MSI R4870 MD1G @ [H]

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,701
MSI R4870 MD1G - MSI is back under the spotlight with a slick new video card with a sleek new cooler. MSI claims a 20 degree temperature reduction on this Radeon HD 4870 1GB, but is that accurate or just a lot of hot air? We'll find out exactly what potential buyers can expect out of this low-priced dynamo!

Today, we know that the MSI R4870 MD1G is a solid performer with an efficient and quiet cooling device, and it comes in at a price that is easy to swallow. In short, it is a good value. If the GeForce GTX 260 was not cheaper, the R4870 MD1G would be a fantastic value.
 
I'd be interested to see how this card affects the temperatures of other components inside a case. The card is still making over 100 watts as heat, regardless of what cooling solution is used. Sure, the exhaust temperature is lower, but its also dumping the heat right back into the case instead of out the back. My GPU may be 10 degrees cooler, but my CPU, chipset, and hard drives may go up 5 each.

I could open up all 4 ports on a fire hydrant and tell you that the water is coming out slower on than on a hydrant that only has 2 ports open. Each individual port will have less flow, but the combined output is the same (or more, if you want to get technical).

MSI seems to be borrowing from Peter to pay Paul.

EDIT: Changed watts
 
No, it's not. Power ratings are listed in big letters "(Total System Wattage At Wall)"

The card itself can't be more than about 200w draw, judging by the load numbers and no-video card draw (although I'd think that's got to be idle). Whatever the case whether it's a bit higher or lower than 200w, not all of it is given off as heat. It's the excess power due to inefficiency, leakage, etc that gets given off in the form of heat.

And I really think such a card wouldn't make a huge difference in case/system temps. If it does your case cooling sucks. Besides, I don't think you can really compare a [H] bench to an "ordinary" user. AFAIK, most testers, including here use open-air benches, not an actual case.

Sure, I like funnel style exhaust coolers, but I'd take a quieter, better performing cooler over the heat exhaust any day. If case cooling is bad enough to be highly affected by such a card, a slow and "silent" 120mm should be enough to offset the difference.
 
Could it be that this Radeon 4870 achieves lower load power by using lower voltage on the core or the RAM? That would explain why the overclocking results are so poor.
 
As of yet I haven't found a computer than can transform energy into matter, so that energy has to go somewhere. Nearly all the energy used by a computer is given off as heat. A small amount goes out as sound, and a small amount goes off as light, but these values are a tiny fraction of the total energy used. All the energy used to create rotation (hard drives, fans, optical) is eventually converted to heat by friction, unless your DVD exploded and sent part of the disc into orbit.
 
Yes, all of that heat has to go somewhere. That is why the first page says this:

It is worth noting here that there is no duct to direct hot air to exit the computer via the ventilation slots on this video card. As such, more warm air will be exhausted into the interior of the PC enclosure, which will raise ambient temperatures. As with any other indirectly exhausted cooling device, proper air circulation is important with this video card to ensure that hot air produced by this video card is removed from the inside of the case.
 
As of yet I haven't found a computer than can transform energy into matter, so that energy has to go somewhere. Nearly all the energy used by a computer is given off as heat. A small amount goes out as sound, and a small amount goes off as light, but these values are a tiny fraction of the total energy used. All the energy used to create rotation (hard drives, fans, optical) is eventually converted to heat by friction, unless your DVD exploded and sent part of the disc into orbit.

What's your point?

The heat from the video card will be exhausted one way or another. Even video cards with heat-exhaust coolers still radiate a lot of heat into the case. The entire surface area of the cooler is radiating heat into the case.

An exhaust cooler may be able to keep your GPU well-cooled and the ambient temps in your case pretty low, but it'll be louder doing it. A non-exhaust cooler can cool the GPU more effectively with less noise, and a well-placed, low-rpm exhaust or intake fan can easily remedy the ambient temps within your case.

There are certain case designs which don't give you a lot of freedom adding extra case fans. There are certain case layouts where it's hard to target the air around a video card. For those specific cases, an exhaust cooler is very appropriate, but for your average mid-tower, you can probably survive without an exhaust cooler.
 
Good article, I wish I would of waited for this card! I'll probably end up selling my 512's and get a single 1gb refresh model soon!

Graphic fixed. Thanks for the extra eyes. - Kyle
 
Quite tempting, love my current 8800GT with MSI's aftermarket cooler. Hope this card does well so MSI keeps up the good work with these cards/coolers.
 
nice. if you have a case for it this is a great card, but I am betting that a lot of people don't and that may outweigh the other benefits of this 4870 vs the GTX260.
 
bloody ugerly card:confused:but if it performs, good for some..
Thnx for your good work again Kyle...been a bit unwell meself, good to see some things don't change;););) What size are DAMMIT down to with their GPUs? Thnx ahead, good health to you and all of yours ;);)
 
Great review [H]. :)

Even though I have two 4870x2s, I wouldn't mind owning a 4870 1GB. The MSI R4870 MD1G appears to be a well-rounded card which would run cooler in a case with excellent airflow.

Fixed, thanks. - Kyle
 
Great review! I had higher hopes for a better overclock with that custom cooler. After I got my HIS stock cooler 4870, I really wish I would have gone with the non reference cooler model. Its intensely loud above the 35% I have it pinned at.

Fixed, thanks. - Kyle
 
Nice review. These cards are also becoming pretty cheap and offers really good value.
 
*sigh* Another review which totally ignores probably the most important part of the 4800-series in terms of temperatures... the VRMs. These 3rd party cooling solutions using passive heatsinks on the VRMs are bound to cause issues for people. I haven't seen ANY review site that bothered to monitor VRM temps, which directly translates into overclocking ability and stability of the card.

My guess is this one will be marginally better than the HIS card, which for me was running 100C+ on the VRMs.
 
*sigh* Another review which totally ignores probably the most important part of the 4800-series in terms of temperatures... the VRMs. These 3rd party cooling solutions using passive heatsinks on the VRMs are bound to cause issues for people. I haven't seen ANY review site that bothered to monitor VRM temps, which directly translates into overclocking ability and stability of the card.

My guess is this one will be marginally better than the HIS card, which for me was running 100C+ on the VRMs.

*sigh* Hope in one hand and shit in the other and see which fills up first.

Please supply links to VRM heat issues that are causing problems and I will have it looked into. Or are you just dreaming things up?
 
I wonder if the temp measurements would have been better done at an arbitrary location in the middle of a closed case and at the outside of a 'main' exhaust (as opposed to the back of the video card). Unfortunately, instead of squelching this discussion, I'm sure it would squawk into a tangent of airflow suggestions...

Kyle or Mark, on the F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin page it says:

"All three video cards were playable at 2560x1600 with 4X MSAA, 16X AF, and the highest possible in-game settings."

The GTX 260 chart shows 4xAA - No AF.

Similar problem with the Crysis: Warhead chart vs. text. Minor.
 
Did I miss something in all the games i looked @ the 512 preforms better fps wise... ?
 
Did I miss any comment on the noise level of the cooler? I only saw the temps data.
 
The Sapphire standard ATi stock cooling card I was playing with a few weeks back OC'ed WAAAAAY better than this. I could hit 850MHz core and 1040MHz memory pegging the fan at 80%. If I leave the fan on manual it will never pass 68% and the card will start to artifact, but it won't crash. No reason to turn that fan to 100% because it's super-loud and only cools the card a few more degrees C.

I probably could have hit higher core except the catalyst control center wouldn't let me. And there were no "it was stable for 5 minutes" on this card, it was stable playing Dead Space and Fallout 3 for 5+ hours straight each and it ran Video Card Stress Test for 16 hours. Frankly I was pretty amazed at how overclockable this Sapphire-reference card was. Seems like if you want an 4870 HD 1GB then you should get a reference card.
 
Back
Top