Microsoft Rewrites Activation Rules For Windows 10

I love these threads. If I change my motherboard and processor why can't I keep windows activated for the new motherboard and combo AND keep it activated for the old one that I've decided to make another computer out of???
People will spend $700 on a video card but not $100 on an OS LICENSE.

Err, most people will sell off the old parts. Besides, I had an SSD replacement trigger reactivation of a MS product in the past few months. So no, I don't plan to buy a new copy of Windows every time I upgrade something.
 
So let me get this strait, people are complaining about a free upgrade to Window's 10, because if they ever change hardware they 'maybe' forced to buy a new licence (no one knows for sure yet).

However, you still have your Windows 7/8 installation files and key, meaning if you upgrade, and IF Microsoft charges you for a window's 10 license (that you didn't pay for in the first place) you can always install 7/8 again.

If you paid for Windows 10, you also bought it with the EULA and everything it comes with, read it or not. Even then you don't know IF Microsoft will just issue a new key, or charge you for it (which I believe they have always had the right to do).

Seems like a bunch of spoilt brats whining over free stuff if you ask me.
 
Err, most people will sell off the old parts. Besides, I had an SSD replacement trigger reactivation of a MS product in the past few months. So no, I don't plan to buy a new copy of Windows every time I upgrade something.

No one said you would. 9 times out of 10 you can reactivate it. That applies here. Also side comment if you have your imaging software keep the Volume label from the previous drive than it wouldn't need to be reactivated. Swapped out a M4 for MX100 a couple weeks ago on Windows 8.1 and didn't get a reactivation request. Nothing about the Windows 10 system is any different than their policies since Windows 95. Just how they keep and track activations has changed.
 
I think a lot of people are missing the fact that OEM keys are already not supposed to be re-used with new motherboards unless the original board has failed. Microsoft isn't changing their policy or terms, they are just eliminating you're ability to scam the system.

You guys are bitching about them cutting out a loophole. It's just like online retailers collecting tax when it shouldn't matter because you're supposed to be paying taxes on the items anyways when you file your taxes.

It wont matter for the next year anyways since a properly cracked version of windows gets a free legit windows 10 upgrade. So you guys can keep scamming the system a bit longer lol.

You're putting words in people's mouths. So you're saying if I have full retail (non-OEM) licenses for Windows 8.1 that I've upgraded to Windows 10, now suddenly I'm supposed to be playing by OEM license rules?

Not everyone is messing with OEM licenses.
 
[L]imey;1041790959 said:
But I'm not trying to keep it activated on the old hardware. I'll sell those parts or whatever. But I still don't have the option to keep that OS license valid on an upgrade. If my motherboard fails, or if I choose to replace it and the processor, and the ram, and keep everything else from the old build, who says that's a "New Computer"?

Microsoft does. As far as I know, it has been their policy that the motherboard is the determining factor for what constitutes a computer. All of the other components should be able to be replaced without requiring re-activation as long as you are not re-installing the OS (which requires re-activation).

It is outlined in their EULA that you are really licensing their software, not physically owning it. OEM licenses are tied to specific hardware (the motherboard) whereas retail licenses are tied to a set number of installations. As long as you are not installing the retail licensed copy on multiple machines simultaneously, it should re-activate.

In the grand scheme, it is annoying, but not really that bad. Microsoft makes a lot of money from their large corporate customers, including OEMs that sell equipment with their software pre-loaded. What they make on the consumer side is a bonus, but last I knew it wasn't their bread and butter.
 
Not true.

1. It was very easy to get free retail licenses for Vista (which means you could upgrade to 7 at a reasonable price)

2. Lots of people used Technet around the time of 7 and those were retail licenses
3. You could buy a retail 8 license for 15 bucks when it came out.

People have retail licenses. Every version of windows I've run has been a retail license (well everything from XP on).

Ditto. I think I own 5 licenses for Windows 8. One is a full retail key, where the others were those cheap ones MS sold early on. I don't remember if they were upgrade keys or what.
 
That's pretty much what they're telling us. They can't give out new keys as there aren't any keys to be given and the hardware hash is stored on the servers.

If you need a new activation you have to reinstall a qualifying OS and upgrade from within it to generate a new activation hash.

Which basically means after the initial year you're screwed b/c the path of installing 7/8 and then upgrading free is no longer there.
 
I love these threads. If I change my motherboard and processor why can't I keep windows activated for the new motherboard and combo AND keep it activated for the old one that I've decided to make another computer out of???
People will spend $700 on a video card but not $100 on an OS LICENSE.

My guess is just like it has been for the last decade people will figure out a way around this. Technically people are not suppose to use upgrades on new builds, people did it anyway. Technically people are not suppose to use OEM copies on new builds, people did it anyway. Chances are people will find a way around all this. My guess right now is that people will figure out they can just take their hard drive from an old build, stick it in a new build. And then tell MS oh my mobo died and was replaced. MS will then activate on the new build. After that you wipe everything and do a clean reformat and are good to go.

Alternatively maybe we will find something as stupid easy as the registry key change that got us around upgrade installs.
 
However, you still have your Windows 7/8 installation files and key, meaning if you upgrade, and IF Microsoft charges you for a window's 10 license (that you didn't pay for in the first place) you can always install 7/8 again.

No you can't, after 30 days your qualifying OS key gets eaten and will be invalid to activate with.
 
OEM license: Follows the motherboard. Change motherboard & you *have* to buy a new license. Same old-same old. OEM has always been like this.

Bottom line: Everything is the same as it has always been--except for the key--which Microsoft has taken out of the activation equation.

OEM allows you to change the mb if it is due to a hardware failure, maybe not with Win10 though, and that is BS if true.

As for the free Win10 upgrade version re-activation. How can Microsoft activate over the phone if there is no activation key to input?
 
Exactly, and I think we are going to see a real hassle and an attempt to charge us for a new license.

They tried to do this before, they just approached it from the wrong direction. Now they are correcting that mistaken attempt to screw us a little bit more.

From all of our point of views, we consider the OS as just another component of the computer and if I buy a single copy of an OS I should be able to use it and port it all I want as long as I don't use a single license for more then one computer at a time.

But not MS, they just don't look at it that way. They look at the license as an agreement for you to be able to run their OS on your computer. If you build a new computer, mobo, CPU, NIC(usually new because the mobo is new), you have bought a new computer and you need a new license.

They know we won't like this but that is where they are going to keep trying to drive it.

No, you can buy Windows and reinstall it on any computer you want, by the sounds of it, you went the OEM way and bought cheaper OEM licenses in the past to save money, but then complain cause you can't move it to a new computer....?
 
[EDIT] read the rest, the one issue is with the upgrade of Win 10.

But we do not know most of [H] did always buy OEM license to save money, and then complain about not being able to move the OEM licenses to new hardware.....

Activation needs to be simple and this does help, if you need to call MS, okay, it happened, over the last..god 15 years? i have had to call MS line once to do an activation on Windows 7, that is using OEM versions, retail versions.

I think as usual people are going to bitch just to bitch cause it is MS doing something different. Some people will have problems, but i am willing to bet, the majority will not, jujst people want to take the very very select few and blow the problem up as if every single last user will have issues.

If you install Win 10 upgrade from 8.1, expect to install 8.1 again and upgrade, as you did in the first place to activate again...

If you don't like it, the free OS, go buy the OS and be done with it?
 
Answers here.

For those that don't like clicking links:



NOTE: Emphasis in italics is my doing.

Essentially, you will either have to go the long route of reinstalling the original OS you upgraded from, then upgrading to 10, or buy a new copy of 10.

Not terrible if you are repurposing the old mobo, since the Windows copy should still be tied to it, but kind of a pain if you are simply updating to a new system.

Yeah, I'm just annoyed they're taking the long pole on this one: cheap up-front, and the expensive when you upgrade/replace the motherboard.

I was previously able to buy a full retail UPGRADE copy of Windows 7 for $50 if I pre-ordered. There was a similar deal for the first few months for Windows 8 Pro Where is my option to "upgrade" my license now for 50 bucks, so I don't have to worry about dropping a hundred years down the road?
 
If you install Win 10 upgrade from 8.1, expect to install 8.1 again and upgrade, as you did in the first place to activate again...

The free upgrade is only valid for one year so you will not be able to do that after one year. Also, your qualifying OS key becomes invalid after 30 days so you will not be able to activate it to use it to upgrade to Win10 from. Correct me if I am wrong.
 
How often has that happened up to now? How many times have YOU had your license revoked and MS has refused to reactivate?
I repaired a PC with XP Home that needed a new PSU, which, besides shorting out, had overvolted the 5 volt and cooked the motherboard, so it needed a new motherboard as well. I replaced it with an identical motherboard, but the product key that came with the system rejected the hardware change and MS wouldn't reactivate the machine. I had an unused product key handy and was able to get it to activate with that one. If I had not had this handy then this person - through no fault of their own - would have been denied operation of their own computer that they paid for.

But if you really want to make this about me... here you go. Windows 7 ultimate decided, for no reason whatsoever and just randomly out-of-the-blue to deactivate itself. No hardware change, no software changes, it just decided to say "Fuck you" and invalidate itself when I booted up one day. Oh I fixed it myself since MS was unwilling to help because, to them, my copy that was genuine just the day before was no longer genuine so I really needed, in their opinion, to purchase a genuine copy. If this had happened to Joe Average User they would have been out some money when MS's activation scheme took a dump on them.

Understand this. I have no problem paying for software. I'll gladly pay for software that works. I prefer to see people compensated for their work.... but if you make my system inoperable for nothing that I've done wrong I will do whatever is necessary to make it work again. I paid for it, I have a right to use it, and if you don't like how I fix the problem you can kiss my finely feathered avian ass. This is why I have no sympathy for Micro$haft when it comes to piracy. The hardcore pirates and crackers won't ever be stopped, the activation software doesn't work right, and when it really doesn't work right it punishes innocent users. I have a serious problem with that, and I'm damned well justified in being bitter towards them.
 
Microsoft does. As far as I know, it has been their policy that the motherboard is the determining factor for what constitutes a computer. All of the other components should be able to be replaced without requiring re-activation as long as you are not re-installing the OS (which requires re-activation).

It is outlined in their EULA that you are really licensing their software, not physically owning it. OEM licenses are tied to specific hardware (the motherboard) whereas retail licenses are tied to a set number of installations. As long as you are not installing the retail licensed copy on multiple machines simultaneously, it should re-activate.

In the grand scheme, it is annoying, but not really that bad.

So, I have a 3 month old Dell system running Windows 7/8
I upgrade the system to Windows 10 for free.
14 months from now the system board dies and Dell replaces it under the 3 warranty.
My "free" upgrade of Windows 10 now assumes I am running it on a new system and won't activate.
So I need to wipe my system and go back to Windows 7/8, and there is no longer a free upgrade to 10 because it's been over a year since 10 was announced?
Doesn't seem right.
Hopefully Microsoft would allow activation over the phone in that case.
 
I repaired a PC with XP Home that needed a new PSU, which, besides shorting out, had overvolted the 5 volt and cooked the motherboard, so it needed a new motherboard as well. I replaced it with an identical motherboard, but the product key that came with the system rejected the hardware change and MS wouldn't reactivate the machine. I had an unused product key handy and was able to get it to activate with that one. If I had not had this handy then this person - through no fault of their own - would have been denied operation of their own computer that they paid for.

The problem is that the replacement motherboard was not "an identical motherboard". Even if the part number was the same, the OEM information for what OS it was licensed for was different. Your replacement board might have originally came with Windows 2000, XP pro or even Vista. Since it didn't match your XP home OEM version, it didn't work.

Not really defending it, just explaining. If the new board was licensed for XP Pro, you could have upgraded the OS to that, assuming you had the right OEM disk to install it.
 
Still not going to upgrade to win10 until MS changes their mandatory update/privacy EULA crap.
 
How often has that happened up to now? How many times have YOU had your license revoked and MS has refused to reactivate?

In all the years they've done this, I've only had to call once and I never talked to a person. If you're into tin foil hats as fashion, then fine, but past experience (not just mine) shows they're not dicks about reactivating.

Yes, they are in fact dicks about reactivating. I have two (2) copies of Vista that are no longer able to be used because I changed hardware too much.
 
Before it was free, it was 20 bucks...essentially free. Most mac users don't hold onto those machines forever. Most of my friends with macs upgrade every 3 years (give or take a year). $60 isn't going to kill apple
10.0 Cheetah: Released March 24, 2001 for $129
10.1 Puma: Released September 25, 2001 for $0
10.2 Jaguar: Released August 23, 2002 for $129
10.3 Panther: Released October 24, 2003 for $129
10.4 Tiger: Released April 29, 2005 for $129
10.5 Leopard: Released October 26, 2007 for $129
10.6 Snow Leopard: Released August 28, 2009 for $29
10.7 Lion: Released July 20, 2011 for $29
10.8 Mountain Lion: Released July 25, 2012 for $19
10.9 Mavericks: Released October 22, 2013 for $0
 
So let me get this strait, people are complaining about a free upgrade to Window's 10, because if they ever change hardware they 'maybe' forced to buy a new licence (no one knows for sure yet).

Seems like a bunch of spoilt brats whining over free stuff if you ask me.
No, people are complaining because all versions previous to this one needed to be activated like this:
1. Install new hardware
2. Windows deactivates
3. call MS to get new key
4. activate Windows

but now it's like this:

1. Install new hardware
2. Windows deactivates
3. call MS to get new key
4. MS reps state they can't give new key
5. a) reinstall 7 then upgrade to 10
b) reinstall 8 then upgrade to 8.1 then upgrade to 10
6. clean reinstall 10
7. activate Windows

It's unknown whether you'll be able to upgrade after a month or a year, but that's the least of people's concerns. Steps 5 and 6 are already a colossal pain in the ass to an already up and running system that has an issue, like a BIOS change, adding a second GPU for SLI (which triggered my reactivation...imagine the fun of installing 8, then 8.1, then 10, then 10 again, then doing it all over again immediately afterward), or any other hardware change that might trigger an issue (a single hard drive might not, but multiple hard drive changes will, for example).

The only people not upset about this are people who are being deliberately obtuse and argumentative, like Tiburian, or people who haven't fully thought it through because they haven't run into the problem. In 7 months when they have a system all configured with all their apps installed and everything nice and squared away, they're going to be royally pissed when they update their GPU and have to wipe their entire drive and install from scratch.
 
http://www.tomshardware.com/news/windows-10-revert-os,29727.html

"Rolling Back From Windows 10 To Your Older OS Appears Problematic"

"From the perspective of the consumer, however, these issues seem to jibe with Mozilla's assertion that Microsoft has reduced user choice in Windows 10, in this case by giving them very limited ability to downgrade the OS, re-install the OS or change hardware. The initial upgrade process itself is needlessly long and complicated, too."
 
MS is on my shit list all ready over Windows 10 Insider Perview
I had do new reinstall on my Laptop so download the MediaCreationToolx64 and made a Bootable USB stick and wipe all partition reinstall Windows 10 Pro everthing done log-in my live acct but god damn thing say activate but it will not activate

It saying in the Activate
Error details 0xC004C003
Your product key info
Currrent product key. *****-3V66T

So just wasted 9 month for nothing
That didn't tell us is we can never ever do clean install after July-29 which should ahve been tie to live acct forever as long as we didn't opt-out of the previews well as see anove that laod BS.
 
It's stuff like this (like what they did with Windows 8 OEM machines not having key stickers) that is going to make legit motherboard replacements far more expensive, and if it's like a $300-400 machine, too expensive to repair. I used to be able to use off-the-shelf motherboards (not the overpriced OEM versions), reuse everything else, and then use the key sticker on the case to reactivate.

After a year, when the upgraded Windows 10 machines go down, they may become worthless since it would cost as much to fix as the computer is worth.
 
My guess is just like it has been for the last decade people will figure out a way around this. Technically people are not suppose to use upgrades on new builds, people did it anyway.

That's only true for OEM licenses. For retail licenses, you're supposed to be able to transfer it to new H/W and someone posted a quote that indicates that's still the case, despite what happened to Mope.

Whether it does or not, is not known and won't be until they fix this or until a year is up...either way, you'll always have your old 7/8 licenses.
 
OEM allows you to change the mb if it is due to a hardware failure, maybe not with Win10 though, and that is BS if true.

As for the free Win10 upgrade version re-activation. How can Microsoft activate over the phone if there is no activation key to input?

Until 30 days have passed and it's confirmed that you can't reinstall 8, I'll remain cautiously optimistic. All of the pages I've seen referring this are rolling back to the old OS. IMO, that makes sense, because who wants to keep Windows 7/8 installs on their drive forever? If you do, then take an image before you upgrade...actually do that either way.

I personally think MS will have legal issues if they invalidate a license for 7/8. I can see them saying you can't have 10 active and 7 active on the same license, but beyond that they'll get sued.
 
10.0 Cheetah: Released March 24, 2001 for $129
10.1 Puma: Released September 25, 2001 for $0
10.2 Jaguar: Released August 23, 2002 for $129
10.3 Panther: Released October 24, 2003 for $129
10.4 Tiger: Released April 29, 2005 for $129
10.5 Leopard: Released October 26, 2007 for $129
10.6 Snow Leopard: Released August 28, 2009 for $29
10.7 Lion: Released July 20, 2011 for $29
10.8 Mountain Lion: Released July 25, 2012 for $19
10.9 Mavericks: Released October 22, 2013 for $0

Sorry, 29 dollars (or less) for the last 6-7 years. The bottom line is that they get you for the OS on the H/W side.
 
Sorry, 29 dollars (or less) for the last 6-7 years. The bottom line is that they get you for the OS on the H/W side.
Nope, you're wrong. Price hasn't changed even though the OS doesn't cost any money.

They make their money via the App Store--same reason MS is shifting to a new model. If you're going to criticize at least get your facts straight.
 
Until 30 days have passed and it's confirmed that you can't reinstall 8, I'll remain cautiously optimistic. All of the pages I've seen referring this are rolling back to the old OS. IMO, that makes sense, because who wants to keep Windows 7/8 installs on their drive forever? If you do, then take an image before you upgrade...actually do that either way.

I personally think MS will have legal issues if they invalidate a license for 7/8. I can see them saying you can't have 10 active and 7 active on the same license, but beyond that they'll get sued.
Cautiously optimistic of what? That you'll always be able to install Windows 7 or 8.1 and then upgrade it and then reinstall Windows 10 after it's been activated?

How is that a good thing in your mind? :confused:
 
I love these threads. If I change my motherboard and processor why can't I keep windows activated for the new motherboard and combo AND keep it activated for the old one that I've decided to make another computer out of???
People will spend $700 on a video card but not $100 on an OS LICENSE.

yeah.

why not just re-buy all your steam games too once you upgrade? rebuy FRAPS, 3dmark as well.

I wonder why people don't like paying for software they own twice... Hmmmm:confused::confused::confused:
 
Technically people are not suppose to use upgrades on new builds, people did it anyway.

Which is ironic in a way. If you're doing an upgrade you'd think you would want some new hardware to go along with it. Few people upgrade to a new OS if they're going to keep the old hardware. May as well just buy the license when they buy a new PC so they don't have to pay for a new OS license twice.
 
Err, most people will sell off the old parts. Besides, I had an SSD replacement trigger reactivation of a MS product in the past few months. So no, I don't plan to buy a new copy of Windows every time I upgrade something.

A few years back I bought a new HDD and cloned my Win 7 install onto the new drive. Wiped the old HDD clean. Still had to reactivate Win 7 (was a clean installed upgrade from Vista).
 
Which is ironic in a way. If you're doing an upgrade you'd think you would want some new hardware to go along with it. Few people upgrade to a new OS if they're going to keep the old hardware. May as well just buy the license when they buy a new PC so they don't have to pay for a new OS license twice.

A lot of the crap MS does doesn't really support people like us at Hard, and that is sad, cant say I agree with it, but the reality is there aren't many options. MS is stuck between a rock and hard place and this is largely because we as consumers are not willing to explore other licensing options. I estimate that an OEM pays somewhere between $45 and $60 for a windows license. But if we want to buy an OEM copy its $85-100. And if we want a full retail version its over 100. Personally I always thought that was really stupid of MS to punish the tech savvy that are the people who would convince others to buy and use windows machines. But I am sure from their view the OEMs are the ones they need to please the most.

I have moved my whole family over to office 365. And it is wonderful. No more license crap. But the thing is the masses out there and perhaps even you are die hard haters of subscriptions. So we can't have it both ways. I was actually looking forward to a time when MS would offer windows as a subscription. Also another thing that holds this back is all the tinfoil hat folks don't want a MS account. Imagine if the whole world moved to subscription based accounts. MS would let anyone download installation media, hell motherboard makers would probably build in the ability to launch an installation right from UEFI. And once windows was installed you would simply login and activate your copy. Hardware changes, reformats, none of it would matter. But because of human behavior we cant have any of those nice things.
 
A lot of the crap MS does doesn't really support people like us at Hard, and that is sad, cant say I agree with it, but the reality is there aren't many options. MS is stuck between a rock and hard place and this is largely because we as consumers are not willing to explore other licensing options. I estimate that an OEM pays somewhere between $45 and $60 for a windows license. But if we want to buy an OEM copy its $85-100. And if we want a full retail version its over 100. Personally I always thought that was really stupid of MS to punish the tech savvy that are the people who would convince others to buy and use windows machines. But I am sure from their view the OEMs are the ones they need to please the most.

I have moved my whole family over to office 365. And it is wonderful. No more license crap. But the thing is the masses out there and perhaps even you are die hard haters of subscriptions. So we can't have it both ways. I was actually looking forward to a time when MS would offer windows as a subscription. Also another thing that holds this back is all the tinfoil hat folks don't want a MS account. Imagine if the whole world moved to subscription based accounts. MS would let anyone download installation media, hell motherboard makers would probably build in the ability to launch an installation right from UEFI. And once windows was installed you would simply login and activate your copy. Hardware changes, reformats, none of it would matter. But because of human behavior we cant have any of those nice things.

Those aren't nice things, it's called you have money to burn and don't care about increased cost for minor convenience. If you like it, great. Not all of us want to throw away additional money on software.
 
Those aren't nice things, it's called you have money to burn and don't care about increased cost for minor convenience. If you like it, great. Not all of us want to throw away additional money on software.

Agreed, that isn't the world I even remotely call good. Everyone already knows exactly what would happen if everything went subscription, everything would cost more period. It already is happening now just look at cable. Subscriptions are a bad idea every single time. It allows any company to start low and then constantly overcharge you for basically nothing as time goes on bu slowly increasing the subscription cost. We'd all be frogs in slowly heated water just slow enough to boil us all to death in fees.
 
Nope, you're wrong. Price hasn't changed even though the OS doesn't cost any money.

They make their money via the App Store--same reason MS is shifting to a new model. If you're going to criticize at least get your facts straight.

Do you really not get that Apple makes money on H/W that gets a premium that allows them to essentially make a premium price on every copy of it's OS? Do you not get that Apple doesn't support old hardware indefinitely, thus forcing users that actually hang on to old H/W to upgrade (and thus buy a full version of the OS all over again)?

If not, then let's end this now, because I've got better things to do and hopefully you do too.
 
Cautiously optimistic of what? That you'll always be able to install Windows 7 or 8.1 and then upgrade it and then reinstall Windows 10 after it's been activated?

How is that a good thing in your mind? :confused:

I replied to the wrong message. I meant to reply to this one

Also, your qualifying OS key becomes invalid after 30 days so you will not be able to activate it to use it to upgrade to Win10 from. Correct me if I am wrong.
 
yeah.

why not just re-buy all your steam games too once you upgrade? rebuy FRAPS, 3dmark as well.

I wonder why people don't like paying for software they own twice... Hmmmm:confused::confused::confused:

If you have a retail license, then I agree. For OEM/System Builder liceneses, we've always known that they weren't supposed to transfer to new H/W
 
If you have a retail license, then I agree. For OEM/System Builder liceneses, we've always known that they weren't supposed to transfer to new H/W

That why they need do away with all OEM/System Builder/Retial liceneses and do it as all-in-one ver.
In stead do it as user account by register licenese to that deive and allow transfer over new deivce by unregister the old device not by stuip hardware hash.
 
That why they need do away with all OEM/System Builder/Retial liceneses and do it as all-in-one ver.
In stead do it as user account by register licenese to that deive and allow transfer over new deivce by unregister the old device not by stuip hardware hash.

You can...you have a Sys Builder/OEM, go buy a full retail version....problem solved. MS absolutely should not say, "Well we're going to upgrade all of these cheaper licenses to full retail licenses." That's just crazy talk. Some of those licenses are free while others are very inexpensive. When you pay 119 for a SB license, you're paying significantly less than a retail license (about 1/4 as I recall).
 
Back
Top