Microsoft Can’t Fix Its Halo: MCC Fail

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
To be fair, this story describes over half the AAA titles that launched this year. It's been a crappy year for gamers.

Microsoft’s launch of Halo: The Master Chief Collection was a disaster. The games were buggy. You couldn’t contact friends. Joining a party was a colossal pain in the ass. Matchmaking within a party was a nightmare. Even the most ardent fans of the game, the ones only too happy to shell out 60 bucks to buy a collection of games they already own, were left wondering: “WTF?"
 
Oh, look, now they're using personal anecdotes for their video game stories. How clever!
 
343 isn't going to finish fixing the game and make everyone happy. People need to realize their beloved franchise was used as a nostalgia cash grab and they fell for it.
 
Wonder if 2015 will be the year the masses will wait for reviews of a stable game before buying...?
 
Wonder if 2015 will be the year the masses will wait for reviews of a stable game before buying...?

Never. People will keep preordering new games so they can get trivial trinkets and boosts, then act like victims when the game turns out to have problems.
 
Reminds me of the lesser titles that simply have the developers say "We're sorry we won't be doing any more updates, <insert excuse here - no more money, its your crappy computer's fault, we're moving on to other projects>
 
Never. People will keep preordering new games so they can get trivial trinkets and boosts, then act like victims when the game turns out to have problems.

Nah, they do it because they are the first to have it and you weren't. You must not be a real gamer because you didn't buy it on day 1. I bought the limited edition, super deluxe, pre-order edition, Day One model, shiny box of SimCity. So, I'm better than you. Just wait until the server works, and I'll make a city better than all of you. Pfft. You guys call yourselves gamers.... Whatever.
 
Never. People will keep preordering new games so they can get trivial trinkets and boosts, then act like victims when the game turns out to have problems.

I'm lucky I only pre-ordered stuff during the 5th and 6th gen era.
Pre-ordered FF7(shirt, and PS1 hat), Lunar 1 Collector Edition(PS1 ver)(Galleon boxing puppet), and the PS2(don't know what I got with that.)

None of this "buy our game, we'll patch it later. And if not, well, fuck you we have your money".

Wonder if the publishers are like this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_hFTR6qyEo
lol
 
It's a sad state that we are in for gaming. We have some amazing tech in our computers and graphics look amazing in many games. We just have the companies making the games ran by greedy people that do not care about anything but making money. The sad part is they really don't have to care about anything else since there is millions of people willing to preorder and day 1 purchase the garbage they keep selling. I read all over the internet people making excuses for the bad games. In the MMO genre people say things like "even though it has all these issues it is still better than everything else that's out". For other genres the most common thing said is "every other game has bugs at release, it's just the way things are these days".

These are horrible reasons to keep giving money to these people. They should be forced to deliver a quality product. The problem though is with all the children that want these games. They want the new shiny and even if every adult decided to vote with their wallet and only buy finished bug free games, those children would still be able to keep the money coming in.

It would be nice if they made lemon laws for games but at the same time it would be fucking retarded.
 
Heck when UBI is required pre-reviewers to sign waivers to not publish till 48 hours after games are released it's getting bad. Make the big bucks and then patch till people give up.
 
343 isn't going to finish fixing the game and make everyone happy. People need to realize their beloved franchise was used as a nostalgia cash grab and they fell for it.
Or they could band together to ruin the reputation of companies ... oh wait, this requires persistence to pull off, nevermind. :D
 
I simply will NOT pre-order a game - been there, done that, got burned. Too much BS with initial release. I'll wait until the reviews come in (user reviews....not the BS magazine reviews) and decide if I want to give it a shot.

Last few years......Nah, I'll pass.
 
Never. People will keep preordering new games so they can get trivial trinkets and boosts, then act like victims when the game turns out to have problems.

It's even worse nowadays, they prepurchase and pay in advance with no refunds allowed.... it's pathetic that people put themselves in such a poor position for no good reason, and it encourages lower quality because the publisher knows they already have sold a huge number of copies at full price.
 
this is why I ... all my games before I decide to buy them



That's not the right thing to do either.... stealing it to try like you're saying, that is (yes, you're embarassingly transparent). The right solution is to wait for release to see how it's reviewed, rated, and received by people.
 
I don't even care about online and it still sucks. You can't change team colors, wtf was microsoft thinking? Can't even play couch 2v2 because we can't setup teams properly.
 
I don't even care about online and it still sucks. You can't change team colors, wtf was microsoft thinking? Can't even play couch 2v2 because we can't setup teams properly.

They knew people would buy it no matter how bad it was. If you bought the game, you are part of the problem.
 
They knew people would buy it no matter how bad it was. If you bought the game, you are part of the problem.

For wanting to play Halo 1 and 2 remastered at good framerates? I didn't expect them to break the game in every other way.
 
Wait.. isn't this the one that had the making of documentary about how passionate they were? Lol.
 
That's not the right thing to do either.... stealing it to try like you're saying, that is (yes, you're embarassingly transparent). The right solution is to wait for release to see how it's reviewed, rated, and received by people.

How is that a solution if it requires a sucker to buy it first? Review magazines are pretty worthless nowadays since most reviews are bought. While stealing isn't a solution, being sold a unfinished broken mess isn't a solution either and just as wrong. In reality it's fraud.

While people should really start paying attention to what publishing house is publishing a game, at the same they should be able to buy a product that works and is complete.

Somehow we have allowed software developers to create situations that are anti-consumer (software you don't own, EULA agreements that usurp constitutional rights, the ability to sell a broken product and not have to provide a refund, etc) and none of it is going to stop unless the public makes it stop.
 
This gen of games and consoles kinda sucks for me. I haven't had a console in a long time but I have wanted to get back into the console realm so I can play with all my buddies who aren't PC enthusiasts. But with all the issues and lack of quality polished games I can't pull the trigger on a console purchase atm. Honestly the Wii U seems like the best option but no one I know has it or really wants it due to the rocky start it had and the stigma of that start. Kinda sad really.
 
Shame that Nintendo doesn't publish their games outside their console eco systems, they seem to be one of the few outlets you can count on for quality right out of the gate still.
 
With all the other releases, wasnt surprise but I still feel Unity is way way buggier than Halo, might still buy halo in the future when all is better, but I dont think ill be shedding cash on Unity anytime soon. Lol
 
Shame that Nintendo doesn't publish their games outside their console eco systems, they seem to be one of the few outlets you can count on for quality right out of the gate still.

That's because they refused to get into the update/DLC game, even psychologically, that's quite a big deal.

Not anymore, though.
 
Then again the Mario Kart DLC was tremendous and relatively cheap.

I want that game on my PC. Also Mario. Don't want their console, just select few (those two series) games.
 
That's because they refused to get into the update/DLC game, even psychologically, that's quite a big deal.

Not anymore, though.

I think it's more because these newer consoles are now basically internet connected devices. Many publishers are abusing that feature by releasing buggy games - then they give them a couple patches if pressured to do so.

It's a lazy and greedy mentality that produces badly tested junk.
 
That's because they refused to get into the update/DLC game, even psychologically, that's quite a big deal.

Not anymore, though.

Well, I should add that rampant DLCs and micro-transaction mania probably falls under the same umbrella of "connected consoles" abuse so in a sense we're talking about the same thing really.
 
How is that a solution if it requires a sucker to buy it first? Review magazines are pretty worthless nowadays since most reviews are bought. While stealing isn't a solution, being sold a unfinished broken mess isn't a solution either and just as wrong. In reality it's fraud.

While people should really start paying attention to what publishing house is publishing a game, at the same they should be able to buy a product that works and is complete.

Somehow we have allowed software developers to create situations that are anti-consumer (software you don't own, EULA agreements that usurp constitutional rights, the ability to sell a broken product and not have to provide a refund, etc) and none of it is going to stop unless the public makes it stop.

I completely agree with you, actually. But for now until things start changing, jumping in first is risky instead of waiting and seeing. I remember thinking it was silly we couldn't return opened physical pc games, back in the days before online activations, but people defended it. Then it moved to even console games. Then steam came and a lot of people hated it but it gained quick acceptance anyway, and things snowballed from there to now having us not own a game at all with it being able to be remotely disabled, horrible release quality being the norm, no ability to sell our game after playing it, and generally no refunds under any circumstances at 99 percent of vendors for games now. It has needed to stop for many years, really more than a decade, but people gobbled it up anyway and well, here we are. :(
 
How do you screw up a collection of games that were published years ago when you've had all that time to iron out any bugs?
 
It seems like the MCC's problems are primarily limited to multiplayer matchmaking. So… if the problems are only affecting one part of the games, why is the entire collection being described as broken? Just go play the single player campaigns. I daresay Halo's campaigns are better than its multiplayer modes anyway.
 
How do you screw up a collection of games that were published years ago when you've had all that time to iron out any bugs?

They farmed out all the exporting of the games and the documentation probably sucked for doing a decent port. When halo 4 came out, it was obvious that 343I was incapable of handling where bungie left off.

Bungie and 343i have lost so much ground that they are now just former shells of themselves.
 
Why do sites still put 'Fail' in titles like "MCC Fail","Xbox Fail", or "Windows Fail"?
Please stop, it's not the 2000s anymore.
 
It seems like the MCC's problems are primarily limited to multiplayer matchmaking. So… if the problems are only affecting one part of the games, why is the entire collection being described as broken? Just go play the single player campaigns. I daresay Halo's campaigns are better than its multiplayer modes anyway.

lol.. while the single player is fun, the game kinda made its name on mutiplayer. After having to deal with 2 crappy multiplayer games for over 5 years, a lot of players wanted a chance to relive a good halo multiplayer. This is where the game ultimately failed. Hell even single player had some issues with mission playlists skipping some missions, achievements not unlocking for completing them and such.

The game shoudl have been launched atleast a month late. it would have been better to get released later and patched once to this point, then for people to get 4 or 5 patches as is and deal with lots of broken stuff.
 
They farmed out all the exporting of the games and the documentation probably sucked for doing a decent port. When halo 4 came out, it was obvious that 343I was incapable of handling where bungie left off.

Bungie and 343i have lost so much ground that they are now just former shells of themselves.

LOL> say what? halo 4 was decent, and pretty much worked pushing the 360 pretty hard. Either 343 themselves or Microsoft forced them to make some crazy multiplayer gameplay decisions. it seemed like they were trying to cash in on the CoD hype,

Bungie on the other hand, some argue they just got lucky with halo. If destiny had a better written story and a little more gameplay variety around the story, plus better party chat/link up. These few things would go long way to simply improve game. dont know why they did some of the decisions they did. Maybe Activision pushed them to release half the game so they can rape us and reap in the dlc?
 
It seems like the MCC's problems are primarily limited to multiplayer matchmaking. So… if the problems are only affecting one part of the games, why is the entire collection being described as broken? Just go play the single player campaigns. I daresay Halo's campaigns are better than its multiplayer modes anyway.

Not quite. Playable? Yes.

Bug riddled piece of shit? Yes.
 
lol.. while the single player is fun, the game kinda made its name on mutiplayer.

I would disagree with this. The campaign mode drew people in, the multiplayer convinced them to stay. Far, far more people play single player modes than multiplayer modes.
 
Very few games that I bought on Day 1 release, Mortal Kombat 9 for the PS3, Red Dead Redemption for PS3, Grand Theft Auto 5 for PS3 and Borderlands 1 for the PC, Orange Box for PC, Starcraft for PC and Starcraft 2 for PC and the expansion Heart of the Swarm for PC.

Was not disappointed .

You can buy games on release date , just be smart about it. Is it a risk? Possibly, but I took a chance cause I can.
 
Back
Top