Need help choosing storage for my build

Undercover_Man

[H]ard Surgeon
2FA
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
1,314
Need to choose storage for my upcoming $4k+ PC

I will be gaming, high res photo/audio/video (1080p/4k)/3D editing, and max quality streaming/recording. When creating/editing, I tend to be a storage hog. I keep old versions of my creations, uncompressed files, old archived data, and lots of full HD photos/videos/audio files when editing. I have files from 1998 still hanging around.

I do not know if I need all the storage drives or just a mixture of them: mSATA, HDD, SSD, Hybrids.

I would like to have the OS and other essential programs housed separately from lesser used/unimportant programs/data.

I would also like to have a specific drive with ONLY extremely important data (photo/video/archived stuff) mirrored (or something) to another drive for safety (If the apartment/house catches fire or tornado is spotted, I can grab the one hard drive with everything else being replaceable data.

I'll use a separate drive for non-essential games and programs. Why do I not want the non-essential stuff also on my irreplaceable mirrored or backup drive system?

I'm still stuck with the old ways of hard drive storage systems. Using that outdated knowledge I need someone to update this:

#1 - OS/Priority programs
#2 & #3 - Essential files I can't live without (pic/vid/audio/doc backups)
#4 - Misc progs/games, misc files, etc.

Sucks huh? My main concern is placing the OS/essential progs on a faster, more efficient drive and essential files somehow backed up on another drive so I can grab it in the event of an emergency while also keeping backup sessions/syncs as quick as possible eliminating non-essential OS files, misc files from programs, and misc files in general, and cache/temp files from various programs.

Can m.2 mSATA be beneficial? How is it used with PC's?

Help me upgrade my hard drive layout knowledge. :D
 
are you into the idea of making a NAS as a long term mass storage and protecting against hard drive failures and bit rot?

If you really want to protect your data thats the first thing to chalk off.

If data loss or bit rot isn't a concern then much simpler cheap solutions exist to solve your question/problem.

You need to answer that before you consider anything else.

From there you can figure out how much RAM, SSD, and HDD space you need in your actual computer. I am going to bed but I can explain to you my end goals. It is pricey but future proof.

FYI these guys on here got to me go from a 1-2k storage budget to a 3-4k storage budget. True salesmen :p
 
I expect my essential data that must be protected to require a max of 1TB. At start, all my data will take less than 300GB's with lots of room to grow. But I may be under estimating. I plan on doing a YouTube gaming channel (Yeah yeah, I know. The world needs ANOTHER YT Gaming channel) to begin with and then expanding with one or two other channels. I got channel ideas swirling around in my head. But 1TB for the essential data (excluding OS/data greedy games & progs/misc & temp files) should be enough for starters. I'll be recording/uploading 1080p games as well as doing other things with 4k video.I have not had a system where I can be fully immersed in my video editing skills.
 
I expect my essential data that must be protected to require a max of 1TB. At start, all my data will take less than 300GB's with lots of room to grow. But I may be under estimating. I plan on doing a YouTube gaming channel (Yeah yeah, I know. The world needs ANOTHER YT Gaming channel) to begin with and then expanding with one or two other channels. I got channel ideas swirling around in my head. But 1TB for the essential data (excluding OS/data greedy games & progs/misc & temp files) should be enough for starters. I'll be recording/uploading 1080p games as well as doing other things with 4k video.I have not had a system where I can be fully immersed in my video editing skills.

I am no buff on the requirements of 1080p or 4k in terms of storage but 1TB seems whoa-fully small. A single BD disc for 2 hours or something is like 50GB. Is your stuff highly compressed?

You should see what 4k and 1080p requires in terms of x GB per hour of footage and if you care if they are lost in a hardrive failure or lost due to bit rot. Snapraid is the only windows option to prevent bit rot and you could easily add a couple HDDs in a SnapRAID for achieving.

This is the thread i have for my NAS that I'll be updating over the weekend probably as i start to build it in phases. You might find some helpful things in there as I try to do things over my head lol.
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1871275


Now back on terms of OS drive. How much space do you want and how fast? I am someone who wants a 1TB os/program/highly used data drive but many are fine with 256GB. I personally recommend nothing less than 480/512GB die OS drive unless you plan on literally not having anything on it like a work computer.

There is NVMe currently becoming available and intel has XPoint coming out end of next year IIRC. Xpoint is crazy awesome...or it should be.

When do you need this/want this by? Can you wait for more NVMe drives or do you just want to drop the dough on a 750/SM951. In your case a Samsung SM951 NVMe would be sufficient. I don't think you need a 750 from the sounds of it. You don't seem to be complaining about SSDs eating crap like me or have anything crazy in terms of load.

For mass storage I would just use some HDDs and RAID them in software but again you need to figure out how much space you need and how important the data is. If learning SnapRAID worth while?

Also what CPU/MB do you plan on using that makes a huge difference in terms of advice. A lot of questions haven't been asked yet in terms of basic hardware goals and needs.

If you got awhile until you need to build this PM me closer to that time and I might have a drawing of my new build at that point. It will have a few stages of storage.
 
I'm not exactly familiar with how a NAS works or sets up. Same goes for what RAID is up to these days. My knowledge of these stops at around 2003.

It sounds like something I would do after I actually get my main PC up and running and I'm more knowledgeable about 2015 PC parts. It's going to cost 4k-5k as is too. If I go with a NAS, I expect to start putting together parts 3-6 months after I build my PC. 3-6 months isn't long and I surely won't be crazy deep into 4k experimentation or have a ton of vids recorded by then.

I will be building my PC in 2.5-4.5 months MAX. It depends on how much money my paychecks will be during that time.

I have decided on a i7-5930K/Rampage V Extreme (still evaluating mobos but this seems to be sticking so far).

Case will be Corsair 900D

I'm thinking SSD for the OS/essential, speed benefited programs. That's the only thing I know for sure. Not sure how else to handle the less important program, essential/important data, or non-essential data beyond that.

I guess I can start with 2TB for the essential/important stuff. I just want to be able to grab a drive with ease in case of emergency. Building next to me burned down and I need safety even before I investigate a NAS. What would work best between my initial build and a NAS if a NAS is the way to go?

Did I forget to answer a question?
 
Your knowledge of RAID is where mine was like 4 months ago So it is cool :)

Read this thread on cases. I have the thermaltake core x9 case and its huge and awesome. I'll be taking pics of it soon and posting it to that thread.
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1869174

A small 4 bay off the shelf NAS could be a decent interim until you go custom.

I don't know video editing so I have no idea if ECC is important but going with one of those unlocked xeons might be worth while if it can be afforded.

I recommend looking into ASRock boards as well. They have some good stuff and they support the unlocked xeons and RDIMMS if you ever need to go registered and high capacity RAM down the road.

Not sure if this works but
@wirk can you help this guy out? You know way way way way way way more than me.

If he doesn't respond maybe shoot him a PM and plead for advice. He knows a lot of stuff with these types of systems since he even owns one of those fancy unlocked xeons that are like 1700 bucks.
 
I'll be gaming as well as editing on this build. After I recover from the first build, financially, I may separate it and have a gaming and editing PC. My gaming PC is going to be a power hog and editing can take hours. If/When I build an editing PC, I'll want to make it quieter and less power hungry. But I won't do all that until 6 months to a year MINIMUM after my initial build.
 
I'll be gaming as well as editing on this build. After I recover from the first build, financially, I may separate it and have a gaming and editing PC. My gaming PC is going to be a power hog and editing can take hours. If/When I build an editing PC, I'll want to make it quieter and less power hungry. But I won't do all that until 6 months to a year MINIMUM after my initial build.

sounds like a solid plan.

I plan on using my server/NAS if possible as the editing/encoding machine so i can go a skylake desktop instead of something wonky and crazy.
 
Whatever storage you plan to have after a year buy at least triple. A lot of people go over their expectations (in the beginning), and you always want a good amount of free space for performance and defrag.

So if you think you need a 1TB drive for data storage, get a 3TB. ;) IMHO Plus 3TB-4TB drives are in the price/size sweet spot right now.
 
Lots of ifs, ands, or buts up in here... You've got so many balls in the air with regards to your needs, budget, and plans that it's gonna be tough for anyone to tell you "just buy this, or that". Sounds like you need to do a lot more research first and then you can get down to brass tacks add far as actual component choices.

I'll say this tho, none of what you've discussed seems like a good solution for grabbing and bugging out if your place catches fire, if you're even there at a time. The only thing that makes sense in that scenario is a single external backup drive that's updated daily.

If your work or data is THAT important you should be thinking about redundancy anyway... Off site backups whether it be thru a simple cloud account (Dropbox, Google, Amazon, etc) or something like Crashplan. There's always the old school route, keeping a couple externals that you rotate/update at work or whatever on a weekly basis.

RAID is for redundancy (an array can keep operating even with a dead drive), performance (particularly with large sequential transfers, large files), or convenience (making a larger volume out of smaller drives).It's not a form of backup... Are you really gonna shut down your rig and yank out a mirrored drive in the middle of a fire?

What if you delete something or something gets corrupted? RAID doesn't protect you against that either. Similarly a NAS is great if you have lots and lots of storage need and/or multiple systems to serve in the household, but you're not gonna edit video off the NAS so you still need local storage.
 
Lots of ifs, ands, or buts up in here... You've got so many balls in the air with regards to your needs, budget, and plans that it's gonna be tough for anyone to tell you "just buy this, or that". Sounds like you need to do a lot more research first and then you can get down to brass tacks add far as actual component choices.

I'll say this tho, none of what you've discussed seems like a good solution for grabbing and bugging out if your place catches fire, if you're even there at a time. The only thing that makes sense in that scenario is a single external backup drive that's updated daily.

If your work or data is THAT important you should be thinking about redundancy anyway... Off site backups whether it be thru a simple cloud account (Dropbox, Google, Amazon, etc) or something like Crashplan. There's always the old school route, keeping a couple externals that you rotate/update at work or whatever on a weekly basis.

RAID is for redundancy (an array can keep operating even with a dead drive), performance (particularly with large sequential transfers, large files), or convenience (making a larger volume out of smaller drives).It's not a form of backup... Are you really gonna shut down your rig and yank out a mirrored drive in the middle of a fire?

What if you delete something or something gets corrupted? RAID doesn't protect you against that either. Similarly a NAS is great if you have lots and lots of storage need and/or multiple systems to serve in the household, but you're not gonna edit video off the NAS so you still need local storage.

FYI he stated he has no idea on what exists and is out there and this is why he is here.

BTW I recommended to him to get a 4 bay NAS for that reason. RAID and large storage. If he can't carry a 4 bay enclosure he has more pressing issues.

other intermediate options exist like DASes. Rosewill has a cool 8 bay DAS for 300 or so. I don't know if its any good but solid options like that exist for unique work environments.

Also a NAS can work like a DAS too if designed to do so. I am trying to figure that out for my NAS
 
On a personal note, if it serves of any help... I still like keeping the OS install and my main programs separate from my game installs and data too, more for convenience than anything else.

It's a little old school I guess but it makes backups much easier too, since I can create multiple image backups of the OS drive or partition (doesn't *have* to be a completely separate drive) while keeping sizes more manageable, and I'm also able to restore it without moving any data around.

Ever since SSD came into the picture the way I've done this is by keeping the OS/apps on the SSD and data/games on HDD, occasionally I'd move a few frequently played games unto the SSD with symbolic links (or Steam Mover) so I wouldn't need to re-install.

With my Skylake build I'm mixing things up... Getting an M.2 Samsung SM951 (like $0.82/GB?) for my OS/apps drive and a little extra space for current projects, 256GB will do for now. Then I'm going with a pair of SATA 850 EVOs for games and data, got one 1TB drive already that I'll probably RAID with a second one for a 2TB volume.

I might partition that further to keep games separate but it's probably unnecessary since games and data area easier to backup. A little expensive at $0.30-0.35/GB or thereabouts but I've gotten a lot more into photography and I think it'll be worth it to keep the bulk of it on SSD, along with all games (I don't have a compulsive need to keep my entire Steam library installed tho).

Single HDD for videos and whatever doesn't fit, single external enclosure to back it all up... I keep multiple forms of off site backup tho. Any document I'm actively working on is either on Dropbox or Google drive, Amazon gives me unlimited RAW & music storage, and I keep a couple backup drives at my parent's.

If SATA SSD keep dropping in price I might eschew internal HDD entirely and just keep adding 850 EVOs or whatever's next. I do dabble in video too but not enough that I have a ton of storage need. We'll see where I'm at once I grab a 4K Panasonic mirrorless camera body later this year, the GX8 was kinda weird so I might end up with an Olympus sans 4K.

PCI-E/M.2 drives can be a big benefit if you're really into photo/video work tho, even if you aren't keeping all your data on them. Just running the OS/Photoshop/Lightroom/etc on it along with their scratch space will speed up a lot of operations, those kinda apps usually work on files in RAM and/or within scratch space anyway, not at their original location.

I'm purely an amateur tho, more hardcore user or pros wouldn't be able to live without a large array for all their ongoing projects, be it an SSD array if they've got the money to throw around or HDDs if not. PCI-E/M.2 drives are still better for your apps regardless, lower latency etc. Doesn't need to be a huge one for those purposes tho...
 
FYI he stated he has no idea on what exists and is out there and this is why he is here.

BTW I recommended to him to get a 4 bay NAS for that reason. RAID and large storage. If he can't carry a 4 bay enclosure he has more pressing issues.

other intermediate options exist like DASes. Rosewill has a cool 8 bay DAS for 300 or so. I don't know if its any good but solid options like that exist for unique work environments.

Also a NAS can work like a DAS too if designed to do so. I am trying to figure that out for my NAS

Are you seriously arguing the merits of carrying a 4 bay NAS out during a life threatening emergency? If the data is THAT important to him he should never find himself in that situation, period. There's better backup strategies.

What if the fire happens when he's not home? Or he has to bail out a window? I hope his local fireman give him a proper beat down if he ever finds himself on their ladder with a NAS under his arm... Hell, what if the NAS is in the middle of a critical op, gonna unplug it and run?

If anything, a single external drive configured to backup the most recent content should be all you grab in a scenario like that. It'd basically be for whatever hasn't been uploaded or transported elsewhere already.

Besides, he's asking about storage needs for his main rig ands you're talking about NAS... :rolleyes:

Edit: Oh and I merely suggested he needs to do some more research because posting a compendium of every form of storage tech here wouldn't be very reasonable.

He's talking about hybrid drives that basically never gained any traction while getting mSATA and M.2 mixed up, AND at the same time he's unsure how much storage he'll really need for various tasks (if he even sticks to them).
 
With my Skylake build I'm mixing things up... Getting an M.2 Samsung SM951 (like $0.82/GB?) for my OS/apps drive and a little extra space for current projects, 256GB will do for now. Then I'm going with a pair of SATA 850 EVOs for games and data,

That's how I do it too. OS & all apps on their own SSD, then games and VMs on their own SSD. Another SSD for working projects, then a 4th SSD as a media cache/scratch disk. Then everything else goes on a NAS, complete projects, storage, music, video, files, etc. It will be interesting to replace the os/apps drive with the new M.2's like the SM951.
 
That's how I do it too. OS & all apps on their own SSD, then games and VMs on their own SSD. Another SSD for working projects, then a 4th SSD as a media cache/scratch disk. Then everything else goes on a NAS, complete projects, storage, music, video, files, etc. It will be interesting to replace the os/apps drive with the new M.2's like the SM951.

Yeah, depending on how prices pan out I might add more/larger SATA SSD drives for data and eventually demote the 1TBs for games only or working files only, etc... Will be nice to get away from HDDs entirely on the main rig.

I think the industry will have to figure out the M.2/U.2/SATA Express mix before those drives really go mainstream. The only reason they even seem remotely affordable is because laptops are using them due to space constraints.

Somehow I doubt Intel would've dropped the 750 at the prices it did if it wasn't for those M.2 rockets flying around in the periphery... M.2 on the desktop seems like a kludge tho, even if I just bought an SM951.
 
Yeah, depending on how prices pan out I might add more/larger SATA SSD drives for data and eventually demote the 1TBs for games only or working files only, etc... Will be nice to get away from HDDs entirely on the main rig.

I think the industry will have to figure out the M.2/U.2/SATA Express mix before those drives really go mainstream. The only reason they even seem remotely affordable is because laptops are using them due to space constraints.

Somehow I doubt Intel would've dropped the 750 at the prices it did if it wasn't for those M.2 rockets flying around in the periphery... M.2 on the desktop seems like a kludge tho, even if I just bought an SM951.

Yeah, It's really exciting how the prices keep coming down while larger capacities just keep rolling out.
 
Are you seriously arguing the merits of carrying a 4 bay NAS out during a life threatening emergency? If the data is THAT important to him he should never find himself in that situation, period. There's better backup strategies.

What if the fire happens when he's not home? Or he has to bail out a window? I hope his local fireman give him a proper beat down if he ever finds himself on their ladder with a NAS under his arm... Hell, what if the NAS is in the middle of a critical op, gonna unplug it and run?

If anything, a single external drive configured to backup the most recent content should be all you grab in a scenario like that. It'd basically be for whatever hasn't been uploaded or transported elsewhere already.

Besides, he's asking about storage needs for his main rig ands you're talking about NAS... :rolleyes:

Edit: Oh and I merely suggested he needs to do some more research because posting a compendium of every form of storage tech here wouldn't be very reasonable.

He's talking about hybrid drives that basically never gained any traction while getting mSATA and M.2 mixed up, AND at the same time he's unsure how much storage he'll really need for various tasks (if he even sticks to them).

are you seriously saying its that big of a deal to grab a 10 pound box as you leave your house?

As i also said there are plenty of intermediate options until he can afford an ideal case. Not everyone can afford everything now. Good lord I hope you are not a project manager or over watch something that needs to be built in phases. -_-

FYI i wasn't arguing i was stating there are multiple options for choose from. Your the one getting butt hurt over this situation for some odd reason.

Besides, he is asking for stuff that isn't a good option to put all into one rig. :rolleyes: Again he asked for options. I am giving him as much info as I can so he can make an intelligent choice with knowing everything that exists. I am sorry for expecting him to have the brains to choose what will work for his needs. He explicitly asked to be educated on all the storage technology that exists since he is outdated on that knowledge. -_-

Again that's why I said in
You need to answer that before you consider anything else.

He has much research to do. I gave him some starting ground to start with and told him what exists. That is kinda the point of his thread. He doesn't even know whats out there and needs guidance on where to start. Just like when I first posted here 5 months ago not knowing that RAID now has concurrent reads -_- (Yea i was that out of date on RAID) and that a custom NAS has so many options and that even bit rot existed.

Look at the thread again and see all the info he just learned about and exists. He now knows that he is whoa-fully behind and needs to read a lot. Mission accomplished.
 
are you seriously saying its that big of a deal to grab a 10 pound box as you leave your house?

In a LIFE THREATENING situation? (which is what was being discussed) Yes, absolutely. I'm not carrying a single pound of anything unless it's another human being. Think about what you're saying for a minute, because it really makes zero sense.

A) Your life and that of others running behind you or trying to save you is worth infinitely more than 10 lbs of silicon. B) Why even put yourself in that spot? We have the technology to make that kinda scenario moot, learn it and use it.

Now if it's a kitchen fire or something tame that's another story, but we were talking about buildings burning down completely. Hell, in that situation if I see an idiot carrying 10 pounds of anything in front of me I'm knocking it off his hands and/or pushing him along.

I'm not the least bit butt hurt btw, maybe you're mis interpreting my tone or something, it happens. Maybe you're projecting? I embrace arguments tho, I don't shy away from them. Intelligent debate is usually a net gain.

I manage my own business too, tho that's neither here nor there, you're taking the OP's thread wildly off topic now with personal attacks and other matters that have little to do with his rig's storage.
 
Last edited:
In a LIFE THREATENING situation? (which is what was being discussed) Yes, absolutely. I'm not carrying a single pound of anything unless it's another human being. Think about what you're saying for a minute, because it really makes zero sense.

A) Your life and that of others running behind you or trying to save you is worth infinitely more than 10 lbs of silicon. B) Why even put yourself in that spot? We have the technology to make that kinda scenario moot, learn it and use it.

Meh i disagree. That 10 pounds holds a lot of value and I will gladly run into a fire burning building for many reasons family, computer, paperwork, dogs, and what not. Most fires are not instantly flash fires or blazing (use common sense if fire is blazing or not. If its blazing well then your screwed). They start slowly and build and you usually notice when its in the early stages.

FYI firefighter normally don't go into burning buildings for any reason. They let it burn and whoever is in there especially under certain cases. House's built with certain types of wood instantly make it a no go for firefighters. They won't go in even if there is a person. I forget the wood. Its some cheap wood that lights really easy.

I also live in a house and not whatever weird scenario you are thinking. There wouldn't be another person and I bet no one would be moving faster than me even with grabbing my stuff.

We just have different views on risks. If its not blazing and I have ample time I'll gladly grab my stuff. I have been in worse situations so I wouldn't care.

The only fast spreading fires are with accelerants. Those are either set by someone or something broke like a gas line.
 
Houses are by and large built out of concrete here, and maybe I watch too many firefighter shows on TV, my point about what you're carrying out stands tho... And I've dealt with loss from fire on a personal level, my grandparent's apartment burnt down due to a cigarette bud from my idiot uncle.

No one was in any really danger, not like it made me touchy on the subject or anything, my uncle ran out shoeless and in his boxers but he was just being dumb start to finish; and yeah, they mostly let it burn and doused it. Firefighters probably caused as much water damage as the fire did in burned stuff...

The insurance stuff on the other side is a nightmare tho, and recovering things after firefighters had their way with them is equally terrible... Stuff that isn't burned down is water logged and even the stuff that escapes those two can end up tossed out a window or axed as they look for embers.

I can imagine the insurance company having a field day if they can establish someone lingered around to drag out 10lbs worth of equipment. Regardless, you're still taking things out of their original context where the guy mentioned an entire building burning down and my comments regarding that still stand.

There's just no reason to be dragging things out, there's a reason firefighters don't unless there is a life in danger, and unless you've been in a burning building I'm not sure you can really say what you would or wouldn't risk. The whole premise seems idiotic given the number of cloud and off site backup options we have.

Edit: I'm talking about the "weird" scenario the OP finds himself in btw, from the start he said building. Not sure when you decided this was about your house. Mine wouldn't even burn down and fire would pretty much never travel outside a single room, this thread ain't about you or me tho, or wasn't... :eek:
 
I

I guess I can start with 2TB for the essential/important stuff. I just want to be able to grab a drive with ease in case of emergency. Building next to me burned down and I need safety even before I investigate a NAS. What would work best between my initial build and a NAS if a NAS is the way to go?
Get an external hard drive as an interim solution. That's still far better than having nothing or using the motherboard's built-in RAID.

I'll be gaming as well as editing on this build. After I recover from the first build, financially, I may separate it and have a gaming and editing PC. My gaming PC is going to be a power hog and editing can take hours. If/When I build an editing PC, I'll want to make it quieter and less power hungry. But I won't do all that until 6 months to a year MINIMUM after my initial build.
With a 5K budget, you can do all three dude.

Gaming PC:
$330 - Intel Core i7-4790K CPU
$154 - MSI Z97 Gaming 5 Intel Z97 ATX Motherboard
$80 - Kingston HyperX FURY HX316C10FK2/16 2x8GB DDR3 1600 RAM
$500 - eVGA 04G-P4-2983-KR GTX 980 4GB PCI-E Video Card
$170 - Crucial BX100 500GB SSD
$90 - Toshiba 3TB Hard Drive
$130 - eVGA SuperNOVA 750G2 750W Modular PSU
$100 - Phanteks Enthoo Pro Full Tower Case
$31 - Cooler Master Hyper 212 Evo HSF
$100 - Windows 10 Home 64bit
---
Total: $1769

Editing PC:
$390 - Intel Core i7 5820K CPU
$211 - AsRock X99 Extreme4 LGA 2011-v3 Intel X99 ATX Motherboard
$170 - Crucial CT4K8G4DFD8213 4 x 8GB DDR4 2133 RAM
$110 - MSI N750TI-2GD5/OC GeForce GTX 750 Ti 2GB PCI-E Video Card
$170 - Crucial BX100 500GB SSD
$85 - Crucial BX100 250GB SSD (Scratch disk)
$90 - Toshiba 3TB Hard Drive
$84 - Seasonic G Series SSR-550RM 550W Modular PSU
$47 - Scythe SCKTT-1000 HSF
$124 - Fractal Design Define R5 Black ATX Case
$100 - Windows 10 Home 64bit
----
Total: $1581

NAS:
$90 - AMD A10-5800K APU
$64 - Gigabyte GA-F2A88XM-D3H AMD A88X mATX Motherboard
$80 - Kingston HyperX FURY HX316C10FK2/16 2x8GB DDR3 1600 RAM
$26 - Mushkin Enhanced Ventura Pro 32GB USB 3.0 Flash Drive (For OS)
$360 - 4 x Toshiba 3TB Hard Drive
$84 - Seasonic G Series SSR-550RM 550W Modular PSU
$50 - NZXT Source 210 Elite White with Black Front Trim ATX Case
---
Total: $754

Grand Total: $4104 plus tax and shipping.

The gaming PC is already setup for a future SLI setup and will outperform the editing setup in games even with the same GPUs. However, the editing setup can already do a far better job of editing than the gaming PC while being significantly quieter. For the NAS, I was assuming that you were going to use FreeNAS for the OS so the build is oriented towards that. With the NAS' 4 x 3TB drives, you're looking at 6TB of available space in a RAIDZ2 array (for large RAID arrays, two parity disks are highly recommended). Both the NAS case and the editing PC case can hold up to 8 hard drives so you have plenty of room for future storage expansion.

Of course pricing is subject to change between now and whenever you plan on building and you should probably be getting the Skylake platform for the gaming PC but the point is that for under $4500, you can accomplish all three of your goals while maximizing performance and performance per dollar.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Houses are by and large built out of concrete here, and maybe I watch too many firefighter shows on TV, my point about what you're carrying out stands tho... And I've dealt with loss from fire on a personal level, my grandparent's apartment burnt down due to a cigarette bud from my idiot uncle.

No one was in any really danger, not like it made me touchy on the subject or anything, my uncle ran out shoeless and in his boxers but he was just being dumb start to finish; and yeah, they mostly let it burn and doused it. Firefighters probably caused as much water damage as the fire did in burned stuff...

The insurance stuff on the other side is a nightmare tho, and recovering things after firefighters had their way with them is equally terrible... Stuff that isn't burned down is water logged and even the stuff that escapes those two can end up tossed out a window or axed as they look for embers.

I can imagine the insurance company having a field day if they can establish someone lingered around to drag out 10lbs worth of equipment. Regardless, you're still taking things out of their original context where the guy mentioned an entire building burning down and my comments regarding that still stand.

There's just no reason to be dragging things out, there's a reason firefighters don't unless there is a life in danger, and unless you've been in a burning building I'm not sure you can really say what you would or wouldn't risk. The whole premise seems idiotic given the number of cloud and off site backup options we have.

Edit: I'm talking about the "weird" scenario the OP finds himself in btw, from the start he said building. Not sure when you decided this was about your house. Mine wouldn't even burn down and fire would pretty much never travel outside a single room, this thread ain't about you or me tho, or wasn't... :eek:

correction. You are the one that brought this up. I just mentioned an option was to have something small like a 4 bay storage. You are the one that had some hay day going off topic like it was blasphemy that anyone would dare grab a 10 pound box. Again I provided him another possible option and a house is a building FYI holy fuck. You seriously have issue with this topic and do take it personal even though you claim not to. You literally don't give up on the topic and go on and on. I just provided some options and examples and you lost it plain and simple.
 
Ok, what about ditching HDD's/Hybrid HDD's and just start throwing in SSD's such as Samsung 850 Pro 1 TB? I'm considering moving away from my Rampage V Extreme, but which ever motherboard I choose, it will support multiple internal drives.

Are HDD's preferable over SSD's for important data? My mobo will most likely support USB 3.1 Type C, Thunderbolt, and/or USB 3.0. What are the transfer speeds/times going from an internal SATA3 to an external USB 3.0/3.1 storage device?

Would using all internal SSD's and frequently syncing specific folders to an external storage device(s) alternating the external device(s) each day or so be advisable?
 
Last edited:
correction. You are the one that brought this up. I just mentioned an option was to have something small like a 4 bay storage. You are the one that had some hay day going off topic like it was blasphemy that anyone would dare grab a 10 pound box. Again I provided him another possible option and a house is a building FYI holy fuck. You seriously have issue with this topic and do take it personal even though you claim not to. You literally don't give up on the topic and go on and on. I just provided some options and examples and you lost it plain and simple.

A building is usually used to refer to multi story structures, and the only one that has indulged in personal attacks and thread hijack is you sir. Save the psychobabble for someone that cares.

I still say that carrying out a NAS box in the middle of a fire isn't a smart idea and you failed to every address all the other issues with that logic (something as simple as not being home...).

Not sure where I "lost it" but I'm not the only one that recommended a simple external drive either.
 
Ok, what about ditching HDD's/Hybrid HDD's and just start throwing in SSD's such as Samsung 850 Pro 1 TB? I'm considering moving away from my Rampage V Extreme, but which ever motherboard I choose, it will support multiple internal drives.

Are HDD's preferable over SSD's for important data? My mobo will most likely support USB 3.1 Type C, Thunderbolt, and/or USB 3.0. What are the transfer speeds/times going from an internal SATA3 to an external USB 3.0/3.1 storage device?

Would using all internal SSD's and frequently syncing specific folders to an external storage device(s) alternating the external device(s) each day or so be advisable?

Not sure why you keep mentioning hybrid HDDs, they were only a thing for a very brief period and never really caught on, by the time they were decent the concept was already kind of irrelevant. Nothing wrong with going all in on SSD if you have the money for it, just depends what you're trying to do.

The builds Dangman posted look pretty dang good to me btw, although I'd question whether you really need separate gaming/editing builds, specially if you're just starting out... A good SATA SSD shouldn't be bottlenecked during large sequential transfers over USB 3.0 (specially to an enclosure that supports UASP).

Mixed writes with smaller files might be a touch slower but not too bad... An M.2/PCI-E drive would be bottlenecked since they can reach read speeds that are 4x higher. Why are ya asking tho? If you're using a HDD as an external drive then the drive itself is gonna be the weakest link.

Not sure what usage case you might be thinking of for an external SSD... A cheap HDD is fine for most basic backup duties, alternating it with a second one can make it easier to keep one off site indeed. Ultimately how often you backup is a pretty subjective thing, only you can attach any real value to your data.
 
Not quite true about the SSHDs Impulse.

Even now, Hybrid drives (at least solutions like Seagate's) are a nice way to give a system a little performance when your ability to add drives is limited/nonexistent and CAPACITY is still an issue.

On the desktop side, you can get 4TB SSHDs.

On the laptop side, you're limited to 1TB (whose capacity is within SSD range). But a 1TB drive costs $80, where even the cheapest 1TB SSD is roughly 4x the price.

As for Western Digital's "software SSHDs"? STAY THE FUCK AWAY! I've been a WD guy for hard drives for years. And even I knew enough to run the hell away from their idiotic driver-based hybrid drives.
 
Not quite true about the SSHDs Impulse.

Even now, Hybrid drives (at least solutions like Seagate's) are a nice way to give a system a little performance when your ability to add drives is limited/nonexistent and CAPACITY is still an issue.

On the desktop side, you can get 4TB SSHDs.

On the laptop side, you're limited to 1TB (whose capacity is within SSD range). But a 1TB drive costs $80, where even the cheapest 1TB SSD is roughly 4x the price.

As for Western Digital's "software SSHDs"? STAY THE FUCK AWAY! I've been a WD guy for hard drives for years. And even I knew enough to run the hell away from their idiotic driver-based hybrid drives.

I'll concede that on certain laptops ands low budget scenarios they might make sense, better than a regular HDD for a small premium... Pretty irrelevant for the kind of build he's planning tho. The Seagate hybrids have basically been the same thing since inception anyway, just took them a few revs to get the cache to the size it should've been to begin with.
 
Ok, what about ditching HDD's/Hybrid HDD's and just start throwing in SSD's such as Samsung 850 Pro 1 TB? I'm considering moving away from my Rampage V Extreme, but which ever motherboard I choose, it will support multiple internal drives.

Are HDD's preferable over SSD's for important data? My mobo will most likely support USB 3.1 Type C, Thunderbolt, and/or USB 3.0. What are the transfer speeds/times going from an internal SATA3 to an external USB 3.0/3.1 storage device?

Would using all internal SSD's and frequently syncing specific folders to an external storage device(s) alternating the external device(s) each day or so be advisable?

Yes HDDs are preferable if you can afford to buy a large number of drives due to redundancy. The transfer speeds/times is mainly limited by the HDD speed/array at that point.

No as I highly doubt you need that level of performance.
 
Yes HDDs are preferable if you can afford to buy a large number of drives due to redundancy. The transfer speeds/times is mainly limited by the HDD speed/array at that point.

No as I highly doubt you need that level of performance.

additionally using HDDs in that can be a bad idea because if you are regularly resaving a GB file or doing back and forth moves that eats up write cycles.

If i understand this corretly (Dangman or Dan correct me please if i am wrong) If you control s on a 1GB file it should rewrite the whole thing right? So if your using let us say a 300MB PSD file and click save 10 times it just used 3GB of writes correct?

If i am correct that will eat writes like crazy.
 
I would do the multiple machines, when the editor is rendering, you can use the gaming machine to edit something else, do some photoshop, or play some games.

For the editing part, do you plan on one monitor or multi monitor?
I recommend multi screens if you use lower res monitors, you can get by with a 34" 3440x1440 ultrawide as a single, but a 4K monitor would be the best for a single monitor workstation, you'll have a lot of real estate to maximize your workflow.

I have a triple setup on my old editor which is now used as a file server,
editor-2010.jpg


and I have the 34" LG on my gaming and editing machine,
editor-2015.jpg
 
Last edited:
additionally using HDDs in that can be a bad idea because if you are regularly resaving a GB file or doing back and forth moves that eats up write cycles.

If i understand this corretly (Dangman or Dan correct me please if i am wrong) If you control s on a 1GB file it should rewrite the whole thing right? So if your using let us say a 300MB PSD file and click save 10 times it just used 3GB of writes correct?

If i am correct that will eat writes like crazy.

That's only true if you assume the program rewrites the entire file each time it's saved (not the norm), and even then it depends on how the file is organised logically by the drive's controller...

You may have an undue amount of angst about SSD longevity, possibly stemming from whatever odd workflow you backed yourself into with your current setup.

Regardless, the average drive is equipped to handle an order of magnitude more than 3GB of writes per day for years on end before it's dead, and dead only means it can't write anymore, it'll still be readable.

I know you're also tallying a lot more than that per day yourself, but that's a different story altogether.
 
I would do the multiple machines, when the editor is rendering, you can use the gaming machine to edit something else, do some photoshop, or play some games.

For the editing part, do you plan on one monitor or multi monitor?
I recommend multi screens if you use lower res monitors, you can get by with a 34" 3440x1440 ultrawide as a single, but a 4K monitor would be the best for a single monitor workstation, you'll have a lot of real estate to maximize your workflow.

I have a triple setup on my old editor which is now used as a file server,
SNIP

and I have the 34" LG on my gaming and editing machine,
SNIP

Nice setup, are you pining to move up to a larger 4K display from your 34"? (since you suggested it'd be better) I'm holding unto my 3x U2412M for now, largely because I can't quite figure out what I'd actually like instead...

On the one hand I use them in PPP mode relatively often and a large (40"+) 4K display would be roughly equivalent... OTOH I go sit in front of a 42" TV and even ignoring the res limitations I can't imagine sitting in front of that full time, heh. Good displays are definitely an investment tho, it'll outlast a lot of other things in a build.

Anyway, two builds makes sense if the OP is fully committed to the projects he's dreaming up, but it wouldn't hurt to start with one and go from there IMO... Could just go X99 and take the gaming cards out later.
 
Last edited:
I don't edit much anymore, stopped shooting wedding and events in 2013 due to my hips starting to fail. Both hips totally failed last year, right one in June and left one in December, so I don't do much of anything nowadays, and am so broke that I won't be upgrading anything for quite some time. :(
 
I don't edit much anymore, stopped shooting wedding and events in 2013 due to my hips starting to fail. Both hips totally failed last year, right one in June and left one in December, so I don't do much of anything nowadays, and am so broke that I won't be upgrading anything for quite some time. :(

Oh! So sorry to hear that man. :( At least you've got some nice hardware to keep ya entertained...
 
Regardless, the average drive is equipped to handle an order of magnitude more than 3GB of writes per day for years on end before it's dead, and dead only means it can't write anymore, it'll still be readable.

Ah you have to be very careful here.. Once you start getting reallocated sectors you should STOP ALL writes to the drive and put it into read only mode. Intel drives especially will DIE after it hits a certain amount of data writes and other drives also suicide themselves when they get too many errors and run out of replacement blocks to allocate. I have not seen a single drive that just stops and still allows you to read the data. That is how good software would behave but no one has actually tested them at those points. I am sure its bugs that cause a lot of the problems, But unless you know you have a drive that will not DIE.. You should keep tabs..
 
Ah you have to be very careful here.. Once you start getting reallocated sectors you should STOP ALL writes to the drive and put it into read only mode. Intel drives especially will DIE after it hits a certain amount of data writes and other drives also suicide themselves when they get too many errors and run out of replacement blocks to allocate. I have not seen a single drive that just stops and still allows you to read the data. That is how good software would behave but no one has actually tested them at those points. I am sure its bugs that cause a lot of the problems, But unless you know you have a drive that will not DIE.. You should keep tabs..

i currently have 72 relocationed sectors but it says that is only 3% of available free space. I have HD sentinel watching it for me. I have a weekly back up of it so I should be alright. I need a damn NVMe drive to replace this thats 1 TB.
 
Back
Top