for a 1000 core CPU and yeild results will be beneficial to making things like GPUs and Cell more competitive to traditional GPUs.

That 1000 croes intel CPU may be EXACTLY what NV wants out of them. AS intel has basically been investing in growth in the smaller more efficient processor and system on a chip designs. Intel is a BIG hitter in the realm of compiler technology R&D, and if they aren't in the game, the tools needed might never show up in a nice commercially viable form.
 
Actually, some folks ARE using graphics processors to process audio, and the performance is phenominal. It won't add the ahrdware to get those channels into or out, but it could give you the punch to do a lot more processing on those streams.

I'd really appreciate a link to a project or an article on the topic if you have one.
My searches for NVidia Audio Processing get a million hits for Soundstorm related stuff.
 
....what unstable chipset? I'm under NDA (typical contract manufacturer crap), but I will say this: there are some very stable products made with their chipsets....and very fast products I might add.

What does your NDA have to do with this....oh wait, its suppose to make me take you seriously. :rolleyes:

You obviously never tried a Nvidia chipped mobo. They were decent for Athlon's, but to use one for an Intel chip is a waste of time, unless you really need SLI.
 
lol @ Nvidia ....lets see them make a chip that overclocks more than 1ghz its factory speed then they can talk sht.

My core 2 duo E8400 runs at 4.1 ghz cost me $189. My nvidia card cost almost $300 and overclocks 30Mhz more.

90% of the work i do on my pc doesnt require a $300 video card. It does use the faster CPU. I only play one game thats call of duty, and i had to buy the overpriced overheating card. So i dont know where nvidia gets the this twisted logic.:confused:
 
*processes

P.S. could we please get a stable edit system again?

wtf happened to our edit button?

I get the edit button on occasion but 9 out of 10 i never see the edit button anymore when I post. :mad:

We've never had an edit button in the news page, just other forums. Maybe that's where you're seeing edit buttons 9 other times ;)
 
Actually, some folks ARE using graphics processors to process audio, and the performance is phenominal.
I'd really appreciate a link to a project or an article on the topic if you have one.
Start here. Then do a search on Google for "gpu" and "dsp." For nVidia specific info, search "cuda" and "dsp." For ATi, "ctm" and "dsp" or "firestream" and "dsp."
 
AMD talked crap about Intel a few years ago too... look at them now.
Only a matter of time before Intel starts making video cards with 12 dedicated cores to crush Nvidia
 
I have stock in Nvidia and I DON'T like what they are saying/doing.

They need to get along with Intel as a partner since AMD/ATI are together.
 
AMD talked crap about Intel a few years ago too... look at them now.
Only a matter of time before Intel starts making video cards with 12 dedicated cores to crush Nvidia

Intel makes video cards now --- they suck.


That being said see my post right above this.

A partnership to destroy AMD and ATI would have been smarter than alienating their potential bed partner.
 
I just find it Ironic that Nvidia is bithcing at Intel for not being cooperative over product specs and licensing.

I'd be making specialized super gaming motherboards... extra flawless mosfet design, special ram speed enhancment, very high quality audio output circuits, and many other innovations IF Nvidia wasn't such a bitch about licensing anyone NOT a multi-billion$ corporation to build with thier chipsets. They basically told me to go fuck myself. How's it feel greenie?

Boo who. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
A partnership to destroy AMD and ATI would have been smarter than alienating their potential bed partner.

And anti-trust concerns (especially in the EU) all around. It is better for both Intel and NVIDIA to have a weak AMD to compete against than none at all. Which is exactly what they have, and why I doubt they would ever strike a finishing blow against it, even if they could, though I doubt they will let AMD get on top again anytime soon.

I just find it Ironic that Nvidia is bithcing at Intel for not being cooperative over product specs and licensing.

I'd be making specialized super gaming motherboards... extra flawless mosfet design, special ram speed enhancment, very high quality audio output circuits, and many other innovations IF Nvidia wasn't such a bitch about licensing anyone NOT a multi-billion$ corporation to build with thier chipsets. They basically told me to go fuck myself. How's it feel greenie?

To be fair, have you tried that with Intel or AMD and have they been more cooperative? Big corporations like dealing with big corporations in general, unfortunately.
 
Intel ain't gonna make 12 core graphics cards. Sure intel is great at doing CPU's, but as has been said before, you can't rush into the graphics party 5 years late and expect to do well... intel's GPUs are terrible at EVERYTHING, hell they can't even run vista smoothly. I think it is a pretty low expectation for a card to score at least 10000 on 3dmark 01, my friend's x3100 paired with a 2.13 GHZ C2D manages 5500 on a GOOD day, these are around 64 bit 5200 scores. For intel to take their graphics up three gens in a period of three months? forget about it. NVIDIA and ATI have the performance (and even some of the low end) graphics market cornered, anyone who dares to enter their domain is going to be punished. Some people may say that intel could do well in the low performance GPU market, but considering the fact that a lot of PC's today come with discreet graphics, I would say it is best for intel to keep to its own game, honestly I wouldn't use an integrated GPU even if all I did was word processing, email and internet, I don't care how sufficient an integrated GPU is, discreet is always better, and seeing that X700's can be had for 20 bucks, I wouldn't hesitate to replace an integrated GPU these days. Nvidia probably shouldn't talk like this, because we all remember what happened with the FX series, but these days, it is pretty much impossible to enter the graphics market, if NV really wanted to, they could probably sell a very low end (but better than integrated) GPU for 10 bucks, with purevideo and all the other benefits of even the Geforce 6/7 series, it would still be more attractive than a $5 intel solution.
 
Anybody remember when Netscape (does anyone even remember netscape) made fun of Microsoft???? There was a special on the History Channel or one of those channels. MS worked their assed off, then laid a fucking beat down on Netscape. nVidia does not want Intel to show them how their backhand is strong!
 
Anybody remember when Netscape (does anyone even remember netscape) made fun of Microsoft???? There was a special on the History Channel or one of those channels. MS worked their assed off, then laid a fucking beat down on Netscape. nVidia does not want Intel to show them how their backhand is strong!

No it was more or less microsoft could afford the fight
 
remember though, NVidia and ATI have both had time to develop their technologies, and if a newcomer tries to take over their marketshare, suddenly it won't be red vs. green, but red and green vs. blue, now consider that both red and green have had time to develop their technology, and also consider that this is ALL they do, it suddenly seems unlikely that anyone would do well to dabble in their realm. if intel comes out wiht a part that rivals the 9800 GX2 (which I sincerely doubt will happen soon) then Nvidia will pull the trigger on the 9900 and ATI will release their 4800. Remember that Intel is there to make money, not to teach Nvidia or ATI a lesson, and they will pull out if they don't see gains in the near future. If intel tries to take the lower end market, Nvidia's PR dep. can work to convince people that the extra 15 bucks for discrete GFX is worth it. Not only this, but the drivers and multi monitor support for NV/ATI have been in development for longer than Intel has made semi-discrete GPU's. Honestly, teaching someone a lesson who challenges you in your ring is one thing, but Nvidia is calling intel over to their ring, which takes enough effort to guarantee that intel GFX would be a net loss by the time they competed. Hell, Nvidia and ATI have almost EVERY part of the GPU market cornered, anything integrated is relegated to the bargain bin. Even intel's best mobile chip is no match for a 9500M or even an 8400M. I wouldn't expect a great comback from intel...
 
Also, consider this, it isn't above NV or ATI to license games NOT to play on their conpetitions GPU. Yes it is quite unreasonable, but there have been a few times where it was considered, even in a market where it would affect half the gamers, not just a third, like it would if Intel joined.
 
What does your NDA have to do with this....oh wait, its suppose to make me take you seriously. :rolleyes:

You obviously never tried a Nvidia chipped mobo. They were decent for Athlon's, but to use one for an Intel chip is a waste of time, unless you really need SLI.

Other than I can't give the exact example.....however nForce chipsets have been in use in some devices aside from typical "computing" products for a while, and have perfomed very well.

Really, up until this thread, I really didn't even notice an issue...but it could be for two things: 1) I'm an AMD user 2) The products we use here are custom fabricated, and designed for 4-6year product life cycles, so they are probably of a better design (since they won't be spinning a V2.0 for a long time).
 
This is like a company that makes Turbo Upgrade Kits telling Car buyers that "the engine is dead"..
 
I have stock in Nvidia and I DON'T like what they are saying/doing.

They need to get along with Intel as a partner since AMD/ATI are together.


Agreed.I own stock in both companies and all this chest thumping on both sides is quite childish.This kinda started with the head of the Larabee project making some very very bold and threatening statements.
 
Also, consider this, it isn't above NV or ATI to license games NOT to play on their conpetitions GPU. Yes it is quite unreasonable, but there have been a few times where it was considered, even in a market where it would affect half the gamers, not just a third, like it would if Intel joined.

No notable dev house is stupid enough to go along with this sort of scheme. The backlash from the community on a major title would be crippling, and on a minor title it'd only guarantee burial under a mountain of bad press straight out the gate.

Think.
 
I'm not sure what nVidia's statement is supposed to mean but the CPU has a long life left. The CPU is a general processor which is good at a lot of different things but excels in few. Something like a GPU or a PPU excels in a few instances but has terrible performance in many other things and can't perform some things at all.

There is a huge difference in the architecture between a general processor and a specialized processor. An example of this is the F@H project. There are different types of clients. Some run on the CPU, some run on a GPU and some run on the Cell processor. The CPU clients can process just about any type of work unit and has the majority of the different types of work units. The Cell (in the PS3) is more specialized than an x86 CPU and can't process as many types of work units as a normal CPU. The units it can process are able to be completed in less time than a normal CPU. Finally you have the GPU client. It is very limited on the type of work units it is able to process. However, the units it can process can be done much faster than if they were run on either the Cell or a regular CPU.

Each one has strengths and weaknesses. Most people here should realize this considering few of us try to use software emulation to play a 3D game on the CPU alone. We have GPUs which are specialized for graphics to do this instead. This is the reason the original Voodoo was created.

While the architectures of GPUs have changed a lot over the years and can be used for more general processing uses, the architecture still does not allow the flexibility of of a CPU. However, being able to offload some tasks from the CPU to the GPU, depending on the software being used, can make a huge difference. The highly parallel nature of GPUs can give a huge boost to certain types of calculations if the software is made to take advantage of the GPU.

 
Remember 5 years back, the EA game thing, or how about valve, they pretty much denied FX users, and that was a large part of the market.
 
Remember 5 years back, the EA game thing, or how about valve, they pretty much denied FX users, and that was a large part of the market.

Valve defaulted 5xxx FX users to the DX8 code path because with the exception of about 2 of the highest end FX cards, the entire series was damn near incapable of running source in DX9 at an acceptable performance level. I do think they should have made the DX9 path an easily acceptable option. But, then that would have caused an uproar in and of itself, once people realized their shiny new 5xxxFX DX9 cards were not really any good at DX9. Valve did NV a favor there, by defaulting to DX8 imho.

Back on topic, processors have reached a point where the graphics card is the big hold up. It seems only obvious that the next big thing to come along to improve iq and performance in games is going to be a new gpu. People running around with c2d and quads at 3ghz and above are not hurting at all for cpu power in games. But that does not mean th cpu is dead. There are still gains to made with the cpu in physics and ai.
 
If nVidia Made and Bundled a CPU capable of running today's applications at a fair clip. (Say E6300 speed), with their Motherboards, would you buy it and forego buying an intel CPU?
 
If nVidia Made and Bundled a CPU capable of running today's applications at a fair clip. (Say E6300 speed), with their Motherboards, would you buy it and forego buying an intel CPU?

Maybe, but only if it: worked on chip sets other than NV's, cost the same or less for = performance in games and everyday computing, used power at a similar level to its' price/performance counterparts, was NOT made into another artificial requirement for sli like NForce SLI chip sets are currently, had similar heat output compared to Intel/Amd chips in the same price/performance bracket.
Even then, I would prolly stick to Intel or Amd.

But on this topic, how does Nv putting out a cpu make Intels CPU dead? Do they think they can out R&D Intel for more than a short while, if at all? Are they gonna sandwich a gpu on the same die as the cpu? Would that somehow kill Intel's cpus if they could?
I don't really think it would. I think Nv is just talking smack, and pumping up a little controversy and hype for it's upcoming gpu launch supposedly happening this summer.
 
Back
Top