MSI any good?

Deutch420

Gawd
Joined
Jun 5, 2004
Messages
601
what do u guys think about this mobo?

MSI "K8N Neo2 Platinum" NVIDIA nForce3 ULTRA Chipset Motherboard For AMD Socket 939 CPU

i will plain to use it will all these componants.. what do u guys think??

1AMD Athlon 64 3200+ 2.0GHz, 512KB L2 Cache 939-Pin 64-bit Processor - OEM
1 Chenming Black Entry level server case with side arcylic window,
3 Thermaltake Thunderblade 80mm (BLUE) LED High Performance DC fan,
1 VANTEC Round Floppy drive cable, Booted, 2-connector, 10-Inch ( CLEAR/SILVER ),
2 VANTEC ROUND, 18-Inch, ATA 66/100/133 IDE Cable, 3-Connector ( CLEAR ) -
1 ELSA nVIDIA GeForce 6800 GT Video Card , 256MB GDDR3, 256-Bit, TV-Out/DVI, 8X AGP,
1 ENERMAX 460W Whisper II Power Supply for AMD K7 & Pentium4,0
1 OCZ EL Platinum Revision 2 Dual Channel Kit 184-Pin 1GB(512MBx2) DDR PC-3200 -
1 NEC 1.44MB Black Internal Floppy Drive, OEM
1 Western Digital 160GB 7200RPM IDE Hard Drive, Model WD1600JB, OEM Drive Only

a little off topic, but doesn anyone know where i could get a cheap OS?
 
I'd say as a whole, Yes.. it's a very good board.. But like any computer product it is not without it's bad side.. some people have gotten bad boards, but most have no problems.. It's the nature of the game.. I doubt you'd have a problem, just get it from a place that has good customer service just in case..

The best thing you can do for the OS is pick up an OEM copy of Windows XP Pro, for around $175... It's the cheapest you can get, and I wouldn't recommend anything less for that system you are putting together.
 
what do u think about getting an OS from ebay... i know they dont allow links here... but i have seen OEM copies of XP PRO sealed, new still reapped... with SP2, for like 129.. i might jump on that.. oh yea, and the sellers are 10K powersellers! they're probally kids taking copies from campus sale for 15$, and selling them for 125, and making tons of$

whats ur take on that?
 
Get it from NewEgg- it is $142 with free shipping(OEM XP Pro). It might be a little more, but worth the knowledge that you are getting the real thing from a reputable seller.

 
hey guys... i just say that neweggs AMD 64 3200 939 pin CPU is OEM only, and im told OEM CPUS DONT come with fans and heatsinks!! is this true?? and if so, what shoud i get?? item numbers or links would be greatly appreciated!
 
the thermaltake is CRAPPY.

do yourself a favor and just get the zalman.....


why do you ask our opinions and then not listen?
 
potroast said:
the thermaltake is CRAPPY.

do yourself a favor and just get the zalman.....


why do you ask our opinions and then not listen?

its expencive # 1. # 2, just because im asking what you think about one i found, doesnt mean i dont take your suggestions into concideration... just because u suggest it doesnt mean i must buy it. thus, its called a suggestion :). # 3 Compatibility:Intel Pentium 4 (Socket478), AMD Athlon/Duron/Athlon XP (Socket 462), and AMD Athlon 64 (Socket754)


im getting the 939 socket AMD 3200... under compatibility it must say 939 or opteron
 
Get a Zalman 7000 or Thermalright XP-90 ($10 more than the Zalman once you add a fan, slightly cooler, easier to install, weighs less), TT = crap, either of the two I mentioned first will fit on the same stuff the TT will too.

Just go to the manufacturer's site if you don't believe me, Newegg stat pages can be kinda sketchy and they leave stuff out often. As for the performance of them, read a few reviews, the Zalman or Thermalright are both leaps and bounds better than TT, quieter to boot.
 
i thought pretty much every msi board is uncompatible with the zalman 7000, at least according to the mobo compatibility list on zalman's site
 
Dephcon said:
i thought pretty much every msi board is uncompatible with the zalman 7000, at least according to the mobo compatibility list on zalman's site

Last time I checked the chart said it was compatible but you had to remove the backplate MSI puts in... If you'd rather not just get an XP-90, will fit no fuss, no problem.
 
uh, that's rich because I've installed at least 50 zalman cnps7000a-cu on msi amd64 mobos.

I think you need to stop preaching what you READ, and leave it to those that KNOW.

it's hard enough to get a straight answer in a forum -- we don't need spreading flat-out lies.
 
I have had an interesting problem with a K8N Neo plat. When I used the Nvidia system utility, the onboard USB would stop working. Other than that, I really like their products.
 
I have an MSI Neo2 and an Asus A8V ..the xp-120 (heatsink) fits them both just fine .. with the Neo2 tho , dimms 1 and 2 are kind of a bugger to get ram in and out of.

with the Neo2 I lost the non-nVidia ethernet port and kept losing my raid0 array (from what I have read , that was from overclocking past 215-220ish fsb) .. the Neo2 didnt like some OCZ PC4000 stuff I had and kept crashing even at stock speeds. ..also with the nVidia ethernet port , my DSL speeds would get slower and slower the longer I was online and I would have to reboot comp to get back up to speed until things slowed down again .. :mad:

..the Asus on the other hand has worked flawlessly running my +3500 @ 2.55ghz (10x255)

I rma'd the Neo2 back to newegg and havnt tried out the returned board yet ..just a lot of work changen stuff out , and I'm a bit lazy I guess.

I like the extra features of the Neo2 over Asus' ..but ..If I cant overclock ..then I would cry... :(
 
I bought the MSI K8N Neo2 the day it was released, and I'm still totally happy with it.
Some people say MSI makes junk, but I've yet to see even a hint of that.
Good choice, imo.
 
ThreeDee said:
with the Neo2 I lost the non-nVidia ethernet port and kept losing my raid0 array (from what I have read , that was from overclocking past 215-220ish fsb) .. the Neo2 didnt like some OCZ PC4000 stuff I had and kept crashing even at stock speeds. ..also with the nVidia ethernet port , my DSL speeds would get slower and slower the longer I was online and I would have to reboot comp to get back up to speed until things slowed down again .. :mad:

I had that problem with my raid array when I was initially overclocking.
every three boots or so, my raid array would be 'offline'.
It is easy to fix though. It doesn't mean you've lost any data. All you have to do is delete the array, and add the drives back into the same array type. Good as new.
After I stopped playing with the overclocking settings, and changed to SATA ports 3&4, the array hasn't broken since.

I havn't had any problems with either onboard LAN port though..
 
Yes, if you OC on the MSI and use SATA ports 1&2, you will probably get hard drive corruption since these parts are NOT affected by the PCI lock.. You will need to use ports 3&4, as this is a limitation with using the Marvel external PHY on ports 1&2. These are still native SATA ports off the chipset, but require the PHY to work..

Considering this is one of the only boards that offers the 4 native SATA controllers off the NF3 chipset, you really don't have much of a choice.. ;)
 
Dephcon said:
i thought pretty much every msi board is uncompatible with the zalman 7000, at least according to the mobo compatibility list on zalman's site

Running the Zalman on mine right now. If you use the Zalman backplate and it ends up shorting out your board(Press power putton, fans start to spin, then stop) like it did mine, just use the MSI backplate and the MSI long screws that held(past tense, as in you removed the following...) the old style HFS holder on.
 
Deutch420 said:
what do u think about getting an OS from ebay... i know they dont allow links here... but i have seen OEM copies of XP PRO sealed, new still reapped... with SP2, for like 129.. i might jump on that.. oh yea, and the sellers are 10K powersellers! they're probally kids taking copies from campus sale for 15$, and selling them for 125, and making tons of$

whats ur take on that?

If you have a friend in college just have him/her go to their bookstore and pick up an OEM win xp pro cd for 10-20 dollars.
 
is that a cut down version? I know in the past MS's academic versions have been missing features..
 
Nope, it's just stock xp pro. You don't get anything extra. At my school (purdue) you can get xp pro for 10 bucks office xp pro for 20 bucks. I think the photoshop and studioMX versions are the educational packages, but I haven't noticed anything different about my PS7 that I use at home (educational version) and the one my friend has (reg version).

Even after I graduate, I'm gonna rely on my college buddies to hook me up with cheapo software :)
 
man, that's got to be a special deal with MS and Purdue worked out or something.. I don't think I've heard of academic versions of office getting that low..
 
FS: Office XP Pro...40 bucks!!! Heh, just jokin. I could do some other comparison shoping at the other local junior colleges around here, but I think this is actually the norm as far as I've seen. Ivy tech also has hugely discounted software bundles...I'll check the price after class tomorrow.
 
man.. I'm going to have to track down some friends in college to pick me up some extra copies of XP and Office for my other rigs that are running earlier versions.. I know the community college I go to doesn't sell MS products in the bookstore..
 
A number of universities have very good deals like those... U of IL had similar deals when I studied there. Failing that there's always one other option, 'least for Office... The Student & Teacher edition that MS sells retail will go for $150 tops (less with rebats at say... CompUSA) and most of the time they don't even check for student ID when you buy it.

It's what I bought last time, the deal comes in on the licensing side, $150 gets you three licenses. Mine's currently at use on my computer, my sister's, and my dad's at home. Split it with some friends and it comes in at $50 per.
 
On OEM processors...

don't know if you've ordered yet, but not only do OEM processors lack Heatsink/Fan they also lack a warranty from the manfacturer..

That's three year on a retail proc. from both Intel and AMD.

OEM (at least the eggs policy)

OEM CPUs--
• Refund period: 7-days from original invoice date.
• Repair/replace: 30-days from invoice date.


So if you kill your CPU or it just happens to crap out on you for some odd reason, if it is after 30-days you are SOL. The manufacturer's will tell you to go back where you bought it.
 
if you buy an OEM cpu from monarchcomputers atleast, you can buy an extended warranty from them, which they will handle any problems directly. I think newegg has extended warranty plans too, but monarch definately does.. You can pick up a 3 year warranty from them..
 
Barnaby said:
if you buy an OEM cpu from monarchcomputers atleast, you can buy an extended warranty from them, which they will handle any problems directly. I think newegg has extended warranty plans too, but monarch definately does.. You can pick up a 3 year warranty from them..
but at what cost? The extra $10 to have the 3 year manufacturer's warranty is worth it, imho...

And although I hate the stock hsf's they include, it gives you a backup should a fan go out in the future.
 
My last 3 main mobo's have been MSI's
Sometimes quirky when installing, but once setup they have been rock solid and trouble free.

Im running the Neo Plat right now and I love it
 
as for the OEM CPU, i decided not to go down that road.

i was gonna get 939 boards, but newegg only had OEM parts on a 939 socket. so im gonna stick with 754. i dont need the best of the best, and my wallett doesnt need the crater left from the best of the best either! :rolleyes: so im gonna get retail everything almost (cept optical drive and floppy drive and cables). i figure since this is my first build, warrenties are crucial.

as for the OS, jubei is gonna look around for me, thanks jubei! :)
 
i have an MSI 6800 Vanilla and an MSI K8N Neo Platnium...i love both to death...although i accidently broke my MSI 6800 vanilla...( well the cat did)...so i gotta save up for another one cuz im not gonna RMA sumthing I broke.....although i did think about it.
 
Back
Top