Motherboard/memory confusion, please help.

Beachhead

n00b
Joined
Mar 17, 2007
Messages
11
I'm looking for a new motherboard to put in a system, however in my searches i've become a bit confused on what memory will work in what motherboard. Most motherboards, with the exception of the latest EVGA boards which say DDR2 1200, say they will only support up to DDR2 800, yet there are a large selection of memory chips available now at much higher speeds than 800.

I've had people tell me that the memory will work up to whatever the FSB in your system is. And i have not been able to find a confirmation of this, or any information on exactly what will work, anywhere.

My question is, will memory such as DDR2 1066 work in a DDR2 800 board, such as the latest ASUS models, does it require overclocking, or is my only option the new EVGA boards? Please help, thank you.
 
My question is, will memory such as DDR2 1066 work in a DDR2 800 board, such as the latest ASUS models, does it require overclocking, or is my only option the new EVGA boards? Please help, thank you
.


Yes, no problems running memory slower than specs, its the faster than specs that is the tricky bit. No, but to get your moneys worth, as in running it at its rated speed, you will have to overclock (or run Async see at bottom). No. :D

Ok heres the deal, short version. Once you see how the math works you can figure out about any set of circumstances you want.

Couple of givens/assumptions.
1) Any decent OCer board out there will do 400+ FSB
2) CPU speed = CPU mulitplier x FSB
3) with a 1:1 memory divider (more on that later) Memory speed is FSB x 2 .
4) Most decent OCer boards let you adjust the mulitplier downwards from default.
5) PC6400 is 800MHz memory speed. I dont know the others off the top of my head. Why I dont will be apparent shortly.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Core_2_microprocessors

Lets use an E6600 as as example, its default mulitplier is 9

Stock speed is 9 mulit x 266 FSB = 2.4GHz
memory speed is 266FSB x 2 = 533MHz (way underclocked for PC6400 but it will work fine, hell its at idle, haveing rum runners on the beach and not even sweating. ) Unless you overclock you just wasted money and with PC1000, jeez its phoneing in the work.

So lets overclock, slap on a decent HS/fan set the FSB to 400 and let her rip.
Stock speed is 9 mulit x 400FSB = 3.6GHz Very very respectiable OC on cpu.
memory speed is 400 FSB x 2 = 800MHz PC6400 memory is running exactly on spec- no OC. its happy.
PC1000 would not even be strained, but you at least would wake it up, still a waste of cash.

OK so why the high speed memory, there are memory dividers that will run the memory faster than the 1:1 ratio say 2:3 and I would have to look up how to calculate the math to be sure I got it right so I will just give exaple with words. The reason I dont know it off the top of my head is that in general a 1:1 memory ratio gives the best system performance because the internal L2 cache memory inside the processor runs at twice the FSB, and if the DRAM is also runing at 2 x FSB no wait states or buffering is needed to slow down memory transfers, everyone in the boat is paddleing at the same speed (syncronized or memory running sync in current jargon) .

But you can run memory timers that while the cpu was using say a 400FSB x 9 = 3.6 the memory was getting 500 x 2 = 1000MHz (memory not running syncronized with L2 cache, Asyncronious or Asyn for short) The question is does the buffering and wait states etc. eat any performance increase or not. You probally come out a little ahead on performance but at what cost ? The PC6400 would have got about the same a hella lot cheaper and it was not OCed, it could go a bit higer if pushed.

Bet you glad I didnt give ya the long version :eek:
 
:confused: I'm lost.

Basically, memory will only run at the motherboard's specs, unless you overclock it? If this is so, why is there all this high speed memory, and no motherboards except for a very select few that support it?
 
:confused: I'm lost.

Basically, memory will only run at the motherboard's specs, unless you overclock it? If this is so, why is there all this high speed memory, and no motherboards except for a very select few that support it?

There you go reading the markting BS again.... :rolleyes:

ER NO, any board can run it, just at a high memory divider (which is not really a good thing as I explained in last post, imo) , cpu stays stock/no-overclock but the memory runs much faster than the standard 1:1 (twice the FSB),

Because this is [H] and we overclock our freaking toasters.

And for PC1000 there are only a couple of 1333 MHz (333FSB) processors that have just been released and even then PC1000 would have to use a silly memory divider to reach full speed, so when a MB says they support it

A) its mostly marketing bullshit cause any good overclocking board can run it. and some can do 500FSB x 2 = 1000MHz memory speed but of course the CPU is having the bejezzus overclocked out of it too.
B) to run PC1000 and not overclock the CPU some ridiculous memory divider would be needed. But that wont stop the marketing guys from saying it "supports" whatever.

C) its incredibly lame not to OC a Core 2 Duo.

Oh and there is so much high speed memory out there because before the core2duos you could make better use of it with P4;s and AMD systems, with C2D's anything more than PC6400 is mainly a waste as I also showed in the previous post. Most people dont have a clue and throw money at a high performance computer cause they want the best but dont know enought about it to make an informed decision or analize the computer as a total system.
 
Alright, help a n00b out here with this then.

Let's say i buy an ASUS P5N32-E nforce 680i as the motherboard. (Marketing says DDR2 800)

For the processor: Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz

What would you recommend as the most efficient memory speed to use in here? (overclocked or non-overclocked, etc.)
And any other comments you could throw in on this package would be good. Thanks again.
 
Read this.

...DDR2-800 is plenty fast for real-word apps and games. Hell, DDR2-667 is plenty fast. With the exception of growing your e-penis, you won't notice the 1-6fps difference in games and if you're not a heavy gamer, the difference is pretty much nil.

As Bill suggests, save yourself some money (and some headaches) and just get a good pair of DDR2-800 (or even 667) sticks. The ones that run lower latency (CAS 4) are better, and the closer to the default 1.8v the better (less trouble getting them to boot on your new mb) as well.
 
Alright, help a n00b out here with this then.

Let's say i buy an ASUS P5N32-E nforce 680i as the motherboard. (Marketing says DDR2 800)

For the processor: Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz

What would you recommend as the most efficient memory speed to use in here? (overclocked or non-overclocked, etc.)
And any other comments you could throw in on this package would be good. Thanks again.


ahh thanks, with specifics I can get right to the point:

You do not strike me as an extreme over-clocker but yet someone who would like to get some extra free performance if it does not impact reliability so that is the under lying basis for the recommendation below.

A 400MHz FSB x the 9 multiplier will give 3.6GHz CPU and if in linked mode running the recommended 1:1 (remember the "everyone paddling at the same speed") PC6400 will be running at its rated specifications, no over clock. Get good stuff rated 4 4 4 12 2.0-2.1Volts. Avoid the stuff that requires very high voltages to give good timings, 2.3 V and up is nuts IMO, what they are doing is over-volting the crap out of the memory chips to get them to run that fast. (Not really a good idea IMO but the stuff has been tested and is warrantied by the manuf. /shrug ) Unless you water cool you wont get much higher CPU speeds and of course the good PC6400(800MHz) memory should be good to 840MHz before you need to loosen the timings and then it would probably go to close to 1000MHz at 5 5 5 15 . See my sig, by loosening the timings I am able to run PC6400(800MHz) 4 4 4 12 memory at 940MHz 5 4 4 12 and it does not even get warm. Testing determined that the increase in CPU speed more than made up for the relaxed memory timings. This is what quality memory gets you. At 420 FSB (840 memory speed ) your 3.6GHz over-clock increases to 3.78MHz just to show you that there is plenty of headroom, but I don't think you really want to push stuff that hard. It will take it, but 3.6GHz would be a screaming machine to start with. Anything more and you are just playing (But no harm in that, some of us nuts think its fun:p )


I investigated your board some and learned some things, in addition to the linked memory dividers, apparently in the async mode (remember not particularly recommended as wait states and buffers are needed to let the CPU and memory talk as they are not "paddling at the same speed) BUT you can set the memory speed to about anything you want up to 1200MHz and the board will automatically figure out the divider (from an internal list of available ones that is apparently pretty extensive) and run your memory at whatever you want. This is where the marketing guys are getting the "support memory up to xxx speeds" So you can put super duper expensive/fast memory in there and run it, how much of a performance increase vs increased cost of ram is the question. Personally, not worth it but around [H] common sense is kept on a short lease when talking overclocking, faster is better end of story :)

See this.
http://forums.anandtech.com/messageview.aspx?catid=29&threadid=2019595&enterthread=y
Here are two screen shots of the bios settings that is enlightening.
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/chipsets/display/nforce-680i-sli_4.html

So that board with the Nforce chipset is more flexible then the Intel chipsets with memory, in unlinked mode you can do about anything you want for memory speed. To be redundant, is it worth the extra cash ? Not really for "normal" people :D

So I am back where I started, really high quality PC6400 4 4 4 12 or if you want to really play some PC8000 stuff if you can find a good sale and it does not take more than 2.2 V to run at advertised speeds, anything else is a waste.

Oh, and you will not get near 3.6GHz with the stock cooler, 3.0-3.2 and the temps will start to climb and you will need a very good heat sink. But thats another post.
 
Thanks for the responses and insight, really. I almost wasted a lot of money without even justifing it. I've come to understand the bases of what you're saying and how the math works out, and that kept on a 1:1 ratio, clocking the FSB to 600 to get 1200mhz out of the ram is impossible because the CPU would become a paper weight.

What I can't grasp though is why anyone would want to run Async, since the RAM is wasting time waiting for the CPU anyway, and what divders are.Try and try as I might, its hard for me to find any laymen's term sites about this stuff. I'm new to overclocking but enthusiastic, and the 680i chipset has thrown in so many features its hard to make heads or tails of most of them, and how exactly they work. Features like "Quad Pumping" the FSB and such.

Is overclocking the FSB to get my E6600 to 3.6 (400 x 9) a Zalman 9700 (http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16835118020) possible? Is there realistically a way to get the Ram to 1200 without it bottlenecking at the CPU?
 
Thanks for the responses and insight, really. I almost wasted a lot of money without even justifing it. I've come to understand the bases of what you're saying and how the math works out, and that kept on a 1:1 ratio, clocking the FSB to 600 to get 1200mhz out of the ram is impossible because the CPU would become a paper weight.

What I can't grasp though is why anyone would want to run Async, since the RAM is wasting time waiting for the CPU anyway, and what divders are.Try and try as I might, its hard for me to find any laymen's term sites about this stuff. I'm new to overclocking but enthusiastic, and the 680i chipset has thrown in so many features its hard to make heads or tails of most of them, and how exactly they work. Features like "Quad Pumping" the FSB and such.

Is overclocking the FSB to get my E6600 to 3.6 (400 x 9) a Zalman 9700 (http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16835118020) possible? Is there realistically a way to get the Ram to 1200 without it bottlenecking at the CPU?

Asynchronous memory is nice because you can run your memory at ANY speed, not just as a divided value of your CPU's speed. If you know your memory can run at exactly DDR2 987 speeds, you can set it right there without having to worry about setting the memory divider to the closest possible value.

I'm not sure you're going to get to 3.6Ghz with air cooling period. At that point it's luck of the draw. I can do about 3.3Ghz on mine without getting the temps too high. I could probably push it to 3.4-3.5Ghz if I wanted to add more voltage, but that would just drive up the temps. My E6600 is run at 367x9 = 3300mhz with a 4:5 memory ratio so I'm getting 460mhz (DDR2 920 speed) with my memory.

Quad pumping the FSB is Intel's marketing. The 1066mhz bus CPU's are 266mhz "quad pumped" to 1066mhz. For CPU calculations, you're still using the 266mhz number times your CPU multiplier.
 
Another thing to keep in mind whenever overclocking is ...EVERY CPU CHIP HAS ITS OWN LIMITS. You will read a lot of threads about "my xxxx chip is only overclocking to xxx?!?!?! what am I doing wrong??" when a lot of the time nothing is being done wrong.. that particular chip has hit its max. Just because the c2d chips are great overclockers doesn't guarantee that YOUR E6600 will be able to reach the shinning heavenly heights of overclockishness. Some chip batches will do better than others and some people here keep track of those, finding out which batches have a higher ceiling than others. Then people who buy from a certain vendor (like Newegg, etc.) and often post that they recieved a xxxxxx batch chip and its a great OC'er or can't OC worth a damn.

Another thing to remember never overclock ANYTHING YOU CAN'T AFFORD TO LOSE. It's just like gambling... actually it is gambling. The odds are much, MUCH better than Vegas, but you still can go broke. Most companies do not warranty their products for overclocking, and if they can determine that you have been overclocking it, the warranty is null and void. :eek:

I am NOT trying to scare you away from overclocking, its a blast! Once I discovered I could take a 9800 Pro and flash it to a 9800 XT and increase my benchmarks MASSIVELY, I was totally hooked. I have tried overclocking every CPU and video card I have owned since then. I have an older machine and anytime I start getting getting more stuttering than I like, I crank up my FSB and run my old 2.8c at 3.4 or 3.5 (depending on how dusty my HS is, hehe). It doesn't turn it into a new CPU, but it does make a difference in how well the game plays. :cool:
 
Hey Bill... I have Ballistix DDR2-1000 actually.. reason being I plan on going 4GHz with my setup and don't want anything holding me back... and for upgradability in the future with the 1333mhz processors.. My question is... where does this memory start to shine.. at what overclock/divider exactly?
 
Yes, it's possible with some work. There is someone on the chart at 4GHz with a 9700 actually.. but running an outrageous vcore... just to make the 4GHz screenshot and shut it down.. but 3.6 can be done.

Thanks for the responses and insight, really. I almost wasted a lot of money without even justifing it. I've come to understand the bases of what you're saying and how the math works out, and that kept on a 1:1 ratio, clocking the FSB to 600 to get 1200mhz out of the ram is impossible because the CPU would become a paper weight.

What I can't grasp though is why anyone would want to run Async, since the RAM is wasting time waiting for the CPU anyway, and what divders are.Try and try as I might, its hard for me to find any laymen's term sites about this stuff. I'm new to overclocking but enthusiastic, and the 680i chipset has thrown in so many features its hard to make heads or tails of most of them, and how exactly they work. Features like "Quad Pumping" the FSB and such.

Is overclocking the FSB to get my E6600 to 3.6 (400 x 9) a Zalman 9700 (http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16835118020) possible? Is there realistically a way to get the Ram to 1200 without it bottlenecking at the CPU?
 

Hi,

I've been trying to educate myself for my next build. I was leaning towards one of the lower level C2Ds (4300 or 6300), along with the Giga 965P-DS3, since it's a big favorite with overclockers. I was planning to pair these with some 6400 RAM. But after reading the above link, I'm left more confused than before:

What this means is budget overclockers really need to get their hands on a Nvidia nForce 650i motherboard which will allow them to heavily overclock a Core 2 Duo processor while running low latency DDR2-800 memory. Unfortunately, those overclocking Core 2 Duo processors with Intel 975X or 965P chipsets will be forced to purchase more expensive high-end memory, as they are limited to a 2x memory multiplier.

How then are so many people having success with rigs just like the one I described (as shown in the C2D OC DB)?

I'm a rank amateur when it comes to hardware, so I'd appreciate any insight.

Thanks.
 
They're using high-quality, low-latency, (generally higher priced) memory, running on highly overclocked, well-cooled systems. There's nothing wrong with the DS3, if you have your eye on that board and it has the features you need.

The point of that article (or at least the statement you quoted) is that the nForce 680/650-based boards allow you more separation between the FSB and the memory speed, so you can (generally) get by with less expensive memory. But if you want to oc to the extreme top-end of e-penis bragging rights on an Intel chipset (965/975), you'll also need top-end (high clocking, low latency, high quality) memory to withstand the (more tightly coupled) FSB speeds.

The primary point of that article was to address the question of whether expensive, high-frequency memory realistically buys you anything for everyday/gaming use (as opposed to benchmarking/bragging-rights) in Core 2 Duo systems.
 
...
What this means is budget overclockers really need to get their hands on a Nvidia nForce 650i motherboard which will allow them to heavily overclock a Core 2 Duo processor while running low latency DDR2-800 memory. Unfortunately, those overclocking Core 2 Duo processors with Intel 975X or 965P chipsets will be forced to purchase more expensive high-end memory, as they are limited to a 2x memory multiplier.

...in other words, if you're running your FSB at 500MHz, with a 975/965 chipset, the memory is going to be running at 1000MHz (as I understand it, the memory divider can only be lowered to 2x the FSB). On the 680/650 chipsets, you can run the memory at any speed you want (whatever it can take), regardless of the FSB speed, in most cases.
 
Thanks Spanki.

From what I understand, the E4300 would be a better option than the E6300, when coupled with 800MHz RAM on a DS3, because the E4300's higher multiplier allows it to run a lower FSB.

For example, the E4300 @ 400 FSB, with a multiplier of 9, would be 3.6GHz. The RAM would be running at stock 800MHz speeds, which would allow me to use relatively cheap stuff, since it wouldn't be stressed. (Or, if I were happy with a ~3GHz clockspeed, I could even run less expensive 667MHz RAM, with a ~333 FSB.)

Whereas the E6300, with its multiplier of 7, would need a 514 FSB to achieve the same speed. The DS3's 2:1 ratio would force the RAM to run @ 1028MHz, which 800MHz RAM would be hard pressed to achieve.

Is any of the above incorrect? If not, do you think a DS3, coupled with 667MHz RAM, would allow me to get the most out of an E4300? I've heard not everyone can push them past ~3GHz, but I'd be happy with that speed. And assuming I were able to go higher, the 667MHz RAM would probably be able to handle up into the 700MHz range, right?
 
Honestly, I don't see the average E4300 or E6300 hitting 3.6Ghz. Not saying they aren't capable of it, but I would guess that it is the exception rather than the rule. I would guess that a top end of 3.0-3.2Ghz is more likely (depending on the cooling).
 
Honestly, I don't see the average E4300 or E6300 hitting 3.6Ghz. Not saying they aren't capable of it, but I would guess that it is the exception rather than the rule. I would guess that a top end of 3.0-3.2Ghz is more likely (depending on the cooling).

You're probably right of course. I was just using that speed for illustrative purposes, regarding the FSB differences.
 
You're probably right of course. I was just using that speed for illustrative purposes, regarding the FSB differences.

I think I read your post wrong anyway :). Yeah, unless you get a good CPU, the E4300/E6300 are good for around 3.0-3.2Ghz. From what I've seen, the E6300 seems to do a little better on average. Not sure if it's the whole Conroe vs. Allendale thing or not. The E6600's seem to do better. I'd be disappointed if one didn't hit 3.2Ghz or so. I'm usually happy with 2.8Ghz on a E6300.
 
Thanks Spanki.

From what I understand, the E4300 would be a better option than the E6300, when coupled with 800MHz RAM on a DS3, because the E4300's higher multiplier allows it to run a lower FSB.

For example, the E4300 @ 400 FSB, with a multiplier of 9, would be 3.6GHz. The RAM would be running at stock 800MHz speeds, which would allow me to use relatively cheap stuff, since it wouldn't be stressed. (Or, if I were happy with a ~3GHz clockspeed, I could even run less expensive 667MHz RAM, with a ~333 FSB.)

Whereas the E6300, with its multiplier of 7, would need a 514 FSB to achieve the same speed. The DS3's 2:1 ratio would force the RAM to run @ 1028MHz, which 800MHz RAM would be hard pressed to achieve.

Is any of the above incorrect? If not, do you think a DS3, coupled with 667MHz RAM, would allow me to get the most out of an E4300? I've heard not everyone can push them past ~3GHz, but I'd be happy with that speed. And assuming I were able to go higher, the 667MHz RAM would probably be able to handle up into the 700MHz range, right?

Correct.. that's a very good recap. The higher multiplier of the 4300 lets you get a higher frequency with a lower FSB, which may allow you to keep lower speed memory on a 1:1 ratio... 400 FSB x 9 cpu multiplier = 3.6GHz, 400 x 2 (DDR) memory = DDR2 800, which you can hit with decent DDR2-667 memory.

As mentioned, 3.6 may be stretching it for a E4300, but you only need around 334 FSB to get 3GHz.... anywhere between there and 400 is gravy.

A 650i-based board, with a E4300 cpu and some decent DDR2-667 running in linked mode with the processor running in the ~3GHz range is a very nice 'budget' over-clocker.
 
Correct.. that's a very good recap. The higher multiplier of the 4300 lets you get a higher frequency with a lower FSB, which may allow you to keep lower speed memory on a 1:1 ratio... 400 FSB x 9 cpu multiplier = 3.6GHz, 400 x 2 (DDR) memory = DDR2 800, which you can hit with decent DDR2-667 memory.

As mentioned, 3.6 may be stretching it for a E4300, but you only need around 334 FSB to get 3GHz.... anywhere between there and 400 is gravy.

A 650i-based board, with a E4300 cpu and some decent DDR2-667 running in linked mode with the processor running in the ~3GHz range is a very nice 'budget' over-clocker.

Excellent, thanks for your help!

But what about a 965P-based board? Did you mean to say 965P, or am I getting confused again? (Sorry!)
 
Excellent, thanks for your help!

But what about a 965P-based board? Did you mean to say 965P, or am I getting confused again? (Sorry!)

Yes, sorry. I've got 650i on the brain right now :). As long as you're planning to run the memory in synced mode with the CPU/FSB anyway, and have no plans for SLI, then the DS3 (965P chipset) is a nice choice if the rest of it's feature set fits your needs.
 
I am looking into a watercooling system to support a good overclock of my CPU and RAM, but I am still in the dark as to what my CPU/RAM can achieve, and what multiliers/voltages would be optimal. I'd like to run at 3.6Ghz stable. Would this be possible with my setup? Is my RAM overkill in this situation? It's volted at 2.1v with 5-5-5-15 T2 and the board is rated at DDR2 1200
 
Back
Top