Microsoft Rewrites Activation Rules For Windows 10

You can...you have a Sys Builder/OEM, go buy a full retail version....problem solved. MS absolutely should not say, "Well we're going to upgrade all of these cheaper licenses to full retail licenses." That's just crazy talk. Some of those licenses are free while others are very inexpensive. When you pay 119 for a SB license, you're paying significantly less than a retail license (about 1/4 as I recall).
That where your wrong they only need sell at one fair price not 3x the price.
Keep in mind that Phone and Tablet and other Small Device are not upgrade able like Decktop and most Laptop.
 
Those aren't nice things, it's called you have money to burn and don't care about increased cost for minor convenience. If you like it, great. Not all of us want to throw away additional money on software.

It doesn't cost me more though..... I get 5 copies of office for 5 PCs for around $75 / year. To outfit those same 5 PCs with office would cost around $500 and in 3-4 years when a new version of office comes out I would be behind again.

If more people switch over to subscription models the price could further come down. On top of that because its a subscription if people become unhappy with the price at any time they can exit the subscription and switch to free software.

I fully realize not all price points for O365 are good right now but they could get better. But consumers blindly fight like you do without actually thinking about what they are saying. Instead of saying what you say if you repositioned your argument and said if you charged me a subscription at this price per year I would buy in that would be FAR more helpful to MS. Instead you just cry that a subscription must cost more than "owning" and so MS delivers what you demand. This is the same problem windows has been having for years, the consumers cant articulate what they want or what the problem really is so MS cant move forward with solving it. Instead the consumers make up some red hering like the big problem is the subscription or the start menu because they don't like change and MS listens to them rather than solving the actual problem they come up with a Rube Goldberg mechanism.
 
That where your wrong they only need sell at one fair price not 3x the price.
Keep in mind that Phone and Tablet and other Small Device are not upgrade able like Decktop and most Laptop.

No but what if companies started shipping phones and telling customers to transfer the key or license from their own phone to avoid paying license fees for an OS. This is why OEM licenses will stay. The only other effective solution for this is a subscription to the OS.
 
No but what if companies started shipping phones and telling customers to transfer the key or license from their own phone to avoid paying license fees for an OS. This is why OEM licenses will stay. The only other effective solution for this is a subscription to the OS.
Boy are you just that clueless do not get that Phone and Tablet and some other device are NoN upgrade hardware so there for thoses can be done diff.

Like all Apple stuff dose
If you turn on your device and you're asked for the previous owner's Apple ID and password, the device is erased it still linked to the previous owner's account.
Now the previous owner has removes the device from their account, in order begin the setup process for new user to take over the device on there account.
 
Looks like MS is distributing Upgrade keys to OEM and Insider machines.
-Most who have dealt with upgrade keys know what this means.
-Clean installs will auto activate until next year when the free upgrade program ends.

Retail Win7 machines are getting full version Retail Win10 keys.
-These keys should persist thru a clean install.

If you can clone the Win7 OS to another drive and upgrade it.
Setup Dual Boot method of your choice.
Turn Win7 upgrade off on the Win7 OS.
 
That where your wrong they only need sell at one fair price not 3x the price.
Keep in mind that Phone and Tablet and other Small Device are not upgrade able like Decktop and most Laptop.

Keep in mind that MS practically gives away the OS on cheaper PCs. Keep in mind that Dell isn't paying much for an OS. Keep in mind that you chose to buy a cheaper license that explicitly said it wasn't transferable

If going forward they want to have a single more expensive license, then sobeit, but I suspect system builders would be less happy, since it'd increase their costs, which they'd have to pass on to consumers. And I can promise you that Dell isn't going pay for a transferable license.
 
It doesn't cost me more though..... I get 5 copies of office for 5 PCs for around $75 / year. To outfit those same 5 PCs with office would cost around $500 and in 3-4 years when a new version of office comes out I would be behind again.

But do you need to upgrade every time on Office? I have 2010, but I could just as easily work with 2007 or even an earlier version. They all do the same thing. I like the newer UI more, but it's not a big deal. Of course I got my 2007 licenses for free and 2010 came with Technet. I don't use them enough to justify paying 75/year for them...and I only use Word/Excel (and not that often at home).

renting only makes sense, to me, for things like Photoshop, where the initial cost is so huge that it'd take 10 years (or more) before the TCO of renting is higher.

As for renting an OS, that's just nuts. Think of it like this. most get an OS with their PC. They keep that PC for 5 years and they never buy a new OS. 75/year is just an increased cost and worse it'd cost them almost as much as buying a full retail license for Pro Windows. even if the price is 5 it's still 300 over 5 years. If I paid full price for 7 in 2009, I'd have an OS I could use for at least 11 years.

Renting is likely to push people towards alternatives.
 
It doesn't cost me more though..... I get 5 copies of office for 5 PCs for around $75 / year. To outfit those same 5 PCs with office would cost around $500 and in 3-4 years when a new version of office comes out I would be behind again.

If more people switch over to subscription models the price could further come down. On top of that because its a subscription if people become unhappy with the price at any time they can exit the subscription and switch to free software.

I fully realize not all price points for O365 are good right now but they could get better. But consumers blindly fight like you do without actually thinking about what they are saying. Instead of saying what you say if you repositioned your argument and said if you charged me a subscription at this price per year I would buy in that would be FAR more helpful to MS. Instead you just cry that a subscription must cost more than "owning" and so MS delivers what you demand. This is the same problem windows has been having for years, the consumers cant articulate what they want or what the problem really is so MS cant move forward with solving it. Instead the consumers make up some red hering like the big problem is the subscription or the start menu because they don't like change and MS listens to them rather than solving the actual problem they come up with a Rube Goldberg mechanism.

Good for you, my point still stands. If you want to throw money at a subscription that everything goes away when you cancel, be my guest. I simply want the choice it'd owning to remain. I still use 2010, there is nothing any version past that offers me yet. When and if one does then I want the option to buy it. I'm not fighting to take your choice away, why are you fighting to take mine? Also sorry but you are extraordinarily naive if you believe pure subscriptions and elimination of bought software will somehow lower prices. As for the stupid argument of "Use free stuff if you don't want a sub" you can take that argument and fuck right off. If the free alternatives were worth a damn, corporations wouldn't be spending millions on the paid. I've tried every free office alternative and every single one blows. So no I don't want subscriptions to be the only means for office or especially windows.
 
So if a game was $15 on release for an "OEM" version that you could only install on 1 system but could be installed on a new build without consequences, and the retail version of the game was $70 but could be installed on any machine, those of you talking about OEM vs retail are going to pay the $70?
 
The problem is that the replacement motherboard was not "an identical motherboard". Even if the part number was the same, the OEM information for what OS it was licensed for was different. Your replacement board might have originally came with Windows 2000, XP pro or even Vista. Since it didn't match your XP home OEM version, it didn't work.

Not really defending it, just explaining. If the new board was licensed for XP Pro, you could have upgraded the OS to that, assuming you had the right OEM disk to install it.

The replacement was just an out-of-the-box factory motherboard. It was never tied to another machine. Why should the person I fixed the machine for be punished just for having a broken part? What am I supposed to do - tell him his system is a brick because Micro$haft considers him to be a pirate because his motherboard died so he needs to go buy a new computer after I fixed the hardware problem? That's why activation is bullshit and needs to go away.
 
And that's exactly what I'm going to face down the line when motherboards go bad on OEM Windows 8 (and newer) machines. Off-the-shelf motherboard replacements are useless because of this (no key stickers) and so will the $300-400 machines that have them since buying the (overpriced or unavailable) exact replacement board will be far more expensive. And one year from now it will be even worse if the OEM machine was upgraded to Win10, since the motherboard replacement would be considered a new computer, possibly rendering the nearly-new dead computer worthless.
 
Well considering the pirates have already gotten around it, calling to reactivate is still just a needless hassle for the legit customers.

It's like asking the DMV for permission to drive your car every time you get in, CRAZY.
 
Good for you, my point still stands. If you want to throw money at a subscription that everything goes away when you cancel, be my guest. I simply want the choice it'd owning to remain. I still use 2010, there is nothing any version past that offers me yet. When and if one does then I want the option to buy it. I'm not fighting to take your choice away, why are you fighting to take mine? Also sorry but you are extraordinarily naive if you believe pure subscriptions and elimination of bought software will somehow lower prices. As for the stupid argument of "Use free stuff if you don't want a sub" you can take that argument and fuck right off. If the free alternatives were worth a damn, corporations wouldn't be spending millions on the paid. I've tried every free office alternative and every single one blows. So no I don't want subscriptions to be the only means for office or especially windows.

You realize that MS currently runs their subscriptions such that if you stop paying you can still view just not edit documents. which means you are not stuck and you can take your time migrating to a competitor. MS also increases the price of office to account for all the cheap skates that buy 1 copy every 10 years or pirate. I am not fighting to take anyone's choice away just pointing out that fallacy of the choice. I fully expect over time MS will slowly push the price of the non subscription versions of their software up and push the subscriptions versions down such that it makes no sense to do a non subscription version of office unless you are so cheap you wait 7+ years.

My problem with MS office has always been the versions. The unfortunate reality that people must save their office files in some ghetto old format because one guy you are sending a document too is too cheap to keep a current version. The reason this system exists is because people fight subscriptions. I just want MS to get their subscription prices right for everyone so that it makes sense for almost everyone to buy a subscription except the few tinfoil hat folks. Then you can just know that if you send a document off to someone they can view it correctly except the couple percent of people using libre or holding out on office 2003.



Boy are you just that clueless do not get that Phone and Tablet and some other device are NoN upgrade hardware so there for thoses can be done diff.

Like all Apple stuff dose
If you turn on your device and you're asked for the previous owner's Apple ID and password, the device is erased it still linked to the previous owner's account.
Now the previous owner has removes the device from their account, in order begin the setup process for new user to take over the device on there account.

The vast majority of consumers never upgrade their hardware in any device so what does that have to do with anything? On top of that apple is not even relevant here since they only allow their OS to run on their own hardware. They don't have to control licenses to sell to themselves.


But do you need to upgrade every time on Office? I have 2010, but I could just as easily work with 2007 or even an earlier version. They all do the same thing. I like the newer UI more, but it's not a big deal. Of course I got my 2007 licenses for free and 2010 came with Technet. I don't use them enough to justify paying 75/year for them...and I only use Word/Excel (and not that often at home).

renting only makes sense, to me, for things like Photoshop, where the initial cost is so huge that it'd take 10 years (or more) before the TCO of renting is higher.

As for renting an OS, that's just nuts. Think of it like this. most get an OS with their PC. They keep that PC for 5 years and they never buy a new OS. 75/year is just an increased cost and worse it'd cost them almost as much as buying a full retail license for Pro Windows. even if the price is 5 it's still 300 over 5 years. If I paid full price for 7 in 2009, I'd have an OS I could use for at least 11 years.

Renting is likely to push people towards alternatives.

I don't have to run on the newest version of office. But see my reply to dekoth to see why I care. BTW I have run both ways. On newest version, and on an older version, and I now run on a subscription. In both the older cases I had the same problem. Too damn many people who don't run the same version of office. If I have the older version I get people sending me documents in the newer version, if I have the newer version its slightly better cause I can see everything correctly but its a pain the ass to constantly have to revert to an older version for some random person or realize they cannot see a feature I am using. I am literally dealing with this right now as we speak. If enough people move to subscriptions we wont have to worry about this crap and MS will be plenty happy with their profit. I have come to this conclusion after realizing it simply does not matter how cheap MS makes a product a certain segment of the population will STILL be too cheap to upgrade. And it seems like its always the same people. Its like their brains are just hard wired to never have to spend a penny if they don't have to without any thought about the actual value.

The replacement was just an out-of-the-box factory motherboard. It was never tied to another machine. Why should the person I fixed the machine for be punished just for having a broken part? What am I supposed to do - tell him his system is a brick because Micro$haft considers him to be a pirate because his motherboard died so he needs to go buy a new computer after I fixed the hardware problem? That's why activation is bullshit and needs to go away.

Maybe because you fixed the machine instead of the company that made it? The point is the company that made the machine doesn't care, if the consumer had sent the machine back to them it would have been given a motherboard with a license and windows reinstalled. And this is largely because MS knows their is a shit ton of people like those on hard who are perpetually reusing OEM keys. But really I don't think you should worry so much, for years MS has had a very relaxed policy and always allowed loopholes to stay that allow people to cheap skate their way out of paying for the correct version of an OS.
 
I don't have to run on the newest version of office. But see my reply to dekoth to see why I care. BTW I have run both ways. On newest version, and on an older version, and I now run on a subscription. In both the older cases I had the same problem. Too damn many people who don't run the same version of office. If I have the older version I get people sending me documents in the newer version, if I have the newer version its slightly better cause I can see everything correctly but its a pain the ass to constantly have to revert to an older version for some random person or realize they cannot see a feature I am using. I am literally dealing with this right now as we speak. If enough people move to subscriptions we wont have to worry about this crap and MS will be plenty happy with their profit. I have come to this conclusion after realizing it simply does not matter how cheap MS makes a product a certain segment of the population will STILL be too cheap to upgrade. And it seems like its always the same people. Its like their brains are just hard wired to never have to spend a penny if they don't have to without any thought about the actual value.

I get what you're arguing, but I can live with those inconveniences. To me, a subscription to Office is not worth much. Maybe 10 bucks a year? I don't use it much at home, and I see no reason to upgrade much. If 2007 wasn't free and 2010 part of technet, I'd use an ancient version. 2010/07 are better UIs,but they don't do anything that I need that I didn't have in Office 97, never mind XP (or whatever was after that).

Hell, the only reason I switched to Word for windows is because Ami Pro withered away due to lack of support and it's replacement was a buggy mess. Excel certainly has lots of new features, but I mostly do basic things that have been in spreadsheets for decades
 
I get what you're arguing, but I can live with those inconveniences. To me, a subscription to Office is not worth much. Maybe 10 bucks a year? I don't use it much at home, and I see no reason to upgrade much. If 2007 wasn't free and 2010 part of technet, I'd use an ancient version. 2010/07 are better UIs,but they don't do anything that I need that I didn't have in Office 97, never mind XP (or whatever was after that).

Hell, the only reason I switched to Word for windows is because Ami Pro withered away due to lack of support and it's replacement was a buggy mess. Excel certainly has lots of new features, but I mostly do basic things that have been in spreadsheets for decades

For people like you I think office live is really sufficient, especially if you find nothing useful past office 97. At least if you use office live you will be running the same version of documents.
 
For people like you I think office live is really sufficient, especially if you find nothing useful past office 97. At least if you use office live you will be running the same version of documents.

The point is I wouldn't pay for something I already own. Renting only makes sense if there's a reason to switch to it. Adobe has features in PS and LR that I want that require a sub. Plus I didn't own PS because the initial cost was very high for CS #.

Office doesn't ahve that advantage. I have 2010. It works and I see no reason to pay just to have the latest version.

It'd have to be free (or very close to free). Now if I was a business, I'd probably feel differently It's a write off at that point.
 
Well then I guess you make a very good argument that MS should get rid of the buy to own license and switch entirely to subscription, after all that is what PS did and it seems to have worked on you.

Or they should just increase the price of the software to the point it is so expensive you can only afford to subscribe.
 
Well then I guess you make a very good argument that MS should get rid of the buy to own license and switch entirely to subscription, after all that is what PS did and it seems to have worked on you.

Or they should just increase the price of the software to the point it is so expensive you can only afford to subscribe.

It's not the same. Adobe sub gets you 800 or 999 bucks of software for 10 bucks a month. Excel and word have been as cheap as 100 bucks each... Free for 2007 And if titty or a collar use in k-grad school then you can get academic versions. If titty need the latest version then renting makes sense.
 
Also in case you didn't know it office live is free.

I didn't. On the link for saw a bunch button and assumed it cost money. For now I'll stick with what's installed but I might try that stone day.

Thanks for the info.
 
Back
Top