Microsoft, McAfee vs. SuperFish

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
If this was a game of football, there would be a flag on the play for piling on. :D If you own one of the infected Lenovo laptops that has the Superfish adware on it, Microsoft and McAfee have taken up the cause and come to the consumers’ rescue. Lenovo has announced it rolled out another patch to fix the problem, (since patch #1 didn’t quite cut the mustard), but Microsoft Defender and McAfee have also pushed out removal tools to aid in Lenovo’s bid to regain street credibility in removing the problem that the company initiated in the first place.

We apologize for causing these concerns among our users – we are learning from this experience and will use it to improve what we do and how we do it in the future.
 
Ars had an article about complications related to MSSE. If another anti-malware package is installed, MSSE can disable itself (you know, to be compliant with AV crybabies overseas) until the trial period of the other AV package expires. So even though MSSE can fix it, it may not be enabled on some systems.

Lenovo has already posted more complete instructions on how to remove SuperFish from its PCs for those who don't want to wait for an automated removal tool. But this is not a complete fix. Some web browsers like FireFox can remain compromised even after uninstalling the ad software package and removing the fake SuperFish root certificate. lol
 
The fact that the company Superfish can legally operate a business that deceptively and intentionally installs malware against the wishes of computer owners is beyond me.

Someone ought to firebomb that place. (or at least, sue them to death)
 
MS just needs to add that superfish cert to the untrusted list, disable that functionality on all updated windows PCs regardless if the user knows about this or not.
 
Ars had an article about complications related to MSSE. If another anti-malware package is installed, MSSE can disable itself (you know, to be compliant with AV crybabies overseas) until the trial period of the other AV package expires. So even though MSSE can fix it, it may not be enabled on some systems.

Lenovo has already posted more complete instructions on how to remove SuperFish from its PCs for those who don't want to wait for an automated removal tool. But this is not a complete fix. Some web browsers like FireFox can remain compromised even after uninstalling the ad software package and removing the fake SuperFish root certificate. lol


lol Wut.... Firefox was the only browser not affected because it has it's own cert store... Got any sources to back what you just dribbled onto this post?
 
I consider McAfee malware.

So true.

Their software just wrecks Windows and slows everything to a crawl. Also, their business practice of tricking users into downloading trials and bundling them with new PCs is shady at best.

McAfee is a very hostile company and should be avoided like the plague.
 
So true.

Their software just wrecks Windows and slows everything to a crawl. Also, their business practice of tricking users into downloading trials and bundling them with new PCs is shady at best.

McAfee is a very hostile company and should be avoided like the plague.

I've never used their consumer products, but their enterprise antivirus software has been installed on pretty much every work laptop I've ever had handed to me across 10 different companies.

Not sure if they are significantly different, but I haven't noticed any slowdowns.

I'm not convinced they have the best detection though.

For my personal use, I have AVG Free on my windows machines, and nothing on my Linux desktops.

I do use ClamAV in Linux to periodically scan my file server though.

I used to like AVG more, but their increasing number of popups in the task bar is starting to bug me. Guess I shouldn't complain for a free tool, but maybe it is time to try something else.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041444314 said:
I've never used their consumer products, but their enterprise antivirus software has been installed on pretty much every work laptop I've ever had handed to me across 10 different companies.

Not sure if they are significantly different, but I haven't noticed any slowdowns.

I'm not convinced they have the best detection though.

For my personal use, I have AVG Free on my windows machines, and nothing on my Linux desktops.

I do use ClamAV in Linux to periodically scan my file server though.

I used to like AVG more, but their increasing number of popups in the task bar is starting to bug me. Guess I shouldn't complain for a free tool, but maybe it is time to try something else.

My main issue with AVG is how they change user's homepage, search engine, and install toolbars. Isn't that something their software should be preventing/blocking and removing?

That classifies as malware as far as I am concerned.
 
My main issue with AVG is how they change user's homepage, search engine, and install toolbars. Isn't that something their software should be preventing/blocking and removing?

That classifies as malware as far as I am concerned.

I believe this is a checkbox during the install process.

I've never had this problem, but I think it's because I've unchecked it.

Obviously something like this ought to be opt in, not opt out.

They claim these are part of the protection tools. That their search page helps discovver potentially malicious sites, etc. I'd argue that it is more likely a profit incentive driving traffic to a search engine on their part, but you never know.
 
lol Wut.... Firefox was the only browser not affected because it has it's own cert store... Got any sources to back what you just dribbled onto this post?

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/02/further-evidence-lenovo-breaking-https-security-its-laptops

The fact that there are significant numbers of Firefox victims somewhat contradicts the speculation that Firefox is safe because it doesn't use the Windows root store. This either indicates that Superfish also injects its certificate into the Firefox root store, or that on a large number of occasions Firefox users have been clicking through certificate warnings caused by Superfish MITM attacks
 
Zarathustra[H];1041444314 said:
I've never used their consumer products, but their enterprise antivirus software has been installed on pretty much every work laptop I've ever had handed to me across 10 different companies.

Not sure if they are significantly different, but I haven't noticed any slowdowns.

I'm not convinced they have the best detection though.

For my personal use, I have AVG Free on my windows machines, and nothing on my Linux desktops.

I do use ClamAV in Linux to periodically scan my file server though.

I used to like AVG more, but their increasing number of popups in the task bar is starting to bug me. Guess I shouldn't complain for a free tool, but maybe it is time to try something else.

McAffee is the worst pay AV and AVG is the worst free one.

For pay: Kaspersky, Eset
For free: Avira, Comodo (if you want an "internet security" package for free which also includes a sandbox feature like a light version of Sandboxie)
 
McAffee is the worst pay AV and AVG is the worst free one.

For pay: Kaspersky, Eset
For free: Avira, Comodo (if you want an "internet security" package for free which also includes a sandbox feature like a light version of Sandboxie)

These things change rather frequently.

At one point AVG was either at or near the top (may have been 5 or more years ago, but I haven't kept up with it).

I wouldn't use Kaspersky at any price, seeing how they appear to be in bed with the Russian government. Just don't trust them at all. I may take a look at Avira.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041444343 said:
I believe this is a checkbox during the install process.

I've never had this problem, but I think it's because I've unchecked it.

Obviously something like this ought to be opt in, not opt out.

They claim these are part of the protection tools. That their search page helps discovver potentially malicious sites, etc. I'd argue that it is more likely a profit incentive driving traffic to a search engine on their part, but you never know.

I get that and yes it definitely is solely a profit related practice and provides no benefit. However, the fact that AVG thinks this an acceptable practice makes them just like Lenovo...untrustworthy.
 
I get that and yes it definitely is solely a profit related practice and provides no benefit. However, the fact that AVG thinks this an acceptable practice makes them just like Lenovo...untrustworthy.

I hear you on that.

I've intended to switch away from AVG many times, but never gotten around to actually doing the research and finding a suitable replacement.

Avira does seem like a pretty good option.

Do you guys still have Malwarebytes anti-malware installed alongside the AV of your choice, or is that no longer the way to go?
 
Zarathustra[H];1041444427 said:
Do you guys still have Malwarebytes anti-malware installed alongside the AV of your choice, or is that no longer the way to go?

For my own PC, I get malware so rarely that I run Malwarebytes if necessary and then uninstall.

For PCs that I fix, I install Malwarebytes and leave it installed. I also recommend that these people do pay for it since they are higher risk. Most of them don't end up doing so but they generally do at least keep the free one installed (though probably most of them never actually run scans with it).

It is still a very good product.
 
For my own PC, I get malware so rarely that I run Malwarebytes if necessary and then uninstall.

For PCs that I fix, I install Malwarebytes and leave it installed. I also recommend that these people do pay for it since they are higher risk. Most of them don't end up doing so but they generally do at least keep the free one installed (though probably most of them never actually run scans with it).

It is still a very good product.

Yeah, I am mostly interested in it for family members and friends who I help out.

My Windows use these days is limited to when I reboot my Linux desktop to Windows 7 pro for some gaming, and then I reboot right back.

My laptop is all Linux, my two HTPC's are Linux, and even my 7 year old stepsons desktop I built him from spare parts is all Linux. (he plays games on it, but luckily enough more of them work in Linux now).

My Fiancee has a Mac, which I am still trying to wrap my head around what to do with. I am unimpressed with Apple's response to security vulnerabilities, and I'm sure that thing is vulnerable and a potential malware problem, but I am not sure if there is anything I can do to help protect it...
 
lol Wut.... Firefox was the only browser not affected because it has it's own cert store... Got any sources to back what you just dribbled onto this post?
Re-read the very first word in the quote you posted for a source. Burying your head in the sand isn't making the problem go away. lol
 
Zarathustra[H];1041444530 said:
My Fiancee has a Mac, which I am still trying to wrap my head around what to do with. I am unimpressed with Apple's response to security vulnerabilities, and I'm sure that thing is vulnerable and a potential malware problem, but I am not sure if there is anything I can do to help protect it...

Just use the option: "Allow apps downloaded from: Mac App Store and identified developers". And convert her user into a standard account, and keep a separate admin account.

If you do that, I doubt you'll ever have to do anything related to malware in her computer.
 
Back
Top