MW2 Something "YOU" should know

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bamboo

Gawd
Joined
Oct 8, 2004
Messages
901
Let me start out by saying this not about deicated servers and turning our rigs into nintendos.

This is about Morality.

http://www.56.com/u82/v_NDcyODkxNTk.html

The above video is an exerpt from the MW2 single player campain. In it you play as a terrorist walking through the airport killing civilians. It is some pretty graffic sick shit for a game.

Maybe I am old but, isn't this disrespectful to the people who have lost their lives in terrorist attacks and the police and soldiers of "ALL COUNTRIES" who risk or have lost their lives preventing this type of shit.

It is a video game I understand that but, watch the video it's really fucked up. I fortunatley/unfortunately have worked in several jobs my life where this shit is no joke. I've seen death up close and personal on several occasions(no I'm not a medical guy). Maybe this just hit a sore spot because they are killing innocent civilians.

This just bums me out even more because, when I log into a game and start shredding fools. I want it to be ...I don't know, killing anything but mom, dad, shelly and timmy going to visit grandma for Christmas.

I don't know. I'll probably reread this and wish I had changed some shit around or not said something.

Either way, I posted the video so you can make a choice. I'm sure most people don't give a fuck. That's fine. That's why Free countries are so great. I guess.

Take care


Disclaimer: No I don't think the game should be censored and nobody is going to use this as a training aid to being an active shooter in an airport.

Edit: I can't spell
 
Last edited:
the video doesn't even load, and it connects to some weird Chinese site ..

hopefully there is nothing wrong with the site :confused:
 
The media will have a field day with this. I can see the headlines now "Murder Simulator, Terrorist Training Brainwashing Videogame 2009"

Personally, I do not find it offensive whatsoever because I can draw the distinction from a videogame and real life.
 
i see what you mean, but its just a game, it's rated M for a reason, so only mature people who can discern between game and reality should play it, that's why we have the ESRB...its no worse then running around in GTA shooting grandmas, and hijacking helicopters and kamikazing them into building/people/whatever you can find. Point is, ITS JUST A GAME ! stop over analyzing it, if you dont like, dont play it. simple as that
 
i see what you mean, but its just a game, it's rated M for a reason, so only mature people who can discern between game and reality should play it, that's why we have the ESRB...its no worse then running around in GTA shooting grandmas, and hijacking helicopters and kamikazing them into building/people/whatever you can find. Point is, ITS JUST A GAME ! stop over analyzing it, if you dont like, dont play it. simple as that

I totally agree with it being just a game. I do believe people should be aware of this though so they can make a choice.

In the long run my opinion is just that. An opinion.

Take care
 
I remember people making a big deal about killing innocent civilians during the WoW Death Knight quests as well.

It's just a game. Get over it.
 
I remember people making a big deal about killing innocent civilians during the WoW Death Knight quests as well.

It's just a game. Get over it.

Indeed, and people bitch about Red Orchestra 2: Heroes of Stalingrad having a German campaign and how they can't fathom playing a evil Nazi shooting at their grand pappy in a single player setting but it's perfectly okay in multiplayer. :rolleyes:
 
Hi, Captain Sensative here.

Time to man up and eat crow. The fricken thing looks so good it caught me off guard. The people crawl when they are wounded. You can blast the one dude as he tries to drag his wife to safety. The people are running from you. My god....that's freakin evil.

Did I over react yeah probably.

Do I agree with it? I don't exactly have a hardon to pretend I'm Jihad Jimmy and kill civilian families in an airport.

Would I still buy it if they had dedicated servers? .....yeah
 
I'm at work therefore I cannot see the video but if this is true then it only reinforces the fact that I wasn't going to purchase it for the small ISP I am running but I also won't be purchasing it for my son.

Yeah, it is just a game, but this is going to far, IMO.
 
too bad it's all scripted otherwise it would have been really cool.
Yeah I'm heartless
 
it's messed up in a way... but yea, I'd play it...

if you can't get over that something is a game/movie and not real then you need help. People that complain about this stuff are the same people who are making the world into one big padded cell. People need to start using their damn brains again.
 
i see what you mean, but its just a game, it's rated M for a reason, so only mature people who can discern between game and reality should play it, that's why we have the ESRB...its no worse then running around in GTA shooting grandmas, and hijacking helicopters and kamikazing them into building/people/whatever you can find. Point is, ITS JUST A GAME ! stop over analyzing it, if you dont like, dont play it. simple as that

I somewhat agree, however according to ESRB "Mature" simple means your of legal age. Taking into account the mentally unstable people in the world brings a whole new layer to this.

However most can discern between games and reality
 
There are novels out there with the same stuff, but since people don't read nowadays, they don't complain. I find it a little short sighted as well. I am not affected by it really. It's fiction, and I don't find anything wrong with fiction from the context of a terrorist, murderer, whatever. It's not a stab at terrorist victims at all, how can you jump to that so quickly or even at all?
 
I somewhat agree, however according to ESRB "Mature" simple means your of legal age. Taking into account the mentally unstable people in the world brings a whole new layer to this.

However most can discern between games and reality

It's not crackpots with games you need to worry about...it's crackpots with guns/explosives you need to worry about.
 
Its a part of war/life, unfortunately. In the first game they started out by driving a president (I think) through a city then they shoot him in the head on national TV. People get shot every day, terrorists are still actively strapping bombs to their chests and detonating in residential areas.
 
Let me know when they have this video at a non-Chinese webpage that actually loads the video, then I'll believe it is legit.
 
I don’t think it's apropos to to give the rating "Mature Audiences" the green light for anything and allything. It's the same as saying you can shout anything because of "Free Speech." We know that's untrue based on the unspoken 'line' we all follow, however wavy it may be from person to person.

What do we gain from placing a highly detailed simulated experience like this in the game? Does the game benefit? Could the developers have put their time and energy into something else which would have been just as affective in conveying their experience?

It comes down to a matter of taste and principals, we as a society are only as strong as the things we let others get away with. If we think it's okay to play as a terrorist and not show our civil disagreement then tomorrow it may be ok to do something worse to which we will let others get away with. How far will we need to go before we've jumped the 'thats f'd up' shark as a society?

~Versius
 
Last edited:
I don’t think it's apropos to to give the rating "Mature Audiences" the green light for anything and allything. It's the same as saying you can shout anything because of "Free Speech." We know that's untrue based on the unspoken 'line' we all follow, however wavy it may be from person to person.

What do we gain from placing a highly detailed simulated experience like this in the game? Does the game benefit? Could the developers have put their time and energy into something else which would have been just as affective in conveying their experience?

It comes down to a matter of taste and principals, we as a society are only as strong as the things we let others get away with. If we think it's okay to play as a terrorist and not show our civil disagreement then tomorrow it may be ok to do something worse to which we will let others get away with. How far will we need to go before we've jumped the 'thats f'd up' shark as a society?

~Versius

I don't think it is your position to decide what is too far for me. If you don't like it then avoid it. Every adult should be permitted to make their own choices and live as they choose so long as their actions do not cause harm to others. Videogames are becoming a modern form of media and they are pushing social boundries. Just like literature, music, and movies before them, videogames are becoming more than a form of entertainment. They are evolving into a new method of conveying social commentarty and making the player think about their world, government, and morals.

Stating that games with scenes like this are solely about killing and violence is equivilent to saying Animal Farm was just about talking animals living on a farm. It misses the whole point. While like most people here, I haven't played MW2, if it is anything like the first one, then you can make one assumption about this level. It is made to make you uneasy, and made to make you think.

Anyone who remembers the gunship level or the nuke explosion in the original game remembers that these scenes weren't some glorified stylized scenes of violence. They were levels that made you think. The brutality of both was severe, but it wasn't glorified. It was hard and cold. I personally, felt very uneasy after playing through those levels. Speaking with friends about them we would devulge into conversations on the harshness of what was experienced and began to relate that to how a nuclear explosion would affect our world, or the morality and the effect of fighting wars on a tv screen in the case of the gunship, removed from the human element.

So to answer your question, what do we gain? We gain the ability to spur thought and discussion about a brutal and horrible occorance that happens all over the world. We gain the ability to realize how horrid these acts are. With videogames the point can be conveyed much more effectively than just reading about the latest bombing. And hopefully, we gain a few more people discussing a very real probelm in the world because the experince, like books, movies and music before it, spurred thought. If as a society we turn a blind eye to distasteful or unpleasant subjects, our world will take a turn for the worse very fast. Ignorance, infact, is not bliss.
 
I don't think it is your position to decide what is too far for me. If you don't like it then avoid it. Every adult should be permitted to make their own choices and live as they choose so long as their actions do not cause harm to others. Videogames are becoming a modern form of media and they are pushing social boundries. Just like literature, music, and movies before them, videogames are becoming more than a form of entertainment. They are evolving into a new method of conveying social commentarty and making the player think about their world, government, and morals.

Stating that games with scenes like this are solely about killing and violence is equivilent to saying Animal Farm was just about talking animals living on a farm. It misses the whole point. While like most people here, I haven't played MW2, if it is anything like the first one, then you can make one assumption about this level. It is made to make you uneasy, and made to make you think.

Anyone who remembers the gunship level or the nuke explosion in the original game remembers that these scenes weren't some glorified stylized scenes of violence. They were levels that made you think. The brutality of both was severe, but it wasn't glorified. It was hard and cold. I personally, felt very uneasy after playing through those levels. Speaking with friends about them we would devulge into conversations on the harshness of what was experienced and began to relate that to how a nuclear explosion would affect our world, or the morality and the effect of fighting wars on a tv screen in the case of the gunship, removed from the human element.

So to answer your question, what do we gain? We gain the ability to spur thought and discussion about a brutal and horrible occorance that happens all over the world. We gain the ability to realize how horrid these acts are. With videogames the point can be conveyed much more effectively than just reading about the latest bombing. And hopefully, we gain a few more people discussing a very real probelm in the world because the experince, like books, movies and music before it, spurred thought. If as a society we turn a blind eye to distasteful or unpleasant subjects, our world will take a turn for the worse very fast. Ignorance, infact, is not bliss.

Before videogames it were:
TV
Heavy Metal
Rock
Radio
Jazz
Comics

Some people will always fear new stuff..and miss the forest for trees ;)
 
I don’t think it's apropos to to give the rating "Mature Audiences" the green light for anything and allything. It's the same as saying you can shout anything because of "Free Speech." We know that's untrue based on the unspoken 'line' we all follow, however wavy it may be from person to person.

Needing to make a seperate comment on this because I believe this statement is extremely dangerous and narrowminded.

I'd just like to point out, it used to be against social norms and against that "unspoken line" to say that a black man was equal to a white man, that a woman should be able to vote, or that gay people should have a right to marry. Now all that has changed or is in the process of changing because there were people who crossed that line and said what they felt was right. The world is transformed by thinkers who are willing to say what people are not comfortable with.
 
Seriously? There are games much more gory and horrific...9/11 didnt even involve a shooting in airports whatsoever so I really find this someone trying to make a thin connection.

Its a game...
 
Media will not always invoke the same response in people. That's how it always has been and how it always should be. The people saying that this is only a game should feel lucky that they have the luxury of looking at such a thing and not have it illicit a negative feeling.
 
It's a fragging game...get over it.

/thread

Whew, thankfully you are here to clear that one up or we'd all be confused still...

I'm actually with the OP on this one. I'm not a LEO nor soldier and I know that IW is going for a "realism factor" and such but I'm sure they could have made a great game and still have omitted this part. In the 1st game yeah, you are in the shoes of the president guy and you get assassinated, but it was more of a 1st person video clip with you taking no actions. Now in this game you're supposed to start shooting innocent people? It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I know similar situations have been done in the GTA games and I'm not looking for some connection between 9/11 and MW2 but it's still a little too close to home for me.

I'm still buying the game but if there's any way to skip over that part I will do so.
 
Whew, thankfully you are here to clear that one up or we'd all be confused still...

I'm actually with the OP on this one. I'm not a LEO nor soldier and I know that IW is going for a "realism factor" and such but I'm sure they could have made a great game and still have omitted this part. In the 1st game yeah, you are in the shoes of the president guy and you get assassinated, but it was more of a 1st person video clip with you taking no actions. Now in this game you're supposed to start shooting innocent people? It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I know similar situations have been done in the GTA games and I'm not looking for some connection between 9/11 and MW2 but it's still a little too close to home for me.

I'm still buying the game but if there's any way to skip over that part I will do so.


I am a fomer soldier and veteran and I can tell you:
Stop claming that Modern Ware II is about "realism"...it's a console-port...for a younger audience.
Stop taking my FREEDOM as hostage, just because you are a wuzz and can't seperate fiction from reality.

And BTW:
You are not supposed to shot innocent people in the game...you shoots PIXELS!
It's a fragging game...get over it.

/thread.
 
I'm not saying it should be in the game or not, but these comments of 'its just a game' or 'its rated M for mature' etc are just easy ways to brush aside the topic. You can't say it's 'just a game' anymore when you support that video games are becoming more of an art form and social statement. The two don't go hand in hand. You're writing them off as play in one hand and elevating them to something grander in the other.

If we want to allow Developers to include content like this there shouldn't be anything wrong with it, but what guarantee do we have that only those whom are mentally able to handle the maturity rating be able to play it? Kids cannot handle these scenes and discuss them maturely (like mentioned above) any better than I could handle Murphy getting shot up in Robocop at too early an age.

As a legal adult yes I have the choice to support the developer by either purchasing the game or not. I do not have the right to tell you not to buy the game. I do wish adults stood on their principals and voted with their money more often though. It's the lack of commercial representation that assures a corporation they can go one step further.

Disclosure: I won't be buying the game. Not because of some philosophical hang-up but because MW2 = Mechwarrior 2 and anything else is just silly.

~Versius
 
I keep seeing "get over it" mentioned.

I guess as a consumer, I don't buy stuff to "get over" it's flaws that it has, and in my own opinion this is a flaw.

If this is in fact in the game, I will probably pass on it. And no, I don't worry that it will turn me into a fool that will carry out those actions, but it's bad taste in my own personal opinion.

I can also at the same time respect those of you that find nothing wrong with it and your own justification that it is simply nothing more than a game.
 
The above video is an exerpt from the MW2 single player campain. In it you play as a terrorist walking through the airport killing civilians. It is some pretty graffic sick shit for a game.

I can't ****ing wait to play this game with my kids. This is going to rock so friggin hard!
 
I am a fomer soldier and veteran and I can tell you:
Stop claming that Modern Ware II is about "realism"...it's a console-port...for a younger audience.
Stop taking my FREEDOM as hostage, just because you are a wuzz and can't seperate fiction from reality.

And BTW:
You are not supposed to shot innocent people in the game...you shoots PIXELS!
It's a fragging game...get over it.

/thread.

Thank you for your service. Now, where did I mention taking your freedoms hostage? Because I said I don't like it in the game? That's a personal preference and I agree with the OP, people need to know if it's in the game as some of people are going to be opposed to it. Did I say I'm going to be rioting in the streets and petitioning to have IW closed? No.

And I have no problems separating fiction and reality but when even fiction can be disturbing.
 
I just watched the video on another site, and I am reserving judgment until it is official and seen in context. On its face, it does appear to be in very poor taste, but none of us know what the real story is at this point.

It sure seems like IW is taking every opportunity to tempt fate (No DS, 3rd Person mode, this, etc.) here on a sequel to a huge game. If this video is legit, they will be getting ass blasted in the media on the left and right.
 
I don't see a huge difference between watching a movie where a terrorists shoots innocents, and a game where you spend one short part of a level shooting innocents.

Has anyone in this thread ever played a GTA game?
 
I don't see a huge difference between watching a movie where a terrorists shoots innocents, and a game where you spend one short part of a level shooting innocents.

Has anyone in this thread ever played a GTA game?

Passive observer versus active participant is a big difference.

Even though they both involve innocent civilians, Grand Theft Auto is not comparable to playing a realistic encounter as a terrorist. In GTA, you don't have to kill civilians. This is seemingly forcing you to do so.
 
Let me start out by saying this not about deicated servers and turning our rigs into nintendos.

This is about Morality.

http://www.56.com/u82/v_NDcyODkxNTk.html

The above video is an exerpt from the MW2 single player campain. In it you play as a terrorist walking through the airport killing civilians. It is some pretty graffic sick shit for a game.

Maybe I am old but, isn't this disrespectful to the people who have lost their lives in terrorist attacks and the police and soldiers of "ALL COUNTRIES" who risk or have lost their lives preventing this type of shit.

It is a video game I understand that but, watch the video it's really fucked up. I fortunatley/unfortunately have worked in several jobs my life where this shit is no joke. I've seen death up close and personal on several occasions(no I'm not a medical guy). Maybe this just hit a sore spot because they are killing innocent civilians.

This just bums me out even more because, when I log into a game and start shredding fools. I want it to be ...I don't know, killing anything but mom, dad, shelly and timmy going to visit grandma for Christmas.

I don't know. I'll probably reread this and wish I had changed some shit around or not said something.

Either way, I posted the video so you can make a choice. I'm sure most people don't give a fuck. That's fine. That's why Free countries are so great. I guess.

Take care


Disclaimer: No I don't think the game should be censored and nobody is going to use this as a training aid to being an active shooter in an airport.

Edit: I can't spell

I think the intention of the game is to prevent this kind of stuff from happening (in-game). Someone's a terrorist and someone's counter-terrorist. Any game where you shoot and kill people can have the same thing said about them. I can shoot whatever they were in Crysis or Germans in earlier Call of Duty(s); I can beat up and kill civilians in Grand Theft Auto...this is really no different. I've played SWAT games and Rainbow Six Vegas; both of which imply terrorists are trying to kill innocent people. I know they don't show it, but it's implied. I don't have a problem with making the game "realistic". My mom used to see parts of war movies or cop movies where people are getting shot and shot at and there are a lot of expletives and she'd say she didn't think they needed to talk like that. But I don't think it's realistic to get shot and here someone say, "Awww, dang it." The bad guys are being bad; you go in and stop them; point of the game.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top