NVIDIA Says Intel’s CPU Is “Dead”

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Nothing like ending the week with a bit of smack talk, eh? According to Engadget, NVIDIA’s VP of Content Relations Roy “Big Pipe” Taylor sent out an e-mail with some pretty bold claims, a bit of a follow-up to the chest thumping we saw earlier this month.

NVIDIA's VP of Content Relations Roy Taylor sending out emails saying that "a war has started" and pronouncing the Intel CPU "dead." Roy says Intel is "panicking" because CPUs have "run out of steam," and that they "no longer make anything run faster." According to Roy -- whose nickname is "Big Pipe," no joke -- the only thing that needs to get faster is the GPU, and NVIDIA's going to make it happen.
 
...so when is he going to STFU and get something done? My 8800 GTXs are ancient by GPU standards and nothing on the market is even vaguely appealing as a replacement.
 
Yeah, let's see how blazingly fast triple-SLI makes Flight Simulator X run, and how the next GPU will offload from my Apache web server.
 
Well.. let's see him take the CPU out of his system and then see how fast it runs.

Kinda like back in the day when somebody said "640k is plenty"
 
Uhm, right. Because data centers, 3d modeling companies, movie companies and game programmers rely only on the GPU to get their work done.

Maybe what he's saying is true for the hardcore gaming sector of computer technology, y'know, less than 1% of the world wide computer market.
 
Actually, if Intel takes them seriously (as a threat) they will step up their game, the same way they have done with AMD (and vice versa) and the result will be better products. Competition is always a good thing for the consumer...having someone nipping at your heels keep you from getting lazy.
 
CPU is dead?

Umm not to my favorite game/sim LockOn Modern Air Combat

I could add Quad SLI and it would only add a few frames (okay maybe more)... CPU is where its at in that game.
 
...so when is he going to STFU and get something done? My 8800 GTXs are ancient by GPU standards and nothing on the market is even vaguely appealing as a replacement.

Too true, seems more like it's nVidia who have run out of steam.
 
I wouldn't say it is dead, but we are seeing more use out of GPUs than ever before. Still need a CPU though... WTF? When I start to see a PC run without a cpu, then I will say that there may be a decreased need for cpus.... but wouldn't that technically make the gpu the cpu?

... decreased not deceased.
 
Oh man. Last time a company got all smart with Intel, they were slapped back into the nobody budget segment and the red.

Don't awaken the beast again, NVIDIA. You just can't win.
 
And all this is coming from a company that cant even make a stable chipset. Those are some bold claims.
 
There is a lot oof truth in what he is saying. For the AVERAGE (not [H]ard) user who just browses the net and does some movie watching and maybe some gaming, faster CPUs just don't make much if any diffrence.
 
Actually I recall a lab working on using GPUs to run some programs off of. IT's basis is that if you have a GPU and you aren't using intensive graphics like command line, the GPU could possibly be used to offload some of the processed from the CPU.

So, if you need a GPU to have graphics but the GPU could also parse code... then why even use a CPU?

The same could be said, why even need a GPU, why not just have a CPU that can parse code and render polygons and what not.

Honestly, I don't think we need both, one of the other. In the future it is likely one will be gone. the CPU or the GPU, my money is the CPU will disappear and GPUs will be the parser for your code and the renderer of your polygons.
 
Actually, if Intel takes them seriously (as a threat) they will step up their game, the same way they have done with AMD (and vice versa) and the result will be better products. Competition is always a good thing for the consumer...having someone nipping at your heels keep you from getting lazy.

And this is exactly why I hope AMD/ATI steps it up soon with nVidia. Competition has been a non-issue ever since the 8000 series came out and unfortunately it seems like nVidia isn't keeping the breakneck pace of development that followed the FX series debacle, simply because they don't have to.
 
*processes

P.S. could we please get a stable edit system again?

wtf happened to our edit button?

I get the edit button on occasion but 9 out of 10 i never see the edit button anymore when I post. :mad:
 
And all this is coming from a company that cant even make a stable chipset. Those are some bold claims.

Uh.. nvidias chipsets have surpassed most others in stability ever since the original nforce was released for socket 462, if you were around back then.
 
And all this is coming from a company that cant even make a stable chipset. Those are some bold claims.

Not to mention, the 9 series? Come on. The 9600GT looks sweet for the midrange card owners, but the 9800GTX is somewhat disappointing, at least for anyone with an 8800GTX looking to step up. For someone who's in a 7 or 6 series its probably a helluva upgrade. How can this guy say such things when the 9 series isn't even all that big of a leap over the previous generation on the high end?
 
Are they just trying to piss Intel off?
Well, anyway, Nv has laid down the smack, now it's time they make something to justify it.

Truthfully, I doubt even Amd is worried about Nv on the cpu front, let alone Intel being concerned. Amd and Intel have the option to NOT license Nv to make chip sets for their upcoming cpu architectures. I would actually like it if they did that. Nv would then have to allow SLI on Intel and Amd chip sets. That or watch SLI die. Where would the smack talk be then I wonder.


If the quotation in the article is taken a little out of context, and Nv is talking about the ultra mobile arena or console arena, (cell phones, consoles, music/video players, pdas, and etc., then they may have a point.
 
Uh.. nvidias chipsets have surpassed most others in stability ever since the original nforce was released for socket 462, if you were around back then.


Maybe they were more stable than Via or Ali chipsets which is not sayin much.
 
...........and to Roy Taylor i say "Put up or shut up!"
 
looks like someone should stop drinking before sending out emails, but if I was that rich I would probably send out drunken emails as well.
 
This is pretty funny as how nvidia has had nine generations to make these statments true. Once they have the gpu able to run any command that the cpu otherwise could, and make it worth having more than one video card that could be a type of co-processor, then they can keep their hot air to themselves. I have zero interest in folding.

You'll still see a hullvua lot more improvement by dropping in a $200 quad core cpu in than $1-2k worth of dual/tri/quad sli to your system. :D

Now if only they stopped the "intel game" and quit releasing all of these useless cut down bullshite video cards all the time, while only having the best showcase of the generation as a release that is out of many peoples reach.

I for one have had it with nvidia anyway. I'm going ati next, which I havn't done since the original radeon. But man, it's looking so attractive with minimal/not at all cut down features across the board just like amd cpus are.
 
Uh.. nvidias chipsets have surpassed most others in stability ever since the original nforce was released for socket 462, if you were around back then.

are joo talkin' our joo ass again?

i used a Nvidia chipset once and I will NEVER go back to using them

SIS, ATI, > Nvidia not to mention that Intel is by far the best IMHO
 
What if Linux or another operating system was built purely on the GPU? Don't see it happening anytime soon, but i think the CPU and GPU will be a big battle for the next 5 years at least, then it'll probably be all one or the other. Although having Sql Server or ESX server running off of a GPU would be pretty sweet.
 
I find my nforce4 to be rather disappointing. I remember turning on the hardware firewall only to find that all it does is corrupt my downloads.

And it's a good thing NVIDIA is doing this. I'm honestly scared of intel taking over the market and driving everyone else out. When everyone got in the game, it was alright, because you didn't need hundreds of millions of dollars to get something going. As is the case with Montalvo, it's been made pretty clear that for a new player to get into the game now is pretty impossible, even with a lot of money backing you up.

But I do agree with NVIDIA saying the whole CPU thing is drawing to an end. Look at the eeePC. Grossly underpowered, yet it sells like mad, and it seems like everyone is jumping into the market. Most people don't need to fold, or play games. They want something that boots up fast and lets them check their email and browse myspace. I know that seems somewhat hypocritical of NVIDIA, but don't forget about that whole Vista debacle with Intel parts being sold as Vista Capable or whatever the wording was when they didn't have the guts to run Aero. At least we have the 3d-desktop space to move into with Vista, Linux (compiz), and OSX, but for CPUs there's not much.

I'm rather content with my 2.97Ghz opty 165, and that's been around for a while. I am looking forward to a nice warm Radeon 4800 and a nice 22in monitor this fall, though.
 
Anybody ever heard of the wheel of karma? It was described about the same time as Moore's law (just before 1970). The basic idea is that to get to the next level of graphics you need high speed hardware. You keep cranking up the power until you can meet the graphical challenge, then you slowly ramp down until you are letting the CPU do almost all of the work. Then wait until you can make hardware to take it to next level (text->graphics->windowed GUIs->3d graphics->???). ATI has been around long enough to see the rise of windows accelerators, fall of same (to the point where just a bitblit register was needed), and back to power with 3d. I think they were happy to hedge their bets with AMD.

Another, less proven, "industry law" says that once x86 works in a sector; it takes over that sector. My guess is that Larabee hasn't a prayer of working as an effective GPU, but graphics will be run off a processor(s) running the x86 (or some evolution thereof) instruction set before 2020. When that happens it won't change again until you need an order of magnitude more operations for something (not rendering 3d graphics onto a 2d screen).
 
Looks like nVidia's trying to get in some last jabs before the GPU goes the way of the PPU.
 
This whole feud is happening because Intel won't give nvidia a QuickPath license (for Nehalem) without getting something in return (i.e. a SLI license). If nvidia thinks it is going to counter Intel with an Isaiah platform, they're in for a huge disappointment. nvidia will blink in this battle.
 
Back
Top